Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
James Phelge

GET UPDATES FROM James Phelge
 

What Makes Bob Dylan Suck?

Posted: 29/12/2011 00:00

This latest Christmas was one of the very few where we didn't play any Christmas music at home, which is no mean feat, as over the years as we seem to have collected a good few listening hours.

Mostly it is a collection of the standard Christmas song favourites performed by different singers. There was a time when we would dig those albums out and start airing them around a week before the event. Over the years, the playing period gradually came down to a few hours on Christmas Eve. This year it was: "I'd better play the Christmas records now" to which the response was: "We're watching TV". Festive spirit in our house has become a memory.

From ever since I can remember, almost every major established recording artist, has at some point in their career, felt the need to add their own interpretation of musical yuletide greetings to their recording port folio. "Your Name" followed by Christmas Album is like the winning of a lifetime achievement award.

That one album suggest you are an acceptable friend to be invited into peoples homes to share the festive period. The good thing about Christmas albums from the commercial side is - the songs never go out of date and the album can be sold to a new bunch of consumers every year. This is a good deal if you are the artist - a potential lifetime selling record that never ages.

Now, some of the rock artists have never succumbed to making a Christmas record, maybe seeing this as a bad move for their images. The Rolling Stones are one such example. This year they released a DVD of the 1978 Some Girls live concert just in time for the gift buying season - but this does not mean they won't have a traditional festive album out next year.

The reason being - their old mate Bob Dylan surprised everybody by releasing his own Christmas in the Heart album in 2009. If a Christmas Album is cool enough for Bob Dylan - then it sure is cool enough for everyone else. Standby to see a flurry of rock bands wanting to spend their future Christmas times with you at home and give your neighbours a good blast. I'm surprised Bob waited almost 50 years before making his move.

Then I began thinking: What else can be done to expand consumers interest to spend money in the pop music Christmas market? When I sat down to eat my Christmas dinner - the answer came in an immediate flash of divine brilliance - Bob Dylan Christmas Crackers. Just imagine some red & silver crackers carrying a picture of Bob wearing a Santa hat on the front - they will be guaranteed to ensure your guests have a common conversation topic right from the start of the meal. I've already come up with the first cracker joke as well. This you will find once you have pulled the cracker and taken out the paper Dylan type hat - taking care not to drop the miniature plastic guitar key ring at this stage. Then you get to the joke Q: What makes Bob Dylan suck? A: Playing the harmonica.

We can call these StarCrackers and they can easily be adapted to feature other artists. Just imagine the difficulty trying to find a present for a Dylan fan - they will already have all the books and records - the crackers will be something you can give every year that also has a use.

Now, let me tell you about the sound-alike battery operated Robin that sings Justin Bieber songs.....

 

Follow James Phelge on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JamesPhelge

FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT
This latest Christmas was one of the very few where we didn't play any Christmas music at home, which is no mean feat, as over the years as we seem to have collected a good few listening hours. Most...
This latest Christmas was one of the very few where we didn't play any Christmas music at home, which is no mean feat, as over the years as we seem to have collected a good few listening hours. Most...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
m320753
04:01 on 30/12/2011
dylan's Christmas album was for charity. dylan didn't receive one penny for it. his newest tribute album is also donating all profits to Amnesty international. something very few artists have done in the history of recorded music. also 70 something artists sang a dylan song gratis for the album. so to take the albums as a money making projects is way off the mark. now if your remark about Christmas cookies, i don't think you have a chance of getting permission to market them, though they are a great idea
21:24 on 29/12/2011
I mean at least listen to the Dylan Christmas album. It's heartfelt and beautiful. The growl adds such emotion to the songs.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:59 on 01/01/2012
And have you seen that video for 'Must be Santa? An absolute hoot, all my family just love it.
13:41 on 29/12/2011
James, this is thin gruel even for the week between Christmas and New Year's. There is no way Bob Dylan could suck as much as your flimsy excuse for writing.
21:49 on 29/12/2011
You obviously didn't get the joke. He's not saying that Bob Dylan sucks, and this is a very amusing and decently written piece. Try again, Oily!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
James Phelge
23:41 on 30/12/2011
Thanks Stuart. Yes, it's just about marketing people finding excuses to sell... Also, for non musicians, when you play harmonica 'Some times you suck in, and sometimes you blow..' -))
23:41 on 28/12/2011
Ah, right. I thought I was going to have to fly to Bob Dylan's defence here, like I've been doing ever since that time he came on the Halfords Newcastle staff room radio in 1964. But Christmas songs...I've bottled out of listening to his Christmas album so far. I still haven't got over Bowie's foray into the genre.

The music snob in me will say that my favourite Christmas record is Big Maybelle's version of 'Silent Night'; ditto the Simon & Garfunkel track '7 O'clock News/SilentNight', but deep down I also love most of Elvis' Christmas Album and wish that Phil Spector's classic hadn't been so overplayed down the years since it came out.

Beyond there lies the magic of Nat King Cole, Dean Martin, Harry Belafonte and Bing Crosby, people I turned my back on for a while when Rock'n'Roll, blues & folk came to town, but they're now fully rehabilitated in my collection. Those rude Stones boys shouldn't have trashed your Perry Como LP, if they haven't replaced it yet they should do so immediately.

But a Christmas record by Dylan? I'd probably skip that, but would definitely buy those Star Crackers, James, and my granddaughter will want the Justin Beiber version. Yes, she likes him; "He doesn't need Autotune and he really plays his own instruments, Granddad!", but she also likes Eminem and Dylan (unless she's just being nice to me when she says that).
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
James Phelge
00:03 on 29/12/2011
Lol, sounds like we may almost have the same Christmas collection. I still have that original Como album. It was also reissued in Stereo, but the cover is a cheapo version. Meanwhile, I still have until this weekend to justify spinning this stuff....-))
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
m320753
23:17 on 30/12/2011
i have a lot of old albums both Christmas and not. they're on the old 78rpm, 6 records to an album given to me by my mom's uncle. the sound isn't that great even though they are in pristine shape
Javalation
Laughing in a Daydream
00:58 on 29/12/2011
I never quite forgave Bowie for appearing on a Bing Crosby special and singing a duet. Bizarre.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
James Phelge
13:36 on 29/12/2011
Maybe because Crosby had a big audience....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
m320753
23:19 on 30/12/2011
that was an honor for bowie to sing with crosby a top of the pack crooner. or he wouldn't have done it
23:33 on 28/12/2011
What makes Bob Dylan suck? He can't sing!
whitebeach
Hey, buddy, can you spare a micro-bio?
00:23 on 29/12/2011
That's what makes him the very first rapper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
m320753
23:25 on 30/12/2011
and he made the 1st video n the opening of the movie don't look back. he had a decent voice until the late 90s when cigarettes and bourbon took his voice
09:55 on 29/12/2011
Ha ha ha - you're a genius StuckinNj. I've never herd that before. Dylan can't sing. Ha ha ha...