Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Monica Luppi

GET UPDATES FROM Monica Luppi
 

An Open Letter to Sir Richard Branson

Posted: 23/02/2012 00:00

Dear Mr Branson,

I have watched you speak on various television shows about your views on drugs and have read the blog where you cite Portugal as a positive example of how successful decriminalisation could be if applied worldwide. I won't go into dissecting the evidence you and the Global Commission cite to support your point of view (there's enough of that around already), because mine is not a rebuttal, but an appeal to dig deeper, and perhaps to put your words into concrete actions that could make a positive impact on many lives.

As someone who has worked for over a decade closely with people fighting addiction in order to regain their lives, to beat the odds society has given them by overcoming myriad personal challenges, I felt your remarks were based more on a political ideology than firsthand knowledge of the problem.

Your flippant remarks about "75% of your children's generation smoking cannabis" simply saddened me. Mr Branson, not everyone has the social and economic safety net that you and your friends have. Many more fragile and vulnerable people are listening to your remarks and will fall through the cracks. Wouldn't your considerable wealth and visibility be better spent advocating for real and sustainable rehabilitation programs or funding community-based prevention projects for marginalised youth, instead of sending a message that legitimises an unhealthy lifestyle and does nothing to improve the lives of those suffering from addiction?

I have no doubt you believe what you are saying about drugs and I can agree that prison is no place for an addict. People suffering from addiction deserve the best help they can get. They deserve the support necessary to live lives just as valuable and fulfilling as your or mine. They need real, long-lasting and sustainable support through education, life skills training, and counselling, so they can become active and contributing members of society. Removing accountability for their actions will not help. Of the thousands of former users I have worked with and come to love, I can guarantee that facing the negative consequences of their actions, even those that involved the criminal justice system, very often provided a wake up call, the "push" that was needed to turn their lives around.

Mr Branson, let me ask you a few questions: How many desperate mothers of addicts have you listened to? How many times have you taken an addict into your home and nursed him back to health, taking the time to understand him? Have you met with many who have lost all their money and possessions while a family member struggled through years of drug abuse? Have you spoken with any recovered addicts to better understand the dynamics which brought them to use drugs and the key to helping them find a better life?

I know you are a busy man, but I would like to invite you to come visit the center where I work. It is called San Patrignano, in Italy. I am sure you know that our country has some of the most progressive policies in Europe when it comes to providing alternatives to prison in cases of drug related crime. Many of the 1,000 plus residents who are getting help here would otherwise be in prison. Our services are provided free of charge and we are not funded by the taxpayers but by private donors and earnings from our social enterprises. Perhaps your opinions on drug policy are unchangeable, but I urge you to get the complete picture before getting on the proverbial soapbox again, as there are many lives in the balance. Our doors are open to you.

 

Follow Monica Luppi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/monicalups

Dear Mr Branson, I have watched you speak on various television shows about your views on drugs and have read the blog where you cite Portugal as a positive example of how successful decriminalisati...
Dear Mr Branson, I have watched you speak on various television shows about your views on drugs and have read the blog where you cite Portugal as a positive example of how successful decriminalisati...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 85
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thinking Clearly
Communication is the key to understanding
08:00 PM on 03/10/2012
Monica, I have spent my life helping people who need help to live clean lives without drugs. They asked for my help all on their own. They were not sent there by a judge. They did quite well and recovered from their problems.

Using the "war on drugs" mentality is an effort to force people to do something against their will. Behavioral modification upon an unwilling subject sent by a court is not treatment and does not work. Force + treatment = a well trained animal that behaves, but wants to bite his trainers.

Prohibition does not work, and I suggest that the system you are using to help them does not work either.
Lets draw a line between the rehab system we have today (forced by the courts) and replace it with helpful methods that do not resemble brainwashing and a funded Governmental attempt at making people behave.

Richard Branson is correct.

The paradigm of "treatment" in America and the rest of the world must change if you truly wish to be effective in helping another human being. Make sure it is really help and not a form of Big Brother exercising control over an unwilling population. During the era of alcohol prohibition the problem was no one really wanted alcohol to go away. I think we have reached that stage with marijuana. People don't smoke because they want to break laws. Nor will laws stop them from doing so if they choose to. It's called freedom of choice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
duncan20903
Why do you think that they call it muggles?
12:43 AM on 03/09/2012
Utter horse puckey Monica.
12:38 PM on 02/29/2012
Dear Monica Luppi,

Should we criminalise the activities of hundreds of thousands of people, making it less safe by making the only point of sale criminals, because a tiny minority of people have realised that getting sent to jail is bad so they should seek help for their addiction?

