Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mimi Bekhechi

GET UPDATES FROM Mimi Bekhechi
 

Killer Whales - Liberty and Justice for All

Posted: 07/02/2012 23:00

In a precedent-setting case, PETA US, three marine-mammal experts and two former orca trainers are suing SeaWorld on behalf of five orcas who were taken from their home by force, locked up, put to work and never allowed to leave. The case intends to prove that these orcas are being held as slaves in violation of the 13th Amendment to the US Constitution. The suit is one of the most groundbreaking legal cases ever to reach the courts - the first ever to assert that a constitutional right should extend to nonhuman animals.

In the not-too-distant past, newspapers vigorously editorialised in opposition to extending to women the right to own property, gain custody of their children or vote. "What's next?" they wrote, "The right of asses to vote?" The idea of women attending medical school was similarly denounced with bold statements asserting that these "frail creatures" would "faint at the sight of blood." Black men and women were declared "subhuman" and "lacking in the emotions, senses and morals of white people," and those who fought for their rights often found themselves attacked not only in print but also by enraged supremacists.

We can be ashamed of our past shortsightedness and bigotry, but to fail to examine our present treatment of those we see as "different" is to put at risk our society's moral evolution. Our current challenge is to put history's lessons to work today, and PETA US' lawsuit can and will do just that.

Orcas in the wild lead rich, complex lives. They are intelligent animals who work cooperatively, form close relationships, communicate using distinct dialects and swim up to 100 miles every day. Orcas at SeaWorld are forced to toil day after day, repeating the same endless tasks with no choice in the matter and no escape. They have been turned into perpetual breeding machines to provide more performers for SeaWorld's cruel shows.

Attorneys will ask for Tilikum, Katina, Kasatka, Ulises and Corky to be released into a more appropriate environment, such as a coastal sanctuary. Protected sea pens would allow these orcas greater freedom of movement; the ability to see, sense and communicate with their wild cousins and other ocean animals; and the ability to feel the tides and waves and engage in the types of behaviour that define who they are.

Our understanding of animals expands every day. Animals are no longer regarded as "things" to dominate but as breathing, feeling beings with families, intellect and emotions. The UK was the first country in the world to introduce an animal welfare law to prevent the cruel treatment of cattle in 1882, and the European Union officially recognised animals as sentient beings back in 1997. What we should really be asking ourselves is this: why is it taking so long for animals to gain legally recognised rights? Just as we look back with shame at a time when humans were viewed by some as property and less deserving of protection and consideration, we will look back with shame on our current treatment of animals.

 

Follow Mimi Bekhechi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@Mimi_Bekhechi

FOLLOW UK
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:55 PM on 02/09/2012
The suit was dismissed as silly. But, we're all hopeful this will mean more naked women.
07:07 PM on 02/08/2012
We know that Orcas and all cetaceans that are held in captivity are unhappy because of changes in their personality and actions. Whales and dolphins in captivity develop bacterial infections, blindness and nutritional deficiencies from living their lives in a tank and being fed a diet of frozen fish and antibiotics. We know that whales and dolphins communicate by sonar, and that their sonar waves bounce off the stiff concrete walls of their holding tanks, causing depression. Whales and dolphins are highly social mammels that construct complex societies just like humans -- Scientists can confirm that cetacean social development is even more developed than humans'.


Whales and dolphins that "live" in captivity are not there of their own volition. Either they, or their mommies and daddies, have been captured from the wild in brutal hunting processes. Their environments are disturbed and they are sold into slavery away from their families. The 2010 award winning documentary "The Cove" exposes the process of how cetaceans are captured, and how most are eventually slaughtered. Please watch the film before making your decision on PeTA's motives and judicial action.
05:19 PM on 02/08/2012
are you kidding? liberty and justice for whales? sometimes I think HP is a comedy website
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
messy
artist, writer, adventurer
03:47 PM on 02/08/2012
Bigoted against WHAT? Earthworms? Ameobas? the candiru catfish?
lastpost
see biography
01:00 PM on 02/08/2012
"these orcas are being held as slaves"
Given that this is home to the highest percentage of incarcerated citizens in the world. It would only provoke a raised eyebrow, if they too were subsidising that economy. By producing licence plates, furniture, and such like.

