Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Newham

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Newham
 

The Hard Left is Giving Student Politics a Bad Name

Posted: 24/02/2012 22:23

Student politics has a bad reputation. Ask average Joe Public and he'd tell you that it enjoys a dubious association with the hard left, with pretentious wannabe revolutionaries and with fierce self-importance in the face of crippling irrelevance. He'd be wrong - but he could be forgiven for indulging in those stereotypes, because parts of the student left do a pretty good job of reinforcing them.

The last couple of years have been utterly disastrous for the reputation of university politics and its practitioners. Minority violence at legitimate protests up and down the country has been underlined by disjointed opposition to tuition fee rises, factionalism within students' unions and a flurry of unsuccessful occupy copy-cat 'movements'. The sensible voices on the left of the student body have been drowned out by extremists, and all pretence of engagement with reality has been washed away by swaggering talk of 'movements', 'resistance' and 'solidarity'.

It's not that I have anything against movements, resistance and solidarity - far from it. I'd just prefer it if the movements were movements, not disjointed and disorganised collections of individuals; I'd prefer it if resistance meant resistance, not utopian demands on the part of isolated bodies claiming to represent great swathes of the student body; and I'd rather those preaching 'solidarity' could practise a bit of it, instead of waging petty and bitter disputes with those who don't share their alternative view of reality.

No single individual represents the utter madness of the hard left than Edd Bauer, a sabbatical officer with responsibility for education at Birmigham University's Students' Guild. After being arrested for a stupid stunt at the 2011 Lib Dem conference he was justifiably suspended from his duties. Far from apologising for shaming his union, and for undermining the previous protests of others who weren't quite as bent on garnering attention, he launched a swaggering crusade to have himself re-instated, culminating in a deplorable attempt to remove the President of Birmingham's Guild.

More recently Bauer managed to half-justify his university's ludicrous protest ban by deliberately deviating from a previously agreed route on a tense demonstration, ruining dialogue between the Guild and the university - presumably in order to bask in the limelight once more. Guild President Mark Harrop - still in power, no thanks to Bauer - had been due to take on Vice Chancellor David Eastwood in a special public Question Time until the difficulties at the protest. The event has now been postponed, and it is not certain that it will go ahead at all. A chance to make the intellectual case for the public university has been trashed. Again.

As one senior figure in the NUS mused to me recently, the irony is that those who profess the gospel of solidarity most strenuously are often those whose childish, self-indulgent factionalism is the most harmful to the student cause. Let's be honest: no intelligent student could really manage to think that sabotaging a protest could encourage solidarity; nobody with half a brain thinks that breaking into Fortnum & Mason's, smashing up Millbank and lobbing a fire extinguisher off the top of a building is going to inspire national sympathy for the students who are suffering for a crisis which they did not cause.

As a student who wholeheartedly opposes the reckless approach this Government takes to higher education, and who absolutely backs the right of students to assert their demands through peaceful and lawful protest - including, by the way, the right to peacefully occupy certain bits of land - I find it infuriating that small cliques of self-aggrandising egotists are using violence and internal subversion for nobodies good but their own. They know who they are, and they should be ashamed of themselves.

Edd Bauer, by the way, was found not guilty of causing danger to the public. It's just a shame that in the months following his arrest he felt it was necessary to do far more serious damage to the interests of students across the country.

 

Follow Tom Newham on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tnewham

Student politics has a bad reputation. Ask average Joe Public and he'd tell you that it enjoys a dubious association with the hard left, with pretentious wannabe revolutionaries and with fierce self-i...
Student politics has a bad reputation. Ask average Joe Public and he'd tell you that it enjoys a dubious association with the hard left, with pretentious wannabe revolutionaries and with fierce self-i...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:15 PM on 03/10/2012
"he was justifiably suspended from his duties.".... it was a legitimate protest. The case was laughed out of court because there was no evidence whatsoever. Why was he justifiably suspended when he was totally innocent? Ever heard of innocent until proven guilty? You're analysis glosses over the facts to show your opinion.

"he launched a swaggering crusade" I think you'll find it was the organised left as a whole that (rightly) launched the campaign.

"Bauer managed to half-justify his university's ludicrous protest ban by deliberately deviating from a previously agreed route [...] ruining dialogue between the Guild and the university" Ruining Dialogue? there is no dialogue. The uni just does what it wants. Nobody on that march wanted to stick to the dull 'agreed route' not just Edd. I was on the march and i think i represent a lot of the protesters when i say i wasn't going there with the intention of doing exactly what the uni wanted me to.

"breaking into Fortnum & Mason's".... people walked through the front door and peacefully sat around they broke nothing. It was the police that lied to them telling them none would be arrested before they all were.

"As a student who wholeheartedly opposes the reckless approach this Government takes" what are you suggesting we do? or what have you done? You attack Edd but the way i see it If everybody protested as hard as Edd the fees would not have risen.
12:42 PM on 02/29/2012
A reactionary backlash from the right is what this article is. Apathy and indifference is giving students a bad name. I doubt that the author has ever taken part in a demonstration and yet he complains about 'movements' and the 'hard-left' both of which he has no understanding. Poor article indeed.
12:58 PM on 02/28/2012
Incidently, regarding the attack on Millbank, was my daughter the only one to gain the impression that the, supposedly peacefull, demonstration was organised with the intention of the protest being taken over by the more extreme Left?
12:53 PM on 02/28/2012
Tom, t'was ever thus!
If you read my posts on Rosslyn McNair's board, you will see that I am a person of long memory who's disillusionment with the Left was triggered by the excesses of the Student Left during the '60s and '70s.

http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/rosslyn-mcnair/students-left-wing-love-affair_b_1301159.html?show_comment_id=137686713#comment_137686713
02:32 AM on 02/28/2012
Good to see that there are also conservatives working for the Hpost! Great job, Tom Newham!
02:18 AM on 02/28/2012
plk