Arab Spring One Year On: What Happened, What Changed?

Arab Spring 2

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 17/12/11 08:29 Updated: 17/12/11 12:10

One year ago today, Mohamed Bouazizi set himself alight in Tunisia. It was a personal protest that had huge ramifications not only for his homeland, but the entire region. This was the incident which triggered the demonstrations that spread from Tunisia into Egypt, Libya, Syria and beyond. This was the start of the Arab Spring.

At Bouazizi's funeral 5,000 marchers chanted: "Farewell, Mohammed, we will avenge you. We weep for you today, we will make those who caused your death weep."

For all their passion, no one expected what happened next: 12 months of intense protests, violence and revolution across North Africa and the Middle East, which brought down governments and resulted in thousands of deaths.

But 12 months later what has the impact really been? Which governments have fallen, which are on the brink - and which, if any, are stronger than ever? Was the Arab Spring really a movement - or was it always an invention of the press?

And with protests breaking out in Russia, Greece, China and even New York throughout 2011, as well as in the Arab world, has the spirit of the Spring spilled become a truly global phenomenon?

IN PICTURES: A Photographic History Of The Arab Spring

ARAB SPRING TIMELINE: How The Arab Spring Unfolded

As the Arab Spring marks a year of protest, we look back at what happened, and what changed.

Above: Protesters in Egypt, 29 January 2011 (Image by PA)

THE ARAB SPRING: Turning Points And Political Reform

Tunisia: On 17 December 2010 in Tunisia, Bouazizi set himself alight in front of the offices of the Sidi Bouzid government. His act set off a wave of protests which quickly spread through the country.

Above all the demonstrators called for democratic reform. Under a wave of pressure, Tunisian President Zine al-Abdine Ben Ali was eventually forced to leave office on 14 January.

For all the fervour, elections for a 'Constituent Assembly' were only eventually held on 23 October. The leader of the Ennahda party was appointed Prime Minister.

Egypt: In Egypt warnings of a 'Tunisia-style explosion' were confirmed when thousands of people took to the streets on 25 January, National Police Day. Centred on Tahir Square in Cairo, the protests grew ever larger despite attempts by President Hosni Mobarak's government to shut down the Internet and mobile networks on 27 January, and put down the demonstrations with force.

Above: Egyptian anti-government activists clash with riot police in Cairo, Egypt, Friday, Jan. 28, 2011. (Image by PA)

A bloody crackdown followed, but on 11 February Mubarak was forced to give up power. Since February, Egyptians have grown disillusioned with their revolution and the continuing strength of the military. Protests again begun to fill Tahir Square in December, with violent outbreaks across Cairo. However the first stage of free elections have been held in the country, and slow, if difficult, progress is being made.

Libya: In Bahrain on 14 February a protest movement led by young people began, and was later taken up by the Shi'ite opposition. Meanwhile, in Libya, protests against leader Colonel Muammar Gaddafi also sparked into life.

Within weeks these came to resemble something closer to a civil war. As the opposition hardened in Benghazi, Gaddafi sent government forces to quell the opposition. Nato and the United Nations stepped in, emboldened by the history of conflict with Gaddafi and his lack of regional support from the Arab League, and set up a no-fly zone to protect Benghazi and aid the rebels.

Above: A Libyan rebel shells pro Gaddafi forces with mortar fire, along the front line outside the eastern town of Brega, Libya Thursday, March 31, 2011. (Image by PA)

Months of violent stalemate followed, but in August the capital Tripoli fell to the opposition National Transitional Council, and Gaddafi's rule came to an end. He was eventually captured and killed on 20 October in his hometown of Sirte.

Syria: In Syria a pro-democracy protest movement directed against Syrian president Bashar al-Assad rose up in mid-March.

The protests have continued in large numbers ever since, but after series of escalating government crackdowns the United Nations estimates that at least 5,000 people have been killed.

As the year comes to a close there are signs that the Syrian protests are gradually transforming into something more closely resembling a civil war, like that in Libya. The increasingly bold Free Syrian Army, made up of defected army officers, has attacked and killed government troops, which some have said has strengthened Assad's regime as much as it has hurt his forces.

As of December 2011, with Assad still defying critics in the Arab League and western nations, wilfully ignoring economic sanctions and denying all knowledge of accusations of child torture and mass violence, there is no sign that the situation is moving towards a close.

Above: Yemeni demonstrators chant slogans and wave their national flags during a rally calling for an end to the government of President Ali Abdullah Saleh, in Sanaa, Yemen, Thursday, Jan. 27, 2011. (Image by PA)

Elsewhere: Other countries around the world have seen large-scale and often violent protests and government crackdowns.

In the Sultanate of Oman social protests have been seen on the streets. In Iraq weekly demonstrations against government corruption have been see, while in Iraqi Kurdistan democratic protests were violently suppressed in February, according to Reporters Without Borders.

