Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Reyhana Patel

GET UPDATES FROM Reyhana Patel
 

Channel 4's Proud and Prejudiced Portrays Inaccurate Impression of Extremism

Posted: 29/02/2012 07:23

On Monday night, Channel 4 screened a documentary entitled Proud and Prejudiced. The show aimed at portraying the two forms of extremism: 'right-wing' extremism and 'Islamist' extremism. Such extremism is currently a threat to British National Security and has been dominating the media in Britain. To add to the media's scrutiny, this documentary has portrayed a completely inaccurate and thoughtless impression of extremism.

The show featured the English Defence League (EDL) leader Tommy Robinson and Sayful Islam, the leader of now banned extremist group Muslim Against Crusades (MAC) (Also, previously known as Al-Muhajiroun).

The programme compared and contrasted these two groups and concluded that they were both alike and extreme as the other. This is far from the case.

MAC is/was a group with no less than one hundred followers out of the hundreds and thousands of Muslims in Britain. The EDL, on the other hand, has a massive grassroots influence with thousands in membership and thousands more unofficial followers.

Muslim Against Crusades believe that Britain should be under Islamic law and conduct their activities mainly through offensive protests and insensitive rhetoric. The EDL opposes the existence of Muslims in Britain and have been at the forefront and cause of mosque attacks and Islamophobia outbreaks across Britain. One can merely look at Andres Breivik, the man behind the Norway attacks , whose motivation and influence to commit acts of terror was heavily influenced by the English Defence League views, to see how dangerous the far-right movement really is.

Proud and Prejudiced portrayed the views of MAC and EDL to be the views held of the people of Luton, either being ' Islamist' or ' right-wing.' The show made Luton appear as a community segregated and marred with violence and protests. The voice of the community of Luton was ignored and replaced with violence, hatred and intolerance.

There was also no mention of the majority of Muslim across Britain who has condemned MAC's activities or the other religious groups who have condemned the EDL.

What was also strange was that Unite Against Fascism, a group which counters every EDL protest was briefly mentioned in the documentary but not featured in the film despite being opposed to both forms of extremism. Why weren't they interviewed? Shouldn't there have been moderate views to counter these arguments?

Let's also not forget the publicity this has given both groups, especially the EDL. Tommy Robinson had the opportunity of declaring to the public that he was not against 'black' people or people of other ethnic minorities. He was only against Muslims.

This could only be an open door for recruits from other ethnic minorities to join his cause. It would be hard for anyone neutral watching the show not to sympathise with him. And this sympathy was prevalent all over Twitter with tweets such as "Well done tommy robinson, well said" and ''Muslims are just scum'' by Twitter users tuning into Channel 4.

On the other hand, there was no prevalent sympathy towards MAC, rather condemnation of both groups from majority of Muslim individuals. Tweets included "Some of the plaquards from MAC are just " by Muslim Public Affairs Committee and "People need to understand that one who is an #extremist can NEVER be a #Muslim and one who is a Muslim can NEVER be an extremist" by a Muslim individual."

The producers of Proud and Prejudiced could not have been more misguided in portraying how extremism operates in Britain.

Instead of challenging MAC and the EDL, Channel 4 essentially encouraged extremism by providing Tommy Robinson and Sayful Islam a platform for their extremist views. This will doubt benefit them by serving as a major recruitment tool for their causes.

 

Follow Reyhana Patel on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ReyhanaPatel

On Monday night, Channel 4 screened a documentary entitled Proud and Prejudiced. The show aimed at portraying the two forms of extremism: 'right-wing' extremism and 'Islamist' extremism. Such extremis...
On Monday night, Channel 4 screened a documentary entitled Proud and Prejudiced. The show aimed at portraying the two forms of extremism: 'right-wing' extremism and 'Islamist' extremism. Such extremis...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:55 on 03/03/2012
@bentyger i didn't empahsise that the entire British population was like Anders Breivik just like how u are implying that Abu Qatada is representative of all Muslims...I emphasised that he was influenced by the EDL's views...that is dangerous and if you disagree it would mean that you are supporting what Breivik did?
_---
whose motivation and influence to commit acts of terror was heavily influenced by the English Defence League views, to see how dangerous the far-right movement really is.
---
Not the man, the movement. Your words, and just because your wrong is no reason to acuse me of supporting a murderer. Not everyone who disagrees with you is a rascist. So accept this critisism, it'll make you a more objective journailst/blogger

Not everyone in the EDL is dangerous, as you have asserted,so by your logic, everyone who's had any involvement with Abu Quatada should be as dangerous as him?

I, of course, use the word logic very loosley in this instance,because your comments seem to be inspired by hatred, understandable to a degree, you may have had several bad experiences,but still wrong, and your reaction to my question backs this up.

