Green Taxes 'Artificially Inflating Energy Bills', Say MPs

Energy Bills Green Carbon Stealth Tax

PA/The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 26/01/2012 08:40 Updated: 26/01/2012 08:40

Households face artificially inflated electricity bills under a government move to make businesses greener, an influential committee has warned.

Setting tougher carbon penalties than the rest of the Europe will also have a "devastating effect" on heavy industry while failing to have any overall impact on emissions, according to MPs.

In a critical report, the Commons Energy and Climate Change committee warned the Treasury against revenue raising exercises "disguised as a green policy".

The government announced last year it was setting a carbon floor price - a minimum cost businesses have to pay for emissions - after the price under the European-wide emissions trading system bottomed out following a collapse in demand sparked by the economic crisis.

By "going it alone" on setting a minimum levy, the UK faces the prospect of industry relocating to elsewhere in Europe, MPs warned.

Higher carbon costs also mean electricity prices will increase as the UK ends up effectively subsidising other European states, they added.

Committee chairman Tim Yeo said: "The Chancellor was right to say we won't save the planet by putting the UK out of business.
"Ironically, however, it is the Treasury's decision to set a Carbon Price Floor that could result in industry and electricity production relocating to other EU countries.

"Unless the price of carbon is increased at an EU-wide level, taking action on our own will have no overall effect on emissions other than to out-source them.

"A revenue raising exercise disguised as a green policy won't help anybody, the price of carbon has to be increased at an EU level to kick-start investment in clean energy."

Energy generators and heavy industry, such as steel and ceramics, face an "exorbitant" top-up tax of up to £25 per tonne of CO2 under current plans, according to the report.

Although UK emissions will be reduced under the Treasury plans, overall levels across Europe may not, the report said.

It calls for EU targets to be toughened up to deliver a 30% emissions reduction target by 2020 and an overall 60-80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

Yeo added: "Instead of going it alone, the Chancellor would be better-off working with other European Governments to make the EU Emissions Trading System more effective as a whole.

"Before phase three starts next year, EU countries must set aside pollution permits to end the glut that has caused the price of carbon to collapse."

A Treasury spokesman said: "The Chancellor has made clear that the UK should go no slower but also no faster than other European countries in cutting emissions.

"To do this we need to reduce our emissions in the way that works best for circumstances in this country. The Carbon Price Floor is vital in reducing uncertainty and creating incentives for investment in low carbon electricity generation now so we have lower emissions in the future.

"At the Autumn Statement, the Government recognised the challenges faced by energy-intensive industries in the transition to a low-carbon economy and announced an ambitious £250 million package of support.

"This includes £100 million in compensation for the added indirect costs of the Carbon Price Floor."

Last year environmentalists warned household electricity bills could be pushed up by around £300 a year by 2020 as a result of a continued reliance on fossil fuels to provide energy.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK POLITICS

Households face artificially inflated electricity bills under a government move to make businesses greener, an influential committee has warned. Setting tougher carbon penalties than the rest of th...
Households face artificially inflated electricity bills under a government move to make businesses greener, an influential committee has warned. Setting tougher carbon penalties than the rest of th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:35 AM on 04/26/2012
A government is a cash hungy machine it has to be to support its lavish life style and that of it friends
peak oil i believe was reached in 2005 ,you would think that any one with an idea to save power or generate it would be welcome ,but the reality is they are not if i were to save 50% on my electric bill with an invention i have ,i would get hit with a mack truck ,imagine the power company taking a 50% hit in profits ,same with the government they would loose 50% of the tax on the company ,the government dont like loosing revenue i would be squashed like a bug .

