Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sarah Bridge

GET UPDATES FROM Sarah Bridge
 

At Which Point Does All This Titanic Stuff Get, Well, Icky?

Posted: 13/04/2012 00:00

According to an Evening Standard article entitled The Last Supper, diners at the HIX restaurant in Selfridges are being given the opportunity to sample the last meal enjoyed by first-class passengers on the Titanic. On the menu are such delights as Lindisfarne rock oysters, duck liver parfait, lamb cutlets and Warldorf pudding with cider brandy ice-cream. The menu has been given a 'contemporary twist' - presumably in case there are people who are so cutting-edge that they might shy away from eating such passé treats - and in, what could be seen as either a witty homage or the height of bad taste, there is even an iceberg-shaped éclair for dessert, called, surprise surprise, The Iceberg.

I can't be the only one who thinks that there are ways to mark such as tragedy as the Titanic and a menu consisting of the dishes eaten by people who were about to die, or lose loved ones, is not the way to do it. A heart-breaking 1,514 souls were lost on that terrible night and the lives of others changed forever. "We wanted to offer customers something a bit special to celebrate," says Mark Hix blithely, using entirely the wrong verb.

He is not the only one jumping onto the Titanic bandwagon. A commemorative voyage to the exact spot where the Titanic sank one hundred years ago has already set sail from Southampton. Its passengers, who have paid up to £6,000 for their tickets, are wearing period costume and will - again, what is it with the food thing? - be served the same meals as on the Titanic. The journey has already been dramatic. When its arrival in Ireland was delayed by a couple of hours due to some entirely typical spring weather, one over-wrought passenger was quoted as saying: "There is a bad feeling on board that maybe the voyage is doomed by bad luck."

Well unless the ship is equipped with the same (that is, totally inadequate) number of life boats and primitive iceberg-spotting equipment as the original ship then I think they're going to be okay, and a BBC cameraman who fell ill on board was airlifted off by a rather modern helicopter.

But it's hard to escape the feeling that the whole thing is in extremely poor taste. Later this year will New York restaurants begin serving the menu from Windows on the World which was on offer that terrible morning of September 11 2001? Will there be memorial flights over Manhattan where people will adopt the clothing worn by those people on board the doomed planes? What about other tragedies, such as the Hindenburg airship disaster, or Chernobyl, or the Columbia space shuttle? Will there be surfing trips to Japan to remember last year's tsunami, or a range of gas-fired barbeques to celebrate the Great Fire of London?

There are ways to remember those who perished in such tragic circumstances: by quiet reflection, a moment of prayer, a concerted effort to make sure such events can never happen again, or to try and minimise the damage and losses when they do. Remembering the Titanic can be done in many ways - a donation to the lifeboat service for example, or lobbying to ensure that passengers will never have to face such risks again (the Costa Concordia tragedy shows us that one hundred years on, there is still much to be done). But eating iceberg-shaped desserts? That just leaves a bad taste.

 
 
 

Follow Sarah Bridge on Twitter: www.twitter.com/sarahbridge10

According to an Evening Standard article entitled The Last Supper, diners at the HIX restaurant in Selfridges are being given the opportunity to sample the last meal enjoyed by first-class passengers ...
According to an Evening Standard article entitled The Last Supper, diners at the HIX restaurant in Selfridges are being given the opportunity to sample the last meal enjoyed by first-class passengers ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
butchcliff
The future is unwritten
10:37 on 15/04/2012
Agree iceberg shaped dessert is tacky & disrespectful. Icky...was when people were dressing up as passengers in vintage clothing for pictures.
17:53 on 14/04/2012
Some of this "Titanic stuff" is indeed icky and silly. But perhaps some of this is just the essay's author pretending to be obtuse. Or the author's full experience with food involves take-away or fish & chips.

It's not at all uncommon for people to mark anniversaries of events with a special menu of foods. Birthday of Samuel Clemens? Dine on his favorite American foods that he missed so much, as described in the book Twain's Feast.

50th anniversary of the film To Kill a Mockingbird? Dine on the dishes that play a role in the novel, including Calpurnia's crackling bread, Miss Maudie's Lane cake, and some of Scout's "damn ham."

