iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Will Porter

GET UPDATES FROM Will Porter
 

Only YouTube Can Save the Falklands Now

Posted: 20/02/2012 23:00

During the international cock waggling competition between Britain and Argentina, the unfortunate Falkland islanders have sat quietly in the middle being ignored.

It's these 3,000 people whose fate is being decided by the finer points of international law and diplomacy and yet they only appear as the faceless child of divorcing parents.

In an age when our press likes to bemoan the increasing importance of Human Rights Legislation it seems that Britain's best defence of the Islanders is their right to self-determination.

Fuelled by patriotic fervour and a historic distaste for the British, this message appears to be lost on an Argentina still hurting from their last ignominious encounter with our beleaguered nation.

We're regularly told that technology is making the world a smaller place yet not small enough for the international power brokers to consider the impact their game of historical top trumps will be having on the islanders.

Perhaps it's time for the residents of the Las Malvinas to go viral in an attempt to reach out to the average Argentinean. It's time for the locals to pick up a camera and show everyone what life is like on the island.

I would suggest they create a tongue-in-cheek tourism video, one that knowingly plays on our national stereotypes and the quirks of a Little Britain abroad. Most importantly though it needs to help bring the territorial dispute down to a human level.

Start by showing the windswept rocky landscape in all its glory; lingering shots of its tree-less terrain surrounded by icy Antarctic waves smashing against these craggy islands.

The presenter could tour the island, seemingly unbothered by the gale force storm blowing around them, discussing its many sheep, boggy plains and array of lichens.

Then, and most importantly, talk to the inhabitants of the Islands. I imagine there is a woman called Margaret who owns the post office, a tour guide called Alan, Bill the fisherman and Janet who runs the local guesthouse.

They should discuss their love of a nice cuppa, custard creams and the importance of queuing. Next visit one of its four pubs to see the clientele supping warm ale and then show the delights of the local fish and chip shop.

Talk to the families; visit the schools, the peat cuttings and traditional Scottish dances. Perhaps the best way of ending such a video would be to explain that the majority of islanders are terrible at the tango, can't speak Spanish and would look awful in a poncho.

I'm not suggesting they morris dance in Beefeater outfits whilst eating spotted dick, although I'd like to see that, simply a little knowing humour and plenty of humanity could give some perspective.

For those argue over uti possidetis juris, continental shelves and Captain John Strong shouldn't forget that 900 people died in 1982 for the sake of pride and some isolated rocks 290 miles off the coast of Argentina.

The Falkland Islands are not an abstract concept, a historical debate or an investment opportunity but a home to a community of people for nearly 200 years. Until jingoism and oil are put to one side and people put at the centre of debate no reasonable solution can be reached.

 

Follow Will Porter on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GlamorousLeft

FOLLOW WORLD
During the international cock waggling competition between Britain and Argentina, the unfortunate Falkland islanders have sat quietly in the middle being ignored. It's these 3,000 people whose fate ...
During the international cock waggling competition between Britain and Argentina, the unfortunate Falkland islanders have sat quietly in the middle being ignored. It's these 3,000 people whose fate ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:19 on 23/02/2012
You should NOT be referring to them as "Las Malvinas", its an insult to the people living there..you put some thought into your article and it seems quite well written, i understand your reasoning in regards to calling them that..but that is not the name and they are not referred to as "Las Malvina'ers". Just referring to the islands as that is liable to get many a back up and have you painted as being on "their side", them being Argentinians who want to invade the islands again
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
15:08 on 22/02/2012
This is the most sensible and well-written feature I've read on the Falklands.

3,000 people have had a community there that dates back 200 years. Before that the islands were uninhabited. What could be more logical or reasonable than letting the people who live there decide their fate?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GingerlyColors
No will to change it, no right to criticize it
07:13 on 22/02/2012
When you consider that the climate in the Falkland Islands is similar to that of the Shetlands, how many Argentinians will be prepared to give up life in sunny Buenos Aires and move to a place where it is cold, wet and rainy for most of the year?
21:59 on 21/02/2012
Please do not refer to our homeland as being Las malvinas, we live in the FALKLAND ISLANDS.
Apart from that I quite like the tone of yoyur article and the humour with which you view the argentine situation.
08:12 on 22/02/2012
Thank you for you kind comments. The use of Las Malvinas was in the context of the Argentinian perspective and no offence was meant.
18:51 on 21/02/2012
Yes, the Islands are a colonial outpost. So what? They have been British for too long to challenge British control. The Islands are British.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uksnapper
15:06 on 21/02/2012
Argentina declared independence from Spain in 1816, and the first constitution was established in 1853.