You can see the difference for your self ,put up a small wind geny in the garden and the council will be on you like a ton of bricks ,put up a giant mobile phone relay aerial and there is no problem
why is this well if the council own the house they get payed every month by the phone company
why do you think it is that every school hospital and or owned council building has all of the aerial,s on that roof ,its called MONEY . and if you want to come up with something thats good for the planet something that saves the person money on heating / power /or water you will be an enemy of the state ,their motive is money not the planet !
06:00 PM on 03/14/2012
Recently New Scientist has put out a couple of issues that read together show just how science is addressing the green issues
The first article was about batteries; it envisaged a situation where brickwork could be replaced by batteries to provide power storage
The second about PV this implied the panels couldbe made more efficient and cheaper
I lnow that these projects are still concepts but if successful there are wide ranging implications for the way we heat our homes
Elsewhere the possibilty of a car body made of carbon fibre that was also the battery driving four motors which charged during braking
My reason for posting this comment is that we need to see our politicians spending more time evaluating these scheme rather than thinking up ways to tax us
10:07 AM on 04/26/2012
Solar panel bodywork has been out for years ,charging via braking is the same .whats not discussed is a lot of inventions have been bought up by the oil companies /power companies
when things get dire with oil running out ,those companies will sell you an answer to your problem
07:40 PM on 02/03/2012
POINT BREAK
Yes we did need to make vehicles with less emissions they started with small things then went into sensors ,cat converters ,more complicated sensors stricter mots then they came out particle filters and a whole raft of legislation to put vehicles off the road and grab more taxes in the process ,thing is if an engine is being made to choke its self to death and uses more fuel and gets less performance it wont be long before we will all be towing a very large cylinder behind us on a trailer to collect any fumes that we may put out .

If you want to tax vehicles on emissions ,dont keep lowering the levels every year ,we have now reached the point where even the manufactures are saying we cant make the vehicles compliant !
If we had horses to get around on, they tax every time it everytime it passed wind !
04:55 PM on 01/27/2012
The best information available seems to indicate that 12% of household energy bills are due to green taxes so the 5% recent cuts and the 5% VAT are not really in the running when people talk about 'not being able to keep themselves warm'!

Scrap the energy taxes, allow industry to manufacture and employ people, allow people to keep their homes warm and let the tax payer see the real cost of alternative energy sources. Yes, insulate houses to save energy, yes look at alternative energy sources to save fossil fuels, yes look at alternative energy sources (Thorium reactors, hydrogen powered vehicles etc.) but why are we paying taxes so that electric cars can get a £5000 subsidy so that every 3 - 4 years that can change their batteries and also contribute to CO2 production whilst being charged?

Why are we paying massive taxes so that wind farms can be paid not to make electricity? What is peculiar about the UK climate when either very hot or very cold? An anticyclone. What is special about anticyclones? No wind! So at times of maximum need, there is no power and we must rely on nuclear, gas, oil and coal! Congratulations to the green movement. You can con some of the people but you cannot con us all the time!"
03:40 PM on 01/26/2012
Article really says nothing because it does not put anything into perspective. Electricity rates are going to go up - OK. From what to what ?? From 10 cents to 1.00 or from 10 cents to .14 cents - big difference. Also electricity is a very small percentage of the average family budget - less than 10%. Heat and hot water are between 70-80%....so even if it doubled it would not be very significant.

Needs elaboration to show significance or non-significance
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:37 PM on 01/26/2012
Wonder if all the green taxes will cause the massive inflation due at the end of this year. Wait I see the future the inflation figure will be adjusted to remove/take account of the green taxes and such
10:10 AM on 04/26/2012
what do you know about racing jags ?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
01:10 PM on 01/26/2012
They need to make household energy bills more transparent so we can see what we're paying for. Household energy bills show the amount of VAT paid so why not show the amount of "green" tax too?
10:45 AM on 04/26/2012
[ The true price of one unit of power ] = take the whole of the bill be it gas or electric and divide the sum total of the bill including the vat [turn it into pennies ] by the amount of units on the bill this will at least give you the true cost of a unit of power ,thats about as transparent as you will get
11:14 AM on 01/26/2012
Tell us something new. Every time someone suggests energy tax we find that us the customers of the utility companies have to pay more and more.
09:44 AM on 01/26/2012
Here we go again and knowing the clowns we've got, the UK will end up subsidising China and India......