Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nicholas Tufnell

GET UPDATES FROM Nicholas Tufnell
 

'I Need to Be Paralysed, It's an Intense Longing'

Posted: 12/12/2012 00:00

"I need to be paralysed. It's an intense longing. I don't know that I have words to describe it today." This is Sean O'Conner, lifelong sufferer of Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID, also referred to as Amputee Identity Disorder). Until very recently I had never heard of BIID, nor had I come across the related hypernym 'transabled'. Sean defines BIID as being...

"... hard to define in just a few words... but in a nutshell, someone who is transabled 'wants' to be disabled. But it is not so much a 'want' as much as a 'need'. Our 'desire' is more a reflection of the fact that our self-image is that of a paraplegic (or amputee, or blind, or any number of other disabilities) than that of an able bodied man or woman."

The medical definition of BIID is a psychological disorder wherein sufferers feel they would be happier living as an amputee. It is typically accompanied by the desire to amputate one or more healthy limbs to achieve that end and can be associated with apotemnophilia, sexual arousal based on the image of one's self as an amputee. I wondered if Sean had any thoughts on what may have caused his, or others' BIID:

"When I was a kid, on long drives, I'd be sitting in the back seat of the car, looking at the scenery and imagining that my legs were paralysed. At the time, I didn't understand 'paralysis'. I thought it meant that the legs couldn't move, that they were stuck in one position, like wooden sticks coming out of one's body. And so I sat in the car, making my legs rigid (though bent at the knee), for hours on end."

"My earliest memory directly related to BIID goes back to when I was about three or four. It is a vivid memory, and when I asked my parents if I had imagined it or not, my parents say that they don't recall exactly, but what I describe fits with what happened at that time in our lives. We were moving house, in the process of packing. A friend of the family picked up a curtain rod, one of those 'L' shaped ones, and placed it along his leg, next to his ankle, and told me that's how you would do a splint for a sprain/broken ankle. Not much of a memory, really. But vivid as if it was yesterday."

I wondered if Sean thought the makeshift splint could have acted as a trigger or a catalyst, whether his BIID was inevitable or born out of circumstance? "I don't know. The thing is, we don't have enough evidence to know. I suspect that the closest answer is that it is a neuropsychological condition. Frankly, I don't care much anymore what caused it. I just want to have access to the only thing currently known to resolve it: surgery."

Sean bought some leg braces in his early 20s and admits there was initially a sexual aspect, "I was a typical teenage boy, full of hormones, and my original interest in braces was a confused one where sexual interest played a big part. The sexual aspect of the interest quickly morphed when I started wearing the braces. I suddenly felt comfortable, safe, supported; it wasn't about sex anymore. I'll readily admit that part of the attraction to braces is still somewhat sexual, but that's not actually directly related to BIID, it has more to do with bondage."

It seems clear to me that BIID is not sexual. Of course, there are some purely fetishised attractions to the notion of disability, it would be naive to suggest otherwise, a minority of BIID sufferers claim there are clear links between sexuality and BIID. But for sexualisation of BIID and BIID itself to be considered one and the same, seems to me to be wrong; a sexual fetish can't possibly be treated with the same amount of respect, understanding and compassion as a neurological disease, which is what BIID sufferers so badly need.

During our brief interview I was struck by the sadness - which admittedly didn't reveal itself often with Sean - and particularly the frustration of his situation. I asked if he could talk to his relatives, parents or friends about his illness "...it depends on the situation. Reactions vary from incredulity to outright rejection, or refusal to listen. It gets easier [to tell people about BIID]. The more self-assured you are of yourself, the easier it is. But there's always fear of rejection which makes it difficult."

Thanks to his website, Sean has managed to gather a small community of BIID as well as different transabled sufferers to share and discuss their stories. Some of the experiences shared by Sean's visitors make for emotional reading. Clare, who seemed to write frequently on the website up until 2009, described how it felt to get her first wheelchair. She writes how, on the morning of its arrival, she was filled with "a strange mixture of excitement and trepidation." She takes it to her office and after unpacking and assembling it, she IMs Sean:

Claire: ok
Claire: are you ready?
Sean: question is, are YOU?
Claire: I don't know

After many doubts and fears over her own self-diagnosis of BIID, and the significance of the situation, she eventually (with the help and encouragement of Sean) sat down for the first time in her wheelchair:

"And the universe shifted... It was off by a few degrees and it made a slight shift and suddenly it was right. I was filled with this unbelievable joy. A feeling of completeness, of rightness, of relief. I felt, rather than heard, a door slamming behind me, the lock turning, no going back now. I could barely keep up the conversation with Sean, my wits were addled, I had nothing coherent to say, but he understood. I couldn't stop smiling. In fact I had a huge, idiot grin on my face."

