Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Ward

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Ward
 

Why I Loved HMV

Posted: 15/01/2013 01:12

As you'll have heard by now, music retailer HMV is on the brink of falling into administration. Unless a buyer can be found for the high street giant, the company (which opened in 1921 on London's Oxford Street) will be forced to close its doors for good. This will mean the loss of over 4000 jobs and for many, the loss of a 'face to face' relationship with music.

For many years, all we had in the small town I grew up in, was a tiny music store. If you could even call it a music store; it seemed to be more concerned with selling the latest TV show winner's flash-in-the-pan albums than real music. Thus, my only real 'hands-on' experiences with music would occur on shopping trips to larger near-by towns. Then, somewhere around ten years ago, a HMV showed up. It didn't just ride into town one day and pitch its tent on the high street. No, instead it was the subject of much excitement and speculation. This anticipation was partly to do with anything new being news in a small town, but there was also a degree of genuine excitement; here was a genuine music store that would carry all the best CDs, DVDs and games. Here was entertainment, under one roof. (HMV if you want to use that as an endorsement, my twitter is at the bottom of the page).

In a small town, things like music and film are important. They're your ways out. They're your ways to live vicariously through rock stars and film heroes and heroines. They inspire you and drive you to escape. There was a bleak time when I had returned from a trip to Mexico and found myself faced with five empty months before university. There were no jobs and so I was on Job Seekers Allowance (or 'the dole' as it's correctly pronounced). After a bottle of Tesco Dark Rum, there wasn't much of the government's money left, but HMV's three for £20 DVDs got me through that time and helped my money stretch further.

Of course, these deals are partly what led to the chain's demise. At the end of the day, their inability to deal with supermarkets and online retailers was the final bullet. Perhaps this is due to the way the company was run, or perhaps it is to do the changing ways in which we consume our media. Downloads of music and film (both legal and illegal) undercut those dealing in good-old fashioned, tangible products and mean it is almost impossible for stores to compete. Even HMV with its fingers reaching across the country could not defeat Amazon.

The worst part of HMV closing down is that the music and film lover will have limited options when it comes to discovering new music. Sure there are record stores, but, especially in small towns, it can be hard to find a decent one. The closure of HMV will not mean a sudden surge of customers fleeing to record stores. Instead, record stores are likely to suffer a decline in sales as consumers accept that online shopping is the future. I digress. All this means is that the 'hands-on', the 'face to face', aspect of interacting with music will slip away and become tangled up in the annals of time. Many delayed train journeys, and half-hours waiting for late friends have been pleasantly spent browsing the CD aisles of HMV.

When, a few years ago and back in my home town, my girlfriend at the time found out she had been accepted for her dream job, she rushed to find me and knew exactly where I would be: HMV. Years before that, aged 13, with pop punk flourishing around me, I spent ages in HMV looking through the MXPX collection, debating which album to spend my paper-round money on. Green Day's International Superhits, Blink-182's Dude Ranch and Foo Fighter's The Color and The Shape, were all purchased after similar lengthily internal debates. Sure, these days you can go on Amazon or iTunes and see the album artwork and listen to a snippet of the song, even read what Greg from Market Rasen thinks about the album, but is it the same as holding a physical copy of the album in your hands? Is it the same as digging out a rare release at the back of the shop? Is it balls.

A friend of mine who claims to love music often asks to borrow my copy of the latest release. The last album was Gaslight Anthem's Handwritten. Each time I tell her to go and buy her own copy. Of course, downloading the album still supports the band, but if they really mean that much to you, don't you want to hold their album in your hands? Don't you want to rush down to the store on release day and grab the deluxe edition off the shelves and then read the lyrics along with the music? The inevitable closure of HMV is a drastic step towards the closure of all record stores. Let's not allow this to happen. Next it'll be our bookstores and a world without record stores or book stores doesn't bear thinking about.

