Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Justin Byworth

GET UPDATES FROM Justin Byworth
 

Defending Aid Should Not Be Hard Sell for New Development Secretary

Posted: 11/10/2012 00:00

Delegates at the Tory Party conference heard some impressive statistics this morning. Among them, aid has helped stop a quarter of a million newborn babies dying needlessly. A further 11million children now have access to permanent schooling.

Justine Greening, the new development secretary, was setting out her stall for Britain's overseas aid spending - stressing the importance of transparency and value for money, arguing that helping the world's poorest is "the right thing to do and the smart thing to do".

We must also reassure critics that modern-day development goes much further than carrying out vaccinations and food distributions to the largest number of people for the least investment.

As the government acknowledges, the reality of effective aid is far more complicated. We need to empower people in the communities we work to campaign for better health services; for better education; and for laws to protect children from early marriage and harmful labour. We will also help to provide the solution but it must be what the community wants and needs.

This means we can help people to lift themselves out of poverty for good, rather than achieve quick-fix results which look good on paper for donors.

As the Secretary of State says, we should be focusing our efforts on countries that are less able to help themselves.

The Overseas Development Institute says that, by 2025, most of the world's poorest people will live in fragile and conflict-affected states.

One of the most fragile countries in the world is Afghanistan. A few months ago I visited a tiny maternity unit in the west of the country where new midwives are being trained. Many take up work in remote parts of the country such as Ghor province. It has a population the size of Leeds but, a few years ago, it didn't have a single trained midwife.

That has changed and lives are being saved. And the community is now equipped with expert knowledge and skills which will be passed on. The overall picture is improving too: in the past nine years, the proportion of children dying in the country has halved.

Midwifes are crucial to protecting children. Without trained birth attendants, mothers are much more likely to die in child-birth leaving their babies extremely vulnerable to death and disease.

In another example of local communities changing their own fortunes, World Vision began working with Kiyeyi, a village in Uganda in 2008. At the Kiyeyi Health Centre staff were over-worked, drugs were regularly out of stock and there were many community complaints.

World Vision held meetings introducing the community to Ugandan government health standards so that the local people could successfully lobby local politicians for more resources. Following this community mobilisation the clinic now has five additional nurses, including two midwives.

It's because of these successes that we will continue to argue the British Government is right to increase its overseas aid spending next year to 0.7 per cent of Gross National Income - a tiny fraction of our budget, and less than one penny in every pound.

The fact is that defending overseas aid to sceptics in the Tory party, and elsewhere, shouldn't be a hard sell.

We will inevitably run into difficulties if we pretend that aid is perfect; or that it's a panacea for the developing world.

Once we admit that it's neither - and that aid is only part of the equation - the perfectly legitimate and vital process of scrutinising and debating overseas aid can continue.

 

Follow Justin Byworth on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JustinByworth

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Delegates at the Tory Party conference heard some impressive statistics this morning. Among them, aid has helped stop a quarter of a million newborn babies dying needlessly. A further 11million childr...
Delegates at the Tory Party conference heard some impressive statistics this morning. Among them, aid has helped stop a quarter of a million newborn babies dying needlessly. A further 11million childr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:04 PM on 10/11/2012
The examples she gives is admirable work. Yes the foreign aid should be exactly for instances like that and to the countries which are not third world but fifth world. India and Pakistan are classified as third world, and they both got a billion each!!! but look at thier economies, particularly India, they are set to overtake us in the next few years. So why? The other thing, instead of sending this vast sums in cash, lets employ British people (remember that word "employ") to go out there and do the jabs, do the education........I for one would love to do it few weeks a year, not for pay but just pay the fares and provide food and a place to sleep.
photo
mrs w waugh
Hail Caesar We Who Are About To Die Salute You
12:29 PM on 10/11/2012
We should not give away our money,to anyone we need It all of it,and Cameron knows it ,so there is no reason at all to do it,otherwise we will be the ones needing it......................
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hitchthehero
The world will be safer when there is no religion
03:20 PM on 10/11/2012
Absolutely right Mrs W
photo
mrs w waugh
Hail Caesar We Who Are About To Die Salute You
05:25 PM on 10/11/2012
Thank you Hitch..............xx
11:37 AM on 10/11/2012
Justin you dont have to justify or sell foreign aid to us, you just take tax payers money and do it.we have no say who is entitled to this so called aid,your government gives money to A, a country that has a bigger growing economy than our own, a country that is pursuing a nuclear programme and give none of that aid to the people of which is intended,and B, a country that you give money to is in league with the taliban,ie Pakistan, and none of that aid goes to the people who need it,so stop putting a feather in your own hat and save this country a lot of money.
11:15 AM on 10/11/2012
There is no excuse for giving aid to countries which spend huge amounts of money on weapons and luxury products for the corrupt elite whilst every other sector of UK government spending is facing evere harsher cuts.
10:04 AM on 10/11/2012
This topic really gets up my nose, overseas aid should be deemed criminal while services and welfare are cut to the quick in the donating nation, I can bet my bottom dollar that when China, India, Pakistan and Africa are all thriving economies the very last thing they'll be thinking about will be aid to western society after our economies have crumbled. It just goes one step further to prove the incompetence of our political establishment when they're willing to place those here on the poverty line while shoring up those overseas we owe nothing to, it must end and the sooner the better.
08:09 AM on 10/11/2012
Let me tell you here and now, First choice are definitely going to be awarded the North West rail line service, and it is most unfair for anyone to suggest that as ministers we have not throughly checked the procedure for handing out this franchise, and as far as we at the transport ministry are concerned this is just sour grapes from virgin! Ps as the MP for Putney, a part of London blighted by Air Traffic in and out of Heathrow I could not be part of a government who has plans for a third runway at Heathrow!