Eating A Red Meat-Rich Diet Can Kill, Warn Experts

The Huffington Post UK   First Posted: 12/03/2012 20:03 Updated: 13/03/2012 09:08

Eating a red meat-rich diet not only raises cholesterol and blood pressure levels but can also have potentially lethal health risks, according to new research.

Researchers from Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, warn that high consumption of red meat, especially processed meats, can dramatically increase heart disease and cancer risks.

During the study, researchers looked at the data of 121,342 men and women over a 20-year period.

Their eating and diet habits were questioned and after two decades, 23,926 deaths were recorded, including 5,910 from heart disease and 9,364 from cancer.

Scientists claim they found a striking link between red meat consumption and premature death. When the deaths were divided into specific causes, researchers discovered that eating any kind of red meat increased the chances of dying from heart disease and cancer by 21%.

Researchers added that a daily serving of unprocessed red meat, for example beef, pork or lamb the size of a deck of cards, raised the risk of death by 13%.

In comparison, processed meats, like a hot dog or bacon, caused death risks soaring by 20%.

“This study provides clear evidence that regular consumption of red meat, especially processed meat, contributes substantially to premature death,” says senior author professor Frank Hu in a statement.

“On the other hand, choosing more healthful source of protein in place of red meat can confer significant health benefits by reducing chronic disease morbidity and mortality.”

The study urges people to cut out red meat from their diet as it can lead to significant health benefits as well as slashing death rates by 7%. Scientists from the study believe that if red meat consumption is reduced, it could prevent 9.3% of deaths in men and 7.6% of deaths in women.

Nuts, for example, are said to reduce mortality rates by 20%, low-fat dairy products lowered it by 10% and whole grains by 14%.

The daily recommended allowance of red meat, as suggested by the World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF), should be stripped down to 500g a week.

Dr Rachel Thompson, from the WCRF, says: "This study strengthens the body of evidence which shows a link between red meat and chronic diseases such as cancer and heart disease. The research itself seems solid and is based on two large scale cohort studies monitored over a long period of time.

"The study calculates that lives would be saved if people replaced red meat with healthy protein sources such as fish, poultry, nuts and legumes and we would like to see more people replacing red meat with these type of foods."

However, not everyone agrees with these findings, as Dr Carrie Ruxton from the Meat Advisory Panel (MAP) believes that red meat is essential to our diet.

“This US study looked at associations between high intakes of red meat and risk of mortality, finding a positive association between the two. However, the study was observational, not controlled, and so cannot be used to determine cause and effect.

“The authors’ conclusion that swapping a portion of red meat for poultry or fish each week may lower mortality risk was based only on a theoretical model. This conflicts with evidence from controlled trials.”

Dr Ruxton added that red meat is an important source of iron, zinc and vitamin D.

Victoria Taylor, Senior Heart Health Dietitian at the British Heart Foundation (BHF), adds: “This study links red meat to deaths from CVD and cancer. Researchers suggest that the saturated fat content of red meat may be to blame. However, the study does not differentiate between leaner and fattier cuts of meat, so it would be useful to know if the association is the same when this is taken into account.

“Red meat can still be eaten as part of a balanced diet, but go for the leaner cuts and use healthier cooking methods such as grilling. If you eat processed meats like bacon, ham, sausages or burgers several times a week, add variation to your diet by substituting these for other protein sources such as fish, poultry, beans or lentils.”

According to the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN), the average meat consumption in the UK is currently in line with Government recommendations.

In the UK, red meat contributes 32% of the total dietary intake in men and 27% for women, and overall, 17% of the UK’s dietary iron intake is from red meat consumption.

“In summary, this paper should not be used to dissuade people from reducing their current intake of red meat when it provides essential nutrients that are required as part of a healthy balanced diet,” says Dr Ruxton.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Peanut Butter

    Spread peanut butter on wholemeal toast or crackers as a protein-rich snack. Peanuts are an excellent source of protein, with one tablespoon containing about four grams of protein.

