Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Benjamin Ward

GET UPDATES FROM Benjamin Ward
 

Beyond Breivik, Hate in Europe Is on the Rise

Posted: 25/04/2012 00:00

With the eyes of the world on the Oslo district court, there are stark contrasts on display. The twisted and hate-filled logic of Anders Breivik contrasts with the calm, dignified and above all fair criminal process against him.

There are contrasts too between the shocking terrorist atrocities he is charged with and the response of Norway and its people: no emergency measures, no hysteria, just a reaffirmation of the fundamental importance of human rights and the rule of law.

The rest of Europe could learn a lot from Norway's response. In the decade that followed the 9/11 attacks in the United States, some countries in Europe, including the UK and France, relied on draconian powers to combat terrorism, bypassing the criminal justice system through the use administrative detention and deportation to countries with poor records on torture. Others, including Poland, Romania and Lithuania, cooperated with the CIA on the illegal transfer, detention and torture of terrorism suspects.

The United States which is trying terrorism suspects using unfair "military commissions" could also learn from Norway. Despite his desire, like many terrorists, to be treated as a warrior, Breivik is rightly being prosecuted as an ordinary criminal.

The lessons from the Breivik case for Europe go beyond the fight against terrorism.

It may be comforting to see Breivik as a lone madman whose actions were an isolated event. But the reality is that hatred and intolerance are growing in Europe today. Three trends stand out.

First, in many European countries, populist, anti-Muslim, anti-Roma, and anti-immigrant extremist parties are now a prominent part of the political landscape.

The National Front secured almost 18 percent of the vote in the April 22 first round presidential elections in France. The Freedom Party withdrew its support from ruling coalition in the Netherlands on April 23 causing it to collapse. Until recently, extremist parties were also part of government coalitions in Italy and Switzerland. Similar parties have made significant gains in Denmark, Sweden, and Finland, and had electoral success in the 2009 European Parliament elections in Hungary, the UK, and elsewhere. An extremist party looks poised to enter the Greek parliament in forthcoming elections.

A 2011 study from Chatham House, a research and policy organization, indicates that support for these parties is a long-term trend, which in many cases pre-dates the economic downturn. And far from neutralizing extremist parties, the response of mainstream parties has served instead to legitimize the extremists, sending a message to voters that xenophobic, anti-Muslim, or anti-Roma sentiment is acceptable rather than a cause for shame.

Second, intolerance toward foreigners, Muslims and other minorities is now common among Europeans. In polling data from 2010 by the Friedrich Ebert Foundation, half of those polled across eight EU states (including France, Germany and the UK) shared the view that there are too many immigrants, and more than 40 percent concluded the same about Muslims. Norway itself was criticized by the UN in 2011 for failing to tackle hate speech. Fears about loss of culture, terrorism, crime and competition all help explain rising intolerance in Europe.

Third, minorities and migrants encounter discrimination in housing, education and employment, as well as racist violence. Research by the EU Fundamental Rights Agency in 2009 demonstrates that Muslims and Roma experience persistent hostility and discrimination across the region. It also found that African migrants face significant problems, including discrimination and violence.

In a statement to the court this week, Breivik described members of a German Neo-Nazi gang who murdered nine migrants and a policewoman during a seven-year spree as "heroic young men." While individual attacks are the typical pattern in Europe, intolerance sometimes spills into mob violence, including attacks on migrants in Greece and Italy and on Roma in Italy, Hungary, the Czech Republic and Slovakia.

Countering extremist parties requires political leadership. Europe's leaders should stop aping extremists, offer a positive alternative vision to their counsel of hate, and forcefully condemn violence and discrimination against migrants and minorities rather than blaming them for crime and other social ills.

The criminal justice system and authorities should redouble their efforts to prevent and punish racist and xenophobic violence, and to enforce anti-discrimination laws. Hate speech should be robustly condemned, and prosecuted when it directly incites violence.

