Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dan Ehrlich

GET UPDATES FROM Dan Ehrlich
 

Religion, Poor Leadership Remain at Heart of Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Posted: 15/11/2012 13:30

America's overture to its Iraq invasion was an intensive bombing campaign nicknamed "shock and awe." Then came the US and UK troops in an eight year-long war that resulted in hundreds of thousands of Iraqi dead and injured.

Yet, at the time there was just as much shock and awe at this trumped up war based on false evidence and not a single shot beforehand being fired at NATO troops.

But, let Israel react to constant provocations against its civilian and military populations and its cause for international outrage. A double, even a triple standard? Very probable since I never heard of an Iraqi missile landing in New York or London. Any nation has a right to respond militarily if attacked by enemies.

The fact remains that Israel is in a rather unique, almost no-win situation. It's the only country in the world surrounded by other countries seeking its destruction. And this pressure will continue, more because of the Palestinian Arab leadership than from popular will. For example, what other independent land, which the Gaza Strip in all but name is, has as it leadership a terrorist group in a constant state of war with it neighbor?

In case you have forgotten over the generations now, the Palestinian problem is the result of lost wars the Arabs have waged against Israel. It is not the root of the problem. Had the Arabs accepted the 1947 UN partition plan there would not have been wars, war refugees and groups such as Hamas.

The root of the problem isn't even about land lost in these wars. It's about religion and tribalism inherent in poor agrarian nations that have long been theocracies. It's also a conflict of cultures... a modern progressive social democracy surrounded by Third World nations. And as long as these nations remain steeped in religion they will not accept a non-Muslim, non-Arab nation in their midst. It doesn't matter if Jewish history goes back 4,000 years there, they won't be accepted. The Arabs states chose war because then, as today, they didn't want a Jewish state there.

At least Hamas is more honest about this than Mahmoud Abbas and his PLO leadership. The PLO now see using legal and political means as the more progressive way of fighting Israel, doing to Israel what the group did to once prosperous Lebanon. But, both Hamas and the PLO still seek Israel's eventual destruction.

Most pressure on Israel these days comes from rocket attacks that ignited the current violence. It's probably fair to say most Palestinians, knowing what the Israeli response will be, could do without these provocations. But Hamas counts on devastating Israeli responses for the sake of press coverage.

That's right; Hamas is willing to sacrifice some of its own people for TV air time. And the Israelis are willing to play the game because in the Middle East, to not play the game is a sign of weakness and come-on for further terrorist attacks.

So what's the answer, a Palestinian state? I feel this is only realistic solution since the Palestinians have become a distinct Arab population unwanted by their brother Arabs and certainly not by Israel. They are a people in limbo and yet until they demand leaders who will negotiate for their good and not the good of the Arab League rejectionist stance against Israel, their hopes will not be realized.

Right now the two-state solution appears to have been replaced by a three-state solution. Until Gaza is run by people other than warlords, this will remain a densely populated terrorist enclave periodically attacking Israel.

Poverty is widespread in the Arab lands... the only Arab nations to rate a place in the UN's top 50 are the oil rich Gulf States. For any Palestinian state to live in peace with Israel, jobs and living standards will have to soar. This will take time and considerable assistance from Israel, rated 17th in the UN's top 200 nation's list (the UK is 28th). The reality is affluent democracies don't make war on each other.

 
 
 

Follow Dan Ehrlich on Twitter: www.twitter.com/danew13

FOLLOW UK
America's overture to its Iraq invasion was an intensive bombing campaign nicknamed "shock and awe." Then came the US and UK troops in an eight year-long war that resulted in hundreds of thousands of ...
America's overture to its Iraq invasion was an intensive bombing campaign nicknamed "shock and awe." Then came the US and UK troops in an eight year-long war that resulted in hundreds of thousands of ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:28 on 19/11/2012
Mr. Ehrlich, Thanks for your well founded, well expressed analysis. AlanD
13:07 on 17/11/2012
So what happened to my post then? I accuse this and other pro Israelli journo apologists of being paid or unpaid stooges across and it's too much for you? Or to near the truth to publish!
07:36 on 16/11/2012
Israel was renamed palestine by the roman occupiers in 135 A.D. All you braindead pro arab types have to do is READ.But no, you won't do that because then you would have to think.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Itsbeenalongday
Eliminating poverty is smart business
23:37 on 15/11/2012
Jews lived in peace in Palestine for thousands of years....until they wanted it all for them self.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Itsbeenalongday
Eliminating poverty is smart business
23:35 on 15/11/2012
"The fact remains that Israel is in a rather unique, almost no-win situation. It's the only country in the world surrounded by other countries seeking its destruction. "

Which suggests it should not have been allowed to establish there in the first place.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pietro Sommavilla
20:33 on 15/11/2012
"... a modern progressive social democracy surrounded by Third World nations."

Yet they are two sides of the same coin.
20:09 on 15/11/2012
The State of Israel is not worthy to be a member of the UN! It is sad how the USA give her a Licence to Kill at a whim!

Of course Hamas are as bad, but Israel can never defend the level of aggression and retaliation they constantly take! Annoyed today with William Hague's support of Israel Never did I think we would become like the USA!
19:22 on 15/11/2012
This is the most fascist blog I have read on Huff Post so far!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:44 on 16/11/2012
Are you new then?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:19 on 15/11/2012
"Israel, rated 17th in the UN's top 200 nation's list (the UK is 28th)." Where would we rank if the US gave us £17k a year for each and every citizen?

It's not a double standard, it's that Israel is in a unique position as the last remaining Western colony in the World. It's creation stems from a time when what Westerners wanted was more important than what Easterners or Southerners owned. I know that's not how we see it, but unfortunately that's the way the rest of the world sees it and as the century progresses, what we want will be progressively less important.
18:50 on 15/11/2012
Mr 'Journalist', I don't see how calling Arab nations 'third world nations' would help us to find peace.
18:42 on 15/11/2012
I thought I would read this kind of nonsense only in the comment section, but now we see 'independent' journalists making such inflammatory, irresponsible and incorrect assumptions based on misconceptions.

Please mind your language Mr 'Journalist'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cardiff1963
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping i
06:28 on 16/11/2012
Please don't mind your language Mr Journalist.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
18:41 on 15/11/2012
In case you have forgotten over the generations now, the Palestinian problem is the result of lost wars the Arabs have waged against Israel. It is not the root of the problem. Had the Arabs accepted the 1947 UN partition plan there would not have been wars, war refugees and groups such as Hamas.
------------------------------------
The above is specious tripe. If Israel wants peace, then they can prove it by withdrawing from ALL territory gained in 1967. Otherwise the expansionist, aggressive label sticks.
18:22 on 15/11/2012
Go back to the pre-1947 borders. Or, failing that, the pre-1967 borders. And no more settlements.
18:19 on 15/11/2012
"And as long as these nations remain steeped in religion they will not accept a non-Muslim, non-Arab nation in their midst." Israel is double-steeped in religion.
18:17 on 15/11/2012
The state of Israel should never have been created. Big mistake.