Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alex Porter

GET UPDATES FROM Alex Porter
 

New Lego 'For Girl' Reinforces Harmful Gender Stereotypes

Posted: 12/02/2012 19:20

In a bid to increase its appeal to girls, Lego has released a new line of toys specifically geared towards to the needs and wants of the fairer sex. The announcement led to a great deal of both anticipation and scepticism, which culminated in the release of 'Lego Friends' earlier this month.

When the product was unveiled, Mads Nipper, the executive vice president of products and markets at Lego waxed lyrical about the intellectual benefits of children playing with Lego: improved concentration, development of spatial awareness and creativity. In light of such passion and commitment to these vital parts of the Lego experience, one would expect the new product to provide all the great learning opportunities that other Lego products offer.

However, that does not seem to be the case. While Lego products have traditionally focussed on building as a creative, universal experience, their marketing has become increasingly divisive in order to appeal to the supposed different requirements of male and female children. The toys aimed at boys have become increasingly conflict based, focussing more on role-playing games with minifigs after the construction is complete, rather than the construction itself. The Lego City range, for example, has recently introduced a series of toys within the theme of 'cops and robbers', emphasising violent forms of conflict resolution.

Girls, meanwhile have the worse lot with the introduction of Lego Friends. Aside from the obviously gendered design, dominated by pink and purple hues in the imaginary location of Heartlake City, Lego Friends fails to promote creativity and development for girls. The creative building aspect has been almost completely eliminated in the advertising, as girls are encouraged to play with the new minifigs as they would any other doll, "going to a party at the new café" or "chilling at the beauty shop". Considering how dominant men are in the construction and engineering industries, with women making up only 11% of the engineering workforce in the USA, this is highly problematic as the failure to engage girls in constructive, creative play at a young age is likely to be a contributing factor to such statistics.

The activities the girls and their minifigs are encouraged to do in Heartlake City are also highly gendered, such as baking at the City Park Café, getting their hair done at the Butterfly Beauty Shop and taking care of pets at the Heartlake Vet. Compared to the exciting range of activities and occupations that boys' Lego toys offer such as astronaut, fire-fighter and construction worker, the girl's universe seems incredibly limiting. Lego underestimates the influence toys hold over children if they believe that such gender segregation of occupations will not influence children's attitudes and ambitions as they grow up and make their own career choices.

The new minifigs themselves also pose a problem. While the traditional minifigs were, at least originally, universal and relatively ungendered, the Lego Friends minifigs look just like miniature Barbies, with long hair and curvaceous figures. This only goes to reinforce and exaggerate the difference between boys and girls, portraying the male as the norm and the female as 'the other'.

Lego claims that segregating their products by gender is necessary due to the demands of their customers: girls want pretty, pink toys that allow them to do 'girly stuff', while boys demand blue, macho, conflict-based Lego sets. However, this seems to me to be self-fulfilling marketing. By taking both sets to such gendered extremes and marketing them solely to one sex, Lego understandably attracts only one gender to each product. The result of such segregation in the toy industry is not just destructive to the development of girls; it also has a negative affect on boys. By having toys that are centred on violence, they fail to develop skills of non-violent conflict resolution and care giving that girls' toys promote. In order to free society of the traditional gender roles, toys must become more universal, promoting both male- and female-indentified skills to all children.

 

Follow Alex Porter on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AlexGPorter

In a bid to increase its appeal to girls, Lego has released a new line of toys specifically geared towards to the needs and wants of the fairer sex. The announcement led to a great deal of both antici...
In a bid to increase its appeal to girls, Lego has released a new line of toys specifically geared towards to the needs and wants of the fairer sex. The announcement led to a great deal of both antici...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:04 PM on 02/17/2012
I disagree with your argument about segregation and feel that your are underestimating the creative capacity and imagination of children. In our house, Star Wars figures regularly visit Stephanie in her cafe for a cake, and our daughter joins in the Star Wars and helps the warriors to negotiate peace. Like boys and girls, the Lego Friends can live alongside, and intermingle with Star Wars. Darth Vadar can enjoy a spot of Karaoke!
02:11 PM on 02/14/2012
I feel that this is a pretty narrow analysis of the product line. The fact of the matter is that LEGO changed it's focus from self-directed constructive play to a more narrative approach involving directed role-playing many years ago - before doing so, LEGO was dying as a brand.

Further, there have been many studies done in the last 20 years showing that interactive media (computers, cell phone gaming, console gaming, etc) have actually changed children's play experiences and expectations - and that children do look for play where roles are more clearly defined to help build narratives on their own. (The LEGO City 'cops and robbers' theme has been around for nearly 20 years).

The line contains typical building complexity for its age range, and is no less focused on building and construction than most other lines LEGO produces. And why is the role of a veterinarian viewed as feminine? Are all nurturers inherently feminine? There are other sets you seem to have glazed over that are less typically feminine, such as the invention workshop, the convertible, and the tree house.