Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
The Guyliner

GET UPDATES FROM The Guyliner
 

Sorry, There's No Cure For Gay - Why Not Pray For an Antidote to Stupid Instead?

Posted: 13/04/2012 00:00

There is a time, I imagine, in the lives of most gay people when they wish, if only for a moment, that they weren't gay. Perhaps it comes when they want to kiss their other half without fear of reproachful look or, worse, a boot to the head. Maybe the trigger is the desire to get married in their local church in a colossal gown, surrounded by chubby bridesmaids. The playgrounds and hallways of school can also be the scene for many an "I just wish I was like everybody else" silent scream. But, for the most part, these feelings pass and many gay people go on to embrace their sexuality, seeing it for what it is: just another part of who they are.

When having these wobbles about sexuality, it can be common to mull over the possible 'escape routes' into 'heteronormality', be it throwing yourself into a straight relationship with gusto, simply abstaining from sex completely or merely restricting your sexual contact to covert assignations. The closet is deep and wide and, despite emptying out considerably since the demonisation of homosexuality became less acceptable, still has many inhabitants. Thank goodness then, gays who don't want to be gay, for conversion therapy! Vulnerable, anxious and scared witless by your predilection for penis, boys? Fretful and confused by your dreams about slamming your face into a large pair of bouncy boobs, ladies? Fear not, there is an answer. It's just a shame that this solution is at least 800 million times more distasteful than the 'problem' it claims to eradicate.

So what is it? Well, simply put, gay conversion therapy is a usually religion-based method of counselling which aims to transform unwilling homosexuals into straight people. That's it, in a tiny nutshell. The gays that just can't help themselves are offered an out that hopes to put them back in.

The major issue for me with conversion therapy is that it requires admission that homosexuality is a 'problem' or 'disorder', that it's a leaky tap which needs to be fixed.

A number of undercover journalists have infiltrated gay conversion therapy - and the majority of them comment on how sinister it is, consisting of little more than scaremongering. On researching this post, I came across many testimonials from 'survivors' of this therapy, some of whom described odd sexual practices and the unhealthy obsessions with homosexual acts displayed by therapists.

The rumours around the Christian clinic owned by erstwhile US presidential candidate Michele Bachmann and her husband Marcus have recently resurfaced, with a documentary filmmaker going undercover to reveal a counsellor tried to influence her questions about her sexuality with the help of a trusty old Bible. While the Bachmanns continue to deny any such practices happen in their clinics, filmmaker Kristina Lapinski says she's got the evidence to back it up.

Things are no better in the UK, really. It doesn't really help that the latest 'celebrity' signing up to be a poster girl for the therapy is none other than nobody's favourite virgin and reality TV show doyenne, former MP Ann Widdecombe. Never known to be a shrinking violet when it comes to speaking on God's behalf, a recent example of a GP suggesting gay therapy to a reporter is what set Ann off frothing at the mouth like an excitable rottweiler. Ann, who was so displeased with the Church of England ordaining women that she packed up her cauldron and converted to Catholicism, has claimed that the therapy should be available on the National Health Service, likening it to the treatment available for those wishing to undergo gender reassignment. This logic doesn't quite work, however, as being gay isn't an illness and, can't necessarily be cured. Also, no matter which side of the 'nature vs nurture' fence you do your sunbathing, homosexuality isn't a choice. It's highly unlikely people can be talked out of it, like a house purchase or being afraid of buttons. For someone who, by her own admission, is yet to experience sexual pleasure, Ann (known as 'Widdy' to idiots who think she is some kind of lovable old curmudgeon) has a lot of opinions on it. She's also been spouting about marriage equality and guess what? She's not keen.

As if Ann and her big mouth weren't enough, there's yet another stick waiting in the wings to beat gays. A potential Christian ad campaign on the side of London's iconic and highly visible red buses has been getting a lot of coverage. Aping the recognisable Stonewall slogan "Some People Are Gay. Get Over It!", this po-faced take, backed by homophobic charity the Core Issues Trust, sneers "Not Gay! Ex-Gay, Post-Gay and Proud. Get Over It!" The crusade is also supported by orthodox Anglican group Anglican Mainstream, who, delightfully, consider homosexuality to be a blight on someone's life comparable to alcoholism. In that case, pass me a gin and tonic; I'm really going out in style. Following an intervention by London mayor Boris Johnson and a media outcry, Transport for London have now said that the campaign will not run, as it doesn't "believe these ads reflect TfL's commitment to a tolerant and inclusive London", but how was the idea they could run ever entertained in the first place?

