Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Edwards

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Edwards
 

Is It Time for an End to Party Politics at City Hall?

Posted: 2/05/2012 00:00

Independent candidate Siobhan Benita is something of an enigma in this year's mayoral race. Materialising as a complete unknown a few months ago she has, in her own words, "flummoxed" the political elite with her soaring poll ratings set against an apparent lack of any serious backing, funding or party-political allegiances.

She has been banned from appearing at any broadcasted mayoral hustings, and having never before held a publicly elected office, she's been criticised by some as being too inexperienced for the job.

But with George Galloway's 'Bradford Spring' still fresh in the memory, and Boris and Ken's slanging matches becoming more and more tiresome with every passing day, Benita argues that the time is right for a departure from mainstream party politics at City Hall.

"I want to be political, I just don't want to be party political" she tells me, reclining on a sofa in her ad-hoc campaign base in the lobby of the Royal Festival Hall. "I think the opinion polls show people have never been this fed up with party politics - they don't trust them and they don't believe what they say any more.

"When you look at Ken and Boris, they're always fighting old party political battles, which gets in the way of actually doing the right thing for London."

She is right, of course. Politics in Britain, like in many other countries, is a never-ending battle between the two opposite sides of our political spectrum. And with her easy demeanour and calm, friendly tone cast stark against the cacophony of screaming school children and coffee-slurping tourists in the Festival Hall, I am finding it hard not to like - and believe - Benita myself.

But although it may not be perfect, our party political system does at least allow the public to know fairly easily what the fundamental leanings of a given politician are.

With such a broad range of policies, which include her backing of Heathrow expansion and a pledge to bring more affordable housing to London, she does admit to having some trouble trying to get people to understand where she sits on this political spectrum.

"People do want to know where you sit on that scale of things. I have always voted Labour, but I don't know how I'd vote in the next election because I honestly think that all the political parties have lost their way. I think they're in a kind of identity crisis and they're fighting over this space in the middle."

It is clear then, that Benita the politician is a left-leaning one, and having worked as a civil servant for 15 years, mostly under Blair and Brown, she is well acquainted with the political system. But the civil service is a politically neutral body, so unlike the other candidates she is in no way tied to Labour, or any other party.

During this campaign Boris has made much of the claim that he was able to secure more funding for London through his Conservative government connections, but Benita is quick to dismiss this as a flawed argument, saying "It's all very well Boris saying 'I've managed to get so much out of the treasury because they're my mates' - but what about when [the government] changes?

"As an independent you will always be able to have a more rational conversation [with the government] because you don't bring the party political baggage with you."

On the question of party financing, however, it is clear that the backing her competitor's enjoy does bring with it a huge war-chest of funds for campaign publicity.

And it is this which I find most intriguing about this election - bookmakers have slashed Benita's odds of winning from 500-1 to 25-1 in a matter of weeks, but without party backing her entire campaign has been run on a shoe-string budget - and she tells me this has led to some imaginative speculations about mystery benefactors, including the Blair Foundation, David Cameron and Richard Branson.

She laughs off my suggestion that Richard Branson himself might have thrown the odds by putting a big bet on her to win, but the point I'm trying to make is that bookmakers are not in the business of backing losers, and if there are in fact no errant billionaires burning up cash backing Benita at the bookies, then she must really be in with a chance.

And as I leave her grandiose adopted office on the Southbank, I can't help but think that if such an outsider as Siobhan Benita were to make it into City Hall at the expense of the megabucks political play-makers, then it must surely be a victory not just for her, but for democracy too.

 

Follow Tom Edwards on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tommy_ray_gun

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Independent candidate Siobhan Benita is something of an enigma in this year's mayoral race. Materialising as a complete unknown a few months ago she has, in her own words, "flummoxed" the political el...
Independent candidate Siobhan Benita is something of an enigma in this year's mayoral race. Materialising as a complete unknown a few months ago she has, in her own words, "flummoxed" the political el...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:49 AM on 05/04/2012
It is time to end party politics altogether. Forget proportional representation. We need candidares who live and have lived in area who have experience of of real life outside the political bubble, not carreer politicians who have learnt how to mislead and are insincere and can move from safe-ish seat to safe-ish seat. If we are to continue with party politics we need candidates who :
(1) Have a long association with the constituency i.e. been educated or worked for a long period in that constituency.
(2) Live in the constituency making them accessible to their electors.
(3) Honest straightforward truthful people who are not tied to the party line for idealogical reasons.
(4) It might be a good idea if the Westminster candidates had cut their teeth in Local politics rather than in some pseudo advisory position at party HQ. After all, how can somebody straight from university honestly be considered to have enough experience to advise? Perhaps enough experience to research, but ADVISE NEVER!!!!
06:00 PM on 05/02/2012
I sympathise with Ms Benita's plight in terms of the anti-democratic BBC "editorial guidelines", and it is indeed outrageous that state radio and tv in the UK should impose effective blackouts on candidates standing for office. What a contrast to France, in which candidates were given quite scrupulous access. But bookies odds are really only the outcome of money placed on a possibility, and it is probable that betting on "others" was very very low, because of the nature of the campaign and how it is presented in the UK media.

Another disgrace in this election is the ban on candidates writing letters to their voters. Given the fact that Ms Benita and two other candidates are excluded by pre-planning from being heard on tv, it is surely a serious affront to democracy that they should also be barred from even sending one letter of their own to their constituents? If they did so, they would be disqualified from office and possibly even jailed. i echo one of your other comments - vote for anyone you like except the two "main" candidates to try and end this farce whereby the two "main" parties have a stranglehold on democracy through the BBC (state radio and tv) and the rules barring candidates from campaigning.
04:54 PM on 05/02/2012
I'm voting for her... The other two major candidates are pathetic, squabbling about nonsense, and in no way am I a supporter of the extremist Communist (Green) party. If Paddock wasn't a LibDem I'd have voted for him. Seems the sensible and best suited choice for the job. Don't want Ken again.
10:18 AM on 05/02/2012
Londoners really need to think about what they want: candidates from the two major political parties who pass London back and forth like a prize to be used to bolster their party leader's influence or an Independent candidate whose first priority is representing London and listening to Londoner's needs. The two major political parties are bogged down in Groupthink. It's time to give an increasing number of Independents a chance to prove themselves. Don't simply give up your vote to people who have failed you before, hoping that things will be different. Research shows that more people will vote for Independent candidates IF they beleieve they have a chance of winning. People have to believe that, put a cross next to an Independent's name and send the major parties and their candidates - with their sense of entitlement - the message that you are not that predictable. The White Ticket wishes Siobhan Benita well in the election. If another candidate wins, however, Siobhan should very rapidly apply herself to analysing which constituencies in London she specifically made the most impact and start campaigning as an Independent there in preparation for the General Election in three years' time. She could be one of the Independents that make a real breakthrough (win her previous candidacy for Mayor as experience) in those coming elections - like the 50 standing NHS protest platform doctors. To read more, check out http://thewhiteticket.blogspot.co.uk/
Zip Zinzel
If a Nation expects to be both Ignorant & Free . .
01:34 AM on 05/02/2012
For anyone interested in seeing how politics works in the UK,
I suggest this BBC Bio about young Margaret Thatcher.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zM390BOmtvU

This is old (politics have changed somewhat)
The actress playing Ms Thatcher is very pretty.
this is 90min, but is far superior to last years major Hollywood movie on her.
11:56 PM on 05/01/2012
It would be very good if she could break 10% in the first round.