Anniversary of the Lewis & Clark expedition? Dine on all the unfamiliar native American foods that Native Americans introduced to the Corps of Discovery.

Leaving aside the Cameron film or the Fellows mini-series, if folks are really interested in the 100th anniversary of the tragedy, a very logical and predictable thing to do is investigate the First or Second Class menus, and perhaps let the food help transport one to a different time and place.

A huge share of the public has been fascinated by the Titanic disaster since the news of it first broke, and been just as fascinated by it in every era since then. Participating in a re-enactment may be peculiar, but let's not pretend that participating in a re-enactment is in any way typical. Or worth writing about. It is not.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
16:13 on 14/04/2012
See you in Kabul. December 2101.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rg9rts
Carpe Diem! This aint rehearsal
15:17 on 14/04/2012
And here I thought that we americans held the corner on bad taste! I'm glad to share that honor with you......and the beat goes on....
12:45 on 14/04/2012
I agree entirely. The whole thing is being treated as some sort of tacky reenactment show.
11:18 on 14/04/2012
At around 2pm on friday 18th April 1914.......
This obsession with the titanic reflects the chronic anxiety of our era of extreme economic inequality, where the current economic model appears to be at a cross roads. It's as if we can only see our circumstance through the prism of an anachronism, as a predicament resembling the titanic's passenger's situation and therefore we betray some sense of desire to self-destruct in order to move on.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
23:31 on 13/04/2012
The third-class menu's more interesting:

Toast
Hard Cheese
All you can drink.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hawkeye58
Open to the truth...
17:25 on 13/04/2012
And they call it a mystery. The ship hit an iceberg and sank, how is that a mystery? How that built the pyramids, now that's a mystery. But the Titanic sinking? I don't think so... enough already.
15:55 on 13/04/2012
Seeing a lady on the news this morning crying over the loss of a relative who died fifty years before she was born was the final straw for me. Let them rest in peace and find some proper news to report please.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zachlen
15:02 on 13/04/2012
I still find it difficult to believe that an ICE BERG was the sinking factor.Why has no one else asked , an ice berg that time of year? More like an enemy ship slpit the Titanic. No differant than today when things are covered up to prevent added trouble.With communications as they were then it would be so much easier to cover up the truth.
21:07 on 13/04/2012
It was an iceberg.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
23:26 on 13/04/2012
A very big cold white U-boat. Dead in the water.
photo
SecularAdvocate
Media Watcher
13:46 on 13/04/2012
Anyone who's tried to get a radio or tv documentary commissioned will understand the obsession with channel controllers of there being a perfect time to tell a particular story.

Their imaginations are pitifully limited. And now we see the ghastly results of that form of stupidity.

"We must do something on the Titanic, darling, it's the 100th anniversary you know!"

Hence, Titanic de foi gras.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rg9rts
Carpe Diem! This aint rehearsal
15:22 on 14/04/2012
I know how the story ends!
lastpost
see biography
12:51 on 13/04/2012
"At Which Point"
Just out of curiosity. Will wreaths be cast overboard at the location on the surface where it sank? Or directly above where it is on the seabed?

"sample the last meal"
Complete with feeling of impending doom in the pit of the stomach?

"The Iceberg."
Pray there’s no Bombe Suprise on the menu either.

"He is not the only one jumping onto the Titanic bandwagon."
Bankers boarded first.

"the whole thing is in extremely poor taste."
Let’s hope French restaurants don’t develop a taste for pre-revolution nostalgia.

"There are ways to remember those who perished in such tragic circumstances: by"
making sure it can’t and doesn’t happen again.

"bad taste."
Washed down with a whine of regret
10:51 on 13/04/2012
Currently, avoiding Titanic-related programmmes / features is about as easy as avoiding Hitler on the History Channel. Enough already!

I'm sure that if programme makers were to look hard enough, they'd find that other things worth talking about have happened in our history.
photo
SecularAdvocate
Media Watcher
13:47 on 13/04/2012
It's not the programme makers fault. It's the disease that is the commissioning process.