Europe's approach to integration also needs to change. With European leaders like Nicholas Sarkozy, Angela Merkel and David Cameron declaring multiculturalism a failure, integration policies focus more and more on assimilation. The immense contribution made by migrants in Europe over the last decades is forgotten or ignored.

Coercive integration policies requiring certain communities to shed fundamental aspects of their identity and treat the process as a one-way street are unlikely to succeed. Sustainable integration should instead aim at giving migrants a real stake in their new home and encourage participation rather than exclusion.

Because of the courage of the Norwegian people and its government, Breivik's efforts to change the country failed. Europe's people and governments need to find the same courage to tackle rising intolerance and hatred in Europe. If we fail, the damage to human rights and the rule of law will be incalculable.

 
 
 

Follow Benjamin Ward on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Benjamin_P_Ward

FOLLOW UK
With the eyes of the world on the Oslo district court, there are stark contrasts on display. The twisted and hate-filled logic of Anders Breivik contrasts with the calm, dignified and above all fair c...
With the eyes of the world on the Oslo district court, there are stark contrasts on display. The twisted and hate-filled logic of Anders Breivik contrasts with the calm, dignified and above all fair c...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 99
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:36 on 29/05/2012
"Sustainable integration should instead aim at giving migrants a real stake in their new home and encourage participation rather than exclusion."

True words, indeed. But there is a flipside to this sense of obligation. Immigrant communities need to be prepared to participate, and refuse to excuse those fundamentalists or traditionalists whose principles and lifestyle are antithetical to those of the host country. After all, rejection of honor killings, genital mutilation, forced marriage etc is not an indicator or racism or intolerance. These are the social norms of the country they have chosen to live in.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hugh Albert
Moderation in somethings
22:31 on 01/05/2012
The cure for fascism, of any hue, is education. Fascism/Communism has never worked over anything but the immediate short term: history bears witness to its myriad failures over any period beyond the immediate.
Before you deave my ears let me state immediately, China does not represent Communism: it is an unstable amalgam of capitalism and communism, with strong overtones of fascism. This system has been evolving at a rate of knots, and only the gods know where it will end up.
Similarly, but not identically, Russia, with it's Managed Democracy is evolving out of control.
We live in interesting times.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
13:54 on 26/04/2012
The cure for neo-Nazism, and people running around going on killing sprees etc., is life in prison. Doesn't matter which form the prosecution takes, so much as emphasis is placed on method and duration of incarceration. Concrete costs a lot less than having these people running around spreading more 'stuff'. Just you, your prison cell, and your copy of The Book. Then, you can Kampf yourself silly, and not present a problem to others.
photo
PermanentVacancy
Those who do not move, do not notice their chains.
23:19 on 26/04/2012
Who is going to decide whose thoughts are impure and whose thoughts are not? thats a slippery slope to Orwell's vision.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
the81kid
12:14 on 26/04/2012
Really?
Our armies and politicians kills thousands of civilians a year, sell weapons to and support dictators who oppress their own people.
And you're worried about a madman who the media love?!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:56 on 26/04/2012
At present, only non-western countries and Muslim cultures actions are being exclusively classified as 'Terrorism', while the actions of 'Judea-Christian' countries comes under the purview of 'Racism' and 'Xenophobia'.
All hate crimes should be treated equally and given the same terminology, else, the debate makes no sense at all.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
the81kid
12:14 on 26/04/2012
"terrorism" is just a political word.
civilians killed by our armies are... regrettable, collateral damage etc.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
15:05 on 26/04/2012
I don't agree with that, I think anytime you have small groups of people or individuals trying to bring the mayhem, it's pretty much still terrorism, doesn't matter which country, or on whose behalf, mad bomber's a mad bomber, doesn't matter if he's wearing a scarf, ski mask, or a business suit. Now, given that we've seen this stuff in multiple countries around the world, is the media itself perhaps implicated, for popularizing it? 'Back in the day' there was Patty Hearst, and the SLA, and there's been a bunch of other little grouplets, and if you go through the video titles at the store, and the video game titles, heck, you could probably call half that stuff some kind of terrorism training material, and if you make a big enough hole in something, they put your picture on the front page of the paper. Wag The Dog? War, social chaos, violence, malcontents, puppeteers, and Nielsen ratings. Virtuosity...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
20:54 on 25/04/2012
"Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, 23, a former president of the Islamic Society at University College London, Abdulmutallab is the fourth president of a London student Islamic society to face terrorist charges in three years.
Security sources said that Islamist radicalisation was rife on university campuses, especially in London, and that college authorities had “a patchy record in facing up to the problem”. Previous anti-terrorist inquiries have uncovered evidence of extremists using political meetings and religious study circles to identify potential recruits."
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article6971098.ece

