Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bishop Gene Robinson

GET UPDATES FROM Bishop Gene Robinson
 

Loving Free

Posted: 19/03/2012 23:00

Like most Episcopalians in the US, I am an Anglophile, and look forward to returning to the land of my "mother church" this week. It has been four years since I was in England, present but not included in the once-a-decade Lambeth conference of Bishops in 2008. As the Archbishop of Canterbury plans for his retirement, I trust that the decision to exclude me will be one of the low points Rowan Williams reflects upon as he leaves office.

My exclusion from the conference was a missed opportunity for Anglican Bishops from around the globe to have an opportunity to chat with someone unashamedly Christian and unashamedly gay. And it was an intentional act of exclusion by Archbishop Williams, my spiritual "father in God," the pain of which lingers with me nearly four years later.

That I am not the first gay bishop should surprise no one. But I am the first gay bishop who has been honest about his orientation. And the punishment for being honest? I have the dubious distinction of being the first duly elected and consecrated Bishop excluded from Lambeth since the event began in the mid-19th century.

I return to England energized by how much has changed in the last four years -- and disheartened by how much has not. The BFI Gay and Lesbian Film Festival will offer its screening of Love Free or Die on March 24, a documentary which premiered at this January's Sundance Film Festival and won the Special Jury Prize. Crafted by filmmaker Macky Alston, the film follows my personal life and public ministry from the Lambeth Conference in 2008 to the 2010 election and consecration of the second openly gay, partnered Bishop in The Episcopal Church, Mary Glasspool, in 2010; from the struggle for marriage equality and equal rights for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people within the church and society, to the inauguration of Barack Obama as President in 2009.

But in my eyes, the real hero of the film is the Church -- that often staid, usually timid, lethargic, slow-to-change institution which, in its American expression, is lively, courageous and changing quite rapidly into the inclusive community we believe Christ would want us to be.

We understand that many in the Church of England believe that The Episcopal Church is moving too fast. With all due respect, the Church of England is moving too slowly!

As I return to England, I am perplexed at how little has changed here. The English Church is still arguing over whether ordained women are fit matter for consecration as bishops. One would think that if they were intrinsically unfit to be a Bishop, they would be unfit to be ordained at all! Women are children of God, and if you don't believe them to be full members of the Body of Christ, then stop baptizing them as well!

Same-gender clergy couples who enter into legal domestic partnerships are supposed to promise their Bishops that they will be celibate in their relationships. The fact is that most Bishops don't really expect it, most couples don't really mean it, and everyone knows it's an absurd charade. Many English bishops respect and love their gay and partnered clergy, accepting dinner invitations to their homes and enjoying an easy relationship with them -- as long as such a relationship doesn't become public. It is embarrassing to the Church to foster this hypocrisy, to stand in the way of truth. And how sad for the Church (not to mention the state Church) to be working against the one institution that is a relationship's highest calling -- marriage -- something even the secular culture seems to understand.

On the first day of marriage equality in New Hampshire, I blessed the marriage of two women, the older of whom, at age 75, longed to have the Church recognize her 25 year relationship before she died. This faithful couple (and I) never thought we would live to see such a thing happen in the Church. It was a joyful day, not just for the happy couple, but for the great number of people who braved a snowstorm to be there. What surprised me the most was how meaningful it was for the straight couples there who realized how much they had largely taken for granted their right to marry the person they love. If only the Archbishop could experience the profound joy present that day.

I appreciate the Church of England from which so many churches around the globe were birthed. But I long for it to express its full and unequivocal acceptance of women, and to find its way toward embracing and celebrating the gay men, lesbians, bisexual, and transgender people within and beyond its congregations. Aren't English Anglicans embarrassed that the secular State is more inclusive than the Church?

Isn't Jesus embarrassed?

