Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sam Parker

GET UPDATES FROM Sam Parker
 

Black Mirror 'White Bear' (REVIEW)

Posted: 19/02/2013 12:18

4starsculture

WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS

The first 45 minutes of White Bear, the second episode of Charlie Brooker's trilogy of technology-fearing dystopias, played out like a low-budget, low-quality version of 28 Days Later. It's basically the worst thing he's ever written, which, you come to realise, is the whole point.

A woman named Victoria wakes up from an apparent suicide attempt, unable to remember who she is. To make matters worse, the world outside makes no sense either: mysterious transmitters have turned most of the population into zombie-like voyeurs incapable of doing anything but filming her on their mobile phones, even as she's being chased by a masked gunman, screaming for help.

white bear Lenora Crichlow as Victoria in 'White Bear'


Victoria soon teams up with Jem, a fellow 'survivor' who is neither affected by the radiowaves nor one of the 'hunters'. Together they embark on half an hour of horror movie clichés, narrowly escaping bad guys, being tricked into the woods where some Hostel-style torture is taking place and, finally, arriving with ludicrous ease to blow up the transmitter and save the day.

The whole thing is so hackneyed and formulaic, you're aghast. Has Brooker really gone this badly off the boil? Nothing about the plot lines or the behaviour of the characters is believable - except, that is, Victoria herself. You keep waiting for her to make the conventional transformation from scared witless victim to hardened heroine, but she doesn't. Lenora Crichlow, the actress playing her, just keeps crying and staring at the world in disbelief. It's a harrowing performance with no arc or resolutions, just sheer fear and distress.

What is revealed in the final act is that this is because Victoria actually is the only real character. The entire ordeal was a Truman Show-esque ruse made up of actors and set pieces. Suddenly finding herself in front of braying live audience, Victoria is told she abducted and murdered a child (which of course, she can't remember) and this - psychological torture and public humiliation - is her punishment. In a dreadful twist, she is then paraded through the street back to her house, where her memory is wiped and, like Prometheus, reanimated and forced to live through the whole nightmare again.

So the reason it all felt like a rubbish horror movie for 45 minutes is because that's what it was, just with a real person in the centre of it. Victoria's ordeal is exactly what a company of actors tasked with fulfilling a cruel society's fantasy of 'real justice' would come up with.

But how does that explain the voiceless hordes with the camera phones? It turns out they're White Bear's most important character, or least the one Brooker wishes to say the most about. They're members of the public, invited to watch and record Victoria's nightmare for fun. As in other episodes, Brooker is riffing on the idea that our compulsion to document our lives is replacing our desire to participate in it, like the people who see violence break out on a bus and decide to film it rather than intervene. The fact Victoria was a murderer allows them to accept her suffering, but it's the mobile phones that allow them to enjoy it - after all, she's just a character on their screens.

 

Follow Sam Parker on Twitter: www.twitter.com/samparkercouk

FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT
WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS The first 45 minutes of White Bear, the second episode of Charlie Brooker's trilogy of technology-fearing dystopias, played out like a low-budget, low-quality version...
WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS The first 45 minutes of White Bear, the second episode of Charlie Brooker's trilogy of technology-fearing dystopias, played out like a low-budget, low-quality version...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:28 PM on 04/01/2013
She wasn't the murderer, her boyfriend was (he hanged himself in prison). Her crime was that she aided in the abduction and then filmed him torturing and killing the girl. Maybe pay a bit more attention to programmes if you're going to review them! That's why the public were told to film her and do nothing whilst people tried to torture and kill her. She wonders why they bystanders won't help her and just film mutely, and it's her punishment for doing the exact same. Just as in real life the public call for child murderers to be killed, (in other words, murderered), in this the public are invited to do as closely as possible the very thing they hate her for doing and the thing she is being punished for.
01:25 AM on 02/22/2013
Really? All the reviews I've seen talk about the 'desire to document our lives' but this one seemed *far* more to be about our desire to scapegoat in order to feel better about ourselves (while in the process being just as cruel; see the Australian DJs/Princess Kate controversy). This girl, who has been convicted (on evidence not entirely the strongest in the world) is now used for a voyeuristic fantasy by the public - that seems to be the message of this episode - see also: paedophiles, Romanians, Romani....
03:53 AM on 02/20/2013
Very brilliant TV. Bravo!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:19 PM on 02/19/2013
Disturbing but incisive and not too far-fetched...... conjured up memories of the kind of arguments made for awful punishments on huffpost for particular crimes.
I thought she might turn out to be innocent, which would have been a kop-out and ruined the message, so I'm glad that way out wasn't taken.
Scary stuff- the worst of which is the idea of being punished so horribly for a crime you can't even remember.

Great song lyric (can't remember it exactly)

"There is nothing so cruel as the righteousness of innocents"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ian Rennie
It irritates people that I'm a librarian :)
02:07 PM on 02/19/2013
I'm quite glad I didn't watch it now. Sounds relentlessly depressing and a bit heavy handed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:17 PM on 02/19/2013
It certainly was depressing, disturbing. A little heavy handed towards the end, I get the impression Brooker really wanted to make sure everyone "got it", and not be too subtle. Worth a watch.