Costa Concordia Owners: Ship's Captain Francesco Schettino Was 'Showing Off'

Francesco Schettino

First Posted: 16/01/12 17:44 GMT Updated: 17/01/12 09:12 GMT   PA

The captain of the wrecked cruise ship which hit rocks off Italy made "an unapproved, unauthorised" deviation to his route, the liner's owners have said.

As the death toll in the disaster rose to six, Costa Cruises' chairman Pier Luigi Foschi apologised for the tragedy which has left dozens of people injured and the 114,000-tonne Costa Concordia lying on its side off Tuscany.

At the centre of the investigation into the disaster is the liner's captain, Francesco Schettino who, according to reports, was "showing off" and sailed as close to land as he did as he wanted to salute to a friend on shore.

He faces accusations that he abandoned the vessel before ensuring that all of the 4,200 people aboard, including 35 Britons, were safely evacuated.

Clarence Mitchell, who is representing Costa Cruises, said: "Mr Foschi confirmed the captain had been approaching the island of Giglio to 'make a salute'.

"The company says this (incident) was caused by an attempt by the captain to show the ship to the port.

"But there's a criminal investigation going on and we're not going to say anything that's going to compromise that or the captain's case."

While British survivors told of the panic on board after the ship began to list, Mr Foschi said the liner had passed all safety and technical tests in its 2011 evaluation.

The ships' masters' union Nautilus said vessels of the size of the Costa Concordia were "inherently unstable".

But the UK Chamber of Shipping and the European Cruise Council said such ships met stringent safety regulations which had recently been tightened.

James Thomas, 19, from Sutton Coldfield, Birmingham, a dancer who helped to direct petrified passengers off the vessel, said the instruction to abandon ship should have been given "an hour earlier, if not more".

Explaining that the ship was "ultra safe", Mr Foschi said the captain had made an unauthorised and unapproved deviation from the ship's programmed course.

Mr Foschi said: "This route was put in correctly. The fact that it left from this course is due solely to a manoeuvre by the commander that was unapproved, unauthorised and unknown to Costa."

Mr Foschi added: "Personally and on behalf of the Costa Crociere (Cruises) I want to say we are very sorry for this tragic accident that's happened."

Capt Schettino, who has commanded the ship since it was built in 2006, has said he is not to blame and that nautical charts did not show the rocks off the tiny island of Giglio.

Mr Thomas said people on board "knew something was deadly wrong" when the ship began to tilt.

He went on: "We knew we were going to have to do something drastic to get out of the situation we were in. Even if it was 'just in case' it (the call to abandon ship) should have been called an hour earlier, if not more."

Mr Thomas added: "All I came off with was wet trousers and wet shoes, luckily without any injuries.

"But I saw people with some horrific injuries and that is one thing which I am never going to be able to get out of my head which is the worst thing.

Another survivor, Rose Metcalf, 23, from Wimborne in Dorset, said: "There was absolute panic. It was just terrifying, it was a case of just trying to keep people calm. People were white, people were crying, screaming."

The body of a sixth victim of the tragedy has been found on the ship.

The search for any survivors continued until it had to be suspended in early afternoon after the vessel shifted a few inches in rough seas. Later, with the weather improving, the search resumed.

Costa Cruises are also concerned about the 500,000 gallons of fuel on board which are in 17 separate tanks.

Allan Graveson, senior national secretary of the ships' masters' union, Nautilus, said large liners such as the Costa Concordia were "inherently unstable".

Operators of such ships were "putting profits before safety" and loading them with too many decks, he added.

But Robert Ashdown, the European Cruise Council's technical, environment and operations director, said Mr Graveson's view was "just not right" and big ships were "more stable than they have ever been".

And David Balston, the UK Chamber of Shipping's safety and environment director, said safety regulations were constantly updated to take account of large vessels.

Costa Cruises owner Carnival, the world's largest cruise operator, said the disaster would wipe £62 million from its profits this year.

