Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sue Cross

GET UPDATES FROM Sue Cross
 

Milk Grows on Trees, Meat Develops in Labs: A Case for the Vegan Option Continued

Posted: 08/09/2012 00:00

Almond milk, coconut milk, milk from hazelnuts, cashew nuts, walnuts. Milk made from grain - from oats, spelt, barley, rice. Legumes-based milk from lupin, pea, peanut, soya. Seed-based milk from hemp, quinoa, sesame, sunflower. Suggest to those who drink cows milk that they replace it with a plant-based milk and most shudder at the thought. They wouldn't even try it. (Yet give it surreptitiously and it usually goes unremarked).

But what is cows' milk? The secretions from the mammary gland of an animal whose milk is specifically designed for her own calf (and in order to produce milk for humans has had her offspring taken from her shortly after birth). Antibiotics and growth hormones might be an added extra. Add to that the welfare of the cows. Udders so huge and engorged that a normal gait is not possible. Mastitis, digestive disorders, swollen knees, sore feet. Cows that produce milk on an industrial scale often last just three to five years.

And what of meat that has been farmed equally intensively? Well-developed muscle makes prime meat. But in industrial-scale units animals have neither the space to exercise nor a natural diet and they make flabby and flavourless meat. Fear makes poor quality meat poorer still. For instance, pork from pigs that suffer porcine stress syndrome is pale, watery and does not keep. This type of meat is used in the cheapest sausages and pies. And the same applies to beef. The lowest quality comes from animals fattened unnaturally quickly and their carcasses hung (hanging improves flavour and texture) too short a time. This is what cheap food is made from.

When it comes to the cheapest of all you are left with hardly any meat at all. Chicken nuggets might be more leftover fat, 'fillers', 'stabilisers' and ground bone than chicken meat. 30% of the weight of bacon can be a cocktail of water, salts, flavourings and E numbers (when it is fried the polyphosphates make it spit and leave a white residue in the pan). 'Turkey ham' or 'turkey rashers' are made from birds so flabby and tasteless that their meat has to be injected with flavouring to make it palatable. Some sliced meat looks the real deal.

But if the label says 'reconstituted' it will have been reformed from the sludge that remains after a butchered carcass has been cleaned off with a high pressure hose. This residue might include cheeks, necks, shins, tongues, kidneys, gristle and sinew. Also called mechanically recovered meat or, MRM, it is also used in the cheapest sausages, pies, pâtés and spreads.

The welfare implications are dire too: chickens, ducks, turkeys, quail, pigs, calves and cattle crammed into stinking sheds. Feedlot cattle fed a grain-based diet lack the fibre they need from grass and can neither ruminate (chew the cud) or belch as much as they need to. The result is acid indigestion and the symptoms are diarrhoea, panting, salivating; they kick their bellies and try to eat dirt.

Sheep fed a grain-based diet suffer in the same way. Ducks reared for foie gras have necks that become so thickened, inflamed and infected after weeks of force feeding that they would never again be able to eat of their own accord (fed like this they become clinically ill with a liver disease called hepatic lipidosis, also known as fatty-liver disease: the diseased liver is the end product). As a rule of thumb, the lower the cost the lower the standard of welfare and - as studies show - the less healthy the food.

But what if there were a humane, cruelty-free real-meat alternative - real muscle tissue, but made in laboratory conditions? The inventors claim it is coming soon. By taking stem cells from the meat of one animal and putting it in a broth of other animal products, cells multiply and muscle tissue forms. To date there is a problem in finding a way to artificially 'exercise' the muscle - at this stage it is too soft. If - or when - this difficulty is solved then the cells of just one animal could be used to create the same amount of meat as millions of slaughtered animals. This is in-vitro technology.

Other scientists are working on replicating the texture, taste and 'mouthfeel' of chicken and beef from vegetable matter. Yet others are working on mimicking the nutrition and characteristics of eggs. All of which means that the meat-based food of the future could still be living flesh. Just not from what was once a sentient being.

Now here is the question. Would you eat living flesh if it were exactly like the meat you currently buy, the only difference being that it did not come from what was once a living animal?

 

Follow Sue Cross on Twitter: www.twitter.com/notafactoryfarm

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Almond milk, coconut milk, milk from hazelnuts, cashew nuts, walnuts. Milk made from grain - from oats, spelt, barley, rice. Legumes-based milk from lupin, pea, peanut, soya. Seed-based milk from hem...
Almond milk, coconut milk, milk from hazelnuts, cashew nuts, walnuts. Milk made from grain - from oats, spelt, barley, rice. Legumes-based milk from lupin, pea, peanut, soya. Seed-based milk from hem...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 44
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
23:20 on 08/09/2012
Sorry love your barking up the wrong tree, meat, yes, make believe meat, no. It has to have a face as far as I'm concerned, lovin offal too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
19:18 on 08/09/2012
Eating less meat is very soon to become an economic and environmental necessity. It's a shame the ethical issues are not reason enough for most people to make the switch.

