Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Dr Raj Persaud
 
GET UPDATES FROM Adrian Furnham
 

Hair Colour and Attraction - Is the Latest Psychological Research Bad News for Redheads?

Posted: 26/09/2012 01:00

Startling new psychological research challenges previous thinking that hair colour is merely about personal preference. Instead a massive consensus appears to exist on which hair colour is preferred, and there also appears to be such severe prejudice associated with the tint of your locks, this is possibly as harsh as racial discrimination.

For example, Nicolas Guéguen from the Université de Bretagne-Sud, in France, has just published a research paper entitled 'Hair Colour and Courtship: Blond Women Received More Courtship Solicitations and Redhead Men Received More Refusals', and it's published in the academic journal 'Psychological Studies'.

In the first study he conducted, female subjects, wearing blond, brown, black or red coloured wigs, were observed while sitting in a nightclub. In a second study, male collaborators wearing different coloured wigs asked women in a nightclub for a dance.

The intriguing results are that blond women were more frequently approached by men, whereas blond males did not receive more acceptances to their requests. However, in both conditions, red hair was associated with significantly less attractiveness.

Guéguen points out that previous surveys across the globe find dark fringes account for more than 90% of all natural hair, whereas blond accounts for only 2%, while red makes up only 1% worldwide. One theory had been that women who change their hair colour, prefer less common tints, so as to increase how they might stand out and therefore attract male attention.

Guéguen cites previous research into blond female door-to-door fundraisers receiving more donations, than their brunette counterparts. Another prior study found waitresses with blond hair got more tips. In yet another previous study, female confederates in their early twenties of the experimenter, were asked to hitchhike while wearing a blond, brown or black wig. Blond, compared to brown or black hair was associated with more male drivers stopping to offer rides, whereas no effect from hair color was found on female drivers who stopped.

In Guéguen's most recent research, a female subject sat in a night club for one hour, and the number of men who approached asking for a dance was measured. The experiment was carried out on 16 different nights in a four-week period. Each subject tested four different wigs four times. In that crucial hour, overall, 127 men approached the women wearing a blond wig, 84 men approached the brown wigged lady, 82 went up to the black haired woman but only 29 approached the red haired lady.

Guéguen reports previous research which found over 80% express a dislike for people with red hair, and also that the skin colour of most redheads was the most disliked of the eight skin colours proposed in a prior experiment.

Given that women are supposed to be less impressed with mere physical appearance, when evaluating how attracted they are to men, how would different hair colour fare on men when it came to women's desire in a similar night club scenario? In the second phase of the experiment, while slow songs were playing in the nightclubs, four 20 year old male confederates were instructed to ask a woman for a dance.

27.5% of the women said yes to men wearing a blond wig, 30% for the men with a brown wig, 35% acceptances for the invitation to dance were received for men wearing black hair, but only 13.8 % for men who donned a red wig.

Although psychologists argue that women are less interested in men's physical characteristics, when it comes to what determines attractiveness, (compared to men's preferences in women), it seems that red hair was associated in this experiment with dramatically less responsiveness to men's courtship requests from women.

Viren Swami and Seishin Barrett, psychologists at the University of Westminster, London, had earlier conducted a similar experiment. In their study the female subject, a natural brunette, dyed her hair blond and red. She sat in various nightclubs over many weeks, and the experimenters observed and counted how many men approached her during a one hour period. When she was blond, 60 men came up to her, while brunette the figure dropped to 42 and then when red, male interest languished at 18 approaches.

Swami and Barrett also surveyed men in these same nightclubs probing them on attitude to female hair colour, using pictures of the same female confederate with different hair colours. In the study entitled 'British men's hair color preferences: An assessment of courtship solicitation and stimulus ratings', when she was brunette the woman was actually rated as most attractive from her image, so how come the men actually approached her more, when she was blond?

One theory Swami and Barrett propose is based on the fact that their female confederate in the experiment was also rated as more 'needy' by men when she was a blond in the photographs, than when she was a brunette or redhead. The study has recently been published in the 'Scandinavian Journal of Psychology' and argues blonds being perceived as needier may have encouraged men to make approaches, possibly because it induced greater feelings of dominance or confidence in them, which in turn reduced their inhibition.

Perceptions of the blond confederate as being more needy may have reduced men's fear of rejection or fear of an hostile response, which increased their chances of approaching her as a blond.

Interestingly men rated the brunette in the pictures as most intelligent compared to all the hair colours, but also the most arrogant. The red head picture was rated as the least shy, the most temperamental and the most sexually promiscuous of all hair colours.

While settling the controversy over who is preferred in the bedroom might have to await more research, there is some intriguing psychological research which finds a preference for red heads in the board room.