Shares in the company fell 21% at one point.

Giglio Mayor Sergio Ortelli said hopes of finding any of the missing still alive were minimal, the Italian press reported.
He added that the only hope was that bubbles of air had formed within the ship.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK

The captain of the wrecked cruise ship which hit rocks off Italy made "an unapproved, unauthorised" deviation to his route, the liner's owners have said. As the death toll in the disaster rose to s...
The captain of the wrecked cruise ship which hit rocks off Italy made "an unapproved, unauthorised" deviation to his route, the liner's owners have said. As the death toll in the disaster rose to s...
Filed by Felicity A Morse  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 79
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:00 AM on 01/19/2012
I have sailed on Costa before and felt very safe. I also sailed on Carnival and felt safe. Of course they blame the Capt., who else can they blame? I am truly sry for the losses and feel such apathy for the families.I know this must have been teriable for the cruisers.But there should have been some sort of sonor or something to show that they were in danger, This is merely a man he can't see what is not presented to him. I am sure he wouldn't put his job or his passengers on the line for a mere wave. There is more to it than we are hearing. Yes he left but I am sure he was in shock. After all he is human and must carry the lives he lost on his ship forever.What about drunk drivers? At least he was there on the bridge. and not impaired he made a bad bad judgement call to the best of his knowledge that ended in tragady, It's a shame but its the real world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
11:12 AM on 01/17/2012
Maybe the captain is related to Gordon Brown?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
11:11 AM on 01/17/2012
Was the captain relayed to the one on the Titanic?
10:36 AM on 01/17/2012
You have a captain showing off, a company instantly and publicly blaming him, and leaking details of the criminal case against him to the press, and a ship that capsized after a pretty minor collision, thank goodness in shallow water - who in their right minds would travel with these people now?
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
10:59 AM on 01/17/2012
You can extend that argument to riding on cruise ships in general.

It was quite a sizeable collision. There's still a house-sized rock sticking out of the good side.
09:28 AM on 01/17/2012
More stable than they've ever been?
I wonder if they said that about the Mary Rose?
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
10:06 AM on 01/17/2012
It was unsinkable. I suspect the accident investigation left no fingernail unpulled though.
09:13 AM on 01/17/2012
I worked for an Italian drilling company in the 1990's and will never forget the cacophony of sound form the so-called Italian managers who where nevertheless still non-essential crew as they argued as to why they should be on the first helicopter rather than in the second helicoper to take them back to Aberdeen. We all lived but there is more.

In those days we had lifeboat drills where we had to get inside the lifeboat for a talk about emergency equipment and what to do etc. The extra weight of the crew inside on one occasion caused a small creaking sound which moved on one accept the senior Italian Toolpusher, and a person who we would have depended on during any emergency for orders and for guidance.

He rushed out of the lifeboat like a rocket propelled jack-in-the-box and then run away. This cause a member of the largely British crew in the lifeboat to say, "Italian book of war heroes - smallest book on Earth".
11:40 AM on 01/17/2012
Oh ofcourse the "Italian book of war heroes" the second most smallest book on earth after the book of famous male British LOVERS.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Squiriferous
Annoying everybody on Huffington Post since 2011
08:50 AM on 01/17/2012
I love it when people are doing something super-dumb to impress somebody... and then disaster strikes. Bwahahaha.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
08:00 AM on 01/17/2012
Never mind the investigations, ordinary people have already given their accounts as to what really happened, after all, they were right there. This celebrity Gigolo, was entertaining when the crucial manoeuvre of the ship was at it's most serious negotiation. Plus he was one of the first away, as he left the majority of terrified people to fend for themselves. Official statistics can and do get covered up, the truth is out before it ever got started. This is why the owners have openly blamed the Captain, sad but true...
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
09:14 AM on 01/17/2012
Inexpert eye witnesses are not usually the best guide to events. Hence, the slew of `no lights, bump' reports, rather than the almost certain actual events: `bump, no lights'.

