Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Michael Morrison

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Morrison
 

Jacintha's Death Is a Tragedy, But it Isn't the DJs' Fault

Posted: 10/12/2012 00:34

FIRST and foremost, let me say this: it's an absolute tragedy that nurse Jacintha Saldanha, who took a prank-call at Princess Kate's hospital has died in a suspected suicide.

I can't begin to imagine how it must feel to think that taking your own life is the only option you have left, and I feel so incredibly strongly for her family, friends and colleagues.

Mrs Saldanha was just 46, had a good career, and was described as "well respected and popular". We don't know why she did what she did. Nobody does.

One thing is clear though: it isn't the fault of Australian DJs Mel Greig and Michael Christian.

They played a practical joke they never thought would succeed, never mind feature so heavily in media coverage across the globe. Some have said it was "journalistic trickery". I disagree. Trickery is one thing, barking and pretending to be a corgi is quite another. It was a silly joke that got out of hand.

Of course, practical jokes on the radio are anything but new, with many stations playing them on unsuspecting 'victims' every day.

In 2003, a Canadian DJ prank-called ex-Beatle Paul McCartney, pretending to be Prime Minister Jean Chretian. A spokesman at the time said "he took it all in good spirits."

And in 2006, it was French President Jacques Chirac's turn to be duped. A DJ pretended to be the new conservative PM-elect Stephen Harper, before letting Chirac in on the joke a little later.

There are literally hundreds of pranks available to watch on YouTube - and even more played out daily in the home and workplace, like the ghost in the elevator that went viral just last week.

They're just jokes - they're not malicious. Nobody set out to hurt anybody and it certainly wasn't the Aussie DJs' intentions to set somebody up for a fall.

Many comedians regularly 'put-down' hecklers and audience members with harsh words.

In 2011, The Mirror published the 'best put-downs to silence hecklers'. Among them is Russell Kanes' "why don't you go into that corner and finish evolving?' and John Cooper Clarke's "your bus leaves in 10 minutes... be under it." Most are meant in jest and none intended to really hurt somebody.

Mrs Saldanha wasn't the butt of the joke and was never the deliberate target.

All she did was answer the phone and put the DJs through to Kate's personal nurse because no receptionist was available. She was not being disciplined by her employer and nobody from the Royal Family had complained about the prank to the hospital.

A simple, harmless joke - with no serious consequences - should never distress somebody to such an extreme, as it is in this case.

I can understand how it could tip somebody over the edge if they have pre-existing conditions, but little is known about Mrs Saldanha's state of mind and mental health advocates have warned against speculation.

So what's the solution? Do we ban jokes in case they lead to something so appalling tragic and upsetting as this? Do we spend £5m on an inquiry before criminalising practical jokes in some sort of angry, over-the-top reaction?

I'll tell you what the answer is: we continue to smash the mental health taboo, so people who are feeling suicidal are known about, cared for and supported.

Scapegoating a pair of pranksters for something that wasn't their fault isn't just wrong; it's scarily ignorant to the plight of those feeling they can't go on.

We need to help people, not attack them. It might be natural to look for somebody to blame, but it certainly isn't helpful.

To some, laughter and joking might actually the way out of their depression. It certainly was for me.

If there's something troubling you, call Samaritans on 08457 90 90 90 or email jo@samaritans.org.

 

Follow Michael Morrison on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@JournoMicky

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 560
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (18 total)
11:42 PM on 12/15/2012
When Candid Camera, Jeremy Beadle, Dom Joly and others carry out wind-ups, don't a large swathe of the population tune in and laugh along?

I didn't hear us all shouting "Stop! Someone may react badly and commit suicide".

A bit hypocritical to insist on seeking to blame someone at all costs.
08:50 AM on 12/13/2012
I think you can blame the fear of the media circus.

