Diet Guru Pierre Dukan: Give Extra Marks To Slim Students

Dukan Diet

Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 3/01/2012 12:51 Updated: 3/01/2012 13:46

Overweight school pupils should be penalised by giving extra marks to slim students, celebrity diet guru Pierre Dukan has said.

In an open letter to the "future French president", Dukan proposed 18-year-old pupils preparing for the Baccalaureat exam should be awarded more marks if they fall within a specific Body Mass Index (BMI) range.

The self-proclaimed expert has sold millions of books around the world and has amassed a cult following. Despite Dukan's claims of one in two French people being overweight, official statistics show the country still boasts the fourth lowest rate of obesity in Europe.

Data released by European statistics agency Eurostat in November last year revealed 12.7% of women and 11.7% of men are obese in France. Of those aged 18 to 24, 4.3% of women are deemed obese, while 2.8% of men fall in the same category.

This is compared to the UK's significantly higher figures; 16.6% of 16 to 24-year-old females and 5.9% of males the same age are obese.

Dukan suggested the Baccalaureat should have an optional extra "exam"; any pupil who can maintain a BMI between 18 and 25 during their final year at school should be awarded marks which would count towards their final grade.

BMI is calculated by the weight in kilos divided by the square of the height in meters. A BMI of less than 18.5 is defined as underweight, 18.5 to less than 25 as normal weight, 25 to less than 30 as overweight and 30 or more as obese.

Dukan's publication, which contains the controversial proposals titled "An open letter to the future president of the Republic", will be available for sale in bookshops in France. Famous fans of the "Dukan Diet" are said to include Kate Middleton, Jennifer Lopez and supermodel Gisele Bundchen.


Diet guru Pierre Dukan, who hopes the next French president will take heed of his proposals.

In an interview with the French newspaper Le Parisien on Monday, Dukan said the idea would be a good way of educating young people about nutrition.

"Nothing will change for those who do not need to lose weight," he told the paper*. "And for others, it will motivate them.

"There is nothing unhealthy about educating youngsters about nutrition."

But Tony Armstrong, chief executive of youth charity Living Streets - who runs the Walk to School campaign - said:

“Whilst we recognise the importance of children leading a healthy lifestyle, this idea is bizarre in its negative approach and risks being counter-productive.

“It’s been proven that fitting more activity into your day can greatly improve your health. Living Streets’ experience of running the Walk to School Campaign shows that a positive and encouraging approach to walking from an early age is the most effective way of increasing walking rates in children.

“We believe that every school and every local council should be promoting cost effective measures such as this to get or children out on the street, healthy and active, rather than taking part in ill thought out schemes that will pressurise and penalise school pupils.”

Dukan, who claims he is "neither left, nor right, but a doctor above all", will send his book to all the presidential candidates.

The guru's proposals come less than a week after the French government approved a "fat tax" on fizzy drinks. The new charge will add more than 1p to a can of soft drink such as Coca-Cola but zero-calorie "diet" drinks would be exempt from the tax, the Daily Mail reported.

*According to a translation.
FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Overweight school pupils should be penalised by giving extra marks to slim students, celebrity diet guru Pierre Dukan has said. In an open letter to the "future French president", Dukan proposed 18...
Overweight school pupils should be penalised by giving extra marks to slim students, celebrity diet guru Pierre Dukan has said. In an open letter to the "future French president", Dukan proposed 18...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
06:44 PM on 04/17/2012
i find it very effective, i trie ggod duka recipes, such as

http://ricette-facili-veloci.blogspot.it/2012/03/dieta-dukan-pasti-principali-colazione.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William Anderson LMHC
Licensed Psychotherapist, Weight Control Expert
01:18 PM on 01/13/2012
So wrong. This man is dangerous.

I grew up the fattest kid in school and was nearly destroyed by ignorant fools like him. It's a shame that our pop Internet culture gives him a stage like this.

I finally solved my weight problem after 25 years of obesity and dieting failure when I discovered the solution as a behavior therapist and addictions counselor. Now I teach others. Please read my article about what school can do to help overweight kids instead of hurting them: http://theandersonmethod.com/what-should-the-schools-do-to-fight-the-childhood-obesity-epidemic/

I pray that those exposed to the media like this are able to separate the good thinking from the bad and seek the good.

