Tesco: Where Did It Go Wrong?

PA/Huffington Post UK  |  Posted: 18/04/2012 07:28 Updated: 18/04/2012 07:39

Tesco
Tesco share price dropped £5bn earlier this year

Tesco saw £5bn wiped from its share price earlier this year after the supermarket giant warned on profits for the first time in two decades.

But while investors were given a rude awakening by the grim Christmas trading update, a failure to invest in pricing and store standards meant Tesco had begun to lose its way in the eyes of shoppers long before.

The business, started by Jack Cohen as a market stall in the East End of London in 1919, enjoyed a meteoric rise in the past two decades as it overtook a struggling Sainsbury's to become the nation's biggest retailer.

However, its performance in the UK since the financial crisis has been weaker, as its lead has been eroded by resurgent rivals Sainsbury's, Asda and Morrisons, while German discounters Aldi and Lidl have shaken up the market.

Despite its immense buying power, price surveys found it was often not the cheapest supermarket and price guarantees from Asda and Sainsbury's in recent months have further hurt sales.

Tesco's latest attempt to draw more people into its stores - its £500 million Big Price Drop - flopped partly because it was funded by a reduction in the number of points awarded through its Clubcard loyalty scheme.

Its share of the grocery market earlier this year dipped below 30% for the first time since 2005.

Analysts believe Tesco is guilty of having used its dominant position in the UK grocery sector to fund its expansion into overseas markets such as the US, Thailand and China.

While it was being undercut on price by rivals, standards in its stores fell behind as a lack of investment left them looking jaded and the numbers of staff were cut to maximise profits.

Tesco, critics argue, spread itself too thin and let its standards drop as a result.

Darren Shirley, an analyst at Shore Capital, said: "The general consensus is that three or four years ago, they took their eye off the ball in the UK and started to focus on overseas and financial services.

"Some of the profitability and cash flow was diverted from the UK and service standards slipped, hence their stores have become quite sterile, dull and clinical."

He said Tesco has also suffered since the financial crisis because it sells a lot of non-food items such as TVs, which have seen demand fall drastically.

Chief executive Philip Clarke has announced plans to invest in stores and staff in a bid to turn the business around.

But analysts say Tesco needs to return to the days when it was at the forefront of innovation and led the way by rolling out new concepts such as its Clubcard and its value and premium own label ranges, which helped it take the grocery market by storm.

