Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alex Dean

GET UPDATES FROM Alex Dean
 

Torn Between Duty and Desire - Being a Gay Lover and a Father

Posted: 19/07/2012 01:00

Torn Between Duty and Desire....being a gay lover and a father

All parents face challenges when raising their children, but some gay parents have an additional complication to contend with.

Imagine being a great, loving father who cherishes his children and loves his wife as a best friend. Your lover is a man who you adore and can't resist.

Just what do you do?

Your loyalty is divided between a sense of duty to your children and the desire to seek pleasure. True love is our ideal. We deserve it, and in our yearning we want to possess it, what could be more natural.

In today's society you face the greatest moral dilemma of your life, one that ultimately forces you to choose from love and duty, infidelity and honour. It is a daily struggle with your conscience that threatens your relationship with your children.

It is hard once you have met your lover, someone that you never believed existed; just one touch and a spark ignites deep inside, yet you have to succumb to your passion in secret. We live in a world of moral ambiguities, where the course of real love never runs smoothly.

In a fairytale: man meets woman, woman has baby and they live happily ever after. For reality it is much more complicated as everyone's needs are different to one another.

Every fight is personal and nobody has the right to choose for you. Children need to grow up surrounded by love from both parents, together or not, whether they are lesbian, gay or straight. A lot of the time it is the act of secrecy rather than the secret itself that is so damaging, but you have no reason to feel ashamed.

The path you are facing is a challenge but it is not insurmountable. Living through the pain of being divided by two courses of action, while you are also aware you are hurting the people you love is agonising. It is not fair on anyone as you are unable to fully commit as a husband, father or lover.

Do you follow your instinct or gut feeling? Do you know the boundary between lust and love or have you crossed a dangerous line that often isn't clear until it is too late. Can you survive on intrigue and flirting alone?

Gavin from Manchester says: "I think the moment that changed my life was when I held that small, vulnerable bundle in my arms. I'm a proud dad, have a treasured little boy and a responsibility to always protect my child. But since meeting my lover, Simon, I feel complete for the first time in my life. It is heartbreaking that I will ultimately hurt someone."

You have a right to be happy and enjoy life at its best... only you can decide what best is.

 

Follow Alex Dean on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ajbookbug

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Torn Between Duty and Desire....being a gay lover and a father All parents face challenges when raising their children, but some gay parents have an additional complication to contend with.
Torn Between Duty and Desire....being a gay lover and a father All parents face challenges when raising their children, but some gay parents have an additional complication to contend with.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gods own child
Weapons legitimise a regime
08:32 on 20/07/2012
Marriage as a norm is an unchallenged concept, nobody seems to question the validity of this binary relationship, but it is a tried and failed method of controlling human nature. Nobody can expect their needs to be fulfilled by one other person, either emotionally or physically or in any other way, this is an unfair burdon.
The world we are brought up in with it's schools, religion etc. is designed to make us all feel useless, and turn us into emotional weaklings only too eager for someone to come along and make us feel good about ourselves, and use the word 'love' as a euphemism for 'you have something I think I need'. This is difficult enough for a heterosexual, but for someone who has another reason for feeling 'wrong' about themselves, their own sense of validity must surely be diminished further.
The concepts of 'fidelity, loyalty' etc are invalid in themselves, nobody has a right to own somebody else's mind or body, this is slavery, tyranny, but who dares to raise the issue? Do we have to blame somebody who has found comfort as a 'cheat, rat traitor' etc. or can we not tell them they have a right to feel happy about themselves rather than crippled with guilt, which will only destroy themselves and ruin the lives of those around them. Treat parental needs and personal needs separately, and don't stop 'loving' the people you already 'love'.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppenguinator
Life's too imprtant to be taken seriously.
22:36 on 19/07/2012
Why is this any more of a problem than a divorced father falling in love with a woman?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:11 on 20/07/2012
Well, unless we're going to assume that the marriage was entered into in bad faith (the man already knew he was gay), then there's the added problem that, after the realization, the gay husband of a woman now knows that he will probably never be able to love his wife like he should, no matter attempts to "tough it out" and stay loyal. A straight husband of a woman, however, may very well be capable of falling back in love with his wife if he toughs it out and gives up the affair.

