Caroline Frost
GET UPDATES FROM Caroline:

Television Review: '56 Up' Shamed What We Laughingly Call Reality TV

Posted: Updated: 16/05/2012 09:21

In 1964, Granada Television brought together a bunch of 7-year-olds, to discuss their dreams, their fears, their hopes for the future.

Nearly half a century later, it has become a unique social document, with the majority of the group agreeing to be interviewed and filmed once every seven years.

This must be a very strange occurrence for the subjects and the people they’re involved with… it’s a long enough gap for professional status, relationships and environments to be completely transformed (see Neil below), but not so long that people’s characters fundamentally change. And the people involved seem to have made their peace with the fact that they are essentially data in this grand experiment, of watching social survival in the 20th and 21st century.

Last night’s first episode of what is now, extraordinarily, 56 Up, concentrated on Sue, Paul and Neil.

Sue is still engaged to Glen, whom we first met in 49 Up, but in no rush to tie the knot again, following her divorce in her early 30’s. Work is an administrative job at London University, where she speaks to up to 500 students at a time. Recreation is local am-dram after a neighbour twisted her arm. “I’ll never be a rich pensioner,” she chuckled, “but as long as I can keep the house warm and we can feed ourselves, I’ll be fine.”

Paul, whom we first met living in care as a 7-year-old, moved to Australia as a schoolboy, and has been married to Susan for many years. The couple are happy grandparents and now work together as well, but Paul continues his battle with low self-esteem. “I can tell you how I feel about her, but I have difficulty telling her…”

There are financial challenges for the extended family, but the cameras found them travelling to the UK together, and still very much a functioning unit.

Sue, Paul and Neil through the years...

Loading Slideshow...
  • Sue with her friends in 7 Up. This slideshow shows 3 of the documentary series subjects - Sue, Paul and Neil - through the years. All pictures: ITV.

Away from the cartoon colours, fake tans and theatrics of the new paradigm “scripted reality” (shudder), the themes that ran through last night’s televisual log-book, were pretty much what you’d expect to find if you sat down long enough with anyone with any awareness and invited them to reflect on the state of their affairs: that, in the final tally, love is more important than money, that building foundations for your children is one of the most important purposes anyone can find for themselves, as Paul puts it, “teaching other people to care”, and that anyone who, by the age of 56, has health and a tiny bit of wealth is basically doing all right.

Perhaps because he lives beyond the confines of a long relationship and all the social buffers this provides, Neil may be best served to demonstrate this. It helps that he is the most reflective and articulate of all of the subjects, as well as being the one whose path has taken the widest turns from what one might consider normal, whatever that is.

Neil, a sweet-faced little 7-year-old, was the most heartbreaking of them all when, during his 30s, the documentary team found him living rough in Scotland. From his Shetland council estate, he reinvented himself completely, as a Liberal Democrat councillor in Hackney, and then in Cumbria, where we meet him now, continuing his council work, and working within the church.

This time around, he felt the need to set the record straight on his life. He remembered how many people watching the previous shows had felt moved to write to him, and tell him they knew how he felt. But, he said, “no one knows….”

He was obviously not interested in winning any kind of Cowell-sponsored popularity contest any time soon, nor in tapping in to some kind of TOWIE-led self-trumpeting fanfare that everything these days could, or should, go in front of the cameras to have meaning.

Neil’s writing, unpaid and unrewarded, feels more important to him than, for example, taking part in this documentary, and he reminds us too, “Maybe we’re at our happiest when we’re least aware of it…”

By shying away from the Twitter orgy of constant self-appraisal, congratulation and simply getting on with it, Neil and his fellow 56-ers have proved once again the difference between reality TV, and truth on the television.

56 Up continues next week on Monday at 9pm, ITV1.


FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT

In 1964, Granada Television brought together a bunch of 7-year-olds, to discuss their dreams, their fears, their hopes for the future. Nearly half a century later, it has become a unique social do...
In 1964, Granada Television brought together a bunch of 7-year-olds, to discuss their dreams, their fears, their hopes for the future. Nearly half a century later, it has become a unique social do...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 58
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
22:26 on 01/10/2012
I discovered this series several years ago and have watched all of them through 49 Up. Was 56 Up broadcast only in Great Britain? I haven't been able to find it on the web or on DVD in the states.Can anyone tell me if it is available for us in the US to watch?
22:26 on 16/05/2012
http://ppt.cc/9iT1
12:33 on 16/05/2012
I remember when we were shown this series as trainee youth and community workers in the early 1990's. I think it was supossed to get us to think on the famous speel of, ''give me the boy till he is 7 and i will give you the man'', thus the title 7 up. I think i remember writing an essay more or less saying things that happen in peoples lives after 7 would probably have more affect on a person's life than after and i'm still of that opinion.
20:23 on 16/05/2012
I think you miss the point of the quote - of course more things happen to you after you are seven and they can be of much greater significance but it is what happened to you BEFORE you are seven that impacts on how you cope with, and get through, these things. To put it another way - our ability to deal with what life throws at us after the age of seven is largly determined by what happened to us before we reached that age. My wife and I saw the original film while at teacher training college in the 70's (as part of our course) and never dreamed that the series would continue right through. Glad that it has though.
07:49 on 17/05/2012
Who marked the essay you think you remember writing ? - If it was me I`d have given you 3 /10 for spelling . The title 7 up referred to a soft drink popular at the time which we drank in prodigious quantities leading to our classic British Teeth .
10:59 on 16/05/2012
What is so interesting about it. The people who ooh and aah about it can just as easily observe people in their neighbourhood. This is pure voyeurism. And also just plain nosiness.
photo
ScottishScript
"I am not a number, I am a person!"
11:25 on 16/05/2012
I would bet good money you haven't even seen this show. It's always a good idea to stick to commenting on things you know because your comment clearly indicates you know nothing about this show.

