Education Secretary Michael Gove's proposals for a new national curriculum were condemned as "fatally flawed" on by an expert who advised him on the overhaul.

Planned changes to what primary school children are taught in English, maths and science are too detailed and do not take into account the needs of pupils, according to Professor Andrew Pollard.

Prof Pollard was a member of the expert panel appointed by Gove last year to advise on the review of the national curriculum.

Writing on an Institute of Education blog on Wednesday, Prof Pollard said the new curriculum is "constraining" and leaves little room for teachers to exercise their professional judgment.

His comments come the day after the Department for Education unveiled new draft curricula for English, maths and science in primary schools.

The changes, which have been published for an informal consultation, focus on a back-to-basics curriculum, with pupils expected to memorise their times tables up to 12 by age nine, multiply and divide fractions by age 11 and begin to learn and recite poetry at five.

The expert panel published its recommendations in December, and Pollard was not involved in working on the programmes of study published on Tuesday.

In his blogpost, Pollard said Gove's instructions to the chair of the expert panel, Tim Oates, were to "trawl the curricula of the world's highest-performing countries, to collect core knowledge and put it in the right order".

He questions why he was appointed to the panel as he was unlikely to go along with this "crude design for curricula reform".

"For my own part, I would not deny that subject knowledge is important nor demur from sustained efforts to consider how it should be most appropriately represented in a programme of study," Pollard writes.

"And of course, the idea sounds wonderful - yes, let's sort out, once and for all, when spelling of particular words will be mastered, and the use of apostrophes, and the subjunctive, and so on. So this approach is likely to be very attractive to the public.

"But the approach is fatally flawed without parallel consideration of the needs of learners."

On the basis of the government's proposals, teachers will be faced with "extremely detailed year-on-year specifications in mathematics, science and most of English," Pollard says.

"This is to be complemented by punitive inspection arrangements and tough new tests at 11. The new curriculum will preserve statutory breadth, we are told, but whilst teaching of a foreign language is to be added, provision for the arts, humanities and physical education is uncertain at this point.

"The constraining effects on the primary curriculum as a whole are likely to be profound and the preservation of breadth, balance and quality of experience will test even the most committed of teachers."

The expert panel had recommended that the curriculum in these subjects be organised into two-year blocks, to give teachers room to use their judgment and take account of children learning at different rates, he said.

Pollard added that the government's proposals should now be subjected to scrutiny by teachers, researchers and others.

Shadow education secretary Stephen Twigg said: "The fact that an expert adviser to the government on the national curriculum has called Michael Gove's plans 'fatally flawed' is highly embarrassing.

"It now seems that after commissioning an in-depth review, the Government is ignoring many of its recommendations in favour of its own prejudice.

"The government should put evidence ahead of dogma when it comes to education. The curriculum mustn't be prey to political ideology."

Oates, who is still working with ministers on the new curriculum, said Pollard's concerns were "misplaced".

"The principles agreed with the expert panel, including Andrew, at the start of the review remain in place," he said.

"There is greater demand and detail in the content of these key subjects and there is greater freedom for teachers in how they teach it.

"Publishing content year by year is not some rigid straitjacket. There remains flexibility for schools in the scheduling of content.

"The draft programmes of study are drawn from a rigorous research base, both domestically and internationally. The frameworks of 18 jurisdictions were considered in unprecedented detail.

"The resulting programmes - now out for informal consultation before a further formal consultation - align us with the best education systems in the world."


Loading Slideshow...
  • Britain's Queen Elizabeth II (C), Prince William (L) and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge (R) wave from the balcony of Council House in Nottingham, central England, on June 13, 2012 during a visit. Britain's Queen Elizabeth II, accompanied by Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge attended several engagements during a visit to the city as the Queen continued her diamond jubilee tour without the Duke of Edinburgh who was convalescing following a bladder infection. (Photo credit: RUI VIEIRA/AFP/GettyImages)

  • Britain's Queen Elizabeth II waves from the balcony of Council House in Nottingham, central England, on June 13, 2012 during a visit. The Queen accompanied by Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge attended several engagements during a visit to the city as the Queen continued her diamond jubilee tour without the Duke of Edinburgh who was convalescing following a bladder infection. (Photo credit: RUI VIEIRA/AFP/GettyImages)

  • Britain's Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, smiles as she meets members of the public in Market Square during a visit to Nottingham, central England, on June 13, 2012 with Britain's Queen Elizabeth II. The Queen accompanied by Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge attended several engagements during a visit to the city as the Queen continued her diamond jubilee tour without the Duke of Edinburgh who was convalescing following a bladder infection. (Photo credit: RUI VIEIRA/AFP/GettyImages)

  • Rebekah Brooks, former chief executive of News International, leaves Westminster Magistrates' Courts after she was granted bail on charges of attempting to cover up tabloid phone-hacking, London, Wednesday, June 13, 2012. (Photo credit: AP Photo/Sang Tan)

  • Torchbearer Mark Beaumont carries the Olympic Flame through the grounds of St Andrews University at the beginning of Day 26 of the London 2012 Olympic Torch Relay. (Photo credit: PA)

  • Torchbearer 002 Joseph Forrester carries the Olympic Flame on the West Sands beach in St Andrews during Day 26 of the London 2012 Olympic Torch Relay. (Photo credit: PA)

  • Emma Stone, right, greets fans as Andrew Garfield takes a photo at the world premiere of "The Amazing Spider-Man" in Tokyo, Wednesday, June 13, 2012. (Photo credit: AP Photo/Itsuo Inouye)

  • Hilary Swank attending the Salvatore Ferragamo Cruise Collection 2013 show presented at Galerie Denon at the Louvre Museum in Paris, France on June 12, 2012. (Photo credit: PA)

  • A Polish fan poses during the Euro 2012 football championships match Russia vs. Poland, on June 12, 2012 at the fanzone in Gdansk. (Photo credit: PATRIK STOLLARZ/AFP/GettyImages)

  • US actress Eva Longoria (C) signs autographs as part of the 52nd Monte-Carlo Television Festival on June 13, 2012 in Monaco. The Monte-Carlo Television Festival held since 1961, aims at encouraging the new art form of television. (Photo credit: VALERY HACHE/AFP/GettyImages)

  • A Rohingya Muslim toddler, fleeing sectarian violence in Myanmar, is pictured on an intercepted boat while trying to cross the Naf river into Bangladesh in Teknaf on June 13, 2012. Bangladesh on Wednesday refused three more boatloads of Rohingya Muslims fleeing sectarian violence in Myanmar, officials said, despite growing calls for the border to be opened. Bangladeshi guards have turned back 16 boats carrying more than 660 Rohingya people, most of them women and children, since June 11 as they tried to enter from neighbouring Myanmar across the river Naf. (Photo credit: MUNIR UZ ZAMAN/AFP/GettyImages)