Margaret Takeda, Marilyn Helms and Natalia Romanova from the University of Tennessee and Dalton State College in the USA recently looked at the hair colour of all 500 Chief Executive Officers of the London Financial Times Stock Exchange (FTSE) top 500 companies by market capitalization.

Of the 500 CEOs analyzed, 5% were blonds and 4% had red hair, but given that within the UK population, approximately 25% boast blond and 1% red hair, the researchers found blonds, who are perceived traditionally as incompetent but likeable, were under-represented in positions of corporate leadership in the UK. Redheads, while normally a minute number in the U.K. population, were 'over-selected' to run some of the UKs (and Europe's) leading, richest companies.

Stereotypically this would be expected, the authors of this study entitled 'Hair Colour Stereotyping and CEO Selection in the United Kingdom', argue, as redheads are perceived to be competent, though not especially congenial.

Takeda and colleagues pose an interesting question in their paper published in 2006 in the academic periodical, 'Journal of Human Behaviour in the Social Environment' - should hair colour be included in the anti-discrimination legislation? They point out if selection of CEOs is partly based on hair colour, as their research indicates, does it constitute discriminatory prejudice?

The authors note that in the US, for example, colour as currently defined in the statutory basis for non-discrimination in employment, refers to the shade of a person's skin, and not race alone. This is because within a race, a variety of skin colours can exist. There is well-documented bias in faviour of lighter skin so US discrimination laws refer to skin colour, but, in the light of recent research, should they now also include hair colour?

Incidentally while discussing discrimination, it might be important to note that in the Takeda study, only two of the 500 CEOs were women.

 
FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Startling new psychological research challenges previous thinking that hair colour is merely about personal preference. Instead a massive consensus appears to exist on which hair colour is preferred, ...
Startling new psychological research challenges previous thinking that hair colour is merely about personal preference. Instead a massive consensus appears to exist on which hair colour is preferred, ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 55
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
19:43 on 03/10/2012
They'll be some over paid, over qualified dim wit making this up as they go along.
15:07 on 02/10/2012
As a redhead of 54 years of age I can say that attitudes towards red hair have deteriorated over the years - and they were not good when I was small. Redheads are the last definable group that can legitimately be targeted by comedians now prohibited from making racist jokes. The damage that this does is considerable, reinforcing negative stereotypes. It is imperative that discrimination legislation should include hair colour as well as skin colour to stop this persecution - for it is persecution and it has a very profound and negative impact on peoples lives. Redheads were once regarded as wildly alluring, look at the work of painters such as Titian, the work of the Pre-Raphaelites or Hollywood stars such as Rita Hayworth. The current prejudice merely reflects current prejudice and it will only be halted when it becomes as unacceptable to abuse people for the colour of thier hair as much as for the colour of their skin. Doubtless the people who think this is all 'piffle' are the same ones who argued against the introduction of legislation designed to prevent racism. Isn't it extraordinary that we work so hard to protect animals that are becoming extinct yet do not acknowledge the impact that the very real prejudice against red-heads is having - please remember that a certain sperm bank reported a year ago that it was no longer prepared to have red-haired donors as people did not want the risk of having a red-haired child.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
22:03 on 27/09/2012
I think attitudes towards red hair have changed a lot. My mother in law is 90 and she still dyes her (now white) hair red. It was her best feature when she was young and much admired. Now it seems to be major target for bullies. Perhaps it is one of the last things that differ between us that can be picked on without fear of rebuke, or accusations of racism? I also used to dye my mousy hair red when I was younger.
23:46 on 27/09/2012
PART 1 --- I have to agree with you about red hair being a target for bullies nowadays.

A sad sign of the times l`m afraid, and carried out by immature and spiteful people, who need an outlet for their own inadequacies and frustrations, and targeting someone else for their perceived " imperfections" somehow makes them feel better about themselves, but only temporarily!

l will never forget the fairly recent article on Parentdish, which was about a Santa, and a mother and her little girl. this child was only 4 years old, but, purely because she had red hair, became the target of abusive and hurtful comments.

l just could not comprehend how people, who were supposed to be adults, but clearly they were not, would choose to react in this nasty, spiteful and immature way and l made many comments on the matter.

l travel a lot to Europe, Germany in particular, and l have NEVER come across such behaviour towards children there as l see here in the uk, on a daily basis, there is something very wrong here when people target a FOUR YEAR OLD, one thing l am certain of is that this little four year old was more mature then those people and put them to shame, and rightly so.

