Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sarah de Carvalho

GET UPDATES FROM Sarah de Carvalho
 

Michael Palin's Cosy Travelogue Ignores the Dark Side of Brazil

Posted: 15/11/2012 00:00

Brazil with Michael Palin, the latest in a series of hugely popular travelogues that have been a staple of BBC television schedules for over two decades, is coming to an end. With the world's attention turning to Brazil ahead of the 2014 World Cup and 2016 Olympics, the series has been an opportunity to shed light on this huge country of which we hear much - but know little.

It's a shame, therefore, that the series has seemed in many ways to be insulated from reality. The usual tropes and images that are associated with Brazil have been dutifully trotted out, with samba dancing and football appearing as expected in the series' first hour. Mention was also promptly made of Brazil's economic growth and its status as the world's sixth largest economy - achievements for which the country has been rightly lauded.

This however is only part of the story of the 'real' Brazil. There is a dark side to modern-day Brazil, a world apart from the lively cultural scene and raucous festivity that has been playing out on our screens every Wednesday evening. According to the World Bank, Brazil is one of the most economically polarised countries in the world, with a level of wealth inequality that compares unfavourably with countries such as the Dominican Republic, El Salvador and Kazakhstan. You see this on the streets. In many parts of Recife, which Palin visited and spoke about its "increasingly lively local scene", you see children begging on the streets and girls as young as nine selling themselves for as little as a plate of food.

Recife is not the only city in Brazil to have this problem. Over half of urban households in the north-east of the country have no access to sewage systems. UNICEF has put the number of street children living and working on the streets of Brazil as high as two million. As many as one in three of these children will likely die before their 18th birthday. Organisations like Happy Child International, which provides care and accommodation to children in some of the poorest parts of Brazil, continue to do what they can with the support of the Brazilian authorities to provide food, care and support to the largely forgotten victims of Brazil's success, but often find that they can barely keep up with the needs and numbers of children on the streets.

My experience of Brazil when I visited at the end of last year was very different from Palin's cosy travelogue. Yes, I saw a country with a beautiful culture, rich history and kind-hearted people. I also saw in the slums of Recife human misery all around, with children living in squalid shacks among pimps, prostitutes and drug dealers.

It was this side of Brazil - or anything approaching a balanced perspective - that was so sorely lacking from Palin's programme. While watching I was occasionally seized by the hope that the programme may take another more daring route. At one point during the first episode, Palin visited the crumbling former slave port of Alcantara and explained how, of the 11 million Africans enslaved between the 16th and 19th centuries, more than a third were shipped to Brazil to work on plantations. The whole sorry episode was spoken about as though it were a historical anachronism with no bearing on contemporary Brazil. In fact, the legacy of slavery is clear for people to see in Brazil, especially in the poorer north-east of the country, where many of the descendants of slaves are begging and selling themselves to survive despite, it must be emphasised, the determined efforts of successive Brazilian governments.

Perhaps it is not surprising that the darker side of this otherwise wonderful country was little in evidence. Palin's programmes have always been popular, one imagines, because they are gentle and amiable. Nevertheless, it would be a very grave mistake indeed to take away from the programme the impression that all is well with the country. To do so would be a disservice to the largely forgotten victims of Brazil's success. There is a lot of work to be done before they too can share in the prosperity of this exceptionally charming but deeply divided country.

www.happychild.org

 
FOLLOW UK ENTERTAINMENT
Brazil with Michael Palin, the latest in a series of hugely popular travelogues that have been a staple of BBC television schedules for over two decades, is coming to an end. With the world's attentio...
Brazil with Michael Palin, the latest in a series of hugely popular travelogues that have been a staple of BBC television schedules for over two decades, is coming to an end. With the world's attentio...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
loulou11
02:47 PM on 11/18/2012
Its sounds a bit like our countries coverage of the London Olympics then.

