Lord Willoughby Condemned For Comparing German EU Policy To Holocaust

Auschwitz

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 17/02/2012 10:07 Updated: 17/02/2012 10:17

A member of the House of Lords has been criticised for comparing German economic policy to the Holocaust.

Speaking during a parliamentary debate on the European Union on Thursday afternoon, Ukip peer Lord Willoughby de Broke said the poorer southern states had been failed by the single currency and the "political adventure of the EU".

"Europe has turned into a weapon of mass economic destruction," he said.

"What is the remedy prescribed by the EU leeches? he said. "It is to take more blood in the form of more wage cuts, more unemployment, lower pensions. 'Austerity macht frei' seems to be the remedy prescribed by the Germans, certainly to Greece and to the rest of the "Club Med" members of the eurozone when they are unable to meet the German requisites."

The Nazi concentration camp of Auschwitz displayed the phrase "arbeit macht frei", meaning "work sets you free", on its gates.

The sign can still be seen at the site of the camp as a reminder of the estimated one million people who died there.

Lord Willoughby's comments were attacked by Lib Dem peer Lord Teverson.

"Can I just say that I find that remark offensive because it likens German economic policy, however wrong we may agree it is, to a camp that practised genocide? I think that that is utterly inappropriate," he said.

However the Ukip peer refused to back down, telling peers that he thought the Nazi comparison was appropriate.

"The fact is that the German Finance Minister, Herr Schaeuble, is recommending more and more pain to be inflicted on Greece regardless of the fact that it is going to do the Greek population and Greece's economy no good at all. That is what austerity is leading to," he said.

"That is why I used that expression. He is saying that more austerity will bring you free-austerity macht frei. I repeat that."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

A member of the House of Lords has been criticised for comparing German economic policy to the Holocaust. Speaking during a parliamentary debate on the European Union on Thursday afternoon, Ukip p...
A member of the House of Lords has been criticised for comparing German economic policy to the Holocaust. Speaking during a parliamentary debate on the European Union on Thursday afternoon, Ukip p...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:46 PM on 02/18/2012
Way over the top Lord Willoughby. You do your argument no justice by tasteless comparisons wth the holocaust and you miss the point anyway. "Club Med" has been swindling those fools in the EU for years. It is now payback time.
northern git
fed up with all the political crap in life
02:12 PM on 02/19/2012
perhaps he was thinking about a the third reich that wanted to control everything but used violence as their means to an end

he may have thought this as a potential Fourth reich,

well they are the super power financially in Europe
northern git
fed up with all the political crap in life
09:21 PM on 02/19/2012
just who has been fooling who?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
stephan67
Eternity and a day
07:23 AM on 02/18/2012
The Germans promote their interests through Euro. All southern European countries are in ruins, because the overrated Euro has destroyed their exports . Italy was 20 years ago one of the richest countries in the world,and now is struggling to survive. Germany found a big market to sell its products,and southern European countries lost the opportunity to export cheap products.
09:24 PM on 02/17/2012
In the hills of Greece there are the graves of many a German soldier from World War 2.

Lord Willougby is exactly correct here. I know nothing of him except this and this is true.

What is the point of punishing Greece for being terrible at international and national finance? Hey lets do Italy, Spain, Portugal and Ireland next. Seems a bit like a takeover. I have friends in Germany and they do not like this either.

Many in Germany do not want to be the "leaders" of Europe because that has a Third Reich flavor to it. Europe need not bail out Greece just let them go and get the Drachma back and see what they can do on their outside the stupid EU.

The Eu should never had a unified currency and all that. The common market and the original EU were more modest in scope and Greece was OK in that.

The big plans for the EU were forced down the various national peoples throats by the economic forces that are now wrecking Europe and America. Watch out England they will come for you later on. Lord Willoughby has foresight. It is an apt comparison and if things go badly it could in fact lead to very dire events.

Do not condemn this man.
10:41 PM on 02/17/2012
I could not agree more.
It is very sad indeed, when entire cultures have been pillaged by outside banking forces, seducing the greediest and vainest within a government.
The sovereign debt fiasco is now demolishing cultures as if they were nothing but ants.
That the so-called 'greek bailout' will actually be paying off all the banks, most of them foreign to Greece, with high interest, further impoverishing generations, is heart-breaking.
These same powers have been on a campaign to present the average Greek (and soon the average citizens of Ireland, Spain, Portugal...), who profited not one euro from this terrible economic attack on their very beings, as lazy and corrupt. It is difficult for people to hear the word 'innocent' -- but the average citizens of these countries are innocent. And now, they are asked to do the austerity crawl to pay for the sins of international bankers and hedge fund brokers. Ironically, the same people demanding every cent of the so-called bailout be given to satisfy outrageous interest rates on sovereign debt, are also 'betting against' Greece. So either way, they will win. I hope the people of Greece, the cradle of democracy, stand up for themselves, and are not taken in by those who say, if they return to the drachma, they will be impoverished and isolated forever. Sadly, but taking these 'bail outs', that is more than guaranteed.
08:20 PM on 02/17/2012
sad to say, he's got a point
the greek state, etc., were unsophisticated players in the bank schemes
and now
they are to become the serfs of europe
not a penny of the so-called greek bail-out goes to anything except to pay the bankers their interest
they should leave the eu and go off on their own
and reclaim their beautiful culture
that was not driven by mindless greed
05:30 PM on 02/17/2012
Spot on.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aroddo
02:51 PM on 02/17/2012
sooooo greeks shouldn't work because that would be the same as killing them?