.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
23:59 on 27/09/2012
I didnt see that,but I heard a phone in on the radio a few weeks ago with some awful accounts of bullying because of red hair. Also nasty comments, like a lady who had someone look at her baby in its pram and say "What a shame!" I cant believe anybody would say something like that, never mind to a complete stranger!
23:47 on 27/09/2012
PART 2 --- And good on your mother in law for defying the bullies, and being her own person, at 90 years old she is great, with that attitude she could live to be 100!!

Remember that ALL bullies are cowards, because they cannot act alone, they are basically sheep, always in a little clique, which makes them feel secure, it`s sad really if you think about it, because quite a few have themselves, often in their childhood been the victims of bullying themselves, a good enough reason to want to stop as they know how a victim feels, but sadly it is often a vicious and ongoing cycle
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:44 on 27/09/2012
Unfortunately this research is flawed - it shows different attitudes to people who wear wigs of different hair colour. The experiment needs to be conducted with people whose REAL hair is of different colours.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr Raj Persaud
17:15 on 27/09/2012
Many thanks for your post - apologies but I don't agree with you. All experiments are flawed to some extent - there is no perfect experiment and the attempt to refine and eliminate error in studies marks the forward progress of science. In the copy above a further experiment was conducted where a woman dyed her hair so the colour was different and a similar experiment was then conducted as to the 'wigs' experiment - with similar results to the 'wigs'. The reason you can't do the experiment you suggest with meaningful results, is that the experimenters need to control for appearance other than hair colour - what that means practically is that everything must be the same - only hair colour changes - in order to test the theory over the impact of hair colour on attraction. You need the same person but different hair colour to test reaction.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
17:43 on 27/09/2012
I wonder what part would non-matching eyebrows play in this experiment? 
10:01 on 27/09/2012
Woman go for looks just as much as men do. I see it all the time, everywhere I go, at work, at clubs etc. Sure, there are exceptions to everything but in most cases, women are no different.
09:31 on 27/09/2012
3 of my 4 children are redheads,2 of them boys (well,men now) all have no no trouble whatsoever getting dates & lovely partners,all have great personalities. The 4th,& only brunette, who is a dad himself was disapointed HIS child did NOT turn out to be ginger like his beloved sister.
WHO says its a 'defective' gene ?/Where did that come from? its known to be RECESSIVE,therefore more rare (tho' I have 3 out of 4 !,when only 1 grandparent out of the 4 was remotely reddish !)
And how come the most popular DYED hair-colour is RED !?!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jan Baer
grandparentoptions
21:39 on 01/10/2012
Yes, I was noticed positively for my red hair, as a child of 5 and on, and as a child whose mother had died and father was serving in the Army, might well have been not noticed at all by the miserable, preoccupied relatives I lived with. Of course, that was a long time ago, but if people can't get beyond one's hair color, are they worth having as friends or colleagues?
07:02 on 27/09/2012
Surely its the person inside that counts not the colour of their hair or skin
photo
Uriella
In the midst of winter I found Invincible Summer
08:40 on 27/09/2012
Absolutely, 100 percent right on, oscar...couldn't agree more...:-)
10:12 on 27/09/2012
I agree.

What I hear is so much more important than what I see! I've found some women that were not physically attractive initially but there inner beauty was so strong that their shell became beautiful to my eyes.

Inner beauty is rare!
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
04:22 on 27/09/2012
"Given that women are supposed to be less impressed with mere physical appearance" Ha! I mean HA!! Supposed by whom?
spudato
It's a hybrid
23:34 on 26/09/2012
Aint nothing wrong with redhead's ....... except maybe Rebekah Brookes .......... but then again , just don't take your mobile with you !
19:54 on 26/09/2012
load of bollock's.
19:31 on 26/09/2012
I think it is one of those ridiculous things that is handed down through the generations, like parents frighten their kids to death about going to the dentist. There is no reason whatsoever for people to be predjudiced against hair colour, or the dentist! What a total nonsense.
17:40 on 26/09/2012
Depends on the red head or the woman what ever colour hair she has.
16:14 on 26/09/2012
Not attracted to redheads? Must be gay. Rebeka Brooks ( phone tapping ), Dr Who's assistant, very hot totty.
08:57 on 27/09/2012
A young blond girl told me that she wasn't ginger, I said I could see she wasn't, silly me, she had to explain it for me!!
16:09 on 26/09/2012
I would have love to marry a red head women they seem to have that fire insde them that make a mrried work will,people I have know to married red heads are still were others have gone they own way.
13:03 on 27/09/2012
I married one, and was told that it wouldnt last, that was well over 30 years ago, I wouldnt say "She Who Must Be Obeyed" is of fiery temperament, but the marriage seems to work
15:52 on 26/09/2012
What a load of piffle !