Diet is just a question of habit. There are already many meat-substitutes (such as Quorn) that are highly nutritious and can taste just like some kinds of meat, or even better. I have lost count of the meat-eaters fed at my house who refuse to believe a spag bol with Quorn mince is vegetarian. Asda's own-brand veggie sausages contain almost the same amount of meat as their own-brand 'normal' sausages (ie none) and the taste is identical.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
11:29 on 09/09/2012
and where does that quorn come from ? how was it made ? what environmental impact does it have ? how far have it's ingredients traveled ? how were they grown/produced ?
the same goes for that vegetarian sausage .
i'm in ireland i THAT is what made me eat meat again, local, grass fed beef from a local farm that i know.
that beef's environmental impact is going to be a good deal lower than your fake meat's and btw. does asda treat it's workers better than it's parent company walmart does?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
12:46 on 09/09/2012
Quorn is mostly mushroom protein. The environmental impact of it's production will be higher than plain vegetables, but lower than meat. See here: 
http://www.foodmanufacture.co.uk/Business-News/Study-indicates-Quorn-s-eco-friendly-nature
It's very rare to find beef raised only on grass. What do your cows eat in winter I wonder?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppenguinator
Life's too imprtant to be taken seriously.
17:52 on 08/09/2012
Lab-grown meat sounds brilliant. I can't wait until it's easily available.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
17:24 on 08/09/2012
where are sheep fed a grain based diet ? i almost wrote '' brain based '' anyone seen that film ?
16:29 on 08/09/2012
if we all went vegan wouldnt we have to eliminate the competition such as all animals that would also feed on the same foods, would we not need vast amounts of land more than we have now dedicated to feeding us, meaning any animals would have to be removed. there are those who choose not to eat certain meats etc, I have always told my children rule nothing out. if you are hungry and there is no other option then food is food even if human. hopefully the day where we have to consider canabalism is far away in some global warmed future, where we have another ice age or whatever, or the third world war. for now i will eat my balanced diet including meat, hopefully raised roaming a field etc but not really necessary for me to enjoy it. when i die i will be put in the ground to feed bacteria and bugs so that the cycle of life continues.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
i love to tumble , ask me why .
17:26 on 08/09/2012
only 1/3 of land is usable for crops.it would be a disaster. animals competing for '' our '' plant foods are already removed. trapped, shot and poisoned. nothing guilt free there.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
18:21 on 08/09/2012
"I have always told my children rule nothing out. if you are hungry and there is no other option then food is food even if human."

Is there something wrong with you?
19:19 on 08/09/2012
read the whole comment or does your diet give you a limited attention span, there have been cases where someone has committed canabalism to survive a difficult situation, people that state they wont eat certain foods through choice have never known hunger these same people would most likely sacrifice that standard as soon as the need arose. we are fortunate that we have a choice how many countries in this world are there people who have none. this planet could never survive a planet of vegans and vegetarians it is the diverse mix that creates the balance and our greed and whims that destroy that balance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SusanElizabeth1949
My micro-bio may be empty but my head isn't.
06:40 on 08/09/2012
It wouldn't be, contrary to your beliefs beef cattle spend most of their life on range land where they do a lot of walking. Lab grown meat would be flacid in texture. Sorry but most of us will just keep on eating animals.
13:29 on 16/09/2012
And most of you lack compassion, empathy and will be dead before you can answer to the atrocities you are responsible for. But that's ok, we will just pick up the pieces for you in the future - what ever helps you keep up the comfortable, self-important, ego-centric life you so worthily deserve. We wouldn't want you to think of something other than yourself and your tiny bubble of existence at all - it might hurt.
TomP100
Got elk?
01:37 on 08/09/2012
Absolutely not. We have too many vile frankenfoods already. I'll keep hunting wild game and buying free range, grass fed meat from small, local family farms.
00:34 on 08/09/2012
Great article, thank you. To answer your question: nope, because I am Vegan, BUT, I certainly hope those who do insist on killing themselves and other sentient beings do!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lesley MacIntyre
Please pass the bacon.
12:00 on 08/09/2012
Ummm. VeganNewsNet..You're diet has killed more sentient creatures than my grass fed one does. As far as killing myself by eating meat. I am doing no such thing. Also, I won't eat meat that was grown in a lab. That is just plain weird and unnatural and not what God has intended.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Wagland
Resistance is fertile
19:12 on 08/09/2012
Please explain how a vegan diet kills more sentient creatures than a meat-based diet? Please also explain how you know God exists, and how you know what 'he' intended?
13:36 on 16/09/2012
Oh yeah, because chickens selectively bred to grow 4 times faster than is natural, that are pumped full of hormones and antibiotics, kept in large sheds with no room to move or carry out natural behaviour, which are then slaughtered by someone else, packaged using petrolium procucts and large amounts of water, shipped all across the country/overseas, which you then go into a supermarket and buy is a completely natural process...