Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Terry Sanderson

GET UPDATES FROM Terry Sanderson
 

Is the Government About to Give in to Religious Pressure Over Gay Marriage?

Posted: 9/03/2012 11:38

The Catholic magazine The Tablet is reporting today that the government is about to bend to religious pressure and change the terms of the consultation on same-sex marriage to include a question about whether such a move is desirable at all.

When the consultation - to be launched later this month - was first announced, the Home Secretary, Teresa May, said that the decision to legalise gay marriage had been made and was supported by the prime minister. The consultation would only be about the finer details, not about the principle of whether it should happen or not.

Since then, the government has been under sustained attack from the Church of England the Catholic Church to drop the proposals. Cardinal Keith O'Brien caused an outcry last week with his intemperate, almost hysterical, attack on the Government's plans.

The Tablet says it was unable to get confirmation from the Home Office that a question about whether people are in favour of or opposed to gay marriage would be included in the consultation, but it said that it had been told by inside sources that this was the case.

Meanwhile, the Catholic Church is gearing up for a major campaign of opposition. A letter will be read out to everyone attending Mass on Sunday from the Archbishop of Westminster, explaining why it is a Catholic duty to oppose same-sex marraige. Later a leaflet will be produced to urge every Catholic to take part in the consultation and stand against the coalition government's proposals.

Catholic Voices, an organisation set up to propagandise and make excuses for the Church's excesses, has produced a ComRes poll that apparently shows that 70% of people oppose gay marriage. But all may not be quite as it seems with this survey, as this analysis of the question finds.

But even if 70% of the population do oppose gay marriage (when asked a loaded question), does it matter? Does this country allow the human rights of minorities to be steamrollered by the prejudice and ignorance of the majority? Or is it that the majority are, in reality, indifferent, and only express an opinion when asked?

Last week the United Nations issued a report arguing that state-sponsored religion was undesirable because of the almost inevitable deleterious effects it has on minority rights.

What is equally undesirable is the Church imposing its will on legislators in this way.

The National Secular Society will be writing to David Cameron urging him to stand firm against this religious assault. If he gives in to this, the Churches will feel emboldened to move on to their next target, and what we have come to see as a progressive and modern society will fall prey to reactionary demands.

There are already moves to impede women's access to abortion.

If the government is defeated on gay marriage, you can expect to see Nadine Dorries back in action - with more confidence that, this time, she can win.

 
The Catholic magazine The Tablet is reporting today that the government is about to bend to religious pressure and change the terms of the consultation on same-sex marriage to include a question about...
The Catholic magazine The Tablet is reporting today that the government is about to bend to religious pressure and change the terms of the consultation on same-sex marriage to include a question about...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
09:45 AM on 03/10/2012
I am with the 70% opposed, no loaded question required and will remain so. Let them be happy with their 'civil partnerships'. I wont vote Tory again if he does agree, and my 70% represents more than a few 'Brighton set' Homosexuals
04:30 PM on 03/10/2012
I'm opposed too. Why the "MINORITY" gay brigade think its all about what they "want" is beyond me, I want lots of things but I'm not getting them. Reading another post on here a few weeks back I was astounded at the depravity considered acceptable these days, the blame for this afaic lies directly at the feet of the likes of the secular society and their gay supporters, I don't believe in god but theres a lot to be said for having certain morals to lead your life by, its no wonder we have 650 politicians creating law after law to control this sick society, not everything is acceptable.
09:19 PM on 03/10/2012
Why is homophobia the only form of predjudice that still seems to be socially acceptable?
photo
Catriona
Wha daur meddle wi me?
09:15 PM on 03/09/2012
What is this? The bl00dy US of A?
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
10:02 PM on 03/14/2012
The 19th century in the UK will do.
photo
Catriona
Wha daur meddle wi me?
10:11 PM on 03/14/2012
Same thing. :(
08:26 PM on 03/09/2012
It seems to me that church authorities do a good job of riling up their minions with their hokum and exerting political pressure on government authorities. I think what would be interesting is a forum where the church picks their best anti-gay marriage guy and someone from the Progressive movement stands up to him in a public debate. It would be so much fun as the Progressive individual ripped right into these self righteous windbags. Besides not having any facts to support their position, all they can do is appeal to tradition and emotion, and can also show how loathsome the catholic churchs program of discrimination really is.
07:41 PM on 03/09/2012
Cameron's last ounce of respectability rests on this issue, in my opinion, as it's one of the only areas in which he's (so far) been going in the right direction. If he caves in to this disgusting propaganda and campaign of hatred from the Church and the right-wing press, then he will lose whatever respect I may have still had for him (however little that may be).
07:31 PM on 03/09/2012
The National Secular Society will "write to David Cameron urging him to stand firm against this religious assault." Well what about the NSS's persisent assaults on the religious community?
A roaring silence no doubt??
I have no problem per se with gay couples entering into Civil Partnerships, allowing them to write wills leaving their assets to their life partners. I know of gay couples who've been together longer than many 'straight'. This does not however validate same sex partnerships to the same level as heterosexual ones. The majority - when the gay + SC activists bother to ask a 'straight' question on whether the two types of union should be made equal - inevitably answer with a resounding NO, much to the chagrin of of the gay and SC MINORITY lobby.
06:28 PM on 03/09/2012
Why use the same language as those apposing gay marriage?