This poor woman realised her simple error would become GLOBAL news as it has done and couldn't cope with the ignominy of the trial by tv. Prank phone calls are as old as the hills but that doesn't mean that everyone can cope with the enormity of the consequences that this one caused. I can only imagine how she felt at work, how she was or perceived she would be treated by management etc. and the subsequent knock on effect for her family. Her mind made the situation worse than it was and she took the only course she felt was open to her, which is such a sad path to have taken and has left her family paying the heaviest price.
04:52 PM on 12/12/2012
Why is everyone NOW getting so wound - up about Phone Prank's.

For has not anyone ever seen a TV SERIES called, Phone-Jacker where there is a NEW Phone Prank going on in this TV Show every 3/4 minutes, for this IS what is part of today's TV's Cheap Entertainment package is now all about.
So therefore, will the next TV Series, or Re-Run's of Phone-Jacker be Banned from all UK TV Screens???
03:44 PM on 12/12/2012
I wish people would stop protecting these 2 DJs The 2 DJs know what they done was wrong be it a prank or not because they are going to pay the family £320.000 from profits made from adverts Maybe others that chose to use a prank for there own enjoyment will give a thought to the family that has lost a loveed one
03:51 PM on 12/12/2012
I don't believe for one minute that these 2 DJ's had any ideas whatsoever that this Prank would back-fire in the way that it did
01:41 PM on 12/12/2012
Its very sad that a dedicated nurse has lost her life however I do wonder if she was in an unstable frame of mind to do something as drastic as this? many people are reprimanded by their bosses but dont take their own life, maybe it was a cry for help that went wrong? from the informarion filtering out it seems she rang someone who then rushed to help her, she she was still alive when found. The DJs are doing what lots of people are and have been doing, it was a prank that went terribly wrong. How many of us have phoned someone and put on a fake voice for fun? I wish her family peace.
03:38 PM on 12/12/2012
I agree.
The strange thing is, that the Day after this Prank occurred Prince Charles was joking that he was NOT a Radio Station, and laughing at the same time.

It seems to me as if Members of the Royal Family took this wind-up in the spirit of the way it was intended, and if this Nurse had not committed Suicide, then this prank would have been re-run, and re-run in Shows like Have I Got News For You, and Mock The Week etc; as being for many the best gotcha prank of 2012, since after all this Prank did fool TWO Nurses.

Me think's that there has to other reasons why Nurse sadly took her own life, as many people would have just laughed it off, for there is MORE to this issue, than currently meets the Eye.
01:13 PM on 12/12/2012
I do not feel sorry for these two 20 something fools. Although a death could not have been foreseen, it does not absolve them from doing something as crass as phoning up a hospital. As many people have pointed out sensible, considerate people would not “prank” with them. Further, Kate was in hospital because the health of herself and her baby were under threat. It is well within the realms of possibility, and thus foreseeable, that the baby could have miscarried. Thank God that did not happen, but in that sort of a scenario then to have seen these fools boasting about how smart and clever they were in order to gain some sort of nebulous publicity for themselves and their radio show would have angered and upset many. The fact that a lovely lady has died quite rightly puts them right in the middle of the storm that nobody but themselves created. I further have little sympathy for them as they are yet to fully apologise, the weepathon was more of a PR exercise and self justification than any sign of genuine contrition.
01:52 PM on 12/12/2012
Its not about feeling sorry at all this was a tragic accident that went horribly wrong and they have got the blame loads of people have done exactly the same thing for many years and this is the first I have ever heard of someone taking their own life. Even tho the hospital have said they did not reprimand her you can be sure they did or what is their hospital policy on things like this?. If I were told off at work I wouldnt hang myself as Im in a good place, so I truly believe that she had to have been depressed or not in a good state of mind at the time. As to Kates condition I had the same and carried my Son full term couldnt even keep water down so I know how she feels normally it means that the pregnancy has a strong hold, she or the baby are not in danger they just need to be monitored and seeing that the Royals get the best of everything you can bet its better treatment than NHS!
04:19 PM on 12/12/2012
"Its not about feeling sorry at all this was a tragic accident that went horribly wrong "

There is NO WAY that any Suicide can be called an "Accident", because Suicide is something you intentionally do to yourself, as the choice is yours to make even if you are in a state of alter awareness, as no more than can this Prank - Call be either called an Accident on the part of the 2 DJ's, as it was Pre-Planned beforehand.

