Baha Mousa Inquiry: Army To Be Cleared Of Systemic Torture During Iraq War

Baha Mousa Iraq

First Posted: 28/08/11 08:58 Updated: 27/10/11 11:12

PRESS ASSOCIATION -- An independent report into how a hotel worker died while being held in British custody in Iraq will clear the Army of systematic torture and mistreatment, according to The Sunday Telegraph.

But the document will criticise the conduct of individual soldiers and highlight "numerous failures" in the Army's chain of command, the newspaper says.

The official findings of the three-year inquiry into the brutal death of Iraqi civilian Baha Mousa and the abuse of nine other Iraqi men detained with him are expected to be released on September 8.

Father-of-two Mr Mousa, 26, sustained 93 injuries while being held by 1st Battalion the Queen's Lancashire Regiment (1QLR) in Basra, southern Iraq, in 2003.

The judge-led inquiry, chaired by Sir William Gage, was ordered in 2008 and became the biggest examination of military conduct in the aftermath of the Iraq invasion.

It heard oral evidence from 247 witnesses over 115 days of hearings between July 2009 and October 2010.

According to the Telegraph, the inquiry has found no evidence that British soldiers conducted wholesale abuse, torture and murder of suspected insurgents during the occupation of southern Iraq.

However, it will accuse former members of 1QLR of "closing ranks" and both senior officers and serving soldiers of a dereliction of duty.

The report will also criticise the nature of the original investigation into how Mr Mousa died, according to the newspaper.

Mr Mousa was working as a receptionist at the Ibn Al Haitham hotel in Basra when it was raided by British forces in the early hours of September 14 2003.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

PRESS ASSOCIATION -- An independent report into how a hotel worker died while being held in British custody in Iraq will clear the Army of systematic torture and mistreatment, according to The Sunday ...
PRESS ASSOCIATION -- An independent report into how a hotel worker died while being held in British custody in Iraq will clear the Army of systematic torture and mistreatment, according to The Sunday ...
Filed by Dina Rickman  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:57 on 29/08/2011
Firstly, it's no surprise that an inquiry came out with a PR-friendly outcome; that's what inquiries are set up to do, and it's understandable from a national security perspective.

However, as a few posters have pointed out, they've performed a little trick here. Their focus was directed to whether there was SYSTEMIC abuse - whether it had been ordered or encouraged.

What was actually alleged was that the Baha Moussa case suggested torture was TOLERATED - the military 'turned a blind-eye', or knowingly took few measures to prevent torture.

In the case of Baha Moussa, it was an innocent civilian tortured to death. The fact that the military weren't specifically ordering torture is of little comfort.
06:06 on 29/08/2011
The report will clear the army of “systematic torture and mistreatmentâ€, which does not answer the question of how Mr Mousa who suffered 93 injuries died in Brit Army custody.
20:34 on 28/08/2011
I hate spell check too.
20:33 on 28/08/2011
I disagree with the idea that Britain lost honor and respect around the world. This new war an tr.ror is against an enemy who will do anything, and I mean anything, to achieve its goals. With all of that, there were a few issolated incidents of abuse by British soldiers. In war things happen, but Britain fought this war honorably. Don't let what a very small number of soldiers did cause you to label the entire British force as dishonorable, and something to be ashamed of.
photo
bocajane
will post for badges!
21:09 on 28/08/2011
The so called 'War on Terror' was nothing to do with Iraq. Iraq was invaded for it's oil reserves and nothing more, under the pretext that they has weapons of mass destruction, which was a lie and the Gov't knew it when they told it. 90% of the people killed in the Iraq war have been innocent civilians. Approximately 2,000,000 have died. You talk about the soldiers as if they are heroes - they are trained killers - trained murderers. And you talk about them in such a calm and removed way. This man had a wife and children - where is your humanity?

You sound like something left over from British Colonialism.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JPETERB
19:12 on 28/08/2011
With all the private for-profit contractors and their ex-US military employees with massive amounts of US bought weapons of all types, it is no surprise the abuse of the people of Iraq was a retail operation and that Iraq became a well traded commodity on the world market. War is a profitable business that only succeeds when mostly innocent people die and mostly rich people profit and plans are made so that no murder or theft charges are ever brought.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sillyfrog
Pastafarian UU student
14:35 on 28/08/2011
So the military investigated itself?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
18:30 on 28/08/2011
"... An independent report into how a hotel worker died while being held in British custody in Iraq will clear the Army of systematic torture and mistreatment, according to The Sunday Telegraph...."

I suggest that 'independent' probably means 'independent'.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sillyfrog
Pastafarian UU student
19:12 on 28/08/2011
I doubt there was any independe­ntcy at all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sillyfrog
Pastafarian UU student
19:15 on 28/08/2011
I hate spell check.
12:22 on 28/08/2011
I've always admired the Brits, sensible, determined and honorable.

Then Iraq....what in the world were you doing there, what did you gain?

More importantly though.......what did you lose?
14:34 on 28/08/2011
I'm afraid us brits lost the respect we once had around the world- we also came to a realisation that we are ill equipped to deal with military conflicts as we once we're, with such failures in southern Iraq and Afghanistan. I personally think we should also be ashamed to have been involved in a conflict that has resulted in the loss of so many innocent civilians lives through our own actions and those of the insurgents.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
16:37 on 28/08/2011
Sorry, mate, but the "British Empire" lost respect years ago. The sun set on it.
The Iraq war was proof positive of the petty egos and religious doorknobs that run the world...my country(Canada) included.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edward Lucie-Smith
Art historian, photographer, poet
16:24 on 28/08/2011
What we lost was honor.