Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rosslyn McNair

GET UPDATES FROM Rosslyn McNair
 

Duffle Coats and Dreams: The Student Love Affair With the Left Wing

Posted: 28/02/2012 00:00

'If you are not a liberal at 20, you have no heart. If you are not conservative by 40, you have no brain'. The radical idealism of young people never changes and Winston Churchill's quote still remains as relevant as ever 70 years on. One only needs to look around at the number of nose piercings, old man jumpers and duffle coats walking around university campuses to know that generally speaking, students lean to the left.

If I chance upon the rare conservative student, when they express right wing views I unfairly and yet automatically write an imaginary post-it note entitled 'FASCIST' and stick it to their forehead. Young conservatives are treated with extreme suspicion, as certain stereotypes of being the most upper of the upper middle class and possessing a complete lack of social responsibility kick in at the mere sight of a string of pearls.

There is, I believe, though a simple reason why young people turn to left wing politics. It is the hope of many students to have an impact on the world and its people. We all want to be 'someone' and effect positive change. Left wing ideology, far more than conservatism, facilitates this zeal. The left is politics for the masses, it has the interest of the people at its heart and consequently it is easier to affect mass change through it.

Conservatism on the other hand is the politics of the individual, protection of your own interests. But as a student that essentially consists of a half-eaten packet of Jaffa Cakes and a formerly expensive dictionary. You are a liberal at 20 because you can be but Churchill is right in that eventually lefties grow up. It is extremely difficult to maintain an 'equality for all' mantra when you have a child struggling in school because the class sizes are too big or you haven't seen a dentist in eight months because all your local surgeries are filled up.

For me, supporting the left wing used to equate to being a fundamentally nice person with a sound moral compass. How could you not want everyone to have access to education, healthcare and asylum? And how can you possibly support the death penalty, the pro-life movement or be against gay marriage?

But in the case of the student community I think that the concept of 'Champagne Socialist' is a long established one, but there is a reason why the term 'Cognac Conservative' is yet to make the OED. It is very easy for a student, with the Bank of Mater and Pater acting as a security net, to commit to abstract concepts such as 'equality' or 'social compassion' with lip service and dreadlocks because whilst in the university bubble it is unlikely these views will ever be contested by the trials of the real world.

So the question is, are students with conservative views ahead of the game? Can they see beyond youthful idealism to the realities of their future life which will inevitably be governed by capitalism? Churchill seemed to think so, but I think he also understood that being young, left and idealistic is a necessary stage in life.

At 20, our politics should be governed by blind optimism whilst they can before it turns to weary cynicism. There needs to be a time in our lives where we believe anything is possible for anybody because that is the basis for political, social and economic innovation.

We should absolutely ponder grand political ideals before we are overwhelmed with the actuality of our own small lives. The left wing simultaneously indulges student idealism and lets us wear duffle coats, it is both fashionable (in more than one sense) and hopeful and that is why the student community will always remain staunch supporters of the left.

 
'If you are not a liberal at 20, you have no heart. If you are not conservative by 40, you have no brain'. The radical idealism of young people never changes and Winston Churchill's quote still remain...
'If you are not a liberal at 20, you have no heart. If you are not conservative by 40, you have no brain'. The radical idealism of young people never changes and Winston Churchill's quote still remain...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:06 PM on 02/29/2012
As a 20 year old leftist, I really enjoyed reading this. I feel like especially with the worldwide economic instability, young socialists in uni will pop up more and hopefully stay leftists throughout their lives.
12:26 PM on 02/28/2012
When I was 20, I voted for Greens. In the decades since then, I have drifted more and more to the right, to the point I would now never consider voting for a socialist or a green. It's called maturing, and for me it's been mainly the result of disliking comments from leftwing relatives and of living in a country which has no true leftwing, but also no train strikes, no politically correct tyranny, and a brilliant economy.
I still regret though that I wasn't rightwing from the very beginning. That might have been the start of a career in politics, which I didn't follow because my views changed as I grew older. I would have had to change about 5 parties along the way.
10:39 AM on 02/28/2012
Rosslyn,
I am of an age where I remember, admittedly with varying degrees of clarity, the Student Protest heydays of the '60s & '70s. However, I did not go to Uni until my mid-40s.
Instead, on leaving school at 16 in 1968, I went into the Army as a boy entrant to the Army Apprentices College at Chepstow.
Your description of how, when meeting Conservative Students you label them as fascist strikes a strong chord with me as it was exactly this attitude that began my conversion from being a keen Labour supporter to the Working Class Thatcherite Tory I now class myself as.
This actual incident was a report on a student protest, possibly the LSE or North London Polytechnical College, where a gentleman living near the protests had objected to the disruption caused.
The response from a young lady that his views were not worth considering because "...He's just and old fascist," I found particularly objectionable as the gentleman concerned was an ex-RAF Wing Commander who had spent his late teens/early 20s flying either Hurricanes or Spitfires against Fascism, loosing many friends doing so.
If you look at Fascism incidently, you will find lots of common ground between with Socialism, with the current intollerance of contradictory views shown by the Left today crossing over into blatently fascist statements and actions in an attempt to deny opponents free speach.

The one saving grace that you show is your acknowledgement that such labeling is unfair.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rosslyn McNair
12:16 PM on 02/28/2012
I find your comment extremely interesting and just wanted to say that I actually agree with you. I think that student politics suffers a little from the 'tyranny of the majority', most people are at the very least, slightly left wing and consequently those who are not are disregarded and, as I said above, treated with some suspicion. I don't believe this is right and very much try to repress my initial reaction because I think that I have a social responsibility, as everyone does, to heed the opinions of others because you never know, you might be completely wrong!

On a side note: I do however believe that student politics is less extreme nowadays anyway. It's not much a case of Fascism vs. Socialism as Centre Right vs. Centre Left.
12:47 PM on 02/28/2012
Rosslynn, Thankyou for responding!
I will disagree with you on one point, Student Politics still suffers, not from the "tyrany of the majority," but the "Tyrany of the Minority" where a small, unrepresentative but EXTEMELY vocal clique can drown out the more reasonable voices.
I think the most shameful use of this tactic in National Politics has been the drowning out of any reasonable attempt to query the last Government's policy on Imigration by the knee jerk scream of RASCISM!!! when ever someone tried to query the policy.
A book for you to read, if you can find a copy, is "Rape of Reason, The Corruption of the Polytechnic of North London" by Keith Jacka and Coroline (now Baroness) Cox.
It contains the supurb comment by a Marxist student to the effect that, because they have studied the Thoughts of Chairman Mao, they have no need to study further!
03:03 AM on 02/28/2012
Some really poor grammar in this article - particularly iin the simple usage of the comma. I know it's student journalism but, c'mon... some sub-editing would be fantastic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:15 AM on 02/28/2012
The only poor grammar I see is yours. Perhaps you could point out the author's?

Why "sub-editing" as opposed to editing?

Style, structure, prose, clarity, punctuation and grammar cannot be faulted. Indeed, it could serve as a template for many HP contributors (and commentators).
01:37 AM on 02/28/2012
When you're young,you're more open.Some talk of the great inking.Some people get the great inking.That's the greatest thing in life.