11/07/2013 15:23 BST | Updated 22/05/2015 06:12 BST

Masterpiece Or Disasterpiece? Sarah Jessica Parker's Carnegie Hall Dress

sarah jessica parker

Who? Actress Sarah Jessica Parker

What? So okay, it's a nice dress. But on SJP it's doing odd things to her proportions. It also feels more like what would happen if a maxi sundress had a torrid affair with a ballgown - their sartorial baby would be this business with a tight bodice, drapey skirt and a casual print. It's more the sort of thing you'd wear to an early evening movie premiere in the California sunshine, perhaps. The necklace also seems far too heavy for the laidback vibe from the dress.

What about you guys? Are you fans?

Where? Carnegie Hall 2012-2013 Season opening night gala at Carnegie Hall on 3 October, 2012 in New York City.