In fact I bet you didn't fully read the article either..
02:47 on 17/05/2012
Go away
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
Might as well laugh while you still can.
10:14 on 16/05/2012
It's a great concept that I'm glad ITV hasn't gave up on. I'd get another going.
07:52 on 16/05/2012
I think this programme is fantastic. The people involved in this weeks series had my emotions all over the place Sue who has done so well for herself and has become a very grounded woman. Paul who seems happy with his lot but i felt for him with his insecurities still there and Niel who my heart goes out to. Looking at this man as a boy he was full of self confidence and to see him lacking now if confidence really touched me. I really hope all good things for Niel. The makers of this programme have given us some sensible interesting reality t.v at least.
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
20:32 on 15/05/2012
Even though I am a few years older than the subjects in this documentary- I wonder how many actually remember the first 7 up programme.
Many think they do because of the flashbacks to the original footage.
I know I could not have watched the first because there was no TV in our house until I was 16 yrs old.
I possibly watched some of 14 up. But as a young gadabout off out all the time when that was broadcast I doubt it.
So I probably only picked this up when the subjects got to be 21.
Fascinating series though.
Without the reminders of the earlier years and well edited presentation I would not be able to follow the progress or otherwise of the brave individuals who play the most important part.
20:55 on 15/05/2012
I watched the first three at school, then the rest on tv

seem to remember their were other episodes done in Russia & USA around the Millenium ??
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
21:06 on 15/05/2012
You went to school for 21 years?
Or was your school very proactive and showed the original three programmes on super 8? (Video players and DVD had not been invented then)
23:04 on 15/05/2012
i too watched it at schol and found the idea quite mind blowing at the time as i was at high school. watched these programmes and feel they have been a part of my growing up and a part of their lives as each programme is made. wish they would show 7 up so youngsters can see what a social divide in class there was and how it has got wider.
photo
Reality always bites
Sometimes just a bit peckish
23:17 on 15/05/2012
My point is that I did not see this while at school. I have followed the series since 21 Up, as circumstances and age would have prevented me from seeing the original programmes.
Most people who comment give the impression that they have seen the whole series from the start as they happened.
They would all have to be at least 65 years old and come from a privileged background to have had television when 7 up was first screened.
I an appreciative of the fact that some schools have actually used this series and shown copies of the original programmes as a learning aid.
Not sure about the social values the teachers have interpreted or instilled during discussion following the screnings.
07:55 on 17/05/2012
So right about the social division - but what do the Tories sing ? " Wider still and wider" a line from Land of hope and Glory .
20:15 on 15/05/2012
I am also of a similar age to the people in the documentary and can relate to their lives in many ways.
What a refreshing programme it has been. I have followed it since 7up and its the best thing on telly.Puts the wannabes to shame.
17:58 on 15/05/2012
reality show with no celebrities, brilliant, no that's what i call interesting tv.
17:49 on 15/05/2012
excellent and all involved should be commended, from participants to producers
17:02 on 15/05/2012
Absolutely right about this program compared with today's so-called reality TV. Let's face it, there is nothing "real" about most of the current shows. The main difference between them and 56UP I guess is that if the show were initiated today all those people taking part would be TV stars in the way that TOWIE and BGT contestants are, except of course 56UP's characters would be more endearing!
16:13 on 15/05/2012
I just love this programme, and have seen them all from 7Up. Can't believe it is seven years since the last one!
I admire the sublects for taking part, and being so candid,and it is really heatwarming to see haw they havfe turned out. The questioner could be better..but hey that's his style.
Lovely to see Paul so happy with his family in Australia, and who hand on heart would have said that of him when he was seven? neil is doing OK happy in his own way, and well done Sue, who has certainly found her niche.
look forward eagerly to the next programme.
16:11 on 15/05/2012
It was lovely remebering when people were real and children spoke from the heart.
15:05 on 15/05/2012
I watched this when it was 35 up and i was at school studying it in English. I liked it then and really felt for Neil and worried for him. Seeing him last night warmed my heart to know that, while his life has been less than perfect, he now seems to have found purpose and direction. I was incredibly moved last night by this programme and felt a little silly, but having read this today, i know i was not alone...
07:58 on 17/05/2012
You`re not alone - most of the posters here are a little silly . They don`t even know it !
14:54 on 15/05/2012
Absolutly love this documentry, because my husband and I are of the same age, its fasinating to see what how theyve grown into the people they are today. Enjoyable and moving, I cannot wait to see all of these episodes and the future.