ah well, it's just a brit talking about germany. nazi comparisons are practically mandatory for that lot.
sore winners ...
photo
rabidrightwatch
Green lefty & active environmentalist
11:13 AM on 02/17/2012
Lord Willoughby is a UKIP peer - what do you expect, common sense??

The comparison is utterly stupid, inaccurate and a scandal; every thinking person should be ashamed of Lord Willoughby.

He's purposely stirring the pot, and of course parrotting Nigel's nonsense, in order to foment racial divide and hatred to suit the UKIP on-horse party with its one-policy agenda.

Blinkered statements such as this undermine the many efforts of UK business to retain some sort of credibility in their largest marketplace, and every time such defamatory statements are made, British business potentially loses the opportunity to thrive & expand, which in turn supports and increases employment.

In a time of severe recession, which is about to get significantly worse, casually abusing & unnecessarily offending our near neighbours won't help the country as a whole to ride out the storm... quite the reverse, in fact...
10:37 AM on 02/17/2012
The Greekes approach appeared to be to have the rest of the EU beavering away and sending EU money to Greece to fund their well paid unproductive lifestyles. A bit like ancient Greece in fact where the salves did most of the labour - except the ancients were quite good at organising the Sate and building infrastructure - unlike their present day Greeks.
photo
philhellene
Far Left and Proud of It!
03:15 PM on 02/17/2012
" well paid unproducti­ve lifestyles"

Wrong! Some quotes from Forbes Magazine, The World's Hardest-Working Countries
Parmy Olson 05.21.08.

"South Koreans work the longest hours per year, on average, out of every other OECD member."

"Greece and Italy are also near the top, at No.s 2 and 8, respectively, because of their large number of self-employed citizens."

"South Korea's hard-working citizenry is not alone. Greece comes second in the OECD's rankings with 2,052 hours worked on average each year..."

But, heaven forbid, don't let facts get in the way of your racist remarks.
photo
philhellene
Far Left and Proud of It!
03:21 PM on 02/17/2012
Ah forbes ! that well knwon impartial commentator ! If the number of self employed people in both greece and Italy were meqasured by the income tax returns in the that country, where in these tables do you suppose they would be ? Last, second last ? Greece has the enviable dinstinction of being one of the few countries where the unemployed get an allowance to maintain thier swimming pools !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Quis Custodiet
Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes
10:22 AM on 02/17/2012
Considering Britain made its' wealth on leeching India, China, and Indonesia he should seriously consider shutting his mouth pronto. When an economic crisis comes there are only three ways out. Internal spending: fueled both by the government sector (dilution of currency or purchase of bonds) ;re-distribution of wages to the mass spenders (middle & lower classes); and austerity measures (higher pension ages, lower aggregate pensions etc).

As things stand right now Europe is caught in a welfare state trap. While the population living expectancy rises the balance sheets pertaining to retirement benefits expand geometrically when compared to projected tax revenues generated by the young. This is the main issue with an attempt to adopt the Western idea of nuclear family in an economic net which up until 20 years ago or so encouraged extended and multi-generational families.

Blaming Germany for this is ridiculous, considering that Britain, of all things, is one of the primary welfare states. Throw in the fact that the bulk of the Euro Zone deficit is being footed by the Germans, and we have a politician who should be resigning due to a show of epic stupidity.

Ironically; I don't see him calling for Europe to cut down on its infamous bureaucratic ball and chain. Then again, as he is a part of that weight, why should he...blame someone else, Eh?
This comment has been removed.
11:07 AM on 02/17/2012
It was said that the sun never sets on the British Empire. That said, the Dutch East Indies - or modern day Indonesia - was never part of that great empire and was never "leeched" by Britain.
Back to the history books or your schoolboy atlas where the East Indies was not coloured red.

CaptainIain
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Quis Custodiet
Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes
11:35 AM on 02/17/2012
Do some more research. The East India Trading Company was *very* much benefiting out of Indonesian economic activity. Perhaps it was not as direct as the "Gem in the Empire's Crown" but it was there.
This comment has been removed.