Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tony Dolphin

GET UPDATES FROM Tony Dolphin
 

Triple Dip? Maybe - Triple Crisis? Definitely

Posted: 25/01/2013 09:43

All the talk is once again of a triple-dip after today's GDP figures for the final quarter of 2012 showed the economy contracted by 0.3%. If GDP also shrinks in the first quarter of 2013, then the economy will be back in technical recession - the third recession in the space of five years.

However, this still remains speculation. We will not know for sure whether the economy is back in recession for another three months. And even then, history suggests there is always a chance that the GDP figures will be revised and that any recession will be subsequently eradicated from the record.

What we do know, however, is that the economy is facing a triple crisis: stagnation, debt and imbalance.

Stagnation because real GDP remains over 3% below its peak level, now five years in the past in the first quarter of 2008; and because over the last year GDP has increased by just 0.1%.

Debt because although household debt has fallen from a peak of 170% of income in 2008 to 150%, it remains at a very high level relative to UK experience prior to 2000 and compared to debt in other advanced economies.

Imbalance because the current account deficit in the first three quarters of 2012 was 3.7% of GDP - on course to be the largest deficit since 1989; and because manufacturing output is now clearly on a declining trend. Hopes of an export-led recovery or a 'march of the makers' have evaporated.

Yet - despite even the IMF now acknowledging that rapid deficit reduction has led to weaker growth - the government persists with its strategy of focusing almost exclusively on cutting its spending, refusing to accept that by taking demand out of the economy it has contributed to stagnation and thereby made it harder for households to reduce debt.

True, the government has announced a series of initiatives to boost growth, from finding money for research into graphene to cutting the rate of corporation tax, but these have proved ineffective. The reason is that, for the most part, they reflect a misdiagnosis of the problem. They focus on improving the supply-side of the economy: its capacity to produce output. But the UK already has plenty of spare capacity.

What the UK lacks is demand to match that capacity. Government spending cuts, slower growth in demand from Europe, the squeeze on households' spending power as a result of inflation running ahead of wage gains and low levels of business confidence have combined to suck demand out of the economy. If the government is not prepared to address this problem directly through extra public spending or tax cuts, which is clearly is not, it is unsurprising that the other measures it has put in place are proving ineffectual.

What is more, the government's efforts to reduce its borrowing are becoming self-defeating. George Osborne has already conceded that he will miss his target for reducing public debt and figures released earlier this week showed, public borrowing in the first nine months of the current fiscal year was £106.5 billion, up from £99 billion in the same period of 2011-12. This is putting the country's AAA credit rating under threat.

It is too much to hope that today's GDP figures will lead to a change of approach from the government; they were after all widely forecast at the time of the Autumn Statement, yet in it George Osborne claimed the UK economy was "healing" and "on the right track." At the moment, that track is leading to an economy that is stagnating, has a larger external imbalance and a household still hamstrung by debt.

But now is the time for a change of path. What is needed is a set of policies that put demand back into the economy in the short-term while beginning to address the long-standing structural weaknesses of the UK economy. As a first step, this should include a temporary cut in employees' national insurance contributions, using the historically low cost of borrowing to increase spending on infrastructure, measures to keep the long-term unemployed in touch with the labour market and an active industrial policy focused specifically on reversing the country's poor export performance.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:41 PM on 01/26/2013
In a nutshell, the economy needs some 'guts' behind it, sadly lacking in this pathetic Cabinet.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
barrysturn
Ut Veniant Omnes
12:49 AM on 01/26/2013
On the brink of a triple dip recession and Osbourne thinks that we need more austerity. More austerity means less growth and less growth means more austerity. This does not of course impact on Mr Osbourne's base. If you are rich it is very easy to get richer in a recession. Buying up assets at knock down prices is one way.
03:38 PM on 01/25/2013
This is just a small demonstration of the fact that the downturn and/or recession will only impact on the lower orders. Those at the top will not suffer - in fact they only grow richer.
11:06 PM on 01/26/2013
Was it ever thus?
03:00 PM on 01/25/2013
The "British Establishment" has a tendency to spend a lot of money on wars and weapons. Their resistance to clean energy has just handed ROI 13000 jobs where they will pipe electricity generated, by the soon to be built wind farms, to Wales where it will connect to the grid. There are several layers to the UK parliament, some of which are unelected. All of those layers cost the public a LOT of money. The UK is developed from London outwards.

