Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
B.J. Epstein

GET UPDATES FROM B.J. Epstein
 

Silence Those Bells

Posted: 11/12/2012 00:00

Jingle bells, jingle bells.

Will someone please turn off those stupid jingling bells?

Why must we be attacked by the ghost of Christmas commercialism everywhere we go? And why has this been the case since, oh, October?

In practically every place you go in this country, Christmas music is playing, so that annoying earworms begin to travel with you. It's as though they're a constant reminder that you're supposed to be feeling jolly and spending lots of money.

And speaking of spending money, why are we supposed to send cards to and buy gifts for everyone in our address books, regardless of whether we (or they) actually celebrate Christmas? Gosh, could it be because merchants are looking to boost their bottom lines, so they not-so-subtly pressure us with their bright, large displays of products?

If I want to buy presents for friends or loved ones, I do. I don't need to be told to do so by stores or greeting card companies. I don't like enforced gift-giving, where people have to buy useless presents for one another simply because that's what you do at Christmas. Where's the fun and joy in that? Wouldn't it be so much nicer to give presents to people when you found things they liked and you wanted to surprise them, rather than because it was the traditional gift-exchange?

I'm not Christian and I don't celebrate Christmas. A number of English friends have informed me that I'm wrong: "everyone" celebrates Christmas and it's not a religious holiday. I think many Christians would beg to differ: Christmas was traditionally a holiday to honour Christ - you remember Christ, right, that guy who was the basis of the Christian religion. And if Christmas isn't a religious holiday, what is it? A stressful season of crowded stores, frantic shopping, and enforced good will? Why is that worth celebrating?

I can understand the desire for a few days off during what is in the northern hemisphere one of the darkest times of year. As a teacher, I certainly appreciate having a short break between semesters. But I definitely don't appreciate the way this time of year has been turned into a non-stop carnival for commercialism, and a very Christian-centric one at that.

A few years ago, I finished off the semester by wishing my students a "relaxing break". A colleague heard of this and told me I was being offensive by not specifically saying "Merry Christmas" or "Happy Christmas". I pointed out that not all my students celebrated Christmas and that I was leaving my well-wishes open to individual interpretation. Hanukkah, Yule, Kwanzaa, Pancha Ganapati, Ashura, and yes, even Christmas, are all holidays that often (but not always) happen in December. On our calendar, the new year starts at the end of December. Why not let my diverse student body choose for themselves which holiday/s, if any, they want to acknowledge and which holiday/s, if any, they want to believe I am referring to? And what's wrong with wishing them a relaxing couple of weeks off from their studies, anyway?

In short, Christmas seems to have taken over December (and November and much of October, too). I don't see why it should. I'm aware I might sound like a grinch who wants to steal Christmas, but that's not actually the case. I think we should leave Christmas to the Christians. And in return, Christmas can leave the rest of us alone.

I for one would be grateful for a month of silent nights, and silent days.

 

Follow B.J. Epstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bjepstein

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Jingle bells, jingle bells. Will someone please turn off those stupid jingling bells? Why must we be attacked by the ghost of Christmas commercialism everywhere we go? And why has this been the case...
Jingle bells, jingle bells. Will someone please turn off those stupid jingling bells? Why must we be attacked by the ghost of Christmas commercialism everywhere we go? And why has this been the case...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:30 PM on 12/12/2012
Oh please!such killjoys. We don't spend a lot of money on Christmas celebrations but we have family time a tree to brighten the darkness and thoughts of those less fortunate. I do not celebrate any other holidays but like to see others enjoying whatever they chose to celebrate. Consumerism in excess is a year round problem. Live and let live and don't spoil things for others.
06:15 PM on 12/12/2012
I am a Pagan and I celebrate the Yule Tide with my coven, I think it is a great time of the year, because it is sacred to many peoples.
Blessed Be to you all (including the scrooges)
09:31 PM on 12/11/2012
Bah humbug. You don't have to be christian to say happy Christmas.
07:53 PM on 12/11/2012
A few years ago, I decided enough was enough with the madness of Christmas and all its commercial frenzy. My family were aghast at first, but afterwards told me they were relieved not to have to try to find that unique present that would fulfill my wildest dreams for the grand sum of 50 quid or so.
We now spend time together instead. This sounds like a cop out, but when your family works full time, or is separated by distance or other commitments, the idea of spending time together is the best present you can give or wish for.
06:09 PM on 12/11/2012
Christmas is a highjacked pagan winter festival. I'm not sure what it is called in every country in Europe but I was told once that only the British and the Greeks have "Christ" in the name of the festival. I don't know whether anyone can confirm that.
10:14 PM on 12/11/2012
saturnalia, and the pagans brought in green shrubs to welcome the next season of spring.Jesus was born in september, the good old victorians hijacked xmas, and wintry xmas cards? Wish i'd a thought of that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fandabidozi
05:59 PM on 12/11/2012
//I think many Christians would beg to differ: Christmas was traditionally a holiday to honour Christ//