Lt Richard Moody was the first British Lieutenant Governor of the Falkland Islands. He sailed to the Falkland Islands arriving in Anson's Harbour in October 1841. He was accompanied by twelve sappers and miners and their families, which,together with Whittington's colonists, this brought the population of Anson's Harbour to approximately 50.
So colonisation of the Falkland islands pre-dates the formation of Argentina.
The Spanish and the French have also laid claim to the islands in the last 500 years
13:20 on 21/02/2012
It's these 3,000 people whose fate is being decided by the finer points of international law and diplomacy and yet they only appear as the faceless child of divorcing parents.
----------------------
Both parents are British. The Tory government which I dislike is doing the simplest and best thing going on about self-determination. If we were France, China, Russia or the States the Falkland Isles would be annexed and that would be it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
McMarcia
06:31 on 21/02/2012
To follow up on my first post...

The Argentines need to make themselves more attractive to the islanders, so they will want to join them in the future. Clean up the corruption, reign in the inflation, stop calling the islanders "kelpers", conquerers, etc, and instead just call them "islanderos". President Fernandez cannot talk out of both sides of her mouth - calling them bad names, and then saying they will be treated like normal Argentines (who at the moment are not treated very well by their government).

Set up a 100 year detente treaty with the Brits - agree to revisit the issue in 100 years, and get on with trading, and rebuilding the Argentine economy. The Argentines are just going to have to accept that the 1982 war caused a lot of trauma, and it doesn't matter if they are democratic today - the islanders don't trust them. It's no different than Germany after 30 years - the Poles, French, Brits, Czechs, Slovaks, Russians, etc still don't trust them. The trauma will continue for many generations.
13:22 on 21/02/2012
It's no different than Germany after 30 years - the Poles, French, Brits, Czechs, Slovaks, Russians, etc still don't trust them. The trauma will continue for many generations.
---------------------------------------------
That would be sixty five years. Not 30.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
McMarcia
02:56 on 22/02/2012
I meant Germany 30 years after the war ended (1975) was still mistrusted by the border countries. Just so for Argentina 30 years after the Falklands war.
22:00 on 21/02/2012
Doesnt matter how attractive the argentines make themselves we will never want to join them.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
McMarcia
06:30 on 21/02/2012
I was in Argentina in 2010 and the population is split 50/50 on the issue. Half don't care, and feel like the 1982 war was a waste of lives and money, and half care very much, and can't think of the islands as anything but Argentine.

I will say that as an American abroad, it's a pretty strange concept to listen to Argentines act as the "injured" party. I listened to all these people with European surnames tell me their reasons, but really, it's just one set of European invader descendants having a whine overland that another group of European invader descendants.

Europeans and their children were planting flags, and upending each other's flags and settlements all over the world in the late 1700's and early 1800's. The Euro-Argentines had a 5 year settlement with a military component that was upended in 1832 (not by the Brits as they've been lead to believe, but by the USS Lexington, BTW, trying to protect American commercial interests).

But that happened all over the place, the Americans uprouted the French forts, the British burned down the White House, the list could go on a very long while. The Russians claimed British Columbia around the same time period, but the Canadians are't about to give it back now.

My advice to the Argentines is to act more like Canadians. If the Falklanders had to pick an American continental government right now, they'd probably pick Canada!
13:23 on 21/02/2012
When Brits took Falklands they were free of human habitation. When Argentinean/Spanish took Argentina, they committed genocide right through Patagonia.
photo
AlanDente
Noses: made to hold glasses
22:24 on 21/02/2012
You don't hear Sean Penn banging on about that, strangely enough...
03:10 on 21/02/2012
reaching out to average argentine a great idea.
00:52 on 21/02/2012
"Perhaps it's time for the residents of the Las Malvinas...."

Good luck finding that resident who calls them La Malvinas, going to be a long hard search.
22:01 on 21/02/2012
How right you are, we will never call them the Malvinas whilst we have breath in our bodies.
08:07 on 22/02/2012
No offence meant, the context of the sentence was about communication with the Argentinians so I knowingly adopted their term for the Island.