Northern Rock Rescue 'Cost Taxpayers £2bn' But Was Best Deal, Says Report

PA/The Huffington Post UK  |  Posted: Updated: 18/05/2012 13:59

Northern Rock
The NAO said the decision was "reasonable" but based on a business plan prepared by Northern Rock management which events showed to have been "optimistic".

The early sale of bank Northern Rock to Virgin Money was the "best way" to protect the taxpayer from greater losses, a report from the spending watchdog said today.

However, the watchdog warned that UKFI had calculated that the former Northern Rock assets that remain in public ownership, under Northern Rock Asset Management, could lead to a net cost to the taxpayer of some £2 billion when taking account of risk and deferred proceeds.

Northern Rock Plc was sold last November to Sir Richard Branson's firm in a deal that is expected to rack up a £480 million loss for the taxpayer, the National Audit Office (NAO) said.

UK Financial Investments (UKFI), the body set up by the Treasury to manage state holdings in bailed-out banks, ran the sales process well, the NAO added.

UKFI earlier this year said the bank's period of public ownership should generate a straight cash profit of up to £11 billion for the taxpayer over the next 10 to 15 years.

Amyas Morse, head of the NAO, said: "A sale of Northern Rock plc at the earliest opportunity was the best option to minimise losses on the £1.4 billion of public money invested in the bank.

"But most of the former Northern Rock's assets will be in public ownership for many years to come and there could be a net cost for the taxpayer of some £2 billion by the time these assets are finally wound down."

The watchdog also hit out at the Treasury in 2009, fronted by the then Chancellor Alistair Darling, for failing to look at the full consequences to the taxpayer when it decided to split Northern Rock in two.

The NAO said the decision was "reasonable" but based on a business plan prepared by Northern Rock management which events showed to have been "optimistic".

However, the NAO said the alternative - selling the deposits and closing down the business - was unlikely to have been significantly better in financial terms.

Sir Richard vowed to challenge the banking industry's "big five" when he agreed the £747 million deal for the Newcastle-based business, which boasts 75 branches, one million customers and holds £14 billion of mortgages.

Chancellor George Osborne insisted the price was the best available for taxpayers, who have owned the business since the first run on a UK bank in 150 years forced the Rock into public hands in February 2008.

Matthew Sinclair, director of the TaxPayers' Alliance pressure group, which campaigns for lower taxes, said: "Investors were hardly queuing up to put their own money into Northern Rock, but politicians kept telling us they knew better and we would make a profit bailing them out.

"Instead, taxpayers are left stumping up for huge losses while those responsible for ordering this bailout remain in denial.

"After taxpayers were lumbered with this dodgy asset, selling the bank was the right decision as there was no guarantee our shares would increase in value. It isn't the Government's business to invest in banks and today we have further evidence of that."

Loading Slideshow...
  • A 19th Century Wild West horse and carriage come London Hackney cab took to the streets of London today to launch new TV Western series Hell on Wheels, which premieres on TCM this Sunday 20th May at 9pm, as Londoners, commuters and tourists were treated to a taxi ride with a difference. Picture date: Thursday May 17, 2012. ÊOnce the original form of the much loved London Hackney Cab, the 19th century horse and carriage was Ã"pimped' with a 21st century taxi complete with leather seating for six people, an electrical outlet for laptops and ipads, an oil burning lantern and a working London Hackney Carriage style Ã"FOR HIRE' light. Photo credit should read: Geoff Caddick/PA Wire

  • A Green-winged Dove chick with his father at the Edinburgh Zoo. It has been a busy time for the Brilliant Birds residents at the Zoo, as the youngsters took flight and left their nests. Picture date: Thursday May 17, 2012. Several chicks put their flying skills to the test for the first time earlier this week. The youngsters who have taken flight in the last month include; three green-winged doves, three chestnut-backed thrushes and a Nicobar pigeon. Photo credit should read: Danny Lawson/PA Wire

  • Protester of the 'Blockupy' movement have pitched tents at the Roemerberg in Frankfurt Main, Germany, 17 May 2012. Police are out in force to prevent riots during the days of action by groups critical of capitalism. Photo: BORIS ROESSLER

  • Cadets walk in a sally port at the U.S. Military Academy in West Point, N.Y., on Thursday, May 17, 2012. (AP Photo/Mike Groll)

  • Fireworks light up crew members and honor guard during the national anthem before the NASCAR Pit Crew Challenge in Charlotte, N.C., Thursday, May 17, 2012. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton)

  • A chandelier is seen from underneath during a preview of the Chihuly Garden and Glass exhibit at the Seattle Center, Thursday May 17, 2012, in Seattle. The new, permanent 1.5 acre exhibit is located near the base of the Space Needle and opens to the public Monday, May 21. It looks at the career of artist Dale Chihuly and features an eight-gallery exhibition hall, conservatory and garden as well as a cafe with a selection of Chihuly's collections of vintage accordions, radios, clocks and other mid-century memorabilia. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

  • Crew members for driver Jimmie Johnson celebrate after winning the NASCAR Pit Crew Challenge in Charlotte, N.C., Thursday, May 17, 2012. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton)