Love Free or Die is a movie about hope and about how God never abandons God's human little church. God never gets it wrong; the Church often does. But the Church can also, by God's grace and with God's help, find the courage to change. And in some places, it is! If you thought you would never again be inspired by the courage of an institution, if you want to watch a Church risking its life for the LGBT community, if you want to see how change can happen against all odds, join us for Love Free or Die.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 47
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
09:50 AM on 03/23/2012
I wonder if the Bishop would be willing to admit they may have just as many satanics in the congregation as homosexuals ?
01:51 PM on 03/21/2012
Thank you for your amazing courage, Bishop Robinson. You are a light in our church!
01:35 PM on 03/21/2012
Thank you, Bishop. Phl 2:1-6
06:22 PM on 03/24/2012
Not really relevant to the Mr. Robinson's situation though, is it. Ephesians 5:21 is a bit more to the point, and he isn't going to submit to anyone else's authority - he's far too proud.
01:18 AM on 03/21/2012
This nonsense is why the mainline Protestant churches have/are becoming spiritually irrelevant. Religion that is defined by the culture has no claim on truth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel Francis
It just ain't right........
04:15 AM on 03/21/2012
Advocating for the rights of others in spite of Biblical sanction for there oppression is a quintessentially Christian act. And truth is defined by the reality of peoples lives. Sometimes that runs in the Bible's favor, sometimes not.
05:31 PM on 03/21/2012
Ignoring Scripture and changing church teaching to fit the culture is not a Christian act.
07:08 PM on 03/20/2012
In an era of pandemic fatherlessness, it's clear that fathers make a specific and distinctive kind of contribution. It's right in the hormones, as most of those who have had a father or who have been fathers can tell. When it comes to religion, the real religion today has become the anything-goes religion, where it's assumed that you can just plug in anybody or nobody and still have the value of a father. This kind of thinking is causing chaos everywhere. As for Robinson, he decided that bailing out on his wife and children was just one of those many options that we up-to-date people might enjoy.
11:36 AM on 03/20/2012
I think there will be a schism and the government will nationalize the more liberal strand.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ioan Lightoller
Proud Gay Pagan Man, Living Happily With Husband
11:18 AM on 03/20/2012
Bishop, Robinson, I hope your next trip to England is a good one. Very sad that Abp. Williams saw fit to pander to those who don't seem to have much of an understanding of Christian kindness and inclusivity.

I respect and thank you for all the work you have done on behalf of GLBT Episcopalians. Bless you.
05:00 AM on 03/20/2012
Bishop Gene, it's wonderful to see you posting. I met you several years ago and will always be grateful to you for your empathy as I was going through a very tough time.

I hope England is kinder to you this time out. Archbishop Williams should be ashamed of excluding any lawfully consecrated and ordained bishop from the conference.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
weathergirl
loved politics as a little girl!
04:45 AM on 03/20/2012
Bishop Robinson, I pray that your experience this time overcomes all of the bad feelings last time around! I have recently switched (as in this year January) to your Church because I could neither understand nor agree with the Church that I was born into using the Sacraments as weapons! I am fortunate to be part of a diocese that has a woman as a bishop. She is absolutely amazing. When I first saw her in the robes of a bishop, it took awhile to accept her but by the end of the Mass, I was comfortable with a woman bishop! All the best! (A new convert and proud of it)!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetlilthing
hurt no one but tell the truth
11:43 PM on 03/19/2012
I'm once again disappointed. "(E)ven the secular culture seems to understand" Of course we understand. We do good and accept others for the sake of goodness not reward or punishment.
09:21 PM on 03/19/2012
What I find perplexing is how any church that genuinely calls itself Christian and actually attempts to follow the Bible as it was written can condone homosexal behavior as an alternate life style. In the original Greek, the New Testament is not unclear that homosexual sexual behavior is unnatural and based on lustful behavior as is any other sexual encounter outside of the confines of a marriage of a man and a woman. While a church body can declare a same sex couple as "married", only God can join two people together to become one flesh.

