Cabinet Minister Baroness Warsi made a half-hearted attempt on BBC Question Time (31 January) to refute the rumour that our government plans to actively discourage Bulgarian and Romanian immigrants from coming to the UK when restrictions are relaxed next year. But it was too late, the horse had already bolted.
Last week the idea crossed the continent in all its arrogant glory and Romanians duly responded with a dollop of humour. 'Half our women look like Kate. The other half, like her sister.' Under the slogan 'We may not like Britain, but you will love Romania. Why don't you come over?' the website gandul invited readers to contribute to a viral poster campaign enticing Brits to sample the delights of Romania. 'We have Dracula, you have David Cameron.' 'Charles bought a house here in 2005. And Harry has never been photographed naked once.' What else could they do? Romanians are used to coming bottom of the European pile. I know, I'm married to one. He lives in Britain, and is often told he 'sounds English' - lucky chap. For those back in Romania, life isn't as straightforward. Common obstacles include a 25% pay cut across the public sector, the lowest wages in the EU, endemic corruption and a shoddy infrastructure. Britain's xenophobic outpouring this week, driven by scaremonger headlines and Tory angst, is just the latest knock for a country that is desperately trying to find its feet.
Romanians are poor, but they are also well educated. It is a toxic mix. Believe it or not most don't want to leave their family, their friends, their culture, they do so because they are frustrated with the lack of opportunities in their homeland. Since the Revolution in 1989 its estimated three million workers have already left Romania. Britain was not their first port of call; more popular destinations include Italy, Germany, France and Spain (before the crash). In the last 20 years young educated Romanians have proved much more adaptable than their nation's sick, struggling economy. That this ex-communist country has already haemorrhaged huge numbers of people - so many, a Romanian politician wanted to pay them to come home - is 'good news' for anxious Brits. There might not be enough willing Romanians left for the predicted flood next year. But, anti-British campaign or not, there will be a trickle.
The idea that we can keep Romanians out by waggling our economic woes at a country where the average salary is scarcely 300 euros per month, (doctors are lucky if they get more than 400 euros) is deeply patronising. Our rain and recession can't argue with basic economics. Romania is broke, limping along on an IMF bailout; Britain is one of the richest countries in the world. Romania is lumbered with no democratic heritage, a mafia style political system and a closed-off communist past; Britain meanwhile boasts the 'Mother of all Parliaments' (and an unelected queen). Young Romanians look to the West not only for a way out but also for experience. How else does a fledgling democracy learn? Isn't that one of the great visions behind the EU?
Surely even Europhobic little Britain wouldn't want to alienate the second largest country in South East Europe? After all there is nothing we like more than hopping about on the military stage and Romania is a good point from which to keep an eye on the unpredictable Balkans (and has proved a willing assistant in Afghanistan and Iraq). It is also the last bastion before that vast, vague and unsettling space left behind by the disintegration of the Soviet Union. Not to mention the country's considerable economic potential. Romania boasts the sixth highest density of certified information technology specialists in a world, (Britain doesn't come close), and their plentiful primary resources make them closer to energy self-sufficiency than any European country other than Russia. They are friends worth keeping I would suggest. Indeed, with a bit of EU help Romania might even reclaim its one-time title as the grain basin of Europe. I know Britain's politicians revel in short-termism (the shimmering horizon rarely stretches more than five years into the distance) but surely it is in our interests to stay in with this tenacious, educated people and their extensive rich landmass? Jokes aside, they are quite keen to be friends with us. They speak good English. And I can confirm, their women (the thinnest in Europe), have a certain royal quality.
Tessa Dunlop's memoir To Romania with Love is published by Quartet Books.
Follow Tessa Dunlop on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tessadunlop
Row breaks out between UK and Romania over targeting of ...
Immigration: Romanian or Bulgarian? You won't like it here | UK ...
BBC News - Romania campaign mocks UK anxiety about worker influx
Romanian protests in Revolutionary Square at Britain's immigration ...
Romania news, all the latest and breaking Romanian ... - Telegraph
Romania Responds to Britain's Campaign: 'We May Not Like Britain, but You Will ...
The UK's approach to Bulgarian and Romanian immigration makes me sick with ...
Bucharest tells London it has 'serious concerns' over British plan to limit ...
Diplomatic row over Romanian immigration
Romanian minister protests at Britain's immigration threat
The test in Bucharest: Romania's women might look like Kate and Pippa but its ...
Immigration: Romanian or Bulgarian? You won't like it here
'Come to Romania, our women look like Kate and Pippa': Newspaper launches ...
in north-east, we've got a 150 euros, salary per month..
and to live a month with that salary is impossible..
and somehow we survive..
i wanna' see a french dude, a spanish dude.. or a another dude of a different nationality who lived all his life with a minimum of 500euros per month manage his life here.. with 150euros salary per month.. and the rent 100euros, if you can find one that cheap... SO YEAH... ROMANIANS ARE OK... if we can survive here where the poverty is at it's maximum.. we can survive anywhere...
In my opinion, this is to pave the way, to employ more foreign nationals.to work on our farms.
