Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mary_McGill

GET UPDATES FROM Mary_McGill
 

Miley Cyrus and Cake Gate: Why We Can't Blame Child Stars for Growing Up

Posted: 29/01/2012 23:00

I do hope you're sitting down for this one, ladies and gentlemen, for it has come to pass once again: another child star is daring to grow up. Miley Cyrus aka Hannah Montana - she of the chipmunk cheeks and chirpy one-liners - is now fast approaching her twenties and all hell has, predictably, broken loose. Miley has acquired (deep breath) a steady boyfriend.

She has also (pass the smelling salts) taken to wearing revealing clothing and as if that wasn't enough to rouse Beelzebub from his tomb, last week 'shocking' pictures emerged of Miley being sexually suggestive with a phallic shaped birthday cake intended for her boyfriend. Imagine. Miley Cyrus has the ruddy cheek to behave exactly like anyone else her age.

The rush to condemn Miley was as predictable as it was utterly hysterical, as anyone who has ever watched an episode of Skins will testify. The fact that the pictures in question were taken at a private party and not meant for public consumption was all but ignored but then, why consider the rational when you're too busy pulling your hair out and stuffing it into your ears at the indecency of it all?

Beneath the outcry, the whole episode was a cautionary tale of trust, friendship and photographs in the digital age. The pictures of Miley and the infamous cake are no better or worse than what gets posted on the average young person's Facebook page but the leak of the pictures is a timely reminder of how quickly and easily someone's privacy can be violated online, a sobering reality most young people could do with being reminded of but why entertain that idea when you can run around the village squawking "off with Miley's head!"

Before we drown in an orgy of judgement, consider this: show me a 19-year-old who isn't up to some class of ribald behaviour and I'll show you a flying pig. It is right and proper that teenagers let off some steam before the responsibilities of adult life come crushing down. Will their antics horrify older generations? Absolutely and if they didn't, there would be something amiss.

Screaming blue murder about Miley Cyrus having the audacity to grow up, criticising her for doing what is typical for her age and demanding that she clean up her act is not only useless and unfair, it misses the point spectacularly since it is not Miley's job to parent anyone's children. The pictures of the offending cake were blurred on most news websites but ultimately, it is a parent's responsibility to monitor what their child is exposed to online or on TV. And if parents feel that certain material should not be so freely available they have every right make that clear to service providers and law makers.

The sad fact is this: there is little to admire in the entertainment industry. Most stars exist only to line the pockets of music, television and film industries that have turned them in global personalities. Sex and sexualised behaviour sells, particularly for young women trying to shake off the shackles of child stardom, which the rules of celebrity dictate that they do swiftly lest they end up on the fiery scrapheap of fame. Expecting celebrities to provide us with a moral compass is like waiting for it to rain penny sweets: delicious as it sounds, it ain't gonna happen.

Alas, young women like Miley (Britney, Lindsay et al) are in a bind: their popularity is built on a fan base comprising of children and some adults who demand they perform the impossible task of staying young and chaste forever. However, to maintain and expand their careers, they are expected to behave in a typically sexual way, which simultaneously opens up new markets and thrusts them under the microscope for increased scrutiny and criticism. Despite the obvious double standard, a young woman behaving badly is still judged much more harshly than her male counterpart, who is often indulged and rewarded for his efforts. If Miss Cyrus hasn't learnt this cruel and backward lesson yet, she soon will.

Hannah Montana, the show that made Miley Cyrus a global superstar, ended a year ago - isn't it time that people moved on and stopped treating Miley's ascent into adulthood as something shocking and filthy when it is in fact as normal as baked beans? To expect a young woman of 19 to still be the little girl she was at eleven is downright creepy. And for those of you who still buy into the idea of princesses in white dresses and pretty songs that glitter like trinkets, well, there's always Taylor Swift.

 

Follow Mary_McGill on Twitter: www.twitter.com/missmarymcgill

FOLLOW UK CELEBRITY
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
17:45 on 02/02/2012
Wasn't she wearing revealing clothes "shock , horror, " years ago. I seem to remember an outcry from parents whose kids watched Hannah Montana when she turned 16. Well maybe from just the mums.
20:37 on 30/01/2012
(Sorry if this posts a 2nd time, I wasn't logged in the 1st time) I actually made a video response to the entire Miley Cyrus cake scandal, and I think we agree on a lot of points. I said that Miley's at that "dumb college girl" phase where girls do a lot of silly things as part of growing up, and we aren't the ones to judge. http://youtu.be/AQmtixDCVqM
12:17 on 30/01/2012
Well if you want people to move on, maybe you should find something useful to write about but God forbid people like yourself should miss an opportunity to exploit this young woman under the guise of preaching to us fron the high moral ground.
10:06 on 30/01/2012
I'm 19 going on 20 and when these 'disgraceful' photos of Miley emerge I'm not shocked at all! If you were to search through photos of my friends and I on nights out I reckon all these holier than thou parents would have to be sedated. I'm sure they behaved immaculately their whole lives and never put a toe wrong. Just because Miley is in the limelight doesn't mean its her responsabilty to behave like Mother Theresa. Shes young and having fun and that's exactly what she should be doing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anastmosis
01:30 on 30/01/2012
Child stars, like children everywhere, are entitled to grow up. As you point out, this includes sexually suggestive clothing and other ribald behaviour, and it is right and proper that teenagers let off some steam and even learn from some mistakes they make before learning to accept the responsibilities of adult life. My concern is when this type of behavior is portrayed as proper and normal adult behavior, rather than a precursor to responsible, mature, adult behavior. This is typical growing up behavior, but not grown up behavior. This is a subtle but important distinction that is worth making, but rarely is. Much media reports these events in a celebratory tone. I accept these events as a necessary growth experience, but I won't be celebrating or cheering until I see some worthwhile mature adult behavior.
photo
AlanDente
Noses: made to hold glasses
15:04 on 30/01/2012
Who are you to dictate what is proper adult behaviour?
01:17 on 30/01/2012
this cake was the ultimate in bad taste

http://www.brobible.com/bronews/story/miley-cyrus-fawning-over-penis-cake
00:28 on 30/01/2012
Thank you. I'm so glad you wrote this. Its nice to see that someone other than myself notices that Miley isn't a child any more, and can do as she pleases.

PS. If you're such a bad role model that your child needs to look up to someone they don't know other than what they see on TV, then that's on you. Not Miley.