 

Follow Tom Ward on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RenegadeViper

FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT
As you'll have heard by now, music retailer HMV is on the brink of falling into administration. Unless a buyer can be found for the high street giant, the company (which opened in 1921 on London's Oxf...
As you'll have heard by now, music retailer HMV is on the brink of falling into administration. Unless a buyer can be found for the high street giant, the company (which opened in 1921 on London's Oxf...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
diaryofanobody
I am a lover of life, learning, politics, philosph
10:40 AM on 01/20/2013
I like Moviemail, a specialist website for movies and movie lovers. It is especially suited to those who, like me, are still wedded to their DVD's.

With regard to unsigned bands, there is always the Internet. I would personally imagine that there was "more out there" nowadays than there ever has been. Without the intermediation of the large record companies, there are less "barriers to entry" and thus more new music available to all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mediumal57
Moderate Extremist
09:09 PM on 01/15/2013
IO have one word for this journalist, who clearly is a product of the pre-file sharing generation: SPOTIFY... All the new music one probably ever needs is to be found on it, and it's growing all the while...
08:40 PM on 01/15/2013
All this media nostalgia for HMV, before I woke up to the internet and downloading, I like millions of others in the 80's and 90's where gladly handing over £18 for a DVD and £12 for a CD. HMV was raking in mountains of cash, basically printing money. HMV management were arrogant, sloppy, and retail products were expensive. They failed to wake up to the net and downloading until it was way too late.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aliktren
07:53 PM on 01/16/2013
even better they were glad to be there when you started trading in Vinyl for CD, how many of us of a certain age ended up buying 2 copies of the same album in different formats, no wonder free downloading took off
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ian Rennie
It irritates people that I'm a librarian :)
07:42 PM on 01/15/2013
HMV was a shark of a retailer. They drove a lot of competitors out of business by undercutting them and being willing to price them out of the market and wait for them to die.

How much sympathy do I have that they were impaled on the weapon they used? Not much, to be honest.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Daley James Francis
05:47 PM on 01/15/2013
Great post, Tom. I'm devastated by HMV closing. When I moved to Leicester from a small town with no record shop, I was blown away by it. I've spent the last 12 years going there at least 2-3 times a week. I don't think people realise how much they've going to miss it yet. Online buying is great, but it's killed the High Street and the social interaction you get in shops. Also, some of my greatest musical finds have been impromptu buys from HMV. I'm gutted.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Ward
06:31 PM on 01/15/2013
I couldn't agree more Daley. Hopefully social interaction will continue as long as indie record shops are around. I'd much rather spend an hour browsing in a record store than spend it with my headphones in, using Spotify on my iPhone.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aliktren
07:48 PM on 01/16/2013
my greatest finds of recent times have come from Spotify, there are tons of ways of finding good music that are still around, magazines, music blogs, last fm, thesixtyone, free sites on the web abound for finding legal music to listen to and try out. I appreciate these arent face to face social. But, if you want to find music now there are a lot better options than random trooping through HMV shelves (something I did 20 years ago as a student). As someone above said, they were very happy for a very long time to muscle out the competition and overcharge for everything, they almost entirely ignored the web, their website was horrible to navigate, it never even tried to reproduce the experience you describe from what I saw. There are very good reasons that HMV, Blockbuster, etc, are going downhill, and the reason isn't always "because Amazon", it's "because lazy management didn't recognize a disruptive market and innovate in it". Exactly the same for Blockbuster. I can't say I'm sad because the last time I visited the Southampton branch of HMV I was shocked at the prices and turned round and left (and that was before Amazon was really that big)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Ward
05:00 PM on 01/15/2013
*Clearly HMV isn't the ONLY record store to close down but (for better or worse) it was the biggest
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tom Ward
04:55 PM on 01/15/2013
Of course there's plenty of music on Youtube and in most cases the internet is the only way to discover new music. What I'll miss is going into a store and picking up a physical copy of a CD. Even with the ability to download music, I have always prefered the physical copy. Like a book, it just means more to me. Cleary HMV had played a big part in shutting down smaller record shops, and now it looks like the circle of record store life has come full circle. Clearly HMV isn't the biggest record store to close down but (for better or worse) it was the biggest and back in the days of dial-up internet it was the perfect way for a young teenager to get into music.
06:50 PM on 01/15/2013
I understand your personal nostalgia.

But time waits for no man Tom. The internet is far better a way to find new music than some old rusty shop.

