Huffpost UK Politics uk

NHS Reforms Rejected By Royal College of Physicians

Posted: Updated:
Lord Howe called the vote 'disappointing'
Lord Howe called the vote 'disappointing'

The Royal College of Physicians (RCP) has voted overwhelmingly in favour to reject the Health and Social Care Bill as it stands.

On Friday it was announced that 69 per cent of those surveyed opted to reject the Bill with only six per cent accepting it.

The RCP conducted the survey ahead of the third reading of Secretary of State Andrew Lansley’s Bill in the House of Lords on the 19th March.

RCP president Sir Richard Thompson said: "We believe that this is the single biggest survey among the medical royal colleges, with the highest turnout, and while it shows there is a clear majority of RCP’s fellows and members who would personally reject the Bill, opinion is divided almost equally on whether the RCP should continue to critically engage or now call for the withdrawal of the Bill."

Health Minister Lord Howe said: "While it is disappointing that some members of the Royal College of Physicians have voted to reject the Bill, it is worth noting that only a third of the college's 25,000 members voted in this process, and under half of those members have asked for it to be withdrawn. This is just 17 per cent of the RCP membership.”

The RCP add their name to an ever increasing list of organisations that are opposed to the Bill including the British Medical Association and the Royal College of Midwives.

The results are yet another blow to the Bill which has seen fierce resistance from the House of Lords with the government having to offer numerous concessions in an attempt to get the Bill passed.

Recent amendments have seen the government capitulate to concerns that the Bill could amount to an effective privatisation of parts of the NHS leading to a two-tier health service.

Howe said: “"We have already strengthened the Health Bill following the listening exercise and have responded directly to the points raised by the Royal College of Physicians, including making clear that competition would only be used to benefit patients, never as an end in itself. “

RCP members were also asked to rate their main areas of concern regarding the Bill and the wider NHS with ‘lack of continuity of care’, ‘efficiency savings and reductions in NHS funding’ and ‘clinical staff shortages’ topping the list.

Thompson said: “The quality of care that patients receive is clearly at the core of physicians’ concerns and mirrors the key areas of the mission and objectives of the RCP.”

Around the Web

Welcome to NHS reforms from bmj.com

Modernisation of health and care | News, information and ...

NHS reforms live blog – Lords debate the health and social care bill ...

NHS reform - The British Medical Association

NHS reform: In depth news, commentary and analysis from the ...

Reform of the National Health Service - a chronology

Who supports these NHS reforms?

Ministers 'fully behind' Lansley and NHS reforms, says Cameron ...

Health and Social Care Bill 2011 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Can the NHS survive Andrew Lansley's health and social care bill reforms?

NHS reforms: seven in 10 hospital doctors reject bill

NHS reforms: the consultant cardiac surgeon's view

NHS reforms: the midwife's view

NHS reforms: Lib Dem divisions resurface as bill returns to parliament

NHS reforms: the hospital porter's view

NHS reforms: the social worker's view

NHS reforms: the clinical scientist's view

NHS reforms: the expert patients programme volunteer's view

NHS Reform Protestors Appeal To Queen To Intervene