How To Travel With Gadgets: Do You Even Need To Turn Them Off?

Pan Am

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 05/12/11 17:12 Updated: 05/12/11 17:29

We've all heard the announcement "switch off mobile phones and electronic devices for take off and landing".

But do we even need to switch phones off anymore? Large numbers of people have accidentally left their phone on during flight, and yet very few planes fall out of the sky.

The UK Civil Authority explains that mobile phones must be turned off during take-off and landing because they compete with signals used for ground communication between the plane and control tower.

So while they won't cause any lasting damage to a plane itself, crucial communication could be interrupted. Which could be annoying and potentially dangerous, but not "plane falls out of sky randomly because you text your mum" dangerous.

But according to a New York Times blog, the interference generated by everyone switching their phones off then on again at the same time could be a worry.

That sames blog says the radio frequencies that are assigned for aviation use are separate from commercial use and that there have never been any reported accidents from these kinds of devices being used on planes.

Still, no cigar from the CAA here in the UK. They stand by the "phones off" view.

The official CAA line reads: "Gadgets, such as laptops, tablets, MP3 players, video games etc might cause interference with aircraft communications and control systems and as such should be switched off during taxi, take off and landing and whenever instructed by the aircraft crew."

Both BA and Easyjet say mobiles must be switched off during take off and landing for these reasons, and used in flight safe mode otherwise. But as BA's press office says: "You won't get a signal, because you're too high up".

BA do have one flight where you can use your phone during the flight - the route from London City Airport to New York JFK.

if you can't bear to be disconnected for a few hours, this business class service is equipped with the OnAir on-board connectivity system which lets you use text, email and internet access during the flight.

That access is becoming popular on US domestic flights. American Airlines introduced Wi-Fi in 2009 and both Delta and Virgin America offer the service.

GADGETS: CHECK-IN OR CARRY ON?

Separately, reports have surfaced recently that Amazon Kindles are being ruined by some strong X-Ray machines. So do double-check yours when you pass it through the scanner at your local hub.

An American traveller quoted by the Daily Mail said that after passing through the x-ray scanner, her son's Kindle looked like an etch-a-sketch, adding that "the screen [was] burned so badly that even in the off position you see all of the lines and squiggles and letters".

Professor Daping Chu, from University of Cambridge Centre for Advanced Photonics, said it might not be caused by the x-ray, but by static electricity build up. He said: "You can get a buildup of static inside these machines, caused by the rubber belt".

The electricity could skew the tiny capsules filled with magnetic particles that make up the letters.

Amazon tells The Huffington Post they are not aware of any complaints, and that "exposing your Kindle to an X-ray machine, such as those used by airport security, should not cause any problems with the Kindle. Many Kindle users travel by air, and their Kindles are screened by airport security every day without issue."

But if you're still worried then check in your Kindle and revert to books.

The most important advice for carrying any kind of gadget through an airport is have them all to hand so you don't hold up the airport queue.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK TECH

We've all heard the announcement "switch off mobile phones and electronic devices for take off and landing". But do we even need to switch phones off anymore? Large numbers of people have accidenta...
We've all heard the announcement "switch off mobile phones and electronic devices for take off and landing". But do we even need to switch phones off anymore? Large numbers of people have accidenta...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
00:28 on 06/12/2011
Too bad you cannot put some of the passengers on mute
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TaiJi2
20:23 on 05/12/2011
The devices may well be harmless, but people who refuse to follow crew instructions can't be trusted - it'll be their bootprints on your back in an emergency. Don't like the rule, don't fly.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
20:31 on 05/12/2011
Indeed. Do what the safety professionals tell you to do.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NerdyStudent
Sorry, your micro-bio doesn't meet our standards
20:04 on 05/12/2011
What an odd choice for a photo, didn't that show get axed (Can't find a definitive "yes" or "no" via the Google)?

Can't we just pay for a stock photo and be done with it?

Anyway, that's my off-topic comment for the day.
19:23 on 05/12/2011
My wife is a stewardess (a term she uses because its funny) and she assures me the devices are almost certainly harmless. but why take the chance?

To those who 'need' to keep their phone on until it loses reception: YOU ARE NOT THAT IMPORTANT-TURN OFF YOUR PHONE!

Additionally, I have witnessed the sad deterioration of travel etiquette the last 20 years (to non-existant) and the LAST thing I need to hear is sales-schlub boasting into his phone about some crap deal he put together, or a gum-crackin woman talking about her latest weave.

Silence is golden.
18:39 on 05/12/2011
mmmm hot stewardesses... did someone say something about gadgets?
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
20:30 on 05/12/2011
You can use those. Purely mechanical.