In Kuwait, Jordan and even in parts of territory governed by the Palestinian Authority and Hamas gatherings have been called aiming at political reform, but progress has been inconclusive.

Other countries have launched pre-emptive reforms in order to prevent rebellions. In Algeria President Abdellaziz Bouteflika announced efforts to reform the political system in April, while King Mohamed of Morocco accepted a series of constitutional reforms.

IN PICTURES: A PHOTOGRAPHIC HISTORY OF THE ARAB SPRING

Above: People celebrate the capture in Tripoli of Moammar Gaddafi's son and one-time heir apparent, Saif al-Islam, at the rebel-held town of Benghazi, Libya, early Monday, Aug. 22, 2011. (Image by PA)

MEDIA: The Role Of The Media, From Facebook To Sky News

The role of social media networks including Twitter and Facebook has been debated endlessly online and in the press ever since the Arab Spring uprisings began.

Some have passionately argued that the new and more open communication afforded by these networks has been a vital organising tool.

Right at the start of the Tunisian uprising in December 2010, for instance, the self-immolation of Sidi Bouzid was not reported by the restrictive national media - but on Facebook the news quickly got out. More than 100 pages on the incident were created - and blocked. Arrests and further shut-downs followed. The libertarian hacking collective Anonymous attached government websites in an operation known as Operation Tunisia in response and once Ben Ali fled the blogger Slim Amamou was appointed secretary of state for youth and sport.

Others have said that at best social media has been an additional weapon for protesters whose concerns are entirely separate to developments in the media.

For journalists, at least, social media tools have proved an important way of speaking to protesters with relative assurance that the security of protesters will not be compromised.

The Huffington Post UK has conducted several interviews with people inside Syria via Skype, for instance. These interviews, usually facilitated by activist networks, have provided important insights to a region that otherwise would be largely inaccessible to foreign media.

Global and local activist networks including Avaaz have also made use of social media in more targeted ways, for instance developing networks of so-called 'citizen journalists' whose work in getting out YouTube videos and accounts of torture and violence have been vital.

Mainstream media networks have also produced some exceptional journalism across the region. We spoke to the team behind a Channel 4 Unreported World documentary recorded secretly inside Syria, for instance, which made an important impact in the UK.

Above: A revolutionary fighter fires at Gaddafi loyalists in downtown Sirte, Libya, Tuesday, Oct. 18, 2011. (Image by PA)

IN PICTURES: A PHOTOGRAPHIC HISTORY OF THE ARAB SPRING

ARAB SPRING TIMELINE: How The Arab Spring Unfolded

DEATH TOLL: What Was The Cost?

The most immediate and visceral impact of the Arab Spring has been on the thousands of people who have died as a result of violence and government crackdowns.

Reports of the total dead and injured are difficult to discern, particularly because of the reporting restrictions still in place in countries such as Syria.

In total, rough and unconfirmed estimates range from 30,000 to 40,000 dead, with many thousands more injured.

IMPACT: What Does 2012 Hold For The Arab Spring?

The lasting impact of the Arab Spring is still a topic of some discussion.

The usefulness of the term itself still causes debate, and the Western assumption that the protesters' aims would always be a Western-style democracy have also been criticised.

Some have argued that the Arab Spring could turn into a cruel winter as those fuelled by the exuberance of revolution wake up to the harsh economic reality of government.

Others have said that the Arab Spring has shown that the one thing protests do well is inspire other protests:

Writing in the Guardian, Ian Black said: "Activists across the Arab world speak of breaking through the barrier of fear so that even the harshest repression no longer deters. The experience of one revolution has inspired another in sympathy and solidarity"

And when Time magazine announced that its person of the year was "the protester", from the Arab Spring to Occupy Wall Street, it drew clear links between the demonstrations in North Africa and the Middle East to those in struggling Western economies.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

One year ago today, Mohamed Bouazizi set himself alight in Tunisia. It was a personal protest that had huge ramifications not only for his homeland, but the entire region. This was the incident which ...
One year ago today, Mohamed Bouazizi set himself alight in Tunisia. It was a personal protest that had huge ramifications not only for his homeland, but the entire region. This was the incident which ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:07 on 24/12/2011
i posted two comments and one disappears. this is not good, my first comment back please.
11:50 on 24/12/2011
all the world to see. now the french dont have to pay back the loans they took from him. the promise to pay it back in 2011 and instead killed him. the real sad thing is the whole world plays with africa and africa never really trouble anybody. as soon as a little bit of stability shows up anywhere in Africa, the Automatic instability program is trigged. do you know that these people sit in thier home and watch on tv, distraction of the African Continent as part of entertainment, they call it news. very very sad day for africa when these people went into Libya. the people that took down Gaddaffi werent Libyans. moved from a strong french influenced north african state only for thier skin colour, they qualified, they are still in libya because there was no return plan. they can not be enlisted into the libyan army because they have no identity.
23:57 on 18/12/2011
The elephant in the room from a Western perspective is the news of how men are treating women in these countries. Remember the American and the French female journalists who were raped by dozens of men on Tahrir square? Today the Sunday Times showed an image of a woman stripped half-naked, held by three police men and a man stamping on her stomach. This is Egyptian democracy. There's no need to imagine how they are treating their own women, simply watch the news.