I suppose it's easy to make glib comments about being unsurprised religious groups believe in these magic therapies given they also put their faith in a big beardy guy in the sky, served on Earth by men in dresses, but that is to detract from the real harm this snake oil-fuelled therapy can do. The gay rights movement has fought tirelessly to improve the image of homosexuality, bringing it kicking and screaming (and there's been plenty of screaming) out from covert cottaging into the perfectly acceptable part of human life it truly is. Its transition from the love that dare not speak its name to the love that never shuts the hell up may have been flawed, but if we continue to market the idea that it can all be magicked away like a troublesome blackhead if only we turn to God, we are playing a very hazardous game. The sanctity of marriage - another cause that gets the God squad all misty-eyed and militant - is surely more threatened by mercurial 'post-gays' going into these unions with nothing more to tell them they're not gay any more than the holy scripture. And what if the feelings return? Should the ex-but-maybe-not-so-ex-gay carry on in their marriage, lying to themselves and their partner? How many 'broken' homes or tense, loveless atmospheres is this kind of thinking creating?

Believe what you want to believe. Pray if you want to pray. But let's not fool ourselves or, more importantly, the vulnerable gay people who just want to fit in. Being gay isn't something you sit down at the kitchen table and decide to become. You can no more choose to be gay than you can choose not to.

But, I guess what's good for the goose is good for the gander, so I'd like to set forth my plans for Straight Conversion Therapy. You don't have to get out the good book, gentleman, to join my support group. No, no. Just bring yourself, a bottle of tequila and cancel all your plans for the weekend and we'll try and hammer out this straight thing nonsense once and for all, man-to-man. Leave your details after the beep.

 

Follow The Guyliner on Twitter: www.twitter.com/theguyliner

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
There is a time, I imagine, in the lives of most gay people when they wish, if only for a moment, that they weren't gay. Perhaps it comes when they want to kiss their other half without fear of reproa...
There is a time, I imagine, in the lives of most gay people when they wish, if only for a moment, that they weren't gay. Perhaps it comes when they want to kiss their other half without fear of reproa...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
02:51 AM on 04/16/2012
Ron White said it best: You can't fix stupid.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Albert Ray DOrazio
07:00 AM on 04/14/2012
I believe God put us gays and lesbians, bis, and transgenders here for a reason. I believe ultimately it's a test. A test for heterosexuals and society on how they would treat others for being born to love someone of the same gender, how they would treat others for being born to feel trapped in the wrong gender, and how they perceive the equality of male vs. female.

I also believe that nature, and God's way of controlling overpopulation is to create homosexuality and gay people. I just checked, the world's population has more than doubled in the last 70 years, counting for a whopping 7,006,906,241-THIS IS UP-TO-DATE ACCURACY-human beings on this planet. I think heterosexuals should be a little more grateful towards us gays and lesbians for helping to not overpopulate this already crowded planet.

Some people are born gay, created in the image of God, not man's. Get beyond this fact of life and get over it. Mind your own sexual orientation and sexuality.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
01:13 AM on 04/14/2012
Is it true that some humans were born to be more like robots, who can do anything other than what they were programmed to do. They could not change anything about themselves for any reason ?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rwgunn
Questioning a truth will not make it false.
11:59 PM on 04/13/2012
Unless we clearly define what criteria is used to label someone as gay, this argument will always be mushy in discussions.

Is a person gay because they have homosexual thoughts and desires? Or are they gay because they have these thoughts and desires and actually act upon them?

If a person, who has homosexual thoughts and desires and possibly has acted on them, undergoes gay-reparative therapy and afterwards still has the homosexual thoughts and desires but has trained themselves to turn away from them, deny them and/or stuff them away, are they really not gay any more?