I didn't see any homeless people, picketpockets or children being prostituted on that either!
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
05:04 AM on 11/16/2012
I watched this, too. I found it a little too touristy, too. Simon Reeves is better I think. But please understand that all docus which are made in non-English speaking countries have a bit of a problem unless your reporter/presenter is bilingual. They can have their wool pulled over their eyes if they do not understand the local language and thus the culture. It may also be that he'd get in trouble with the local authorities if he showed street kinds. Do you see much of the impoverished old Germans on TV? No, you have to read Spiegel in German. Could you go to the 'scene' in Leipzig - no, but I probably could if I pretended to make a home movie exploring the region where I was born.

Brazil is also a Catholic country. They always have more children than they can feed so they beg in the street. I know this view is verboten, it's mine nonetheless.
05:00 AM on 11/16/2012
I have lived and worked in Latin America for many years. I've owned a home and have had employes in Brasil for the past 13 years. Yes it would be more informative if these travel programs gave a better representation of the social economic differences in Brasil. But that would be horribly depressing viewing and that is not what the Michael Palins travel programs are about. Who wants to see the Macho, rude, corrupt, opportunistic side of this culture. There have been many reporters that have put peoples lives at risk by trying to expose criminality and corruption in all levels of government in Brazil. Some poor little villager from the Hosa accidentally says the wrong thing on TV about the local Mayor or one of the local officials. The repercussions for him/her could be horrific.
03:45 AM on 11/16/2012
When I read "Founder and Chief Executive of Happy Child International", I kind of knew what I was going to read.
10:54 PM on 11/15/2012
I find all Michael Pailns programmes tend to be about Michael Pailn, so i have given up watching them.
09:08 PM on 11/15/2012
I'd like to know where dear "compatriot' you have gotten these data.Thats just another NGO which only purpose is to disseminated the bad news(and misinterpretations) of the the trendy PC agenda.I suppose you dont live in Brazil and represent a foreign NGO.Thats a bingo,I'd say.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
01:59 PM on 11/15/2012
I love Michael Palin's shows. Such a refreshing change to travel programmes of yesteryear, from Whicker mingling with the hoit toity, to Judith Chalmers supping on a pina colada lying on an inflatable sunbed in the hotel pool. Palin does his best to interact with people he comes across on his travels, his willingness to engage & communicate with the locals, we learn so much from.

That said, I do agree with the points in this article. I remember Palin in Mumbai, then Bombay in 'Around The World In 80 Days' shielding himself from beggars knocking on his taxi door. But we're all guilty of this to some extent. To deny these (poverty) problems is an unfair reflection on what's really going on in the countries. But in Palin's defence also, he teaches us more about the culture within a country more than any host or programme, and through such programmes, can at least open the door to what's really going on.
03:48 AM on 11/16/2012
The poverty in India and the poverty in Brazil are really really different.
01:42 PM on 11/15/2012
I'm not sure what your complaining about. The Palin programme is a travelogue; it is not a politics programme. I am quite sure you are right; there is a dark side to Brazil but you could make that argument about most countries, ourselves included. Perhaps the next time David Attenborough is discussing the gorillas he could break off and make political statements about the sanitation. And the next time the antique road show is on . . .
12:52 PM on 11/15/2012
Having just watched the third of Palin's episodes, "the Road to Rio", I think it is unfair to say that the series is entirely cosy and "lacking balanced perspective". Much of the episode focussed on the disparity between rich and poor in Rio, on poverty and criminality in the favelas, and how this is being tackled. In some sense, including this as part of a generally-upbeat and balanced series can highlight such issues to a wider audience, compared to a documentary focussed on the negatives alone.
10:27 AM on 11/15/2012
It will be interesting to see how Brazil presents itself for the World Cup and Olympics. Hopefully they won't follow the example of President Mobutu Sese Seko of Zaire, who prior to the "Rumble in the Jungle" had wild dogs shot, beggars driven out of town and a sample of the criminal class murdered so there would be no street crime for the duration!
03:49 PM on 11/15/2012
Perhaps not as toal but both China and the UK got rid of street people.