  • Cottage Cheese

    A half cup of cottage cheese contains around 16 grams of protein, yet only has 102 calories and two grams of fat, as opposed to other cheese, where the protein benefits are counteracted by the high fat content. If you're not too keen on the cheesy taste, add a handful of berries or fruit to the bowl, or spread it on a wholemeal cracker for a savoury snack.

  • Egg Whites

    Egg white contains four grams of protein and is cholesterol-free. Whip up an egg white omelette for your lunch or some scrambled egg sandwiches for a tasty way to boost your protein intake.

  • Tuna

    Tuna fish is a great source of protein, with one tin can containing 25 grams of protein. Snack on it straight from the tin if you like it enough, or mix it with sweetcorn and a tiny bit of low-fat mayonaise to make a spread that you can have with pitta bread or crackers.

  • Lentils

    Although lentils can taste a little bland on their own, they can be easily added to your lunchtime salad or into a hearty homemade soup. Lentils are a great source of protein and an easy way to boost your protein levels. One cup of lentils equals to around 18 grams of protein.

  • Quinoa

    A single cup of quinoa contains around 18g of protein and it can be easily added to homemade granola bars or cookies if you fancied a sweeter snack.

  • Beans

    Beans contain a high level of protein and can be eaten in all different ways. Why not make a bean dip by blending different types together mixed with a little bit of olive oil? Or add them to a homemade soup and sprinkle them on your lunchtime salad.

  • Nuts

    A handful of raw, unsalted nuts, like almonds, hazelnuts, walnuts are great snacks to keep handy throughout the day. You only need a small handful for your daily allowance on these, but they are high in fiber, protein, and "good" fats.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST UK LIFESTYLE

 
 
  • Comments
  • 163
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
04:05 AM on 12/28/2012
All I ever eat is beef or pork. I'm allergic to fish and seafood, greens go right through me, and I can't stand chicken! At it way too much as a kid and food poisoning from KFC turned me from it for good. I've always had low blood pressure and below avg cholesterol, good and bad. So red meat doesn't really hurt you since that's all I ever eat for lunch or dinner with a few veggies. Course I eat small portions, so it's really all about your consumption.
05:40 PM on 06/17/2012
Would be interesting to see the life expectancy rates due to meat consumption in countries like Argentina, seeing as meat is a staple part of their diet, far more than countries like the UK.
08:29 PM on 06/14/2012
I don't really have anything to say about this as I eat red meat in moderation, but I need to vent and here it is.

My husband, baby & I are staying with my mother-in-law because our house is up for sale and we're waiting until it sells to buy a new place. I'm a Northeasterner who's been cooking from scratch since I was 8--Chinese/Japanese/Italian/Indian/Middle Eastern food is generally what I go for. MIL is Midwestern. She makes lasagna using cottage cheese. She suggested McDonald's for dinner one night. What? She rarely eats vegetables unless smothered in Velveeta. She made what was essentially a KFC bowl meal at home using instant potatoes and thawed KFC gravy. I made pizza from scratch and she hovered over me and got out no less than 10 more ingredients to load on top of it. She had nachos for dinner tonight. Sour cream on everything. She uses Miracle Whip and I make my own may.

I made her feel bad because I refused to let her feed my 11 month old white toasted bread or instant potatoes.

I'm very grateful to her--but I'm going to lose my mind. It is so different how people out here eat. The family was absolutely shocked that I made my own gravy over Christmas.

One bright spot is that she does want to learn and I've managed to get her diabetic numbers down. http://www.rxgs.com
02:44 PM on 03/15/2012
All you have to do to realize that these studies are basically worthless is to look at the example of HRT therapy and heart disease. Back in the early 1990s, the Nurses Health Study (Yes, the exact same data that was part of this meat study) was analyzed with similar methods as was done in the meat study. And, there was a correlation between hormone replacement therapy and lowered incidence of heart disease. To be clear, the study took the data from the NHS and corrected for various factors (just like in the meat study did!) and found that nurses who were on HRT were 50% less likely to die from heart disease.

To make a long story short, some real science was done a decade later, and this showed that HRT therapy actually leads to a 30% increase in risk of heart disease. Wait, what?