An Accident, is something that occurs that is NOT pre-planned in anyway, either upon the part of yourself or anyone else, but otherwise, - yes, the end outcome of Events were Tragic for the family of the Nurse.
12:24 PM on 12/12/2012
No-one has mentioned the fact that after the DJ's made this call, the tape went to their bosses and the station lawyers for approval before it was played. So they are the ones who should be made accountable.

The nurse didn't even give out any information, all she did was put the call through to someone else so it does seem a bit strange that she took her own life over that, especially when she had two children. I am sure she must have seen and dealt with much worse things in her job.
Plus, of course whoever did give out the information was not thinking straight. I have teleponed hospitals before to ask about the health of friends and have always been told they are not allowed to give out any information.
11:53 AM on 12/12/2012
Pranks are usually intended to make someone look stupid. For some people that is easy to take for others it isn't. I have heard many calls like this on radio stations and I have to say I would hate to be the one duped. It would make me feel awful so to me they are all cruel and likely to cause upset. No-one knows how the person affected will cope so maybe all should be stopped.
If in this case the nurse was already fragile it might just have been to tip her over the edge.
I don't blame the DJ's for her death but maybe it will give them food for thought if there is a next time when they want someone to look silly.
11:43 AM on 12/12/2012
Methinks thou dost protest too much.
11:30 AM on 12/12/2012
I think these DJs should now be left alone but surely anyone phoning a hospital and lying to get through to speak to someone, whether a prank or not should think of the consequences to the staff. No one could have possibly imagined that a death would be the outcome but a sacking or some sort of action against staff surely could be expected. I worked in a hospital for many years and found some senior staff to be very petty and vindictive and would certainly have sacked someone for this.
This comment has been removed.
11:14 AM on 12/12/2012
I tried to post a similar view days ago, but comments were not allowed.

The people to blame in this, if anyone is to blame, are the hospital and Kate's security people. The fact that they had put possibly the most famous woman on the planet at the moment into a hospital would warn everyone about security breaches. After all, her security people haven't done a very good job even before this incident.

Everybody at the hospital, from nurses to cleaners, should have been told that if ANYONE calls to ask about the Duchess, they should take a number and say someone will call back. It's not rocket science is it?

Add to that the media frenzy, with all the journalists no doubt hassling her and making fun of her &c. The hospital said they were taking care of her and counselling her, well they didn't do a very good job of that did they? Now the hospital is trying to lay the blame on the TV station.

No enquiry needed, just a big reprimand for the people who failed in their duty, and they are not on the other side of the world.
02:33 AM on 12/13/2012
Spot on.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:07 AM on 12/12/2012
These two DJs have no role in this womans suicide. She took it upon herself to die. For whatever reason, and there will have been one lurking somewhere, she decided to take her own life.. Why people, the press mainly, have to look for a scapegoat just because there is a royal connection, i'll never know..
11:03 AM on 12/12/2012
some humour can be interupted as BULLYING, they are totally in the wrong
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:10 AM on 12/12/2012
Don't be silly... you mean interpreted don't you ?
11:23 AM on 12/12/2012
I think he did mean interrupted, but it should have been followed by 'by'. And the 'they' he refers to is the bullying hospital management
11:03 AM on 12/12/2012
Im just wondering if the hospital is being totally honest, saying that no disciplinary measures were taken over the matter, with the two nurses in question. After all one of them broke the Data Protection Act by giving imformation over the phone.
This prank call not only humiliated the nurses but also the hospital itself. This is the wife of Royalty after all, a high profile name who should have been protected during her stay in hospital, just as we all should be. I cant imagine that it was just swept under the carpet and nothing was said.
Having worked in the care industry i know how seriously that hospitals take with breaches of confidentiality and complaints. Fingers would be pointed and heads would roll.
Yes the DJ's should take some of the blame, after all if they had not pulled the prank then the matter in question would not exist, but they are not the only ones..........