At the end of the day, despite our man-made attempts to declare a marriage as legal or proper, only God can actually "marry" two individuals. All the state sponsored pronouncements and laws to define marriage won't change the mind of the one who created it. God defined a marriage as the union of a husband( male) and a wife ( female) regardless of our opinion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:35 PM on 03/19/2012
Seeing as we allow atheists and those not of Christian religions to marry, I don't think your argument has much sway in civil matters.
12:10 AM on 03/20/2012
Biblical Marriage is not really a civil matter. Biblical Marriage is a covenant before God. The state may declare that you are married, but it will always be a civil union unless God makes the two one flesh. I have no problem with civil unions for any two people who live together for an extended period of time. But, living together doesn't make someone married or make their sexual relationship a marriage relationship.
10:26 PM on 03/19/2012
What God has said doesn't need science to corroborate, but it is gradually doing that anyway -- cognitive neuroscience, to be exact. What it's basically doing is restoring balance to the wrong-headed ideology out there that says that nothing, not even gender, is ingrained, that our minds are just blank slates for society to write upon. What's becoming clear is that there are brain patterns in women that are complementary to those in men. One of the implications is that the mommy style of love is important and so is the daddy style. Even where no children are involved, it's a lack of complementarity that results in the unsatisfactory and short-lived relationships among gays. What all the great religions have said, and millennia of university observation have confirmed, is that, as you said, the two shall be one flesh.
photo
BeninOakland
Don't tell me you love me. Let me guess.
10:38 PM on 03/19/2012
Complete nonsense in every way.

Complementarity is just another, loftier sounding way of saying that only penis-and-vagina need apply. "Brain patterns complementary to those in men?" It doesn't even make any sense, though it sounds like it ought to.

Obvously, you know no gay people, and certainly nothing about us. I have myself NUMEROUS coupled friends that have been together longer than all seven of the Gingrich-Limbaugh marriages combined. If you want to talk about shortlived relationshiops, you really ought to look at the hetero majority.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetlilthing
hurt no one but tell the truth
11:56 PM on 03/19/2012
"unsatisfactory and short-lived relationships among gays" While marriage is at an all time low, the divorce rate was at 41% in 2011. Looks like marriage between a man and a woman is " unsatisfactory and short-lived" as well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marchmont
08:23 PM on 03/19/2012
The New Testament in the original Greek is ambiguous about homosexuality and does not contain any clear references to gay activity within a committed relationship. Paul did condemn homosexual orgies, ritual gay sex in Pagan temples and the rape of boys by adult males but that would be deplored by all Christians, homophobic or otherwise. The problem is that, after having been filtered through the belief systems of the many translators, some English versions of the Bible do condemn all homosexual behaviour. Marriage is not a creation of the church but a natural institution of great antiquity and diversity which has merely been overlaid in this country with a Christian veneer. Some Christians such as me are no longer prepared to have people told they have no right to partake in such a basic human ritual on the basis of sexual orientation alone. I look forward to a time when this dispute - which seems jarringly ridiculous even today - will be relegated to the dust-bin of history and children taught about it alongside slavery and the burning of witches to show how we have far we have progressed from barbarism.
Syllogizer
Barely Left of Pobedonostsev
12:07 AM on 03/21/2012
The NT is indirect and euphemistic, but it is NOT 'ambiguous'. On the contrary: Rom 1:18-32 leave no room for reasonable doubt: homosexual acts are very serious sins indeed, "worthy of death".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel Francis
It just ain't right........
04:13 AM on 03/21/2012
Agreed.
Now is that Good? Right? Moral?
And if not, should Christians agree with it or go along with it ?
I would say that the answer should be No, for every Christian.
And that our Christian duty is to challenge every scripture which in the end does not
enhance justice, mercy and love in our lives and that of our fellow men.
06:24 PM on 03/24/2012
It isn't ambiguous at all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
practiceempathy
Tolerance need not yield to willful ignorance.
08:01 PM on 03/19/2012
Rev. Gene, it was so nice meeting you, and honoring you as you received the Spirit of Justice Award, at the annual GLAD dinner in Boston.

Having said that...

"As I return to England, I am perplexed at how little has changed here. The English Church is still arguing over whether ordained women are fit matter for consecration as bishops. One would think that if they were intrinsically unfit to be a Bishop, they would be unfit to be ordained at all! Women are children of God, and if you don't believe them to be full members of the Body of Christ, then stop baptizing them as well."

It boggles my mind that we, an advanced version of our species, compared to the version of biblical times, can't comprehend that the patriarchy that wrote the Bible undoubtedly included male heterosexual bias.

Could it really be any more obvious, evident?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Northcote
11:22 PM on 03/19/2012
Not to the stupid old ringmasters that still run this sorry circus.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
practiceempathy
Tolerance need not yield to willful ignorance.
01:34 PM on 03/20/2012
It's depressing, our being so in the Dark Ages, still, in terms of our lack of enlightenment on matters of human sexuality and gender.