Discussion of extremism in Europe without addressing the phenomenon of Islamic radicalism cannot be taken seriously.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimbraid1
15:51 on 26/04/2012
Wise words Allegro
20:32 on 25/04/2012
This scoundrel Ward never stops to consider that maybe, just maybe, the Left could be wrong in supporting mass immigration into Europe--especially from dysfunctional, incompatible Muslim countries who still revel in their "golden age" which was at the expense of the Western World.

Sounds like a bad idea huh? No wonder there have been so many social conflicts.

When are european Leftists going to do some critical analysis of their own beliefs?
photo
Erikhuffpost
It's all about the precious bodily fluids
19:30 on 25/04/2012
The responses to this article painfully illustrates 95% of Homo Sapiens is either dumb, criminal or both.
20:33 on 25/04/2012
Where do you fall within that 95% if you can't or won't take the time to elaborate?
photo
Erikhuffpost
It's all about the precious bodily fluids
21:11 on 25/04/2012
If I say 95% of Homo Sapiens is either dumb, criminal or both, it would follow to be most likely I'm part of that very 95%.

Few of us realize that we have eminated from an environmental disaster that struck Earth some 65 million years ago. Even fewer of us seem to realize we only have one planet to live on, and that we are headed for a global environmental disaster that may well wipe out human civilization as we know it. There is nowhere else, at least in the near future, to which we could migrate.

Moreover, we still cling to instincts we inherited from our forebearers that lived in the trees. So, basically, we are dumb.

Nevertheless, we also cling to the idea we are enlightened, intelligent, and rational, and that these attributes allow us to commit rape, mass murder, enslavement of our fellow species. Thus, if it is granted crime is any activity that influences another person's life in a negative way, we are criminal.

It is the remaining 5% of us that is truely dangerous. They are the Machiavellists, beating the drums of superiority of race, creed, colour, culture or whatever.

The majority of us never realize human history is hardly ever used as a learning tool, but constantly adapted to suit our purposes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
21:11 on 25/04/2012
Naturally, Erikhuff places himself in enlightened, intelligent elite-- the natural stance of quasi-educated.
photo
Erikhuffpost
It's all about the precious bodily fluids
00:25 on 26/04/2012
Ad hominem
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cory Gudwin
examine thyself before blaming the system
17:20 on 25/04/2012
Antisemitism has certainly increased among the Far Left in both the UK and Europe.
My view is this has very little to do with love for the Palestinians.
Belief in secretive Jewish control of things has never died .
It is pure bigotry now, same as it ever was.
Only difference is that today few Leftists will freely admit that they dislike Jews.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deluk
disgusted.
18:07 on 25/04/2012
nonsense, most people in the UK wouldn't know if someone was a Jew, if one landed on them from the sky, even less would they care.

Britain has more Jews in it's government and legislature than any nation outside of Israel, and we elected an ethnically Jewish prime minister in the 19th century, something that would still be impossible in the USA and it's the USA where "Belief in secretive Jewish control of things has never died".

Basically Britons just don't care about ethnicity/religion, whereas Americans are absolutely obsessed by these things.

