Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Helen Croydon

GET UPDATES FROM Helen Croydon
 

Can't Stomach a Grunting Female on Court? Go Listen to Yourselves in the Gym Guys!

Posted: 11/07/2012 00:00

Not since the sexist introduction the male-only Gentleman's Club has there been such an outrageous gender double standard as the plans to curb grunting in women's tennis. The International Tennis Federation and the Women's Tennis Association are drawing up plans to put a stop to the female grunter because of 'complaints by fans and players.'

Last week Sabine Lisicki accused opponent Bojana Jovanovski of grunting so loudly it gave her an advantage in their Wimbledon match. World number one Maria Sharapova and Serena Williams are also common culprits in these 'complaints'.

I've found that many bar-stool social commentators on the annoyance of the female grunt are men. Ha, the audacity! The male species complaining about the vociferous nature of women? That's like Bob Diamond complaining about interest rates or Jimmy Carr complaining about the tax system.

Anyone who finds female grunting remotely offensive clearly does not keep up their gym routine. The grunting, panting and overall aural outbursts of sonant strain from the free weights area is a right old cacophony.

From cheap basement muscle gyms of my student days with the aroma of pungent feet to my current spa-like riverside club, the grunting barely varies. But for a few middle-class accented mid-vowels and a softer delivery on some of alveolar flaps, a toff grunt is just as offensive as any exercising male's groaning, snorting and heavy breathing.

I've never heard anyone complain about weight-lifting discord, but believe me, as cardio goes out of fashion and we turn to kettle bells and building core strength, gym grunting is a ticking time bomb social taboo. It's gonna be right up there with burping, farting, spitting, picking noses and talking with your mouth full.

Actually, a vociferous, sweating, male bench-presser is even more offensive than any of the above. That's because his sonorific similarities to sex is unmistakable and he darn well knows it. I can't help thinking that men who make no attempt to reign in their workout caterwauling do so because on some misogynist level they know that the sexual association will make the women in the room feel uncomfortable. It's the equivalent of scratching balls whilst walking down the street to greet a woman and then offering your hand - they know it's offensive but they do it anyway because it stamps a wonton masculinity to his presence.

Like a dog peeing on a post, the male gym grunter is filling marking his bench with audible pheromones.

Being a five-times-a-week gym-goer for about 12 years, I've filtered out any uncomfortable carnal connections and instead taken to entertaining myself between bicep curls by personality typing the grunters:

Firstly, there are the ones who use open front unrounded vowel sounds (like as in aaaaahhhhhh): Probably lack self-control and shout to get attention.

Secondly, there are the ones who resort to fricatives so they barely even need to open their mouths. (like as in a sssssssssssss or ttttthhhhhhhhh): Probably repressed and harbour anger.

Thirdly, there are those that articulate glottal stops, producing a short but repeated obtrusion of air (kind of like ugh, ugh, ugh like a desperate unsympathetic lover): Lack patience and do terribly with the opposite sex.

And finally there are the growlers. Grrrrrrr, go their throats as they try to lift two 20kg dumbbells. Grrrrr again! Then they drop it after a pathetic three reps and let out the most almighty sigh, letting the entire gym floor know how hard that was: They think they are irresistible. Grrrrr, come get me, I am a tiger.

To impose vociferous restraint on female tennis players is no less than gender engineering - the sort we'd expect to find in the eighteenth century. Men are intrusively more vocal than women on every level. They huff and they puff and they sigh and they click fingers. And need I say anything about snoring? The statistics weren't available when I researched but I bet you 90% of purchasers of earplugs are women who share bed space with men. To add insult to insomnia, the foam ones fall out and the silicone ones get stuck in our hair. And they collect dust if you leave them out on the side table. Yuk, you say? Yes isn't it just.

It is also yuk when some nationalities of men click at attractive women in the street, like we are a horse. It is yuk when men in some other cultures clear their throat and spit in the street - the phelgmmier the sound the better. In some cultures they burp to show appreciation of food. In all these noisy protocols it is always the male voice which reverberates the strongest. The dense, deep, rasping, throaty tones send sound waves booming across large spaces. The idea that few female tennis players letting off a little baying on the courts has caused such a ruckus is quite hilarious. I had a good cackling hoot about that.

 
 
 

Follow Helen Croydon on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Helen_Croydon

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Not since the sexist introduction the male-only Gentleman's Club has there been such an outrageous gender double standard as the plans to curb grunting in women's tennis. The International Tennis Fede...
Not since the sexist introduction the male-only Gentleman's Club has there been such an outrageous gender double standard as the plans to curb grunting in women's tennis. The International Tennis Fede...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
21:40 on 13/07/2012
Ms. Croydon, I have nothing against women grunting. I'd like to encourage it when possible.

