Female Teachers Give Male Pupils Lower Marks, Claims Study

Female Marking

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 16/02/2012 12:02 Updated: 16/02/2012 12:02

Female teachers mark male pupils more harshly than they do their female students, research has claimed.

Additionally, girls tend to believe male teachers will look upon them more favourably than female teaching staff, but men treat all students the same, regardless of gender.

The study, released on Thursday, told 1,200 students in 29 schools to place financial bets on who would give them higher grades: external examiners or their teacher.

Conducted by professors Amine Ouazad and Lionel Page, for the London School of Economic's Centre for Economic Performance, the report said:

"Male students tend to bet less [money] when assessed by a female teacher than by an external examiner or by a male teacher. This is consistent with female teachers' grading practices; female teachers give lower grades to male students.

"Female students bet more when assessed by a male teacher than when assessed by an external examiner or a female teacher. Female students' behavior is not consistent with male teachers' grading practices, since male teachers tend to reward male students more than female students."

Additionally, the results showed the students' beliefs tended to increase the gender gap in investment and effort. Having a male teacher increased the efforts of female students whereas a female teacher lowered the efforts of boys.

But, more encouragingly, the study found no significant evidence of ethnic discrimination.

"Our results suggest that students from low-income families and minority ethnic backgrounds do not believe in systematic teacher biases. This result is significant given that in some countries, including the United States, studies have found that minority students state beliefs in detrimental teacher biases."

Professor Smithers said: "It is fascinating research. It does stress the importance of independent marking for high-status examinations."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Female teachers mark male pupils more harshly than they do their female students, research has claimed. Additionally, girls tend to believe male teachers will look upon them more favourably than fe...
Female teachers mark male pupils more harshly than they do their female students, research has claimed. Additionally, girls tend to believe male teachers will look upon them more favourably than fe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 46
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WillistonElkoAlum2002
Strongly favor abortion rights & less government.
07:02 on 10/05/2013
Blatant discrimination against boys by female teachers. I'm disgusted. They should know better. THIS is why the far right are busting their unions here in the States.
20:55 on 11/05/2013
Williston, it's been happening in reverse for hundreds and hundreds of years!!! Including allowing girls to attend school!!! Where was your voice then??!?!? ( I know I know - it's a figure of speech).
This comment has been removed.
20:24 on 08/05/2013
The extent to which feminism encourages male resentment in women is something we should take seriously. If we tolerate bigotry against males we will see more of it. Women are only human and they too can engage in negative bias. Arguing that male dominance precludes men becoming victims of sexist men or women ignores the very real power that women do have in our society. For example in America they are half the managers.

We need to discourage the use of anti male bigotry in our discussions on gender and failing to do that has allowed bigots to rationalize their hatred of men and boys. In addition we need to encourage greater compassion for men and boys, particularly victims of sexual abuse and violence. There are many and we too often ignore them.
20:25 on 13/05/2013
We are all just different colored crayons trying to live in the same box. Embrace and learn from differences.
18:40 on 21/03/2013
PROOF that women are NOT the reason for marriage break ups!!!

http://dailycaller.com/2012/02/06/lesbian-divorce-shocker

Oh, sorry,,, women ARE the cause for more "couple" break ups!

Never mind, it can't be true, women are never "responsible" for break ups!
18:10 on 21/03/2013
How can there be a war on women when women are the teachers,,, Feminization of the male species is where the war is!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
06:41 on 13/03/2013
I wonder if the marking is linked to behaviour within the classroom?
08:58 on 08/05/2013
Yes, it's quite possible systematic discrimination will make you more inclined to be unruly in the classroom.
04:43 on 13/03/2013
Essays should be marked using the outline of the essay for the number of ideas (and the quality/creativity, depending on the subject). Then, the essay or story should be scored for style, grammar, spelling, mechanics, ...
04:59 on 12/02/2013
Excellent article, but I would like to have seen some of the actual numbers with regards to how teachers marked the different sexes.
18:30 on 21/03/2013
Ever hear of Google??
19:47 on 24/01/2013
LOL. I feel sorry for the authors of this research. Feminists will employ a take no prisoners approach to vilify, discredit, and silence them.
photo
LiberalOutlaw
Yes I am and NO you can't watch
21:11 on 02/01/2013
So why do people enjoy bickering with me when I assert that there NEEDS to be girls only schools staffed with female teachers and a female administration.

Of course there can also be all boy public schools staffed with male teachers.

Then we will see which ones outperform the others. ;)
23:38 on 23/11/2012
Well, we all know that the Patriarchy oppresses women. So, I guess those female teachers have a right to "get even" by making those little boys feel the heat for a change . . .eh? (Yes, yes, that was sarcasm!)
05:49 on 15/12/2012
Our society has been corrupted by Feminism Dogma (Feminism Lies) and the "Feminist" Domestic Violence Industry Evil Indoctrination.

The Problem - The Root of the Problem - I came to understand - is Lack of Moral Values.
20:28 on 08/05/2013
We should demand principled equity feminism rather than the hate em to beat em variety that has become popular. Until then men need to stand up for themselves. They are people and they need compassion for each other. There are far too many men competing to see who can throw men and boys under the bus first.
23:06 on 22/11/2012
Men are biased towards women, women are highly biased towards women.
STUDY:Gender differences in automatic in-group bias: why do women like women more than men like men?
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15491274
Also see:
https://news.uns.purdue.edu/html4ever/2004/041213.Goodwin.gender.html
http://www.apa.org/monitor/dec04/women.aspx
17:00 on 23/02/2012
If this is suggesting that female teachers penalise biys in their marking, yet external examiners don't, why are there still so many subjects which largely consist of external exams where girls out perform boys?
20:33 on 22/11/2012
By the time you get to the exam the negative effects of the bias have taken their toll. As it says in the article "boys lower their performance with female teachers".
23:03 on 22/11/2012
Are you serious?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TeamSanity
strong emotions don't equate strong arguments
09:06 on 22/02/2012
If the presence of "a female teacher lower[s] the efforts of boys" wouldn't it be logical that those male students would receive poorer grades than their counterparts?
20:31 on 22/11/2012
They probably controlled for that. ;) Multiple teachers probably graded every assignment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
delbridgebaird
06:58 on 22/02/2012
With the sexist behavior of women being reported now this doesn't surprise me; I wish it did.