FOLLOW UK

Tesco saw £5bn wiped from its share price earlier this year after the supermarket giant warned on profits for the first time in two decades. But while investors were given a rude awakening by the ...
Tesco saw £5bn wiped from its share price earlier this year after the supermarket giant warned on profits for the first time in two decades. But while investors were given a rude awakening by the ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 91
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:39 AM on 04/19/2012
corporately, they don't seem to give a s**t.
There are so many Tesco Metros near where I live. We are talking three within one mile. So the councils are equally to blame. Don't give them permission to open.
The large supermarkets are so expensive and their quality is the same as Sainsburys or Asda, but their prices are as high as Waitrose's or Marks'. Only when you get to the hypermarkets can you get the bargains, and they can be incredible, but I haven't got one near where I live.
And most important. the wine section is rubbish
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:56 PM on 04/18/2012
Tesco are in big trouble, because this is not the result of a one off like an additional company take over that backfired, but instead this is the worst kind of trouble brought about by years of Tesco's own arrogance and managerial incompetence alienating its own customers. If it can be fixed it will take years to try to rectify. Unfortunately for Tesco I don't think it can be because when you have allowed things to reach this stage of going wrong for so long you clearly lack the chain of command capable of even starting to put things right.
06:41 PM on 04/18/2012
£5bn knocked of it's share value. Couldn't have happened to a nicer supermarket.
05:55 PM on 04/18/2012
PS to previous post:
Try shopping in the COOP - ethically sound - or Sainsbury's who like the COOP are pretty sound ethically...
Just dump TESCO...please................
06:44 PM on 04/18/2012
We've just had the displeasure of a huge Tesco opening in a neighbouring little town, but we will continue to use the much smaller Co-op. We don't use Tesco out of principle. That's our principles, and their lack of principles.
08:55 PM on 04/18/2012
Good on you!! Can I encourage you to encourage others in yr locale to follow yr ethical lead?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clownzozo
Magician, Novelist and an Angry Old Git
05:54 PM on 04/18/2012
Perhaps people read the article, Supermarkets, the Cancer on the High Street, which pointed out that we taxpayers subsidise supermarket staff's wages and pay their national insurance contributions. To help Tesco out, the Government have announced that their current workers on their 16-18 hrs per week contracts now need to work an extra eight hours, before they can claim benefits. Tesco, can now cut the number of its its part time workers by a third, and allow the remainder to work the extra eight hours on minimum wages.
The net result is that although Tesco will have to contribute to their National Insurance, contributions, the cost will be more than covered by the wages saved from those made redundant.
You and I will fund the benefits of those laid off, and those working longer hours with benefit entitlement, who will not be contributing Income Tax.
Gainers - Tesco
Losers - Taxpayers.
This logic can be applied to all the other retailers employing staff working, 'Family friendly hours'.
The High street retailers cannot compete.
05:53 PM on 04/18/2012
At long last the UK consumer has woken up!! The slogan 'Every little helps".. should continue "Tesco to screw more profit out of its customers, by hook or by crook!" Witness the bright yellow tags saying "Special Offer Buy 2 for £XXX" when a quick bit of maths will tell you that 2 singles of the exactly same product equals the same price as the "Special Offer".. So basically a lie of epic proportions..
Tesco are simply and utterly nefarious!!! When the banking crisis first hit - Lehman's going bust - i noticed the same day that in my local Tesco every single Fairtrade item had been removed.. Oh I could go on but.......
05:11 PM on 04/18/2012
Many shopper with me included shop around nowadays looking for the best prices. there are many products which go for 35% less in price at Aldi and Lidl and the things I can find in those stores I buy at Sainbury or Tesco.
04:59 PM on 04/18/2012
Probably when they stopped giving a percentage of their profits to Cancer Research UK ( because of the recession ) but yet started giving the same amount to Gay Pride... People should boycott them for being so stupid and plain wrong.
04:48 PM on 04/18/2012
Many shoppers simply don't trust either Tesco or Asda/Walmart they deliberately raise prices then drop them back to where they were and then claim a 'big price drop', with so many people using these supermarkets why bother lying when they are sure to get quickly caught out.
04:26 PM on 04/18/2012
Where did it all go wrong? Read on...
Inconsistant pricing
Crap slogans i.e. Big price drop
Scruffy staff with poor training
Security staff resembling thugs at the door
NO OUTSTANDING BARGAINS ANY MORE
Nicer feel at Aldi and especially Lidl
Too many Charity hasslers in the exit isles
No prescence of senior management on the floor
Lack of clarity
General smell of complacence
I could go on but this typewriter ribbon is running out
04:50 PM on 04/18/2012
Here here .
Also switch and bait with prices .
Too many tesco expresses .
So slow on check out .
I still use tesco but have it delivered .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Laatab
All The Worlds A Stage
03:44 PM on 04/18/2012
Over the last two years I have had to split my shopping between Tesco and Asda to get the best prices. As for customer service both are pretty bad. I always shopped at asda prior to this but the walmart creep took a grip, staff morale obviously took a decline along with the quality of their own brands. I often use the delivery service with tesco but gave up doing so with asda as they will deliver a weeks shopping thats out of date the next day.
03:18 PM on 04/18/2012
aldis and lidl for me dont need bonnie lights to make the food etc to look better tescos and all the other high profile supermarkets you can keep them
03:08 PM on 04/18/2012
Tesco's Portland - 14 months old, spacious, has a good read across price with the other supermarkets, good parking facilities and polite staff....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:09 PM on 04/18/2012
meatpatty81
Wait untill its been there about 3 years then as usual the whole experiance will just plumit to rock bottom. The store will be unrecognisable with everything going downmarket except the prices.
02:09 PM on 04/18/2012
In our town we have 3 Tesco's!! Asda tried to get in but the local mafia (sorry I mean Town Council) would not let them, even though we were crying out for it! We have a population of 60,000 + in the summer months we have the largest Haven holiday Park that can accomodate up to 12,000 people. Our Tesco is the priciest in the country as there is no serious competition, prices go up and down depending what day of the week it is - i.e. if it is changeover day at the holiday park up the prices go the quality for the fresh fruit & veg is disgusting - as another poster said if it is not eaten within 2 days you are binning it. The nearest Asda is 26 miles away, Morrisons, Sainsburys & Waitrose 10 miles, back in the 80's/90's I loved shopping at Tesco, now I seem to suffer 'trolley rage' whenever I have to step foot in there!!
01:42 PM on 04/18/2012
Each time I go into Tescos the prices have changed, often going up by large amounts on certain but seemingly random items. Example: 2kg Allinsons strong white flour £2, next week it was £3.15, needless to say I didn't buy the flour on that occasion (Morrisons were still selling for £2). You have to be careful how you shop in Tesco.
photo
gimmeanamethen
saying it like it is
04:20 PM on 04/18/2012
i think you will find things like eggs 50p cheaper, 20p off milk, all sorts of deals that add up to the extra £1.15 that has gone onto the price of flour..

its a certain amount that floats around the store so you are never saving anything in the long run