Too much projection both in the article and your comment
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deluk
disgusted.
18:18 on 25/04/2012
adds, people dislike Israel, NOT because it's a Jewish state, bit because it's a European state transplanted to the Middle East, they feel disappointed in it, as if it's let us all down, we expect better.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
19:27 on 25/04/2012
re."Basically Britons just don't care about ethnicity/religion,"

Unfortunately the reverse is true of British Muslims.

And that's a serious problem for British society.

According to many polls,including Pew International and Gallup, overwhelming majority of British Muslims consider their religious identity as primary determinant.

"When f asked whether they consider themselves Muslim first or British first, the vast majority (81 per cent) said Muslim first--- Pew Global Attitudes Survey
18:45 on 25/04/2012
Rubbish! Even when the ADL tried desperately to find it in their recent poll they couldn't come up with an increase beyond their own margin of error. In other words none.

But it's telling that you automatically go for the Palestinian issue because the one thing Europeans are is more critical of Israel's policies, and that's the REAL reason Zionists are increasingly desperate to invoke the ghost of anti-semitism past - they don't want scrutiny of the Zionist State.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
17:06 on 25/04/2012
It the people, not the politician who witness firsthand the utter havoc unlimited asylum laws and mulch-cultural policies have wrecked on European economies and societies.
It is UNACCEPTABLE that a European politician like Wilders now needs a 24- armed protection and unable to walk the streets of his own city.
It is UNACCEPTABLE that a European cartoonists now need hiding rooms and armed protection.
NO to failed multiculturalism.
YES to policies of assimilation
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
17:01 on 25/04/2012
"European leaders like Nicholas Sarkozy, Angela Merkel and David Cameron declaring multiculturalism a failure, integration policies focus more and more on assimilation."

Amazing! Now multiculturalists attempt to blame politicians for failure of multi-culti
doctrines!!
Reality: Majority of Europeans agree that multicultural approach has failed and failed utterly.
And not coincidentally they now elect leaders who oppose multicultural doctrines.
This comment has been removed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
16:40 on 25/04/2012
U.S. treats Americans arrested in U.S. as criminals. Just like in Norway.
Therefore the main premise of the article is fallacious.
The debate in U.S. is how to treat foreign combatants or those caught on foreign battlefields
My option is to follow Geneva and Hague convention and to classify them as POWs and hold them indefinitely without trail ( as per Geneva Convention).
14:49 on 25/04/2012
Immigration has been replaced with colonisation that's the real problem
photo
PermanentVacancy
Those who do not move, do not notice their chains.
18:52 on 25/04/2012
I think u hit the nail on the head. Although it takes several generations for an immigrant community to assimulate. When u go to south florida and you have the next generation still fluently speaking the old language and not comprehending the language of their country of birth then u have a problem.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
19:51 on 25/04/2012
"t takes several generations for an immigrant community to assimulate."

Not in Europe. the European-born generation of Muslim youth displays an alarmingly high rate of radicalism. Far in excess of their parents because they lack first-hand experience of the Islamic paradises their immigrant parents escaped from.
This comment has been removed.
14:11 on 25/04/2012
Neo Nazis like Breivik are an extremely tiny majority in most European countries, certainly in Western Europe.
The biggest hate groups in the West are Islamist extremists, with their attacks on Jews, gays and women who don't dress the way they want. They are the most dangerous group because they are growing and finding no opposition from governments and from human rights organizations who should be stopping their expansion instead of picturing them as victims of discrimination.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
15:20 on 25/04/2012
Not only don't they find opposition, but they find the welcoming embrace of leftists who defend them
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
15:29 on 25/04/2012
No sane person (left or right) would welcome religious extreamists I'm sure...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
15:32 on 25/04/2012
It's hard to gauge the size of 'hate groups' but it's certain that Islamic extreamism is more visible via the media (or was until Brevik came along). Not the same as being the biggest.

Human Rights organisations are unlikey to defend extreamists of any relegion - I think you may be referring to groups such as 'Free Palestine'? In which case I agree with you - I will not support any Palestinian cause when they consider buses and schools as legitimate targets.