It seems to me you have been rendered myopic by your proximity to the main losers in the drug wars and while I applaud your empathy and activities in helping people I feel your comments are overly emotional and ultimately harmful.
12:21 PM on 02/28/2012
I don't think drug addiction should be fighted against through imprisonment either. Branson was trying to shake things up a bit to generate new modes of thinking about this given problem. I watched a fascinating debate on the drugs recently. One of the speakers suggest that we should reflect on what particular effect and social impact each drug has and assess the framework for prevention on that basis, I think it makes sense - although the other speakers make really stron cases on different methods for dealing with drug cultures. you acn watch the debate on iai.tv: http://iai.tv/video/drug-culture
11:02 AM on 02/27/2012
so i take it that when they are legalised Branson will happily fly with a drugged up plane crew being guided down by a druggie air traffic controller?
photo
WoodyCPM
Now what?
05:49 PM on 02/26/2012
Marijuana, cocaine, sex, gambling, food, nicotine, war, overwork, alcohol, environmental destruction, shopping, oil, religion....name your poison. It's not that we lock people up that's the problem, it's that we lock the wrong people up over the wrong things.
05:34 PM on 02/26/2012
SInce you mention politics. Let us talk about the whole scheme. See extremists on the left and right want to instigate a crisis, rise to power to restore order and oppress us all not just criminals. That being said narcotics and cocaine are being supplied by or due to protection offered by extremist groups. They want to destabilize the United States and reduce us to poverty and force us to work as slaves. This is being done by Americans as well. Alcohol and tobacco are used to enslave lower paid workers. It can cost more than a car payment to smoke and much more to drink. Victims of this conspiracy are not at fault they are often entrapped by government as youths. Government is involved in this conspiracy. That being said these victims are not responsible for being sick and owe nothing for it. They are responsible for their recovery not society since society is to blame for legal and illegal substances.
04:30 PM on 02/26/2012
Ms Luppi, I respect the efforts which you are making to support many people whose lives have been ruined by drug addiction. Your argument that going through the criminal justice system is a useful and effective wake-up call for addicts is, however, not based on good evidence.

The criminalisation of drug use during the last century has instead resulted (like the badly thought-through prohibition of alcohol in the US) in a dramatic increase in users and a phenomenol increase in crime necessary to feed drug habits. Your support system would work as well (indeed much better) in a world in which addiction was treated as a medical problem ratgher than a criminal one.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Monica Luppi
08:14 AM on 02/27/2012
There is a medical component to addiction, but I fear seeing it as a purely medical problem would probably benefit Big Pharma more than drug users themselves (see methadone, subutex, and the boom in psyche med prescriptions).
There are complex underlying factors that lead to and feed addiction, that need to be addressed in a continuum of care that brings about real recovery. On this we agree.
By mentioning the criminal justice system, I was referring also to excellent and effective drug court programs like HOPE in Hawaii which have had real results - these projects do not remove accountability but do not exacerbate the problem by putting people in jail and throwing away the key.
12:27 AM on 03/08/2012
Prohibition entrenches addiction. 'Dealers' don't affix health warnings or turn child customers away. Addicts often forced into drug trade. People not harmed by cannabis doubt credibility of government warnings about other drugs; see harms of tobacco widely accepted whereas harms of cannabis questioned. Prohibition undermines our ability to discourage drug use. Prohibition is a scourge that has magnified drug problems.
11:42 AM on 02/26/2012
Dear Monica congratulations. Your invitation to Mr. Richard Branson to visit San Patrignano is the most clever way to tell him drug legalization is not the most correct way to aid someone who chose drugs to do a living and their suffered families. Last year you were gentle enough to show me what I consider the most fantastic therapeutic community in the world and I saw a lot of them. The speech of those more than one thousand people running San Patrignano rehab facilities, can prove easily each and everyone who actually thinks like Mr. Richard Branson that legalizing drugs is not the most clever tool to teach others to avoid all the "San Patrignano" clinics in our world
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
06:18 AM on 02/26/2012
Nicotin, alcohol, and gambling are also very addictive. But since you do not have to enter the criminal world to get them, the problems are not anywhere near as bad as with the illicit drugs.

