Rich People 'More Likely To Lie, Cheat And Break The Law'

Upper Classes Cheat

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 28/02/2012 12:03 Updated: 28/02/2012 12:57

People from privileged, wealthy backgrounds are more likely to be dishonest and unethical than their poorer counterparts, a study has found.

From depriving children of sweets and reckless driving to lying for financial gain, the researchers at the University of California found that upper-class participants were more prone to immoral behaviour.

Subjects were divided into groups according to their social backgrounds and asked to carry out a series of tasks to test their scruples. The tests focused on traits such as honesty and consideration for others.

It was found that the wealthier the participant, the more likely they were to break the law, make unethical decisions and take valued goods from others.

They were also more likely to lie in a negotiation, cheat in order to attain a prize and endorse unethical behaviour at work.

The researchers concluded that the unethical tendencies of upper-class individuals were partly down to greed. They also were deemed to be more self-absorbed, less aware of others and less able to identify the emotions of others.

They went on to say that the theory could partly explain the banking crisis, as self-confident, wealthy bankers would be more likely to make reckless decisions.

The participants were first asked about their wealth, schooling, social background, religious persuasions and attitudes to money in an attempt to establish their perceived social class.

The tasks they performed included conducting a fake job interview in which they knew that the job might become redundant within six months. They were encouraged to conceal this from the candidate to test their compliance in unethical behavior and dishonesty.

They were also given the opportunity to cheat in a self-scoring dice game in order to gain a cash prize.

Another test assessed the social status of drivers based on their appearance and the make of their car. Those who were categorised as wealthier were more likely to drive through pedestrian crossings without stopping and cut up other drivers.

Lead researcher, Dr Paul Piff found conflicting reasons for the responses, the Telegraph reports: "On the one hand, lower-class individuals live in environments defined by fewer resources, greater threat and more uncertainty.

"It stands to reason, therefore, that lower-class individuals may be more motivated to behave unethically to increase their resources or overcome their disadvantage.

"A second line of reasoning, however, suggests the opposite prediction: namely, that the upper class may be more disposed to the unethical.

"Greater resources, freedom, and independence from others among the upper class give rise to self-focused social cognitive tendencies, which we predict will facilitate unethical behaviour.

"Historical observation lends credence to this idea. For example, the recent economic crisis has been attributed in part to the unethical actions of the wealthy.

"Religious teachings extol the poor and admonish the rich with claims like, 'It will be hard for a rich person to enter the kingdom of heaven'."

The link between economics and ethics has been the subject of numerous studies. According to research presented at the 105th Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, the more financially dependant a man is on his female partner, the more likely he is to cheat on her. However, conversely, the more dependent a women is on her partner, the less likely she is to be unfaithful, said researcher, Christin Munsch, a sociology Ph.D. candidate at Cornell University.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK LIFESTYLE

People from privileged, wealthy backgrounds are more likely to be dishonest and unethical than their poorer counterparts, a study has found. From depriving children of sweets and reckless driving ...
People from privileged, wealthy backgrounds are more likely to be dishonest and unethical than their poorer counterparts, a study has found. From depriving children of sweets and reckless driving ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 118
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
mainecoonkat4
Never give up! Never surrender!
23:41 on 01/03/2012
I'm sure that you can find dishonesty in any economic strata, any political background. However, I have to ask that if rich are so much more dishonest, why aren't they over-represented in prisons? Here in the US, we have the problem of hundreds of thousands of illegal visitors crossing borders every year, then the added problem of them using bogus, illegal identities to stay, and still more problems with them siphoning huge federal money with their schemes to stay. Not only unethical, but illegal.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
messy
artist, writer, adventurer
20:05 on 29/02/2012
You can find a study that can prove just about anything.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pakaal
Pigs, in cages, on antibiotics
20:35 on 29/02/2012
I suppose the question that arises from that statement is whether or not there are studies that provide evidence that refutes or contradicts the findings of this study. I'm not seeing anything online that leads in that direction so far.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
messy
artist, writer, adventurer
21:45 on 29/02/2012
Well, this is a new attack on those who have wealth. No one has tried to do a pseudo-scientific study to show that only the poor are honest before.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
earwicker7
19:13 on 29/02/2012
I've always said that someone who makes $1,000,000 a year is primarily being paid that amount to sell his/her soul by doing stuff that people who aren't sociopaths won't do, such as firing an entire department just to make an extra .05% profit that quarter. I always view ambition as a negative attribute (although laziness is just as bad), but Americans seem to think it is the end-all, be-all of human existence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
catbyte
Anishinaabe in MI
19:05 on 29/02/2012
"In other news, water is wet..."

And people wonder why we need to regulate corporations?!?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
earwicker7
19:02 on 29/02/2012
Does this surprise anyone? After my experiences going to both a lower/middle-class public school and a super-elite private school, I can tell you that this article is spot on.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Novotny
What happened to Democracy?
18:27 on 29/02/2012
And this is something we all couldn't figure out on our own? Or at least most of us with rational heads on our shoulders, which would rule out Republicans however, as they idolize the 1%. Take one look at the financial melt down and that should give us good enough insight into the personalities that ran the world economy into the gutter for their own personal gains.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Yorksgal
Violence doesn't end violence, it extends it.
18:13 on 29/02/2012
And when they do get caught their sentences are much lighter than someone who is of a different background.

Always remember growing up and told the poor commit crimes, but the rich commit "high jinks".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Martini
Your micro-bio is empty
17:36 on 29/02/2012
Quick, someone alert the Rick Romero news team!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
16:34 on 29/02/2012
In other news water is wet, fire is hot and the sun just rose in the east.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony Wang
Practicing random acts of reality based thinking
16:01 on 29/02/2012
So much for these people being noble people who just want to create jobs for the middle class if only we would cut their taxes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Canary503
An opinionated Iowan
15:10 on 29/02/2012
And the more political power the very wealthy amass, helped along by such things as Citizens United, the more corruption will affect our everyday lives, drive our dissatisfaction and,even, outrage. We will be helpless to change anything because the crooks will have all the power. Must.separate.money. from.policy.now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tikotheboy
Entrepreneur from Chicago.
15:07 on 29/02/2012
I live in Chicago and in my twenties I had many friends and roommates who thought I was silly because of my morality, they were brought up in wealthy families and because I was raised in a less than wealthy family somehow I just didn't measure up. It's funny though, now with facebook we have tracked each other down and I seem to be not only doing better financially but in other ways as well.
11:56 on 29/02/2012
It would explain why the burden of the crisi has been shifted to everybody except the ones who did create it ;). More seriously, it made me think of debate I watched on the super-richs and whether they contribute enough to society - have a look here: http://iai.tv/video/the-global-aristocracy
09:49 on 29/02/2012
Yes this is true and we all no it anyway
I mix in different areas of London all the time and I've notice a major comparison with the upper class and the way the men act
GENTLEMEN - yeah right, they have a sleezey manner for I get what I want attitude its not hot
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jim Schreiber
The scientific method is my Bible.
09:38 on 29/02/2012
Film at 11.