These countries are deeply homosexual societies (see Afghanistan) without a love for their own daughters. Obviously there's nothing wrong with gay men, as long as they don't attack women as the Taliban are doing and Egyptian's 'seekers of democracy' are learning to do. Not to mention the massacre of Africans, widely documented, by so-called Islamists in Lybia - simply shocking.

I'm alienated by the support the West has given so-called rebels (in Lybia, Syria ...) in overthrowing their governments to prevent these countries to align with China, knowing full well that they are handing over power to illiterate women-hating barbarians with a century-old penchant for killing and enslaving black people.

I don't have a solution for people who are convinced that a course of Taliban-like rule is the righteous one, see Iraq, Egypt and so on. I for one will be doing everything in my powers to discourage those aspects of Sharia law which dehumanises women.
09:42 on 18/12/2011
Thanks for the article.

A review or our site links documents how LIO suportive Libertarians and Liberals were announcing in 2010 a push in the Mid-east and other problem countries for democracy.Operation Democracy continues and indirectly networks several million people. Many such as the Libertarian collectives mentioned-- beyond awareness and spread of information-- pursue a variety of autonomous strategies. The changes are slow and long term, and in no sense do Libertarians advocate anything but peaceful protest. This is continuation of the work begun against the Communist and Right-Wing dictatorships.

For more on voluntary solutions at work please see http://www.LibertarianInternational.org the non-partisan Libertarian International Organization.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norma Ward
02:15 on 18/12/2011
Here's what Freedom House said about the concept of civil and political freedom in Middle East nations:

"Freedom House concludes that there is a dramatic, expanding gap in the levels of freedom and democracy between Islamic countries and the rest of the world. Freedom in the World finds that a non-Islamic country is more than three times likely to be democratic than an Islamic state."

Here is an article outlining the conclusions of the Freedom House study:

http://viableopposition.blogspot.com/2011/02/defining-and-quantifying-freedom-in.html
15:08 on 18/12/2011
So you are saying that Islam is bad? Isn't that soon to be against the law in your country?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
19:09 on 17/12/2011
Sadly these people have no idea how long it takes to establish any democracy. It will take decades to overcome the extremism they have become accustomed to. In any country, trust is no easy option, as we in the UK know very well indeed. It appears that, they are trying to find their way into democracy, as we here are leaving ours behind, due to perpetual lies, corrupt practices and deception. The personal greed for the EU luxuries, has turned minds of greedy politicians of all 3 parties. The people of Britain, do not count to these gluttons for power and money in Wetminster. However, most recently there has been a shift in policy, as Cameron played his veto card, even so, trust still has to be established before we will ever believe any of them again..Hope this helps Egypt, all the very best....
15:09 on 18/12/2011
Don't worry your dear greedy politicians will see to it that UK standards and laws will slide way back to meet these idiots in the middle or at the bottom maybe.
18:14 on 17/12/2011
http://youtu.be/QTLPOFWF1YA
17:31 on 17/12/2011
What's changed? A few tantrums were thrown, on all accounts. Chests were bumped, fists were thrown, those in charge showed their true colours and those they're supposed to serve are getting it through their skulls. Oh, the self-destructive nature human condition and undeniable sense of self-preservation

2012 is gonna be fun.
14:45 on 17/12/2011
The top 1% are no longer seen as entitled.

The 99% are waking up.
04:42 on 18/12/2011
You guys have funny ways of making yourselves seem bigger. Inducting Egypt into the OWS. Pfft.
14:32 on 17/12/2011
All ready bars are closing and plans are a foot for women not to be allowed out after dark and made to wear the hijab.
13:16 on 17/12/2011
From the song by the who [wont get fooled again ]
we will be fighting in the streets with our children at our feet,
and another line that said [meet the new boss same as the old boss ]

the song was 1970s,nothing changes much !
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
majesticjkr
Always look on the bright side of life
12:02 on 17/12/2011
the human race is pucked up, how can we advance to the skies and space when we still have nations on earth fighting and killing its own people, we need to control the people on earth, we need one goverment to rule the hole population, one law for all we need to kill all the trouble makers and try and get the world to understand that we have to live in peace, and if your not with it your against it and you will suffer, the main new ruling would be to make pot legal, it will bring a calm to the people, and help build bridges, god bless the world
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ramkshrestha
Lumbini-Kapilvastu Day Movement
11:31 on 17/12/2011
Yes 2011 could be the year of change - year of 'Protesters'