  • Actress Ino Menegaki, dressed as a high priestess, lights the torch at a ceremony in Panathinean stadium in Athens, Thursday, May 17, 2012. The torch begins its 70-day journey to arrive at the opening ceremony of the London 2012 Olympics, from the Greek capital, to cover about 8,000-mile (12,875-kilometer) on its progress over many parts of England to start the games. (AP Photo/Petros Giannakouris)

  • French bullfighter Sebastian Castella is gored during a bullfight of the San Isidro's fair at the Las Ventas Bullring in Madrid, Thursday, May 17, 2012. Castella continued with the bullfight, bleeding from his injured groin. Bullfighting is an ancient tradition in Spain and the season runs from March to October. (AP Photo/Daniel Ochoa de Olza)

  • An artwork titled " The Earth and the World " by Indonesian artist Rudi Mantofani is displayed at the ART HK 12 art fair in Hong Kong Thursday, May 17, 2012. ART HK 12 is a fair showcasing artwork for sale from 266 galleries representing 39 international territories. (AP Photo/Vincent Yu)

FOLLOW UK

The early sale of bank Northern Rock to Virgin Money was the "best way" to protect the taxpayer from greater losses, a report from the spending watchdog said today. However, the watchdog warned tha...
The early sale of bank Northern Rock to Virgin Money was the "best way" to protect the taxpayer from greater losses, a report from the spending watchdog said today. However, the watchdog warned tha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:46 PM on 05/18/2012
So the Government weren't concerned about the Deficit when they decided to sell off NR for a song.
01:18 PM on 05/18/2012
2 billion are we going to get this money back i doubt it very much,oh well sometime soon Cameron or clegg will be made directors so they will be set for life.its all planned
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janno000
11:59 AM on 05/18/2012
Funny that £2billion is almost what they want to take off sick and disabled people.
Craigzz
God must like pinball
11:34 AM on 05/18/2012
There's something strange here. First of all, Branson's never purchased anything which may be considered overly risky, clearly an excellent move on his part, given his Virgin money endeavour.

Why the government would sell off Northern rock (and at a massive loss) is certainly open to debate and certainly not explained here. The government may not have any business running a bank, but neither do they have any business buying one, given that they did, the bank should have been run by the government until such time as losses to public funds were recovered, and/or the bank sold with public shares to recover such losses, whether projected many years ahead or not, yet I see no provision for that or any other recovery of public funds, which is just poor management and government strategy, or worse, of which I would not wish to speculate.

Given recent news of the governments plan to squeeze 2 billion from disabled people, t seems incredible they would simply throw this 2 billion away as if t were a few quid.
02:59 PM on 05/18/2012
I think Northern Rock shares should have been sold on the open market and whatever wasn't bought should be given to US the Taxpayer who actually paid for it in the first place.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hugh Albert
Moderation in somethings
09:15 AM on 05/18/2012
Does anyone know what they are about in the Treasury? We are told that Northern Rock could generate good profit in the future then we learn that it has been sold off cheaply to Branson, because it was going to cost the tax payer oodles of cash.
If Branson can see a profit, and he must or he would not have bought it, why could the Treasury not either have had it run at a profit for the tax payer, or sold it at a reasonable price!
This comment has been removed.
10:22 AM on 05/18/2012
Because "they're all in it together", politicians and finance buddies that is, original NR investors, mostly ordinary people were duped out of their investment which became worthless as government bailed them out, the bank sat in gov hands a couple of years then was sold on to a "crony" at a loss, to the treasury, the taxpayer. Prior to the Branson buyout this bank had been climbing back up the ladder but our illustrious leaders want to put any profit in the hands of a private company, hence conservatism, they'll sell their own mothers to ensure their chums make oodles which is the reason state ownership of anything ended 30 years back, basically giving companies the "right" to rip off the consumer.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hugh Albert
Moderation in somethings
09:27 PM on 05/18/2012
Have to agree. Something stinks.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
09:11 AM on 05/18/2012
Financed by the people's hard earned cash. Politically robbed to repair their incompetence. As always, the elitists, politicians, intellectuals, and entrepreneurs just continue to make Millions and Billions, and it is they who contributed to the mess they made.......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Laatab
All The Worlds A Stage
07:29 AM on 05/18/2012
Dont worry it's only 2bil of taxpayers money so nothing to get concerned about!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:23 PM on 05/18/2012
Unless you're one of the disabled people whose financial lifelines are about to be put at risk to the tune of... oh goshamighty!!.. 2 billion! Coincidence? Perhaps not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Laatab
All The Worlds A Stage
05:31 PM on 05/18/2012
Well whats the welfare of the disabled compared to having the sheer joy of being able to present ricky branson with a gift of a bargain bank. Get your priorities right!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gunderan
Who let the Libertarians out without supervision?
01:17 AM on 05/19/2012
So now the disabled are an issue nice.What about all those that were kicked off prior to the budget don't they count.
Sour grapes moi never,but then again i am one of those benefit stealing entitlement types that have never worked a day in my life i am so glad they told me as i wouldn't have known otherwise.