This was a life changing moment for Clare and no doubt there are countless other individuals who have gone through similar experiences, yet are forced to hide them through shame, fear, guilt or confusion. This may have been a moment of elation, but after talking to Sean, reading his website and trying as best as I could to immerse myself in the community, I fear these happier moments are few and far between.

I asked Sean if BIID ever became too much for him, if he ever felt overwhelmed? "Yes. I often wish I were dead. I don't enjoy being transabled. I don't enjoy the pain it has caused, and is likely to cause, to my family and loved ones who know about how I feel. To quote a transexual acquaintance of mine, 'transition is very hard'. Living as a paraplegic is hard. I'd venture to say that it's actually harder to NOT be a para and live as one than it would be to actually be a paraplegic, because not only do you have all the logistics and difficulties of living from a wheelchair, but you also have all the problems of leading a double life and having no real logistical support for your wheeling. I could go on and on with why life as a transabled individual is hard, but I think there's no need, and I don't want to appear like I'm having a pity-party, which I'm not."

Sean is most certainly not having a pity-party. Time and again I was amazed at the acceptance of his disorder and his unwavering stoicism. He has a problem, he deals with it the best he can, and he gets on with his life. Despite everything, Sean pushes on and is a willing support for other sufferers of the disease; I know if I had BIID, I would be grateful for having Sean around. As with everything out of the ordinary, the rubber-necking comes first, the empathy severely delayed.

Also on HuffPost UK Lifestyle:

Loading Slideshow...

 

Follow Nicholas Tufnell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/nicholastufnell

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
"I need to be paralysed. It's an intense longing. I don't know that I have words to describe it today." This is Sean O'Conner, lifelong sufferer of Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID, also referre...
"I need to be paralysed. It's an intense longing. I don't know that I have words to describe it today." This is Sean O'Conner, lifelong sufferer of Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID, also referre...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 83
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:16 PM on 12/17/2012
I am disabled. I have been in constant pain from fibromyalgia for 26 years. During a severe episode I am not able either to dress or to feed myself. I have a minor spinal cord injury. This gives me constant back pain, muscle spasms, necessity for incontinence protection, etc. I was born with moderate reverse slope hearing loss. I am disabled.

None of this protects me from also being afflicted by the congenital neuropsychological condition of BIID.

There seems to be an agenda of pretending that BIID is a condition which affects only those who are able bodied and not those who have physical impairments. This is a complete fiction. BIID shows no such discretion. I know people with cerebral palsy, spina bifida, spinal cord injuries, etc, who also suffer from BIID. It is utterly disingenuous to suggest that such as these are clueless as to what it is like to live with a disability.

My physician recommended that I use a wheelchair on account of my physical impairments. However, it is of the most utility for treating my BIID. Does this magically make me not a wheelchair user? I am physically unable to ride a bicycle on account of my spinal cord injury. Is not a wheelchair therefore a more sensible choice?

If you are going to criticise me for having BIID, then you should also criticise me for my congenital hearing loss. If not, then the onus is on you to explain the difference.
09:21 PM on 12/13/2012
What a tit.
12:49 PM on 12/13/2012
I really dont understand people like this. You should be glad that you are healthy and that there is very little wrong with you. Im disabled and i get up every day in severe pain. I dont get benifits as i am deemed to be able to go out to work. I have to be helped out of a chair i cant have a bath on my own and im reliant on other people for my care. My condition isnt in my head it is real. I struggle every day and i would love to be able to go out to work and earn my own money.
So this person needs to get a grip there are people who really need help.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Longstaff
12:32 PM on 12/13/2012
Need putting in an asylum that are totally mental. I wonder what a poor disabled person thinks. This person needs some serious treatment. Maybe he wants to live off Tax Payers money he won't have to work then.
11:29 AM on 12/13/2012
Just someone looking for their [rather bizarre] five minutes of fame.

