Universities Could Face Fines Over 'Failures To Protect Free Speech'

'No-platforming' is stifling debate on campus, says universities minister Jo Johnson.
<strong>Universities minister Jo Johnson will warn against 'no-platforming' on campus</strong>
Universities minister Jo Johnson will warn against 'no-platforming' on campus
PA Archive/PA Images

Universities must be places that “open minds, not close them”, Jo Johnson will warn during a speech in Birmingham today.

Students must be able to challenge controversial opinions, according to the universities minister, who says there are dangers to shielding students from differing views under the banner of “no-platforming” or “safe spaces”.

Under government plans, universities that fail to protect free speech could face fines.

The Press Association reported that in a speech later today at the Limmud Festival, a celebration of Jewish learning and culture, Johnson will argue that free speech is a key part of university life.

“Universities should be places that open minds, not close them, where ideas can be freely challenged,” he will say.

“In universities in America and worryingly in the UK, we have seen examples of groups seeking to stifle those who do not agree with them.

“We must not allow this to happen. Young people should have the resilience and confidence to challenge controversial opinions and take part in open, frank and rigorous discussions. That is why the new regulator, the Office for Students, will go even further to ensure that universities promote freedom of speech within the law.”

<strong>Universities which fail to protect free speech could face fines under new government rules </strong>
Universities which fail to protect free speech could face fines under new government rules
PA Wire/PA Images

His comments come amid an ongoing debate about free speech at universities, and a number of reports of speakers, debates, literature and organisations being opposed or criticised, often by student unions, societies or particular groups of students.

Johnson will also say that institutions must ensure there is no place for hatred, discrimination, extremism or racism.

“A racist or anti-Semitic environment is by definition an illiberal one that is completely in opposition the liberal tradition of our universities,” he will tell the festival.

Institutions must ensure that students can take part in ”rigorous, open debate”, or risk action from the new higher education watchdog, the Office for Students, ministers announced in October.

The proposals, which are open for consultation, could also see universities facing action including suspension and deregulation, if they do not protect free speech.

“No-platforming” is a practice in which a group or individuals seen to have unacceptable or offensive views are banned from taking part in a public debate or meeting, while “safe space” policies aim to ensure all students feel able to express themselves and are protected from views and language they find offensive, as well as discrimination.

But there are concerns that these policies are increasingly affecting free speech, and are being used to prevent speakers and discussions that some find uncomfortable or disagreeable.