To be absolutely fair,the winter solstice was a time of celebration for pagans and was highjacked by christianity but other than that I'm with you :)
05:45 PM on 12/11/2012
Christmas is a time of year when I am reminded of my economic inadequacies. I won't be spending time with my family because I will be scrubbing vomit splattered loos, the result of others' excesses, for little more than minimum wage. Nevertheless it will be a time for celebration since the small debt collection agency will indubitably leave me alone for a few days.
They say that charity begins at home, specifically my home. So here is my christmas wish list:
1 bottle + Williams and Humbert 12 year Oloroso
A years supply of fillet steak (Organic)
A years supply of white truffle oil
1 Pair Tuffa Roxburghe sheepskin lined leather country boots.
1 Apple ipad
Few pairs of Levis
1 Pair Crockett and Jones hand made-to-order brogue boots
1 Chevrolet Volt (My ancient Volvo is a killer on petrol costs)
Replacement windows - my Crittal ones don't even have an energy efficiency rating.
1 Esse Ironheart woodburner/cooker with back boiler (plus installation costs)
1 LaCanche Vezelay Cooker
1 Hotpoint Integrated fridge drawer
1 Two storey oak framed garage + car port + log store
The field behind my house
A seasons fly-fishing at Broadlands
1 Beretta 692 + years supply of clay pigeons and cartridges
Heavy, lined, full-length curtains for 27 windows.

Champagne taste on a piss-weak beer income sucks. Perhaps my new years resolution should be to secure myself a wealthy husband. With that in mind, I also wish for a good supply of Diki lingerie.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:24 PM on 12/11/2012
I've kind of figured out over a few decades that the world will not bend in all things to my will and desires. I don't get to hear the music I want the rest of the year in shops and thus the Christmas version doesn't surprise me any more than the rest of the year. I respond to the Christmas greetings with a mumble or 'Aye have a good one', ask not to be given any presents and send cheques to family members in the hope they do something deranged with the money.
It doesn't effect me any more than everything else I dislike the rest of the year and is therefore to be ignored, don't like it, don't participate and don't feel guilty about it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Prickly Herbert
Mine's a large gin
05:19 PM on 12/11/2012
Me neither, but I have no problem with a celebration of goodwill to all men. Don't like the current commercialism but any excuse for a p*ss up is fine by me. Equally happy to wish all & sundry a Happy Christmas. So there it is, Happy Christmas folks xxx.
04:51 PM on 12/11/2012
Apparently, the season of good cheer did not start out as exclusively a Christian festival. According to Pagans the early Christian church hijacked December 25 to celebrate the birth of Jesus because they saw that everyone was already having a good time and decided to take advantage of it. Personally, as a non believer, I don't mind sharing! T'is the season of good will and all that.
03:41 PM on 12/11/2012
I am a Christian and I celebrate Christmas. If I didn't know Ms Epstein was Jewish and had such strong views on the subject, I would probably wish her a Merry Christmas. As it is, I wish her a Happy Hanukkah. I also suspect Ms Epstein is not British, she is probably American, since we have Terms, not Semesters. If Ms Epstein is going to come and work in a foreign country, she should get used to the customs of that country or at least accept them, or go home.
Incidentally, as a Brit ex-pat living in the USA, I notice that the commercialisation of Christmas is even more obvious in America than it is in Britain. I do accept what are for me non-holidays in America like Memorial Day, 4th July, Labor Day and Thanksgiving. I don't celebrate, but I do accept.
06:30 PM on 12/25/2012
I am English/British as far back as my family can remember. Like most British people I was indoctrinated into the Christian religion, but once I was able to think for myself I realised what a load of nonsense it all was. I still celebrate the 25th of December as my ancestors did as a time when the days began to draw out again and the dark nights became shorter. Now THAT is something to celebrate! I send Seasons Greetings cards....not Xmas cards which oddly celebrate the birth of Jesus who was born in Sept if indeed he existed at all.
02:10 PM on 12/11/2012
It has lost the true meaning in 2000 years, It is now a make or break time for all our stores tempting people without money to spend themselves into bankruptcy and misery
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Michael Rundle
01:49 PM on 12/11/2012
"Why do people enjoy a thing! Let's stop enjoying a thing! Who's with me?"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WillieBlack
07:32 PM on 12/12/2012
"I demand that everyone stops enjoying this thing as well!"
01:18 PM on 12/11/2012
Wow, you sound like a real kill-joy.

Of course everyone realises that "Chirst"mas is technically a Christian holiday... And everyone is also aware that not everyone in this country is a Christian. I'm certainly not one.

But, Jesus Christ (to borrow from religion for my expletitive) get over yourself. This is the one time of year where we all get some time off work, we all get to relax for a few days.

And I know, I know, it's awful having a special day where people go out of their way to show affection to those they're close to by exchanging gifts.

Can I just ask? Who exactly is forcing you to buy useless presents for people? And sending Christmas Cards to everyone you know?

Just take a step back, realise that there's no law requiring you take part, and let the rest of us find a little bit of enjoyment in this dark, cold time of year.
12:58 PM on 12/11/2012
Crikey, how glum. Also culturally tone-deaf. I am not American but I understand Thanksgiving is a very big more-or-less religious deal over there, which everyone participates in. Good manners dictates foreigners do too, when visiting. Objecting on the basis of atheism would be, see above, culturally tone-deaf. As well as rude. Christmas is a cultural holiday here, and for a reducing minority also religious. I suspect you might come at this issue differently were the context gay marriage.

Complaining about the over-commercialisation of Christmas is very British though, so well done there.