Try and relax, not everyone hates Muslims, and when you stop reacting to questions like a personal assault, then a proper, open debate can begin. (and yes, I'm sure I'd get a similar reaction from the EDL too,'cause I'd say the same things too them)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppenguinator
Life's too imprtant to be taken seriously.
20:49 on 01/03/2012
The far-right is associated with extreme nationalist, xenophobic, racist, religious fundamentalist, or reactionary views. So in a way, the EDL and MAC have more in common than they'd like to admit.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Reyhana Patel
19:40 on 29/02/2012
@bentyger i didn't empahsise that the entire British population was like Anders Breivik just like how u are implying that Abu Qatada is representative of all Muslims...I emphasised that he was influenced by the EDL's views...that is dangerous and if you disagree it would mean that you are supporting what Breivik did? @1959greenarrow, who said Muslims wanted shria law in this country? So i guess you're all for racism and intolerance...that's smart!
09:17 on 02/03/2012
are muslims tollerant of us. If so why are there a reported 2000 groups of muslims planning attacks of mass slaugter in this country. Can you immigine the uproar from labour and other parties if the edl had 2000 groups planning the same against muslims. We are being racially descriminated against in our own country by the do gooders in jobs and housing on a massive scale. Thats why my vote goes to the bnp
16:34 on 05/03/2012
Not living in the UK any more could you provide a link to where you got this 2000 number from please?

Whilst I did live in the UK I knew many Muslims and not one was an extremist. Not denying they do exist quite obviously they do and like many I agree that those wanting to impose Sharia would be better off looking for another country to live in, maybe with a gentle shove from those not wanting it. However the Muslims I knew were happy enough, they didn't like the UK's foreign policy but then not that many non-Muslims I knew did either, but that was about it. If the younger generation were worried or concerned about anything it was having the latest consumer goods, fashionable clothes and nice cars and not much else to be honest. Just like non-Muslims really.

As for "do-gooders" in my experience (again sorry) you could not hope to meet a bigger bunch of bigots in the middle of a KKK rally, they just think condescension is somehow the same thing as acceptance. For example the repeated stories of Christmas plays being banned in schools. Not ONE Muslim, Hindu or Jew I knew in the UK agreed with that silly idea, an idea that came from white middle class "do-gooders" for whom the people of other races and minorities were there merely as fashion accessories to prove that they "cared" about whichever people are trendy this month.
13:44 on 02/03/2012
I do believe 1959greenarrow may have evolved from the same British white ape as Nick Griffin.
18:31 on 29/02/2012
me and my family do not want to be a minority in our own country or live under sharia law . SO MY VOTE GOES TO THE BNP
11:56 on 01/03/2012
Since when was this country going to be ran under Sharia law?!
What you need my friend is an education because you are sounding completely unhinged.

The enemy is not Islam but groups like MAC and the EDL which divide us.
If you vote for the BNP you disgrace every man and woman who fought and died against the Nazis so that you could live in a society free from prejudice.
11:49 on 02/03/2012
to be a minority in your own country will mean that other races with different views on how we live our lives will decide the future of the british people DO YOU REALLY WANT THAT
18:24 on 29/02/2012
very well said Reyhana, the documentary made me feel pysically ill, especially to think that some people see muslims according to the actions of Sayful Islam. Also the level of hatred from both sides was scary, I hope things can change inshaAllah
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allison Knight-Khan
Love 4 All, Hatred 4 None
15:27 on 29/02/2012
I am afraid that the journalists simplify and dramatize the news because they are competing with so many other forms of media. The truth gets lost when drama is more important.

When I visited Scotland, I told my aunt of my interest in Islam and they assumed the group I was interested in was one of these extremist groups. I didn't know who they were talking about at the time, so I had no idea how to explain the difference. Educating ourselves on the different sects and what they represent is very important.

Ahmadiyyat = Peace Our motto: Love for All, Hatred for None. Check out: www.mta.tv
11:59 on 01/03/2012
I am from Scotland and until last week i thought that groups like the EDL and MAC were confined to England. Then i saw the SDL in the papers and died a little inside.

Extremism and hatred is spreading like a cancer and as you say education is the only way to prevent it
15:19 on 29/02/2012
One can merely look at Andres Breivik, the man behind the Norway attacks , whose motivation and influence to commit acts of terror was heavily influenced by the English Defence League views, to see how dangerous the far-right movement really is.
---
I do not agree with the views of the EDL. But isn't your above statement like saying that Abu Quatada is proof of how dangerous the muslim community are?

Be objective please, it's something that journalists these days seem to totally lack
14:01 on 29/02/2012
we have engaged the borg, for a blog weaved with many diverse threads

http://onmymindbyadam.wordpress.com/2012/02/29/36-we-have-engaged-the-borg/