The NFU thinks this is great. Wait till all the gear go's missing, and they kick the Farmers of the land. It won't be such a good deal then.
Becareful who you trust to provide your food.
With the prison problem in America, you could be eating imported filet Americano.
There is just no way to know until it is too late!!
That is so funny when we now know Romania was a culprit in the horse meat scandal.
I think you didn't get it ... that was romanians' idea, but I can guarantee the british campaign addressed the wrong people ... the gypsies did not see the british posters and for them is not as good as for romanians, anyway :)
All countries should adjust the basic education system by adding honour to their curricula in order to dilute greed and money making related cynicism. Is UK considering this? It seems there is a lot of room for it?
Remember Palestina, Yalta. It seemed great to play the God but it turned a kind of messy.
Keep in mind that you are now politically a colony of your ex-colony. A bit of assumed humility would do some good to Brits too..
I live between British ex-pats (in far, far away country) and I understand them. They agree that immigrants are needed for economic growth but they question whether it is worth losing ones identify (as a country and people) for the sake of it. Some countries do well while discouraging immigration (see again Japan). I think that it would be better for UK to leave EU, create laws to make immigration almost impossible (like Switzerland or Japan) and see how they do.
The economic, political, and environmental mess the world is in at the moment is partly to do with this idea that powerful countries have earned the right to break the rules. Of course the UK can try to alter the rules by renegotiating its relation with the EU or exiting, which is fair enough and their choice. But this idea that the most dominant gets respect, while the others will have to earn it by challenging their dominance sounds to me more like a pack of wolves. Fortunately Homo Sapiens have discovered that the rule of law is a better way of doing things.
We can talk a long time about what powerful countries should do or "respect" but in realpolitik they will do as their interests dictate. All countries do that... some can do more, some less. Look at Holland how it keeps Romanian and Bulgaria out of Schengen just because they can. At least the British want to do it properly (like get out of EU), not hide behind technicalities.
The actual problems Western Europe is dealing with right now are these:
- Aged population with very few active tax payers to support them
- Too many production facilities are moved to Asia, Africa or Eastern Europe because of cheap labor and taxes, generating unemployment
- People's living standard is decreasing
So actually from 2014 UK will get for free Romanian immigrants that will pay their taxes better than UK citizens, because they are watched closer, they are young with a great desire to work and prove they are better, they are very competitive on the work market and the most beautiful thing is that UK didn't spend a penny with their education and training.
Will they improve the aged/active population ratio? Will they give a boost to UK economy being more efficient and creating a more competitive labor market? Will they be efficient enough to maybe keep some of production facilities inside UK?
I'll end my post here and let everyone draw his own conclusion.
But I suppose it's easier to whine on benefits ....
Britain should't be worried about Romanians. They can be put to good use if one knows how to.
For some bloody reason, that remark actually bothers me more than anyone else's about my nation.
And by the way, just to put things on the straight and narrow here:
I am a Romanian and I still live here. I rather like it here to be honest. Sure I have a horrible paycheck of arround 200 dollars right now, but I don't think about it that much. I'm building a career and if that's how it is, that's how it is. Lots of people are calling us poor arround the internet... a damn third world country... WHAT? Whilst I may agree that our government has drained us to bare bones, we're still pretty far from poor. And if you don't bellieve that, come to Bucharest and look arround. Sure we have the seedier parts of town arround, but then again so do Rome, Berlin, London and many other great european cities.
That's what it's like to be one of the honest ones in this country. I don't know how long it's going to take us to wise up and just leave like others did, but we keep trying to change things, and we just get lost in a sea of dirty sweet-talking politicians. Maybe another revolution is needed... but as a wise woman once said: "Ain nobody got time fo that!"
I hate to say it, but it's nothing personal against Romania, whichever country was about to have restrictions against it lowered next would have received the same treatment. This is not about who wants to come here, this is about the native population believing there's no more room left for any more migrants.
We are just fine throwing ourselves outside UK or not coming (I can tell you people are not keen on coming here, anyway) if you throw out every migrant and do not receive any other one. That will convince me you're trying to solve a problem and make a better living for yourself with which I do not have the slightest intention to disagree with you or any other brit.
But, for as long you keep accepting thousands of refugees + other Non-EU(asian and african) workforce and GB is willing to dodge the treaties your elected have signed with us, we will simply not buy the argument. And yes, we will take it as a personal offence because that exactly what it is. Whether you, GB, care about the offence or not, may have an impact on whether we care about it or not, once the time has come.
A big mistake your country has already made in this matter is that instead of keeping it low profile, your abhorrent press thought is a good idea to make all romanians and bulgarians aware about their new opportunities, by lecturing them on hardship and bad weather ... what stupid a joke to attempt with countries who have 45 years under communism, -30 in the winter and +40 in the summer ...
I think our press, and a vocal minority of the people, give the Brits a reputation for xenophobia. In reality, anyone who comes here and makes an effort to interact/contribute/improve themselves is treated with respect.
Racism makes good headlines, in short.