The Uk gov being untruthful is one thing, the public ignoring the above is another. We are to blame as much as the Uk Gov. If we really, actually want to do something other than moan, then we need to stop this political ping pong match between Tory and Labour. Only having two parties is part of the UK’s problem.
11:10 PM on 01/26/2013
A true coalition made up of all political parties and the brightest and best from industry,science and the arts,dedicated solely to bringing the UK out of recession with petty politics and squabbles put away until we are back on our feet again is the only answer.
01:54 PM on 01/25/2013
Is the goverment been un-truthful with the Britsh public,deficit,debt, borrowing, unemployed etc?
Are they using the last Labour goverment as a smoke screen,to hit the poor,unemployed,less well off and the pensioners?
09:10 PM on 01/25/2013
Definitely
11:15 PM on 01/26/2013
Yes but all politicians do the same thing,what we need is for petty politics,point scoring and blame to be put aside and for all politicians to have the emergence from recession as their only aim..
11:42 PM on 01/26/2013
That's a very good point,but we dont have the politicians with the bottle to do that.
12:25 PM on 01/25/2013
How can we be in recession when the jobless total is the lowest it has ever been in years. More people are in work than at any time in years. The young unemployed have virtually been irradiated? So surely were there The land of milk and honey,

No No, It couldn't possibly be that the government haven't been quite truthful with us,,, Could it?
09:14 PM on 01/25/2013
Actually its the lowest for 18 months, not not, as you say in years. And thats only if you can believe the figures. There's more people doing part time work, not full time work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clownzozo
Magician, Novelist and an Angry Old Git
11:01 AM on 01/25/2013
Stop pimping for the scoundrels of the IMF and sell our 29% as settlement iof the national debt, in full Print our own English money backed by Government, and from which it can borrow to finance public works, interest free and without burdening the taxpayers. End the madness of state subsidising supermarkets, which is a government backed swindle, designed to wipe out retail competition and cause mass unemployment, a ready source of cheap slave labour.
10:56 AM on 01/25/2013
40 years of rightwing neo-liberalsim was going to take a while to drain out of the UK's body politic.

Unfortunately we've had to endure another gratuitous Thatcherite economic experiment to see the true failure of this creed.

This morning's bad Q4 2012 GDP figures and the inevitable loss of the UKs AAA rating will hopefully drive a stake through this disastrous flirtation with fantasy.

Although the damage is deep-rooted, long lasting and will take a generation for a pragmatic, grounded-in-economic-reality government to fix.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
battleofalma
11:33 AM on 01/25/2013
I'm inclined to agree, but seeing as European economies with far more leftist policies (bigger public sectors, higher taxes, stronger welfare states), such as France or Denmark, are also in financial difficulties, what is the solution?

I would argue that the macroeconomic factors make a lot of our policy-making irrelevant.
How can countries like us attract foreign investment when we are up against areas such as states in the US with no statutory minimum wage?
Essentially, we're all in for a big shift down in living standards as other economies have caught up and can provide the manufacturing and service industries we can, but at a much lower price.

It's hard not to look at these factors and wonder whether our arguing about cuts to the rates at which benefits will rise as totally frivolous.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:23 PM on 01/25/2013
Dose not matter the government, left or right, its global economic policy. Since the collaspse of communism and socialism as a political power, all political decisions are dictated by anarcho-capitalist libertarian economic theories (neo-liberal, neo classical, supply-side, trickle down), which are built upon 'game theory' and 'self interest'.
All governments do now is regulate their own populations to suit. Thus, even so called left wing parties, like New Labour, are at best centre right, and implement stratagies like privatisation, low wage (flexible workforce), outsourcing, etc., to suit corporate demands.
Fufuyama's 'End of History' describes (and promotes) this shift.
Also, google the 'political compas' which states where political parties now stand on the political spectrum (for example, all parties in Europe are now firmly entrenched on the authoritarian right).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gussom
On the message
10:44 AM on 01/25/2013
The point about any economy is that it does rely on demand, whether from companies government or consumers. The problem we have is that the policies pursued by this government is economically illiterate.