Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Richard Pass

GET UPDATES FROM Richard Pass
 

University Remembrance Day Disgrace

Posted: 11/11/2012 23:02

Daniel Cooper, as acting President of the University of London Union (ULU), has brought shame on himself and the 120 000 students he is supposed to represent by refusing to place a wreath on their behalf at a remembrance service in London last Sunday. Cooper's decision to boycott the service was particularly poignant given the death of recent UCL graduate, Lieutenant Edward Drummond-Baxter, in Afghanistan last week.

Within hours of Cooper's decision going public, hundreds of University of London students under the newly formed group 'London Students for Remembrance' launched a social media campaign and pledged to force his resignation. Founder of the group Jonny Prince, who graduated from UCL this year and lost a family member - also a UCL alumnus - at Loos in the Great War, says he is 'absolutely incensed' by Cooper's decision.

Instead of attending the Remembrance Day service, Cooper announced on his blog that he would be holding an event this Thursday entitled 'Our remembrance: A working class history of war'. According to Cooper, the event aims to provide an 'alternative, socialist, account of the war and remembrance'. This event in itself is a deeply insulting message to the huge number of 'middle' and 'upper class' members of the armed forces who have perished and continue to perish with their 'working class' counterparts.

Indeed, it is most shocking that this unfortunate episode in the University of London's history smacks of political opportunism on the part of Cooper and the ULU leadership who have used the death of millions to publicly promote their own political beliefs. The whole point of Remembrance Day as we know it today is to cast politics aside and pay tribute to the courage, bravery and selflessness of those in uniform both past and present. It is for this reason we see politicians from the left and right of the political spectrum coming together to respect the fallen, as the vast majority of the British public expect.

As a recent UCL graduate, I am hugely disappointed that Cooper, as an elected representative of my former university's student population, made the decision to put his personal beliefs before those he represents. It was unprofessional, shortsighted and wrong. If Cooper wished to make such a profoundly powerful and controversial statement which runs so strongly against common decency and the values of our society, he should have held a referendum on the issue instead of acting without consent. It is for this reason that I, along with many other University of London students, strongly feel that he should resign from office.

2012-11-11-DanielCooper.jpg

 
FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
Daniel Cooper, as acting President of the University of London Union (ULU), has brought shame on himself and the 120 000 students he is supposed to represent by refusing to place a wreath on their beh...
Daniel Cooper, as acting President of the University of London Union (ULU), has brought shame on himself and the 120 000 students he is supposed to represent by refusing to place a wreath on their beh...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:59 AM on 11/15/2012
"The whole point of Remembrance Day as we know it today", writes Richard Pass, "is to cast politics aside and pay tribute to the courage, bravery and selflessness of those in uniform both past and present." No doubt this is so in the eyes of most individuals attending these ceremonies, but from a structural point of view it is nonsense. Questions of sensitivity aside (and I'm not suggesting they should be laid aside), Daniel Cooper is absolutely right to point out the onesideness of the view of war that these ceremonies enshrine. Many years ago I attended a talk by the left-wing broadcaster John Pilger. I’d expected a simple anti-war tirade, but instead Pilger spoke movingly of the heroism and sacrifice shown in war as well as – equally – of its barbarism. Perhaps we should work towards a similarly balanced national ‘Thinking About War’ day, one that would have a role for but not be dominated by the military and (state) church, and that could, figuratively and actually, include the ritual throwing away of weapons as well as the ritual firing off of them we have now. We teach Owen and Sassoon in our schools, but can’t reflect their message in the socio-political sphere. Would they have been happy attending our commemorative ceremonies, or agree that they’re not militaristic, and if not, would they be wrong?
01:26 AM on 11/14/2012
We live in a world of revisionism ,where what is black becomes white. In this world terrorists are freedom fighters, imperial Japan was a victim and rememberence day for some reason glorifies war. No doubt in a few years times Bin Laden will be seen as a victim.
06:55 PM on 11/13/2012
He does not have to lay a wreath, entirely his choice, however in his position as acting President of UCL surely he must be aware that his supposed "duties" must/will/possibly require him to do certain things that require him to put his personal opinion aside, in the course of these duties! This smacks of a cheap political shot, ensuring the maximum publicity of a self serving individual, who sees an opportunity to get his face seen. Grow up son, and when your older maybe you can see the real world of the working classes, not the one told to you from a book. Pillock.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cardiff1963
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping i
06:23 PM on 11/13/2012
Why does this spoiled little boy think he represents the working class, has he ever had to work for a living? will he be off down the pits the pits after the working class have funded his degree?
as a working class ex soldier, don't speak for me you waste of space.
How many students are will speak out against this kid, none? Our education system is in a bad way.
10:37 AM on 11/16/2012
It says that 120000 students organized themselves immediately to ask for his resignation. I wouls say that is speaking out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cardiff1963
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping i
08:28 AM on 11/17/2012
good, thank you for letting me know, well done students
03:27 PM on 11/13/2012
Everyone is entitled to their own views on history. Just some have the decency not to hijack events to spew their own views. This was in no way how he should have acted. I agree, it was pretty disgraceful. He should have put it to a referendum for the university electorate if he felt that strongly about it, not do as he pleased.