"The National Secular Society will be writing to David Cameron urging him to stand firm against this religious assault. If he gives in to this, the Churches will feel emboldened to move on to their next target, and what we have come to see as a progressive and modern society will fall prey to reactionary demands."

They may not feel emboldened, it isn't a slippery slope. Surely it's just a case of allowing gay people to call themselves "married".

Let's leave the rhetoric to those who need it.
05:25 PM on 03/09/2012
The question here is not merely what one religion says, but I imagine what all religions agree on, i.e. that marriage has always been between a man and a woman. This has not just been the stance of religious people, but has also been the general meaning of the term 'marriage'. What is disturbing is that we are now considering redefining marriage to mean what we ( or at least some people) want it to mean.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bernard O'Leary
07:59 PM on 03/09/2012
"What is disturbing is that we are now considering redefining marriage to mean what we ( or at least some people) want it to mean."

"We" are the people who have to live with society's rules and their effects. We don't have any obligation to live with old rules just because they're old; our obligation is to try and make the best possible world for everyone to live in.

Given the state of heterosexual marriage these days, it's just not good enough to say "marriage between a man and a woman is what works and we need to keep it". Relationships are changing, sexuality is changing, and we need to change how we think about these things.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
08:01 PM on 03/09/2012
Actually marriage was around a long time before Christianity. It was widespread enough in Imperial Rome that both Martail and Jevenal referred to it as something that occurs 'not infrequently'.

It was only in the 4th Century, as Rome became more Christianised, that legal prohibitions against gay marriage began to appear.

Early Christian churches performed a number of gay marriages. Check out christianity-revealed.com.

If anyone has redefined the traditional idea of marriage, it's the Christians.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
05:04 PM on 03/09/2012
More lies from the Catholic church, who claim that condoms help to spread AIDs.

Dawkin's recent MORI poll showed that 61% of Christians are in favour of gay marriage.
03:02 PM on 03/09/2012
I hope the UK Government doesn't withdraw the plans to legalise gay marriage. I sincerely doubt they would, though; too many people want it.
02:01 PM on 03/09/2012
BSCParty defends all to have the right to free speech.The CofE is not up to date with how it views the latest documented discoveries about the early Church, which was of course RCath. The basis of the CofE is the ten commandments which comes from the Old Testament and is basic Jewish belief.
All christian churchs interpret New Testament for their own purpose. This is their right. With regard to Marriage we also have a legal civil marriage. Anyone can choose this. ALL churches change their dogma from time to time but you don't have to wait for them. What more doe's anyone want?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Northcote
01:20 PM on 03/09/2012
A poll of 2,004 Catholics is not indicative of anything.
photo
JohnFromCensornati
Free your mind and your ass will follow.
01:11 PM on 03/09/2012
"Catholic Voices, an organisation set up to propagandise and make excuses for the Church's excesses, has produced a ComRes poll that apparently shows that 70% of people oppose gay marriage. But all may not be quite as it seems with this survey, as this analysis of the question finds."

There are always lots of willing liars for Jesus.