So, the observational study showed a large benefit to having HRT, which was subsequently shown to be completely incorrect. In other words, these kinds of studies are basically unreliable at this level. If you see 4x the risk or higher (in other words, 400%, not 13%), then maybe you have grounds to start making some claims. Otherwise, it is complete fallacy. Please disregard this study, as it basically is akin to saying nothing.
photo
surfinnonreality
EIT Excellence in Trolling Thanks for the talking
10:08 AM on 03/15/2012
Humans have a 100% mortality rate. No matter what you eat, you are still going to be part of that percentage. If you worry about every bite of food it will be a miserable life. If you enjoy what you eat, you will have an enjoyable life. Red meat is just the latest food scare. Eggs and coffee have been scare items. I never took them off my diet and I won't take red meat off my diet. When a new study shows red meat is good for you, I won't care about that either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
psnyder325
Yep, I'm a Socialist. Deal.
10:00 AM on 03/15/2012
Red meat was never meant in the human diet to be eaten daily. The problem is that we Americans go overboard on EVERYTHING and think that, if a little is good, more is better. It is part of our inborn greed as Americans. And this greed and gluttony is having a natural effect. It is killing us. "Live simply so others can simply live." Stop doing 5 planet living and try one planet living. If you want to eat steak...fine. Once every couple of weeks isn't going to prematurely kill you. But every night?? That is simple gluttony and people reap the natural consequences.
photo
PLDgyrl
We won Mitches!!!!!!!
04:07 AM on 03/15/2012
Yeah, yeah, yeah, notice the articles includes processed meat. Yeah if you each factory farmed, toxic beef all the time your not going to have good outcomes. Nothing is wrong with correctly raised pastured meat.
08:07 PM on 03/14/2012
Let's correct the headline.
It should read
"American Beef Dangerous"
British & Irish Beef, fed on grass, unlike American cattle which are fed on grain.have been shown to be safer.
Of course every type of food is good in moderation but harmful if overdone. It's just that American Beef has a lower safety limit than it's British equivalent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GaryNOVA
Fear My Micro-bio!!!!!!!!
07:10 PM on 03/14/2012
It's true guys. Sadly my father was randomly killed in a freak accident involving a half ton of frozen steaks falling from a 6 story building.
06:05 PM on 03/14/2012
Is this article suggesting that if we don't eat red meat we won't die? I find that questionable.
05:59 PM on 03/14/2012
This guy does a pretty good job breaking it down..
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/will-eating-red-meat-kill-you/#axzz1p78eSTDK
watch out world
Frankly My Dear, I don't give a ......
05:08 PM on 03/14/2012
These one-sided studies are so annoying. Especially when it comes to beef -or any meat for that matter. The big beef scare!! Ooohhhh, scary!

Why doesn't someone do a study on grass-fed beef? Those of us who eat grass-fed don't need you to tell us that all meat is bad because some dolt decided to study corn-fed beef and claim it is bad for your health. No duh!! Of course something fed GMO corn and soy isn't going to be good for you. GMOs have been proven to change cell structure. Pig farmers have gone out of business because GMOs made their pigs sterile, so what do you think it is doing physiologically to cattle?

Then of course, cows weren't meant to live on a diet of corn alone, so they become sick and then need drugs. So combine the fact that the cattle has been stressed out from living in a CAFO, drugged up because the diet he was forced to eat didn't sustain his body properly and throw in some GMO corn and soy, and OF COURSE THE MEAT WILL BE BAD FOR YOU!!!

Yet, the masses will listen to it and never seek further explanation. Whatever. More grass-fed meat for me! Someone get me a potato!!
04:14 PM on 03/14/2012
Tuna is not a "meat free" protein source. Tuna=fish=animal
03:59 PM on 03/14/2012
Fish: is it an animal, vegetable or mineral? I'm going to go out on a limb here and put it in the "animal" category thus making it a curious choice for your list of "meat-free foods rich in protein".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:48 PM on 03/14/2012
This article has inspired me to grill up a ribeye for dinner tonight.