Or, to put it another way... a woman can compete with a mistress for her husbands affections. She can't really compete with a man.
19:08 on 19/07/2012
I wish this had more of a "personal" story...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ron Hovey
Empathy, Rationality, Equanimity
19:07 on 19/07/2012
There is another (unaddressed) dimension here. What about the wife. She is living in a relationship where the partner is not being honest with her. She deserves compassion and honesty too.

I have friends who have navigated this and it is difficult, they assure me, for all. I have also seen in those cases that they have navigated a very difficult situation with no small amount of grace. Because of how they handled themselves, it worked out better than expected.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richie2012
Your micro bio is empty.
15:57 on 19/07/2012
I want to be an advocate for equal rights here. But some of you won't like it one little bit.

"Imagine being a great, loving father who cherishes his children and loves his wife as a best friend. Your lover is a man who you adore and can't resist. Just what do you do?"

Imagine the same, but that it is another woman who you adore and cannot resist. Just what do you do? Society will tell you that this is not a dilema. They will say you should stop being a cheating rat. Either leave your wife or stop seeing your mistress. But the situation is the same. You are treating your gay lover in the same way. You love your wife as a companion but you don't fancy her. The only difference is that the mistress can potentially give you another child. Your gay lover cannot. I guess another big difference is the taboo of same sex relations and how the taboo will affect your existing child. But running off with your mistress is no moral walk in the park either.

It is interesting how it's easier to speak about gay taboo subjects without getting flamed than it is to speak about hetero taboo subjects - like mistresses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
esperando
17:14 on 19/07/2012
You conveniently overlook the fact that the straight guy with the wandering eye wasn't pressured to marry his wife even though he was incapable of loving her the way a husband should love a wife. Promises (like wedding vows) made under duress (like the threat of ridicule, ostracization from family, loss of home or career, or even violent attack a la Matthew Shephard) do not carry the same moral obligations as those made freely. The only situation that I find even remotely analogous would be in countries like Afghanistan, where young women are often forced by their families and communities into marriages with powerful, abusive, older men. True, they "consent" to these marriages (under enormous pressure), but I wouldn't expect her to endure a lifetime of what is essentially rape for the sake of her children (the benefit to them would be dubious in that situation anyway, as it would have been for me if my parents had opted to keep our lie of a family together), and even less because she was forced to make a promise to do so. If you're a decent person, I don't think you would hold her breaking that kind of "faith" to protect her own emotional and psychological well-being against her. I wish you could extend that kind of empathy to gay people. If you "love the sinner," then I think they are worth that much at least.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richie2012
Your micro bio is empty.
17:46 on 19/07/2012
Oh it's not that I am not extending the empathy - I get it - I'm just saying that a hetero man can i) marry his wife thinking that he loves her and then find he is trapped; or ii) realise that his grey sexuality that he thoughts was largely hetero is not hetero at all and that he is actually gay. I understand that a gay man's path to infedility might be more tortuous but neither part chose to fall out of love with their partner. I'll give you the 'gay man marrying out of obligation' point though.  
15:24 on 19/07/2012
I teared up at reading this article. It only scratches the surface of the torment that men in this situation can feel.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BarryS
12:52 on 19/07/2012
Adoption. So obvious. Or maybe surrogacy.
12:48 on 19/07/2012
How is this any dilemma whatsoever?
photo
Alec Falconer
God save our queen.
10:40 on 19/07/2012
How can you be a homosexual and father children.Does this mean that a man has sex with a woman knowing it is wrong,and even worse gets her pregnant.No bitchy replies please.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
esperando
13:58 on 19/07/2012
As the son of a gay man, I can tell you that gay people are perfectly capable of fathering children. My father married my mother not "knowing it was wrong" but under enormous pressure from his church, his family, and his community, that sent a strong message that a man who doesn't marry a woman and father biological children is not a man at all, and is likely some kind of deviant freak as well. I wish we could agree, as a society, that pressuring gay people into having sexual relationships that they are not comfortable with is no more "right" than doing that to anyone else.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ron Hovey
Empathy, Rationality, Equanimity
19:09 on 19/07/2012
Smart reply. Glad to see such empathy too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gods own child
Weapons legitimise a regime
10:11 on 20/07/2012
Maybe you should ask the woman, Alec, if she thought it was wrong, she obviously didn't while they were having sex.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
coffeemadman
09:07 on 19/07/2012
I think it's age dependent. I don't think anyone in a younger generation should have married in the first place to a woman, exceptions being an arranged marriage (which shouldn't happen either but it does).