And his letter... Well if you're going to make a historical argument, at least have the nous to actually right an essay explaining how you interpret the evidence and reach your own conclusions, not a long rant with little actual basis.

As an academic piece it's quite awful.
03:28 PM on 11/13/2012
*write
12:44 PM on 11/13/2012
Before passing judgment I recommend everyone who has read this article reads Cooper's letter posted on his blog explaining his decision, rather than the 'wicker man' of his argument featured in this news site. His explanation should have been featured as a link from this article. For those interested in making their own judgment here is his blog site:

http://dancooperulu.wordpress.com/2012/11/09/why-i-declined-an-invitation-to-lay-a-wreath-at-the-uols-rememberance-service/
12:17 PM on 11/13/2012
Before passing judgment I recommend everyone who has read this article reads Cooper's letter posted on his blog explaining his decision, rather than the 'wicker man' of his argument featured in this news site. His explanation should have been featured as a link from this article. For those interested in making their own judgment here is his blog site:

http://dancooperulu.wordpress.com/2012/11/09/why-i-declined-an-invitation-to-lay-a-wreath-at-the-uols-rememberance-service/

As for my opinion on the above article:

-Pass is confusing the Marxist definition of class with the cultural definition, when he states that a 'working class history meeting' is insulting. I don't think this is intentional, but think it needs clearing up. In this sense 'working class' refers to an individual's relation to the means of production in society not a broader cultural idea of class based on accent, living standards, education etc.

-The above article constructs remembrance day as a non-political event, which is unfortunately not the case. In fact politicians are routinely 'using the deaths of millions to publically promote their own beliefs'. The only difference this time is that Cooper's beliefs don't match the author of this articles and are being construed in a way which falsely portrays Coopers position as un-caring.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony Booth
11:07 AM on 11/13/2012
no reason to go against his principles, (we're not training politicians here) and the wreath got laid by his deputy.
being a good little citizen doesn't necessarily mean doing as the press demand. and he speaks for many who deplore unnecessary wars of opportunity. the military is there to protect the UK not work as mercenaries for our masters over the pond.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cardiff1963
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping i
02:18 AM on 11/13/2012
jumped up little tw..
08:21 PM on 11/12/2012
Laying a wreath in support of entrenched societal attitudes that glorify war and militaries is itself a deeply political action. Typing up a public defence of such an action is just as much so. But this article goes further. It delivers a reactionary diatribe whilst seeking political impunity by waving a populist card. Normally I would just consider this disingenuous and lazy. But the distinctive attributes displayed here were shared by the very same fascist regimes that the millions we remember died to oppose. That makes this sinister.
04:36 PM on 11/12/2012
Cooper was under no obligation to be present, formally or professionally. Additionally, a ULU member of staff *did* lay a wreath for Remembrance Day.

So what's your point?
05:17 PM on 11/12/2012
That he used his position as a spokesman for London students to voice views that are highly controversial to say the least, and which certainly mischaracterise the work of the British Legion and the nature of Remembrance Sunday. No one cares about Dan Cooper's dull-as-dishwater student Spartism. But if ULU can't understand why so many students are offended that he used his official position to spout it, they're even more dense than it seems.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jacksdad41
Quant Je Puis
06:34 PM on 11/12/2012
Well @Unistudent, congratulations for your reply, your struggle for further education and the amount of money it will cost you in student loans and tuition fees etc. are worth every penny. Please allow me the honour of being your first fan for your common sense and erudite response.
04:18 PM on 11/12/2012
Why has my comment been removed? Because it disagreed with the article?!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:03 PM on 11/13/2012
Don't look for logic: there isn't any.
02:05 PM on 11/12/2012
Well-written and sensitive article. What Mr Cooper doesn't seem to understand is that his office should confer on him the duty to act in a way that transcends his own political opinions. I'm not outraged, but choosing to lecture the reverend who invited him on Marxism rather than taking up the invitation simply to lay a wreath in memory of all those who died was a small and petty decision, one which I think he will come to regret.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
coffeemadman
03:21 PM on 11/12/2012
Good comment. I fear, however, that he will not come to regret this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
coffeemadman
01:08 PM on 11/12/2012
Quite how Mr Cooper thought he had the remit to do this on behalf of all the University of London student body - and alumni like myself - is beyond me. I'm outraged at this decision.