I agree with Branson, but rest assured he will not be successful. Many people have tried over the decades to wrestle these billions from organised crime - but it cannot be done. You just can't deprive organised crime of their revenues. If he pushes too hard he will have an accident, in a tunnel, in a helicopter, on the water. It could be a fire or corrupt medical treatment. It will be so important to shut him up that death in his entourage will not matter. If it has to be done through doctors, then they will soon be dead, too.

You should also not forget that the Secret Services have often conducted their affairs with drug money, because they wanted to keep things away from parliaments and the public. It would castrate the Secret Services if drugs were suddenly legal; they'd have no dough for one and the possibility to make people obedient through drugs would also disappear.
TransformDrugs
for more just and effective drug laws
03:30 PM on 02/25/2012
This implication here appears to be that Branson is either closed to the reality of problematic drug use or worse, somehow, pro drug. If you actually look at it There is nothing in what Branson has said or what is in the Global Commission report that is unsupportive of effective treatment and rehabilitation or suggesting they are un aware of the plight of addicts and their dependents.

Among the primary recommendations of the Commission report are "Offer health and treatment services to those in need. Ensure that a variety of treatment modalities are available" and "Invest in activities that can both prevent young people from taking drugs in the first place and also prevent those who do use drugs from developing more serious problems."

The entire thrust of the report is to focus on efforts that reduce the health harms associated with drugs, as well as the harms associated with policy, by reorienting resources to proven public health interventions rather than failed punitive enforcement approaches. Theres nothing in that core message that disagrees with what you are saying. We all want the same thing - a safer, healthier society.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
06:03 AM on 02/24/2012
"Mine is not a rebuttal, but an appeal to dig deeper..." Ignore the facts and work the emotions.
This comment has been removed.
01:01 AM on 02/24/2012
Dear Monica,
Spare a thought too for the thousands who are being killed and tortured daily in Latin America, where I live and work, in the cause of supply to the insatiable demand for illegal drugs, tritely described as "recreational," in the U.S. and Europe. Drug income is deligitimising whole states in our region by the corruption of their judiciaries, law enforcment agencies and executives. There will come a point soon when we say "enough". We will make it legal and those regions of the world who want it can have as much as they want. We are wasting no more lives on those who, from their own choice, elect to use the cursed stuff.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
06:04 AM on 02/24/2012
Legalize drugs and the killing and torturing will stop.
03:53 PM on 02/24/2012
send drug uses to prison for the maximum sentences and it will stop. at the moment we have decriminalization by the back door. to many in the establishment use drugs and are keen to cover for their children. 10years for possession and 25 for supply( no parole) would end the issue within 18 months.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Monicalups
08:16 AM on 02/24/2012
I have been to Colombia, the Golden Triangle and Afghanistan to meet with farmers, development professionals, UN workers, volunteers, etc in researching the issue and have met very very few (I avoid using absolutes) who want drugs to be in their country, legal or not. To the huge majority, there is no honor in growing that "stuff" and they would greatly prefer all the help they can get to convert their crops into sustainable cash (like coffee and cocoa) ad food crops.
Do you work in the field of development or with campesinos? You live in L.A. but do not say how you formed your opinion...
11:32 PM on 02/24/2012
I work in exploration for natural resources, much of the time in the field among settlers and indigenous peoples. Nothing, Monica, pays them better than to grow coca but the business is dangerous and most would indeed prefer a normal life. However, that alternative is not an option for them, either perforce of the gangs who capitalise on their efforts or a total lack of viable alternatives. Simple to provide alternatives? Not so. We lack infrastructure, government, funding and markets for alternative cultivations in much of Latin America and the gangs would do their very best to stop them in any case. No easy solutions I am afraid.
01:41 AM on 03/08/2012
When did coffee bean become a sustainable crop? After they cut down the rain forest to grow it?

By the way, more people have died from caffeine overdose in the last 10 years than during the last 5000 years of cannabis use.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppenguinator
Life's too imprtant to be taken seriously.
09:29 PM on 02/23/2012
Most of the danger of most drugs is caused, notby the drugs themselves, but by other substances mixed in by the dealer in order to strech his supply. If drugs were legalised, this danger would not exist, and far fewer people would be harmed by drugs.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:22 PM on 02/24/2012
One caveat many people don't know is that the sensationalized "drug overdose" with substances like heroin, is not from heroin alone. There are many other substance involved when an overdose occurs. Usually alcohol and/or prescription medication.