I go online and listen to lots of new acts, read about them and find it more interesting than going into a shop who simply want to sell you the music.

Online I do not have to pay until I want it, I can listen, read and watch new media for hours on end, then message friends with the treasures I have found.

I prefer new media to old.
08:55 PM on 01/15/2013
though I think it depends on how you like information - if you are visual, or kinaesthetic you will feel happier making a judgement on the sleeve illustration, inner lyric sheet etc - it adds something. I liked it for all the film covers of the DVD's. Not just because of the films, also enjoyed generally browsing how they presented themselves, and reading the blurb.
08:56 PM on 01/15/2013
though I love friends like you that are good at finding stuff on You Tube :)
10:07 AM on 01/16/2013
You realise of course that you can go on Amazon (or Play, or eBay, or wherever) and actually buy your physical copy. You'll have it in your hands the very next day. And for quite a bit cheaper, if you shop around, than good old HMV!! I think this is a blog-gone-wrong Tom!
02:30 PM on 01/15/2013
I'm not too bothered about the demise of HMV, but as far as I know Fopp is owned by HMV and I don't know what its fate is. Nowhere better (That's Entertainment possibly comes close but it doesn't have any new releases) for cheap, sometimes second-hand and sometimes new stock. I've bought a great many films from there that I'd never have thought of picking up otherwise - always willing to take a chance on something if it's only three quid or so.
02:15 PM on 01/15/2013
"The worst part of HMV closing down is that the music and film lover will have limited options when it comes to discovering new music. "...someone needs to watch youtube.

You can find new music online better than in HMV.

Time moves on and technology advances. There is just the same passion for music now as ever before. People just sue the internet thats all.

Move on.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ian Rennie
It irritates people that I'm a librarian :)
01:26 PM on 01/15/2013
"The worst part of HMV closing down is that the music and film lover will have limited options when it comes to discovering new music. Sure there are record stores, but, especially in small towns, it can be hard to find a decent one."

have you heard of this thing called "the Internet"? I think it might be the next big thing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:01 PM on 01/15/2013
Yes! "The colour and the shape"- fantastic album. I also bought "Meat is murder" at HMV, my first taste of The Smiths.
But to be honest the overriding memory is waiting inside for an hour or more whilst a couple of indecisive friends made up their minds.
Buying music/dvds online is far cheaper. I'm not into free downloading but that is probably another problem for shops like this.
12:58 PM on 01/15/2013
Tom,
Unfortunately I have to disagree. HMV in the late 90's pursued an aggressive price-everyone-else-out-of-the-market approach; then ramped up prices when they'd killed off the competition. I'm sure everyone of a certain age remembers Our Price right?
If I remember rightly, there used to be three or four music stores in my local town, all reasonably priced, 2 or 3 of which were independently run.
All of these have gone.
Who is to blame?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:55 PM on 01/15/2013
If, by new music, you mean the latest George Michael single, then it's the place for you. If you genuinely want music by a new artist then the only option is online or to attend festivals. The music industry, including distribution channels, has failed to evolve and will therefore die in its present form.
12:11 PM on 01/15/2013
Young Tom, what decade, indeed century, do you live in? Online resources have become so vastly superior in terms of finding new music, sharing discoveries, sampling things that otherwise would probably have passed you by, etc. that HMV's physical stores became an anachronism and, even sadder, and embarrassment. I'm 56 and grew up haunting record stores, flipping through the album bins and listening on the "listening posts" (isn't that what Virgin called them?). I look back fondly, but the options my kids have are so much better that I can't realistically mourn the old days. If you're bored waiting for the train, pop out the smart phone and go on Spotify or Youtube (etc, etc).
12:23 PM on 01/15/2013
got to agree with you there, hard copy media has been dying for a long time.
Get with times Tom, you sound like my mum!! ; )
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:59 PM on 01/15/2013
Spot on, Stephen. To say nothing of internet radio stations - I mean actual radio stations, FMs, broadcasting around the world via the web. We never had it as good.

As for the (author's) need for "physical" attachment to records and books, I can understand that - probably vaguely remember it - but really it's the intellectual content that matters, not the plastic, vinyl and paper. Time to rethink, Tom.