I want to apologize on behalf of decent men everywhere for the hateful comments you've received under this blog. It is unconscionable that some men behave this way. Please do not think all of us are like this.
19:53 on 12/07/2012
Oh please, I've not heard this complaint from men once, and as the only female student at the school I attend for training in bukti-negara, I hear a lot. As far as my guru is concerned if you're not grunting you're not working hard enough.
This comment has been removed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
22:21 on 11/07/2012
Wow...your therapist must have such a nice boat.
20:48 on 11/07/2012
Letting off steam and losing it is best kept for the bars you appear to know so well.
20:28 on 11/07/2012
I hope the author realizes that it's their female opponents that are complaining about the grunts.

What mental gymnastics did the author perform to blame men for this?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
22:22 on 11/07/2012
It's actually a pretty simple two step process...it just seems complicated to thinking human beings.

1- ignore reality.

2- blame men.

This is Chapter 1 of Feminism 101.
18:15 on 11/07/2012
First, find me the men who are into women's tennis. Yes, I know there are some - I just don't know any. Then, narrow that down to the ones complaining about women grunting in tennis.

Now, answer 2 questions:
1) Are men really complaining more than women?
2) Even if the answer to 1 is yes, how are you going to get everybody to buy into the idea that this tiny subset of men are somehow representative of men in general?
20:27 on 11/07/2012
Exactly.

The only people complaining about the grunts are other female tennis players who are saying it distracts them.

But never mind facts, Men are always the problem with these misandrists.
16:54 on 11/07/2012
"Like a dog peeing on a post, the male gym grunter is filling marking his bench with audible pheromones."

The author sees men as dogs, peeing dogs.

It is also yuk when some nationalities of men click at attractive women in the street, like we are a horse.

She also resents the idea of being thought of as a horse.

BTW, I like grunting women in tennis. Female athletes should be free to win however they can. If it's part of their game, who cares.
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
16:48 on 11/07/2012
Growler here, but not during sex. Your first type "Uhh! Oof!" are following well understood vocalization principles, like the "Heeyah!" in karate.
16:11 on 13/07/2012
Yup, in martial arts breathing (which causes the grunting) is just as essential to every movement as where you place your body. Most times you strike on the exhale, hence some grunting or vocalization occurs.
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
16:24 on 13/07/2012
I'm pretty loud, boisterous, ok probably annoying. I agree with the author that men tend to be louder, at least partly because it works, as you say. I have some weights but I don't usually go to a gym anymore, except maybe like a hotel gym, mostly because there's women there now, and I'm simply not ever voluntarily going to make myself be around a bunch of half naked (quietly) sweating women. All of the men-only gyms around here became coed years ago, but there are women-only gyms.
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
16:43 on 13/07/2012
I do have a grunting story. I had a wreck and lost the use of my right leg, and it atrophied over 6 months. I had to complete a 12 week rehab to get me out of the wheelchair. There was always other patients doing physical therapy, and the therapists were always trying to encourage the women to make noise "C'mon Elissa, you can do it, push yourself!" But even the querulous out-of-breath old men were always making painful noises and did not need to encouraged. Me, they kept telling me to quiet down!

The hardest thing I ever did was at the end of the 12 wks, I had to lift my good left leg and stand on my bad leg. It hurt, but that wasn't the problem. It refused to obey; my good leg; it worked fine, but it would not let me change my full weight to my bad leg. My own body rebelled. I was shocked, then scared, then angry. I fussed, and shouted at it, and stood there trembling and sweating, and tried to use my hands to lift it.
continued
13:15 on 11/07/2012
I still don't want to watch women's tennis.
12:53 on 11/07/2012
I suspect Ms Croydon has had this little article rattling round the empty cavity in her head called 'essay ideas' for some time. She has chosen to misunderstand the intention of the grunting debate, so that she could pen her own little 'Menoupausal in the City and still Slim' style column for her fans (the coven of divorcees that usually meet midweek for chardonnay and fat free cottage cheese no doubt). The fact that quite a few ex tennis pro's, Ms Navratilova, included view the excessive grunting in womens tennis as plain and simple cheating, designed to disturb the opponents concentration. But then what would she know?
12:52 on 11/07/2012
Oh shame on me for being a man!
If men are such dreadfully noisy beasts why is it just female tennis players that are complained about?
22:01 on 10/07/2012
Ms. Croydon knows little about tennis: grunting is done to unsettle opponents. It could more properly be called "screaming." In spite of the writer's nastiness, she qualifies as little more than another feminist whiner. Nice try.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
parlimentMike
It's not un-American to investigate 4 crimes.
20:48 on 10/07/2012
Author seems to be quite uninformed on the matter.
leftcoastindy
Where did I put my MOJO
20:39 on 10/07/2012
Its not the grunt of effort we dont like. Its the noise for even medium effort shots.

And I like to watch Maria anyway.
21:23 on 10/07/2012
Yep. Maria--whom I like, too---shrieks. She doesn't grunt. And she doesn't do it all the time. She can turn it on and off. This article is just more anti-male HP claptrap.

It even leads with other female players, not men, complaining about the shriek sisters.

But, somehow, it's all the fault of men.
leftcoastindy
Where did I put my MOJO
21:53 on 10/07/2012
Yep, and very few men make stupid sounds in the gym, same as tennis.