"What's next?" they wrote, "The right of asses to vote?"
If they are good enough to sit in Parliament and the Lords, then…

"supremacists"
litmus test: To be valid. The most primitive example of the superior form, would have to be less primitive than the most advanced example of the inferior form.

"communicate using distinct dialects and swim up to 100 miles every day."
The ideal pet for David Walliams?

"why is it taking so long for animals to gain legally recognised rights?"
Is it because humans still beat them? When it comes to ease of liquidating assets.
12:57 PM on 02/08/2012
Last time I been to Sea World, the animals didn't look unhappy to me. It's OK to fight for animal's right's, but nobody fight's for the case of a family in which a long standing US legal resident with a clean past cannot bring his wife to the country, regardless of her having a clean past with no immigration violations and being married for several years! Don't families have rights??
08:19 PM on 02/08/2012
Oh.... don't be so ignorant. I went to Sea World as well and I can honestly say that I did not see onee, no not one, single orca laughing. It is animals like you that call them 'Killer Whales' just to give them a bad name.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kevin Mcilroy
10:00 AM on 02/08/2012
Words fail me ... how can PETA know that the Orca aren't quite happy? If a court was stupid enough to agree that the case was right, how long before it is applied to all animals for example guide dog, sniffer dogs, pets used in therpeutic environments?

And how is their treatment that much different to the way I am treated by society? I am not allowed freedom - I am forced to carry out the same dreary tasks day after day - commuting, sitting at a desk pressing buttons - all to support a society that I have no particular relish for?

When will PETA campaign on my behalf?
12:52 PM on 02/08/2012
I imagine PETA assumes that, because in the wild whales will travel for miles and miles in a single day, keeping them in a tank is preventing them from behaving naturally. In UK animal welfare legislation the animal must be allowed, under the 'five freedoms', to express normal behaviour. There is nothing normal about a whale being cooped up in a tiny environment in comparison to its body size, so perhaps this idea is being applied in this case?

You may be treated by society, as you say, in much the same way, but your way of life is out of choice (not matter what you may believe!). If someone came into your house, took you far away from home, put you in a cage and got you to carry out those 'dreary tasks' that would then be criminal offence on their part. See where I'm going with this?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kevin Mcilroy
01:03 PM on 02/08/2012
But WHY do whales travel so far ? Maybe it is because that is the only way that they can be sure of a decent food supply sine if they stay in one place they will starve... the whales in captivity are fed and kept safe from predators (OK the only real predator that threatens an orca is probably man).

As for having a choice in how I live my life, I would like to be able to roam the country freely and set up home where I liked for as long as I like (much as wild whales do according to PETA) but I am not allowed to do that. I have to have a home place that the authorities can find me at or they will harrass me and maybe even imprison me.... where is the freedom in that?

Tongue firmly in cheek - well only to reduce PETA's position to the absurdity I believe it to be
08:55 AM on 02/08/2012
People sometimes read this kind of argument and say that it's insulting to women and non-white people because they are equal to white men in mental and moral capacities whereas animals are not. It's true, of course, that non-human animals aren't our equals in many ways but that misses the point. Not all human beings are of equal mental capacity yet we rightly recognise their rights to life and freedom, and that they shouldn't be enslaved or treated as the instruments of those more intelligent than them. Just as colour or gender differences previously blinded the dominant culture to what was right and fair, so physical and generalised mental differences blind us to what is right and fair with animals. They can suffer and enjoy life, they have needs and desires. Those should be respected and this article is absolutely right to point out that we can be just as blinkered as our predecessors. It is offensive to no one to extend justice - we just need to coolly and rationally consider what the true basis of the rights we recognise for all humans are, and ask whether denying them to other sentient beings is justified. It isn't.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Ruyur
I can't believe you like money too. We should h...
12:39 AM on 02/08/2012
"and the European Union officially recognised animals as sentient beings back in 1997."

If there are extraterrestrials observing us, I like to think this is one of the signs of civilization they are watching for.