The World's Most Controversial Anti-Smoking Images: But Do They Really Work?

The Huffington Post UK  |  By Posted: 24/04/2012 14:33 Updated: 24/04/2012 15:23

These controversial anti-smoking adverts put art and photography to perhaps the most noble aim possible - savings lives. But how effective are they?

Since the world's first anti-smoking campaign appeared in Germany in 1912 in a journal called Der Tabakgegner ('The Tobacco Opponent'), tactics employed by the anti-smoking lobby have grown more and more extreme as the true cost of the habit became apparent.

Today, governments and charities across the world employ their own version of 'shock tactics' to scare their population out of smoking, drawing on everything from its affect on your health, sexual performance - and most harrowing of all - children.

In a sense, working on these images must be liberating for the artists involved - there is literally no image too stark, no concept too upsetting that can't be justified with a simple nod towards the scenes in any cancer ward.

While art and photography play their role in administrating a short, sharp shock to anyone puffing away, books have played a vital role in the anti-smoking fight too.

Allen Carr, a reformed smoker turned self-help guru released the best-seller The Easy Way to Stop Smoking in 1985 and declared it a phenomenal success, with a 90% success rate in helping smokers stop for 3 months and 51% in helping them stop for a year.

Carr's contention was that hammering home the evils of smoking is an ineffective and - furthermore - disingenuous approach for any government to take when his own method, which focuses on positive reinforcement of the benefits of stopping smoking, is demonstratively more successful.

Quick Poll

Do shock tactics work in putting people off smoking?

VOTE

Loading Slideshow...
  • A stop smoking campaign which shows a tumour growing from a cigarette was launched in December 2012. According to the Department of Health (DoH), just 15 cigarettes can cause a mutation than can lead to cancerous tumours. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/12/27/shocking-anti-smoking-advert-cancer-cigarette-tumour-tv_n_2370655.html">Read the full story here.</a>

FOLLOW UK CULTURE

These controversial anti-smoking adverts put art and photography to perhaps the most noble aim possible - savings lives. But how effective are they? Since the world's first anti-smoking campaign ap...
These controversial anti-smoking adverts put art and photography to perhaps the most noble aim possible - savings lives. But how effective are they? Since the world's first anti-smoking campaign ap...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
02:37 AM on 04/27/2012
Some of those posters are very striking I must say, will have some impact I think, only some.
01:48 PM on 04/25/2012
I forgot to mention (and apologies if this is not allowed) you can find out more about Allen Carr's method on www.allencarr.com
10:22 AM on 04/25/2012
Allen Carr was quite right. Smokers believe that cigarettes help them to relax and handle stress. Show them a scary photo/picture - what's the first thing they'll do? Obviously...they'll light a cigarette.

Assuming a smoker doesn't manage to switch channels/turn the page quickly enough shocking/scary/unpleasant images can motivate them to attempt to stop...but they certainly do not help them succeed. To do that - the smoker needs help to understanding the smoking trap and that's what Allen Carr's Easyway To Stop Smoking method does. A lot of people think of it as brainwashing - in fact it's quite the reverse...the book or the seminar or webcast take around 4-6 hours to counter a life-times brainwashing about smoking.

John Dicey
Worldwide Director
Allen Carr's Easyway
04:30 PM on 04/24/2012
If that what it takes to stop parents poisoning their children then do it im completely behind it i think people should see how their actions affect their loved ones, If a parent cant even give up smoking for the sake of their children who can they give up for, i dont understand how people can look at their childrens beautiful faces and smiles and say they would do anything for them and then go light up and fill their lungs with poison in my eyes its child abuse
04:54 PM on 04/24/2012
Idiot...adiction is much more complicated that you understand.
09:06 AM on 04/25/2012
i do understand i lived with a family of smokers my mother, father sister and brother, but not one of them smoke now my parents quit because of their children, my sister because of her children and my brother because it suddenly dawned on him the damage it was and could cause to his body. There is plenty of help out there these days, you dont have to struggle through on your own, my partner is also addicted to smoking and we are battling together to make him stop for the sake of our children and his health and the amount of money we are wasting on tobacco products, so yes actually i think i do understand , i may not be or have ever been a smoker but i have been very close to them. I am entiltled to my opinion as are you , so dont insult me.