Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Afroze Zaidi-Jivraj

GET UPDATES FROM Afroze Zaidi-Jivraj
 

Are Muslims Just Too Sensitive? Some Reflections after 'Citizen Khan' and 'Untold Story'

Posted: 02/09/2012 03:46

Anyone who watches television, or uses on-line social networks, will know that it has been a contentious week for British Muslims. From the BBC sitcom 'Citizen Khan', which piloted on bank holiday Monday, to Channel 4's 'Islam: The Untold Story' which was broadcast the following day, both Islam and Muslims have come under scrutiny in mainstream entertainment this week. This has given rise to the question- can British Muslims handle this scrutiny, or are they just too sensitive?

I have already discussed in detail the problems with Tom Holland's 'Islam: The Untold Story', which focused on Islam but inevitably affected Muslims with the Islamophobic backlash they received on Twitter and other on-line forums (after they complained on these forums about several significant shortcomings in Holland's approach). 'Citizen Khan' was not short of controversy either, as the BBC reportedly received over 200 complaints the day after the pilot for the sitcom was aired.

Personally, as a Muslim of Pakistani origin, I didn't find 'Citizen Khan' to be disrespectful towards Islam. I did, however, find that it enforced racial stereotypes of Pakistanis, and this is something I found more objectionable than anything else about the show - apart from the fact, of course, that it wasn't all that funny! I feel quite strongly, as do many others, that we cannot move on from racism and prejudice if we keep legitimising racist ideas by exploiting them for the purpose of entertainment. So I found it offensive on a human level. I didn't, however, find it offensive as a Muslim, which a few others seemed to have done. Yes, there are some questionable scenes filmed in a mosque, but that's not to say that nothing untoward ever takes place in our mosques. We live in a society where we have the liberty to discuss and despise the treatment of predatory priests towards choir boys in churches, and so we must be willing to accept that the institution of the mosque is not beyond reproach either.

It's important to make the distinction that this sitcom is ultimately a commentary on the Muslim community, not on Islam, and considering that it probably offers Muslims some much-needed food for thought. Mr. Khan should make us ask ourselves: what are our attitudes towards White converts? His daughter Aliya's character should make us consider: what are our youth really up to these days? And Mrs Khan should make us think: how much importance are we placing on ridiculous things such as gossip in the community? In that sense, Citizen K holds up a mirror to the Muslim community, and if we refuse to look into it, we are not only being arrogant but are proving right the claims of those who say that Muslims are an overly-sensitive, irrational lot who cannot handle any kind of criticism.

It was refreshing to see that a lot of the Pakistani/Muslim demographic on Twitter were in fact not offended by Citizen K at all - some found it funny, others grossly un-funny, but not so many were convinced of it being complaint-worthy. As someone pointed out, if they got several million viewers then a couple of hundred complaints isn't too bad. There were complaints about Tom Holland's documentary as well, but the number of complaints received remains unknown. In response to complaints for both, where on one hand the anti-Muslim bigots came out in all their glory, on the other we saw dogmatic secularists have a good old rant (again) about Muslims not being able to take criticism and not appreciating the importance of freedom of speech in a secular society.

All things considered, do we, as Muslims in the West, need to develop a thicker skin when it comes to our religious sensibilities? Probably; at least if we are to continue living harmoniously in a secular society. Does that mean we should stop speaking out against genuine misrepresentations of Islam or Muslims in the media? Absolutely not; after all, that's what freedom of speech is all about.

 
FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:30 PM on 09/11/2012
A very well written and thought provoking piece. When we rise above the low level bigotry and racism though would you not agree that one fundamental problem remains: that although Muslims are prepared to be teased or criticised, the one thing that they will not tolerate is criticism or questioning of Islam itself. Now this is true of the other great faiths also, but in Western countries we have fought very hard for the right to free speech and questioning and no longer hold anything exempt from it.
Or to take another example a commentator I read today on line dismissed the documentary citing the Qu'ran as proof that it must be wrong, but the secular, scientific mind does not accept sacred texts as proof. How, then, can even those of good will ever be reconciled on these matters?
01:31 AM on 09/05/2012
If I was going to locate quotes from Sikhs or hindus, or even 'indigenous white people' on any given matter from online forums, places like twitter/youtube, I could paint an entirely dramatic picture too. Like 'THOUSANDS OF WHITE PEOPLE ARE GOING MENTAL RIGHT NOW' with proof from youtube comments. Pathetic journalism (not you, but you ought to at least highlight what I have or at least realise it).
10:53 AM on 09/05/2012
I do realise it; the point of this post was not to look at the content of people's comments but the overall attitude towards criticism of Muslims. As a Muslim, I don't take unfair or imbalanced criticism of Islam lightly, but I do think Muslims need to be objective about the shortcomings within their own communities.

This post is a general comment. Picking out specific tweets or youtube comments (I'm guessing, though not entirely clear, that this is what you're suggesting I should have done) would make it seem like I'm trying to portray those responses as a representation of the overall British Muslim opinion on the subject, which was not my aim and would not, in my opinion, be an objective way of discussing the issue.
04:59 PM on 09/03/2012
Continued....

If these and many issues are addressed then sitcoms like Citizen Khan won’t be able to stereotype them.

In my opinion (Having lived in the most segregated community in Britain for over twenty years) This show has little to do with Muslims and more to do with the 1st and 2nd Generation Sub Asian Culture. It’s good to see that the country I am proud to be a part of is now showing programmes that depict the true multi-cultural and multi-faith society. The people who are attacking Citizen Khan should not be attacking the TV programme itself (as surely they used a different book and not the Quran), but should really be looking at how to stop these sort of actions really happening by educating their children and themselves values such as; living a proper Islamic life, understanding that Muslims are not only Pakistanis and that they come in all different colours and sizes and the fact that these norms from the good old days need to change.

Finally, thank you BBC for putting in a tokenistic convert. This was a great touch, as most mosques across the country now have at least 1 – 10 converts attending the mosque regularly and should not be seen as outsiders in mosques by those Sub Asian’s who think they are better than them.

Well done and keep up with the good work.