William Anderson, LMHC
Author of The Anderson Method – Secrets of Permanent Weight Loss’
www.TheAndersonMethod.com
04:09 PM on 01/06/2012
It's just one more effort to force conformity amongst students.
09:30 PM on 01/04/2012
Ignorance and Arrogance out of his own mouth are destroying his reputation and reflect badly on his work. Shame on him for proposing negative reinforcement and penalties on those already stigmatized by this condition while (he apparently) does not even considering a positive approach.

It is obvious to those knowledgeable in the sciences that BMI is badly broken w.r.t. larger than average professional athletes, let alone average individuals with a skeletal frame that is above or below the median (height, width, depth, circumference, density, etc.).

Anytime BMI is referred to as (causally) being meaningful the author immediately identifies themselves as a "soft on science" personality with at best a superficial understanding of technical disciplines and practitioner of pseudo-science (as compared to hard sciences such as physics).

For that metric to be meaningful requires almost an entire book complete with validating and verifying studies that as of this date (strangely enough) have not been performed. This infers that those who insist on using BMI are either Ignorant, Arrogant (as mentioned earlier) or psychologically dysfunctional.
07:38 PM on 01/04/2012
Oh.. so many fantastic ideas!!!
05:19 PM on 01/04/2012
Nonsense. Obesity is an affirmative action class and a handicap. We must give them BETTER grades for being obese in order to make up for the unfairness they will receive in life.
photo
lemmyk73
When you see a Rainbow, it is God having gay sex.
05:01 PM on 01/04/2012
Bad decision- parents taxes should increase for their fat kids. Do not punish kids for their parents lack of parenting. Punish the parents. Along the same lines- all should be taxed by weight- and said tax goes into a healthcare pool.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Savage Saint Roger
Card Carrying Liberal
04:53 PM on 01/04/2012
What an egotistical bast*rd!
"Nothing will change for those who do not need to lose weight," he told the paper*. "And for others, it will motivate them"
The world will disadvantage them anyway and he just wants to twist the screws because he is such a stand up and motivating guy. A pox on him!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:41 PM on 01/04/2012
This lunacy is what you get with socialized medicine.
09:32 AM on 01/16/2012
what a stupid comment. What on earth are you talking about? What does this have to do with socialized medicine?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:39 PM on 01/16/2012
Countries with socialized medicine dole out care based on lifestyle choices that patients make. A patient who chooses to smoke, drink or have a diet that leads to obesity may not receive certain types of treatment. This proposal of rewarding slim students with good grades is an attempt to "get 'em while they're young." If the state can influence the decisions citizens make early on in their lives, it will be easier to influence them later.
02:32 PM on 01/04/2012
If we're all so darn worried about overweight children, why do we tolerate overt marketing of processed food-like products to children? I wonder...http://heresheisboys.com/2012/01/02/lose-pounds-and-inches-fast/
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cam1002
The People's Budget - It WILL Work
05:57 AM on 01/04/2012
Yeah, let's take the overweight kids who have low self-esteem and decrease that self-esteem 10 fold. Some people are just plain cruel.
04:41 AM on 01/04/2012
Proof that, in French..."celebrity diet guru" translates the same as "le idiot"
tm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
count4eternity
Grace greater than all our sin!
03:44 AM on 01/04/2012
Where's a stupid tax, when you need one?
12:53 AM on 01/04/2012
Would this be retroactive? I was skinny as a rail in high school. I would have probably been given straight A's and could have goofed off more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CitizenPane
Why isn't phonetic spelled the way it sounds?
04:47 PM on 01/04/2012
Your comment was so funny. You just made my morning. Fanned!
llwlknsn
Adequate words fail me.
10:59 PM on 01/03/2012
Repeat after me "It is not my business."

Let's follow the logic. Kids don't get enough exercise. Shcools cut PE deeming it irrelevant. Then Schools punich children for being overweight.

Follow? It is sadism at its very special best.