Michael Gove's Proposed Changes To School Hours Are 'Condescending To Teachers'

Teacher Interview

First Posted: 15/02/2012 12:01 Updated: 15/02/2012 12:22

Michael Gove's proposal to extend school hours in a bid to benefit poorer children have been slammed as "condescending" by a teacher.

The education secretary recently said teachers should welcome the touted initiative, which would see school days extended and summer holidays cut.

"If you [teachers] love your job then there is, I think, absolutely nothing to complain about in making sure you have more of a chance to do it well," he said at the time.

But, when questioned in a poll by Teacher Support Network in 2010, 96% of teaching staff, school leaders and lecturers said their current workload had a negative effect on their health and wellbeing.

Gove's comments prompted one teacher, Emily*, who teaches reception children in Suffolk, to ask whether the minister had "even spent more than 10 minutes in school?".

She told The Huffington Post UK that Gove "has absolutely no understanding of what a teacher does on a daily basis".

"What Gove doesn't seem to understand is the hours teachers put in outside of school time.

"In the hours between teaching and home most teachers are marking, running after school clubs or in meetings.

"When teachers get home most spend a further two to three hours planning, preparing and assessing lessons. Then at weekends most people spend part of the time getting everything ready for the next week. Going away for the weekend becomes a logistical nightmare."

Emily, who has worked in non-teaching jobs longer than she has been a teacher, says she remembers working in an office job where "I would turn the computer off at 5.30 on Friday and not think about work until nine on a Monday morning".

"With teaching," she adds, "you never stop thinking about it.

"His comments make me think he has never met a teacher. Does he honestly think we walk out of the door at 3.30pm and go home only to walk back in at 9am?"

Emily, whose school has broken up for half term, says the week is a much need mental break.

"It allows me to have some time where I am not a teacher. I love my job. I don't want to do another job. Nothing else gives you the sense of achievement of seeing a child grow, progress and succeed but the holidays allow me to stop."

"Teaching is emotionally exhausting. Most people don't appreciate the emotional investment a teacher has in the class, especially in primary school.

"When you have nurtured these children and seen them grow….I cry at the end of each year because I feel I am sending them off into the big wide world. The holidays are needed for an emotional break."

But, most importantly, she describes the impact of longer days and shorter holidays for the people who this is all really about: the children.

"They have been forgotten here. When would they see their parents? When do they play?

"Ultimately," she concludes, "I cannot see what can be gained from doing this other than providing free child care.

"Which is something we teachers are at pains to point out we do not do."

*Emily's name has been changed to preserve her anonymity.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK UNIVERSITIES & EDUCATION

Michael Gove's proposal to extend school hours in a bid to benefit poorer children have been slammed as "condescending" by a teacher. The education secretary recently said teachers should welcome t...
Michael Gove's proposal to extend school hours in a bid to benefit poorer children have been slammed as "condescending" by a teacher. The education secretary recently said teachers should welcome t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:18 PM on 02/19/2012
Teachers work long enough hours preparing and planning lessons. Their home lifer is not their own. I left teaching 10 years ago because I was working 60 hours a week. I work in an office for a third of the pay but at least my health is good. Too many teachers leave because of stress and breakdowns. And if the pupils have to work longer hours, when do they get the chance to play and relax. It'll be like going back to the dark ages.
06:34 PM on 02/17/2012
Our Ministerial system amazes me, The PM just says to the person of choice you are from this day an expert in the field of education and a new Minister is born.
Here we have Gove seemingly speaking with authority on a subject he knows absolutely nothing about. This a criticism of all ministerial posts, though this one I think illustrates my concern most.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tabiyeh
Macro-Bio?
06:01 PM on 02/17/2012
This is interesting to read, I do not generally follow news on education, which is a regret for myself. However I was just thinking the other day that shorter class lengths with a more intesive teaching style might be much more beneficial to both students and teachers, allowing teachers to have more time to recuperate. I'm not an expert and not saying this idea is flawless just kind of throwing it out there as a possibility.
05:58 PM on 02/15/2012
Whatever he extends it to people are probably working longer than the extension. If he puts it in highly defined restricted hours then teachers can just work to those - not much would get done.
04:59 PM on 02/15/2012
Sometime in the near future........

Gove: " Unfortunately due to me being an insignificant little follower who's always trying to impress the prefects... I mean cabinet members.. we are going to have to cut teacher's pay. But as you all love your jobs so much that won't be a problem will it?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:39 AM on 02/16/2012
No. No. No. " As you love your jobs so much, you'll do it for free! After all, we have an army of unemployed people who we will oblige to do it as part of 'work experience' or as a 'placement' and look how cheap they are! Next? Nurses!"
04:37 PM on 02/15/2012
You love your job.So do it more.Does Gove think that this idea makes sense
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
04:33 PM on 02/15/2012
Well done, 'Emily'. The end of this horrendous politician as education chief can't come soon enough imo. He's a very damaging influence and the impact of what he's done already will take years to repair.
12:23 PM on 02/15/2012
I think you are forgetting the students here, for my age (16) longer hours would be annoying but we could live. For younger years, i cant see them surviving.
05:52 PM on 02/16/2012
I agree, primary school children just don't have the attention spans to make this worthwhile. My son's school have cut out afternoon playtime and the children come out buzzing with energy and needing fresh air - they just aren't built to be still for long periods of time. It's quality not quantity that's needed.