It sounds like a choice to become mentally ill from the conflict being artificially created between what the person was born with and what they thing society wants from them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:38 PM on 04/13/2012
pretty much every gay friend of mine wishes they weren't born gay, so its a pity for them there isn't a cure.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
11:14 PM on 04/13/2012
It's always good to know what zero people think about a subject.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rwgunn
Questioning a truth will not make it false.
11:47 PM on 04/13/2012
"pretty much every gay friend of mine wishes they weren't born gay, so its a pity for them there isn't a cure." -- greencardclose

It's more likely that any gay person you know wishes they didn't have around thinking you were their friend. You obviously have a limited ability to look at the world through those tinted glasses your wearing.
04:23 PM on 04/13/2012
I suppose it's easy to make glib comments about being unsurprised religious groups believe in these magic therapies given they also put their faith in a big beardy guy in the sky, served on Earth by men in dresses,
-----------------------------------------------------
Maybe you should check out these notions with some gay Christians. There are many.
01:32 PM on 04/13/2012
So The Anglican mainstream who, from my own experience, do not repersent the Anglican mainstream, in this country want to pretend that being gay is a disease. I know that most religious people do not agree with this stuff but this is why religious groups need to follow discrimination laws as keenly as they try to use those laws to protect themselves
10:04 AM on 04/13/2012
Clever headline? Maybe. Informed and balanced article? Not really. It's a collage of rumours and allegations with very little substance. Look, everyone knows there are some weird Christians out there, just like there are weird fringes to every human grouping. The fact is that few Christians think that most gays are 'changed' by prayer or therapy, and to say that grass roots Christianity views homosexuality as a disease is as naive and ill-informed as the pathetic suggestion that Christians "put their faith in a big beardy guy in the sky, served on Earth by men in dresses". I'm a pretty typical Christian. Some of my best friends are gay. My wife and I were married by a brilliant gay priest. But the fact is that there are some gays who are no longer gay. Got a problem with that? Or does your tolerance have limits?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
Might as well laugh while you still can.
11:47 AM on 04/13/2012
It's not about tolerance, it's about calling a spade a spade. Were they actually bi sexual? Or playing a game that got out of hand eg seeking attention? Or were they depressed and got influential advice of the wrong people? Did they follow a crowd rather than being themselves? The gay community accepts sexuality is diverse, hence the rainbow flag, and we all know people that flip flop on their sexuality. Gay enough for sex not gay enough for a relationship is the commen situation. Gay people aren't happy with this because we know at our lowest ebb when all the nasines and bullying gets to you we feel we could have succomb to such nonsense in the right place and time. It's a con job wih very good salesman that plays into every fear and doubt you have.
04:09 PM on 04/13/2012
So apparently to be tolerant, we should tolerate someone else's intolerance?

Wow. We really DO need a cure for stupid.
08:03 PM on 04/13/2012
So let's get this straight. Accepting a formerly gay person who is now comfortable with being heterosexual is stupid ... and means tolerating intolerance? No comment required!
photo
hearthammer
If left is right and right is wrong, decide!
09:30 AM on 04/13/2012
Excellent. Let's now have the religious retort to common sense!
03:52 AM on 04/13/2012
I want to congratulate the author on a fantastic title-headline. It's great!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
03:33 AM on 04/13/2012
There is an antidote to stupid: education.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
03:39 PM on 04/13/2012
It doesn't seem to be able to get delivered to the right spot in some patients.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rwgunn
Questioning a truth will not make it false.
09:48 PM on 04/13/2012
"There is an antidote to stupid: education." -- FearlessFreep

I disagree. There's an antidote to ignorance: education. Stupid, too often, is never ending. Especially when the "stupid" is by making the choice to actively ignore many provable facts, as in religious faith.
11:21 PM on 04/13/2012
As you so rightly say, "Questioning a truth will not make it false." So why are you so naive and confused about faith?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nicholas Hylton
Earth, Orion Spiral Arm
02:53 AM on 04/13/2012
I love this headline!! I hope it goes viral!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PTAOfficerforObama
It's arithmetic, stupid
01:54 AM on 04/13/2012
Best headline I have read in months!
photo
Catriona
Wha daur meddle wi me?
01:54 AM on 04/13/2012
"Sorry, There's No Cure For Gay - Why Not Pray For an Antidote to Stupid Instead?"

=LOL= Praying doesn't work. The US is proof of this.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
03:40 PM on 04/13/2012
Do they just need to pray better?
photo
Catriona
Wha daur meddle wi me?
05:57 PM on 04/13/2012
Now that's a possibility.
01:45 AM on 04/13/2012
Love this. Such a fresh expression of a topic that I feel has already been beaten to the dirt.

"...no matter which side of the 'nature vs nurture' fence you do your sunbathing, homosexuality isn't a choice."

If it's a choice, then why do you have to work so relentlessly to suppress it?