I'm sure he must have some issues, but I feel pretty certain a good psychiatrist can get to the bottom of it.
10:39 AM on 12/13/2012
I have had my leg amputated below the knee,but the goverment says i am not disabled and i get no benifits,also they say i am fit for work ,but after many applications for work i am still unemployed
10:35 AM on 12/13/2012
I have had my leg amputated below the knee,but acording to the goverment i am not disabled and an not elegible to any benifits at all.Also i am able to work,which i would love to do,but cannot find anyone to employ me,i have tried and will keep on trying
09:34 AM on 12/13/2012
The man obviously has a mental disorder, so all those saying he's after benefits then its irrelevant if he has his limbs amputated as he'll be entitled to benefits anyway. Anyone with a serious psychiatric order normally gets the full mobility whack too - even those murderers who have been sent to a psych secure unit!
He needs some Prozac!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SATCHMAN99
09:50 AM on 12/13/2012
Sorry but if he volunteers to become disabled he shouldn't get a penny of tax payers money!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
denspark1560
10:41 AM on 12/13/2012
But we all know he will.
08:31 PM on 12/16/2012
Sorry, you misunderstood me - i meant he will ALREADY be getting benefits now, on account of being mentally ill - with or without the amputations.  Not saying he should get anything, just pointing out that he will be.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SATCHMAN99
08:59 AM on 12/13/2012
What can you say? There's nothing stranger than the human race!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dodgymerchant
01:33 AM on 12/13/2012
Start with the head.
01:10 AM on 12/13/2012
He can swap and have my body as long as I keep my mind and thinking.
It would be great to run around again.
Being disabled is no fun.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
denspark1560
10:42 AM on 12/13/2012
It can be, it's all about your outlook on life.
12:32 PM on 12/13/2012
It can also be how much pain you are in when you open your eyes in the morning. I am in severe pain every day so i can see where this lady is coming from.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulliallon
12:52 AM on 12/13/2012
in the first instance I would take this guy ,to a hospital where OUR lads are coming back from a futile war minus their limbs and in pain and ask if they are glad to be rid off ,he has a mental problem and should be sectioned or given a lethal jab end off PLEASE FOR ONCE DONT PUT THIS COMMENT ON HOLD
Makalha
Opinions are not facts.
09:32 AM on 12/13/2012
Obviously he has a " mental problem " but people aren't sectioned unless they are a danger to others or themselves . Why do you think taking him to a hospital of injured servicemen would help ? As for giving him a lethal jab ..... words fail me !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Longstaff
12:37 PM on 12/13/2012
Maybe he wants a lethal jab then he would be out of his misery and we would not have to put up with his whinging about being wanting to be disabled. Like you when I think of the poor servicemen and some very young being disabled fighting for their country words too fail me.
12:50 PM on 12/13/2012
Totally agree. Hubbt in the forces.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:18 PM on 12/12/2012
hey huff, wheres my post gone?
10:46 PM on 12/12/2012
If he was just after disability benefits he could pretend to have a bad back like many of the so-called disabled these days. I was at the local bingo hall one night. We saw a lady "struggle" out of her seat at the break and hobble outside on calipers for a ciggy. She must of been way-layed by something, talking to a friend maybe, because the second half started. About 30 seconds later we saw this woman come flying through the doors, calipers up in the air running to her seat and she sat down without a struggle and continued playing bingo. It's unbelieveable how people blatantly abuse the system.
I've often sat in the car in Tescos car park waiting for my wife and seen loads od people getting in and out of cars with blue badges, without any kind of struggle, walking casually into and around the store. Talk about taking the mick. It makes your blood boil !!
12:55 PM on 12/13/2012
I know what you are saying and i agree to some extent but they give blue badges to the likes of people with heart problems and Astma sufferes so when you see them with a blue bage it might not be a physical disability that you can see.
10:53 PM on 12/13/2012
True, but still I bet a lot of people are wagging it.
09:38 PM on 12/12/2012
Perhaps he would like my disability then because I sure don't want the blasted thing!!

13 years ago today I was left disabled and wheelchair bound by my surgeons mistake during a routine bladder operation. I developed bi-lateral compartment syndrome as he had occluded the blood supply to my of my legs somehow during the surgery. I lost the majority of muscle in my calf and severe nerve damage which means that sensation on my leg is severely compromised and sensation and pain is heightened in one leg whilst the other leg has 90% recovered on its own, my right leg below the knee is to use a medical term......knackered!!

It has taken me 13 years to get back some minimal use in my right leg and today I can actually walk a short distance albeit in severe pain and discomfort.

If he thinks its so bloody great being disabled, I will happily swap with him any day!! He needs locking up and the key tossed in the ocean!!