In the circumstances, the crew did well to get it beached/arocked rather than sunk in deeper water.

The investigation process in italy does however have inadequate separation between finding cause and finding fault. Usually, a safety agency will produce an accident report, detailing causes, contributory factors and safety recommendations before any criminal trial is set. When the investigation process is under a magistrate, the most important first part can become a legal arguing ground rather than a useful inquiry into lessons to learn.

The owners blamed the captain to try to reduce their bad publicity. Very honorable. They selected him, and organized safety oversight and ongoing training. If he really did try to shoot a 10-m deep, 70-m wide passage in a 80,000-ton fast-food restaurant, then they can't claim to be free of liability.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
09:25 AM on 01/17/2012
Therefore, you never believe what you see or hear applies to everyone, no it doesn't. All the hierarchy of authority, ie, the coppers, depend heavily on eye witnesses at the scene of any accident. What you are saying, is that those unfortunate people had clouded judgements under stress conditions. Let me tell you as a professional rescuer, the versions of fear could never be more lucid and very real, at that very time, it is called survival...Never to forget or become clouded by doubt....
06:28 AM on 01/17/2012
The main question, after what the old man was doing deviating of course, is why did it list so quickly to stbd, were the water tight doors open, allso how quickly will this boat be sailing on the high seas again renamed and reflagged, look at the herald of free enterprise, a year later the dubai enterprise, the exxon valdez, renamed the esso mediterranian???? how many passengers will realise in a years time what there wineing and dining on???? food for thought.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
09:17 AM on 01/17/2012
It's hard to see how it's ever going anywhere again. Bets have to be on leaving the site in bits.

Herald of Free Enterprise was scrapped. Exxon Valdez was holed, but only slightly damaged.
09:54 AM on 01/17/2012
thinkcreeps
genuine reply, unlike tontogary, i was on a stolt ship at anchor of rashid dubai, the chief off asked if i new the ship in front of us, dubai enterprise, the old herald of free?
Thanks
05:07 AM on 01/17/2012
We shall see whether or not the company is right on this. What isn't in doubt however is that this huge, modern vessel with four thousand passengers on board, suddenly tipped over onto its side. As it was in shallow water its collapse was halted at a near 90' angle. In deep water the consequences could have meant at least hundreds and very possibly thousands of deaths.

In its design, construction and safety features this ship is one of many in service and this is the really big issue that needs to be explained.
photo
ljmck
Stand Up, Show Up, Speak Up
04:01 AM on 01/17/2012
The company would say that, wouldn't it. I'll wait for the investigation, thank you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
degirl
10:06 PM on 01/16/2012
costa is owned by carnivale. i see lots of lawsuits
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
05:23 AM on 01/17/2012
In very expensive jurisdictions.
09:50 PM on 01/16/2012
surley this ship id controlled by computer not any one on the bridge if it was under hand control that person will be in big trouble for at least 25 years these shioe have been driven by computer
dont ne to wuick in blaming the captain
07:15 AM on 01/17/2012
The above comment has been written on a computer, but the writer, and not the computer, remains responsible for the numerous errors. Computers do nothing of themselves, slapdash programmers, on the other hand - .
09:35 PM on 01/16/2012
Schettino is Italian for " roller skate " I I think this guy might just lose his wheels !!!!!
09:33 PM on 01/16/2012
Where were all the other officers, there are more officers than just the Captain and his assistant? Why wasn't life jacket safety drill not completed as the ship started on the cruise? I've never cruised when the safety drill was not done as the cruise started. My sons comments on hearing about the ships problems - Bet it was an Italian ship!

These cruise companies are getting too big, too many ships, wonder where the buck will stop on this tragedy? The company spokesman was deciding the outcome of the cause at the press talk, thought this would have been held back for the enquiry?